The rollout of smart motorways should be suspended amid safety concerns, MPs and campaigners have said.
Government plans to remove the hard shoulder from all future smart motorways and use the lane for live traffic are “premature”, a report from Commons Transport Select Committee (TSC) has said.
Demonstrators carried 38 cardboard coffins to the Houses of Parliament today in protest over the Government’s motorway plan, which was first announced in March last year.
Image: The TSC urged ministers to ‘consider alternative options for enhancing capacity’ on motorways
A smart motorway is a section of a motorway that uses traffic management methods to increase capacity.
Advertisement
One type is known as an “all-lane running” scheme, and permanently removes the hard shoulder and converts it into a lane for traffic. On this type of motorway, lane one (formerly the hard shoulder) should close if there is an accident – with a red X appearing above the lane.
However, there have been mounting concerns after several fatal accidents saw stationary vehicles being hit from behind.
More from UK
Claire Mercer, whose husband, Jason, died on a smart motorway stretch of the M1 in June 2019, welcomed the recommendation the rollout be paused, adding: “That will give us more time to get into the High Court and get these banned anyway”.
Mr Mercer, 44, and Alexandru Murgeanu, 22, died near Sheffield when a lorry crashed into their vehicles which had stopped on the motorway after a “minor shunt”.
Mrs Mercer said: “They keep doing review after review after review. In the meantime, people are still dying.
“There’s a really strong feeling against these. We need to embarrass the Government into actually doing something.
“We don’t need a raft of changes. We just need the hard shoulder back in every single instance.”
Image: Jason Mercer, 44, died following a collision on the M1 northbound on 7 June 2019. Pic: South Yorkshire Police @syptweet
However, the TSC was “not convinced” that such a policy would boost safety.
The committee concluded: “The evidence suggests that doing so could put more drivers and passengers at risk of death and serious injury.
“The Government is right to focus on upgrading the safety of all-lane running motorways.”
The TSC urged ministers to “consider alternative options for enhancing capacity” on motorways.
Image: Protesters carry 38 38 cardboard coffins, one for each life lost on smart motorways between 2014 and 2019
Image: Smart motorways protester march across Westminster Bridge.
It is calling on the government to install controlled smart motorways, instead of all-lane running motorways.
Controlled smart motorways have a permanent hard shoulder and use technology to regulate traffic and have the “lowest casualty rates” of all roads across motorways and major A roads in England.
The committee’s report said: “The Government and National Highways should pause the rollout of new all-lane running schemes until five years of safety and economic data is available for every all-lane running scheme introduced before 2020 and the implementation of the safety improvements in the Government’s action plan has been independently evaluated.”
Mrs Mercer, from Rotherham, said the number of coffins corresponded to the official number of people killed on smart motorways between 2014 and 2019.
Image: Protesters carry placards saying ‘Just turn the first lane off’ and ‘restore the hard shoulder save lives’
Mrs Mercer said her campaign is educating the public about the risks of smart motorways.
“My husband might still be alive if he’d known what a smart motorway was,” she added.
Jack Szwarc, who was wearing a leg brace, said he almost died on a smart motorway in April.
The 33-year-old from Wolverhampton said he came off his motorbike at 60mph on the M6, having nowhere safe to escape when the engine died.
“Smart motorways almost cost me an arm and a leg,” he said, describing how his bike slammed against the barrier, causing him to lose “a big chunk” of his leg, shattering his kneecap and dislocating his shoulder.
Image: Jack Szwarc almost died on a smart motorway in April
“We’re all here as receipts from the hidden costs of profits over people,” he added.
Conservative MP Sir Mike Penning, who claims he was misled when he supported the rollout of smart motorways in his role as roads minister from 2010-2012, said the TSC’s findings were “another significant step in the fight to improve safety on these motorways”.
An additional 300 miles of smart motorways without hard shoulders could be rolled out across England by 2025.
The Duke of Sussex has written about the privilege of serving his country ahead of Remembrance Day and appealed for people to consider former service personnel who carry the “weight of war”.
In a passionate essay, Prince Harry has warned how easy it is for veterans to be forgotten “once the uniform comes off”.
Former soldier Harry, who undertook two frontline tours to Afghanistan, has paid tribute to former servicemen and women across the UK, and describes Remembrance as “not simply a minute’s silence” but “a call to collective responsibility”.
Image: Prince Harry at the Field of Remembrance at Westminster Abbey in 2018. Pic: Reuters
“Every November the world, for a moment, grows quieter. We pause, together, to remember.
“Remembrance has never been about glorifying war. It’s about recognising its cost: the lives changed forever and the lessons paid for, through unimaginable sacrifice. It’s also about honouring those who, knowing that cost, still choose to serve,” he wrote.
In the 647-word essay entitled The Bond, The Banter, The Bravery: What it means to be British, Harry called on people to remember “not only the fallen, but the living” who carry the “weight of war” and urged them to knock on veterans’ doors and “join them for a cuppa… or a pint” to hear their stories and “remind them their service still matters”.
He added that he was “moved” each year by Norfolk-based Scotty’s Little Soldiers charity, which supports bereaved military children.
More on Prince Harry
Related Topics:
He also praised the “resilience” of those he met in Ukraine who had been injured in the war, and described the “courage reborn, camaraderie restored” seen at his Invictus Games competition.
It is “proof that service doesn’t end when the uniform comes off”, he wrote in the piece, released as his brother Prince William prepared to hand out awards for his Earthshot Prize in Brazil.
Image: The Duke of Sussex, pictured here with Royal Marines in 2018, has long championed the work of the armed forces. Pic: PA
While recognising he is no longer a working royal in the UK, he expressed his love of the “things that make us British”.
He wrote: “Though currently, I may live in the United States, Britain is, and always will be, the country I proudly served and fought for.
“The banter of the mess, the clubhouse, the pub, the stands ridiculous as it sounds, these are the things that make us British. I make no apology for it. I love it.”
Harry’s personal message may feel like an own goal
To us it may feel like an unfortunate clash. William in Brazil to talk about the environment, Harry in Canada for Remembrance, both brothers trying to draw attention to causes they’ve supported for a very long time.
Both, I suspect, wishing we’d focus on what they’re actually trying to say, rather than what we think it means that they’re both on significant trips at the same time.
I know that both sides share a frustration that the headlines will pit them against each other, it has also been suggested that Harry’s team did make royal communications aware of his Canada plans.
The release of a particularly personal article about his life in the military, his observation that it’s easy for veterans to be forgotten and an apparent longing for what he defines as Britain, is intriguing though.
Especially when you can’t help but wonder whether it really needed to be published on the same day as his brother’s Earthshot Awards.
Sometimes these things feel like an own goal when it comes to the stream of stories about brothers divided, although how much should we bear the responsibility for perpetuating that narrative?
Harry also wrote that: “Remembrance isn’t confined to one weekend in November”.
“It’s a lifelong commitment to empathy, gratitude, and action; to be kinder, more united, and braver in protecting what those before us fought to preserve.”
New York has followed London by choosing hope over fear in electing Democrat Zohran Mamdani as its new mayor, Sir Sadiq Khan said.
Mr Mamdani, 34, defeated former New York governor Andrew Cuomo and Republican Curtis Sliwa to become the city’s first Muslim mayor and the first of South Asian heritage.
Sir Sadiq called it a “historic campaign”, adding on X: “New Yorkers faced a clear choice – between hope and fear – and just like we’ve seen in London – hope won.”
Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson also congratulated Mr Mamdani, telling Sky News: “I wish him well.
“It’s a wonderful job to have secured.”
More on Donald Trump
Related Topics:
Green Party leader Zack Polanski said Mr Mamdani’s success “will resonate throughout the world” as he called it a “story where no one is left behind”.
“It’s time to write that story across England and Wales too,” he added.
Image: Zohran Mamdani with his wife, Rama Duwaji. Pic Reuters
Mr Mamdani’s victory was a setback for Donald Trump, who had thrown his weight behind Andrew Cuomo, a former Democrat running as an independent.
The mayor-elect described himself as “Trump’s worst nightmare” and said New York had shown “a nation betrayed by Donald Trump how to defeat him”.
The US president had threatened to cut federal funding to New York if Mr Mamdani won.
In his victory speech, Mr Mamdani said: “New York will remain a city of immigrants, a city built by immigrants, powered by immigrants and as of tonight, led by an immigrant.
“If anyone can show a nation betrayed by Donald Trump how to defeat him, it is the city that gave rise to him.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
3:35
Deported sex offender says police ignored him
The Metropolitan Police confirmed to Sky News: “Shortly after 1pm on Tuesday 4 November, the Met was informed by the Prison Service that a prisoner had been released in error from HMP Wandsworth on Wednesday 29 October.
“The prisoner is a 24-year-old Algerian man.
“Officers are carrying out urgent enquiries in an effort to locate him and return him to custody.”
Sky News understands the prisoner was serving time for trespass with an intent to steal but has previously committed sexual offences.
It is understood he is not an asylum seeker.
Image: HMP Wandsworth in south London. Pic: PA
‘Utterly unacceptable’
It is not yet clear why it was nearly a week between the latest release at Wandsworth and the police being informed that an offender was at large.
Sir Keir Starmer was not aware of the incident until the Met Police announcement, Downing Street said.
The prime minister’s spokesman told reporters: “The Met have released a statement I think in the last few minutes.”
He said “one mistaken release is one too many” and the case was “utterly unacceptable”.
“It’s important the police are given the time and space to bring him back into custody. And we will look into the circumstances behind this as a matter of urgency,” he added.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
4:01
‘What on earth is going on within the Prison Service?’
The PM’s spokesman could not say when Mr Lammy became aware of the error, after the cabinet minister refused to answer several questions in the House of Commons on the incident from the shadow defence secretary.
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch wrote on X: “James Cartlidge asked the Deputy PM FIVE times to tell us if ANOTHER migrant sex offender had been accidentally released from prison.
“Instead of answering, Lammy lost his temper.
“Now we read it HAS happened again & he’s been on the run for a week.
“This is a shambles of a government.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:46
Lammy refuses to say if more prisoners mistakenly released
Lammy ‘outraged and appalled’
Sky News understands Mr Lammy did know about the prisoner release before he stood up in the Commons and was pressed on the issue by the Conservatives.
“If we knew, one can only assume the justice secretary knew,” a spokesman for Ms Badenoch said, adding Mr Lammy should come back to the chamber “and do a statement as soon as possible”.
Mr Lammy said afterwards he was “absolutely outraged and appalled by the mistaken release of a foreign criminal wanted by the police”, adding his “officials have been working through the night to take him back to prison”.
“Victims deserve better and the public deserve answers,” he said.
It is understood Mr Lammy believed it would have been irresponsible to talk about the case – involving several agencies – while details were still emerging.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage posted on social media: “Another dangerous criminal is on the loose thanks to Labour. What a total farce.”
The numbers of these types of errors has risen recently, with 262 instances between March 2024 and March 2025.
The Conservatives described the Kebatu episode as a “national embarrassment”.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
5:26
Lammy has ‘egg on his face’, former prison governor says
In the aftermath of the Kebatu manhunt, Mr Lammy promised “the strongest release checks that have ever been in place”.
He also ordered an independent investigation into the Kebatu release, which is being led by former Deputy Commissioner of the Met Police Dame Lynne Owens.
“This latest incident exposes deeper flaws across the failing criminal justice system we inherited,” Mr Lammy added in his statement on Wednesday on the HMP Wandsworth error.
“Dame Lynne Owens’ investigation will leave no stone unturned to identify these issues, so we can fix them, improve safeguards and ensure the public is properly protected.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
5:51
Analysis: Did Lammy walk into a trap?
‘Dangerous situation’
The Liberal Democrats’ justice spokesperson Jess Brown-Fuller said: “Just when you couldn’t think things could get any worse for the Ministry of Justice, somehow they have. It would be laughable if the situation weren’t so dangerous.
“This is yet another grave mistake from the government. The public deserves a full explanation about how this has happened again. That should start with David Lammy coming back before Parliament this afternoon for why he failed to answer this pressing question in PMQs as well as a full explanation of how it took almost a week for this to come to light.
“It’s utterly unacceptable that public safety has been put at risk yet again. Both the government and the Prison Service must own up to their failures and guarantee that these mistakes will stop happening once and for all.”