Connect with us

Published

on

The anti-strikes bill has been branded “shoddy and unworkable” after an independent watchdog ruled the impact assessment of the policy was “not fit for purpose”.

The Regulatory Policy Committee (RPC), a panel that analyses new laws, said ministers have not considered all the effects of its controversial Minimum Service Levels Bill and has not backed up its assumptions with evidence.

The legislation seeks to ensure a legally mandated level of service across key sectors like the NHS, and will allow bosses to fire employees who ignore notices ordering them to work on strike days.

Politics latest: Brexiteers criticise Rishi Sunak’s handling of EU talks

Unions and Labour fiercely oppose the bill, which they say is an attack on the right to strike.

The legislation has passed through the Commons and is now facing scrutiny in the House of Lords.

The RPC criticised ministers for not submitting the impact assessment (IA) of the legislation before it was debated by MPs – as is required under the government’s “own policy for timely submission”.

More on Strikes

The watchdog said it received the assessment several weeks later and what was produced was not good enough – resulting in a “red rating”.

“The RPC found that the IA is not-fit-for-purpose and, therefore red rated,” it said.

The body said the rating “reflects the insufficient assessment of the impacts of the bill on small and micro-businesses”.

Labour called it a “damning judgement by independent experts on the government’s ‘Sacking Nurses’ Bill”.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Mhari Aurora explains all you need to know about the bill

Deputy leader Angela Rayner said: “Tory ministers have failed utterly to do due diligence on this shoddy, unworkable policy, breaking their own rules and failing to provide evidence for their claims.

“Clearly the government is trying to hide the severe and disproportionate impacts its legislation will have on small businesses.

“It’s little wonder they’re trying to rush this legislation through parliament because not one bit of it stands up to scrutiny. This is a complete dereliction of ministerial duty.”

Ministers ‘should drop bill entirely’

Pat Cullen, chief executive of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN), said: “This is a damning assessment of the government’s attempt to stifle the rights of workers. The independent committee is saying it is not fit for purpose and should essentially go ‘back to the drawing board’.

“The government is ploughing ahead with an ill thought through bill that allows for nursing staff to be sacked for taking otherwise lawful strike action.

“Ministers would be better listening to the mounting opposition, drop the bill entirely and work with unions to resolve these disputes.”

Read More;
What the anti-strike bill means for workers and why the government wants it
Anti-strike bill moves one step closer to law – hours after new walkouts announced

The government has insisted the legislation – being tabled at a time of widespread action across the public sector – hits the right balance between the right to strike and ensuring public safety during walkouts.

The RPC noted that while work notices have been proposed to stop employees from striking to ensure minimum service levels, the IA “does not consider these impacts in any detail”.

It said the government “must ensure that all direct business impacts (including those to trade unions) have been clearly identified and discussed” and called the cost-benefit analysis of the policy “weak”.

A Downing Street spokesperson said further impact assessments on the bill will be published by the government.

Continue Reading

UK

Special educational needs children ‘segregated and left to struggle in wrong schools to save money’

Published

on

By

Special educational needs children 'segregated and left to struggle in wrong schools to save money'

Children with special educational needs are being “segregated” and left to struggle in the wrong schools because councils are trying to “save on costs”, parents have told Sky News. 

Maire Leigh Wilson, whose four-year-old son has Down’s syndrome, says she “shudders to think” where he would be now had she not been in a “constant battle” with her council.

“I think he would probably just be at the back of a classroom, running around with no support and no ability to sign or communicate,” she said.

Mrs Leigh Wilson wanted her son Aidan to go to a mainstream school with additional specialist support, but her council, who decide what is known as a child’s Education Health and Care Plan (EHCP), wanted him to attend a special school.

The number of EHCPs being appealed by parents has risen “massively”, according to education barrister Alice De Coverley.

She said councils are struggling to meet the volume of demand with “stretched budgets”, and parents are also more aware of their ability to appeal.

Mrs De Coverley said more than 90% of tribunals are won by parents, in part because councils do not have the resources to fight their cases.

More on Education

She said, in her experience, parents of children with special educational needs will put “anything on the line, their homes, their jobs”.

On whether she thinks the system is rigged against parents, Mrs De Coverley said: “I’m not sure it’s meant to be. But I think that parents are certainly finding it very tough.”

She added the number of “unlawful decisions” being made by local authorities means parents who can afford it are being “utterly burnt out” by legal challenges.

Read more:
Three in four parents of SEND children forced to give up work or cut hours

Maire Leigh Wilson with her son, Aiden, four
Image:
Maire Leigh Wilson with her son, Aiden, four

Mrs Leigh Wilson’s case was resolved before making it to court.

Her council, Hounslow in southwest London, said they complete more than four in five new EHCPs within the statutory 20-week timescale, twice the national average.

Hounslow Council said they “put families at the heart of decision-making” and young people in the area with special educational needs and disabilities achieve, on average, above their peers nationally.

They admitted there are areas of their offer “that need to be further improved” and they are “working closely with families as a partnership”.

“We have a clear and credible plan to achieve this, and we can see over the last 18 months where we have focused our improvement work, the real benefits of an improved experience for children, young people, and their families,” a Hounslow Council spokesman said.

He added the council had seen the number of EHCPs double in the last decade and they “share parents’ frustrations amid rising levels of national demand, and what’s widely acknowledged as a broken SEND system”.

Emma Dunville wanted her son, Albie, to go to a special school but the council took too long to assess him
Image:
Emma Dunville wanted her son, Albie, to go to a special school but the council took too long to assess him

Emma Dunville, a friend of Mrs Leigh Wilson whose son also has Down’s syndrome, describes her experience trying to get the right education provision for her child as “exhausting mentally and physically”.

She said: “For the rest of his life we’ll be battling, battling, battling, everything is stacked up against you.”

Unlike Mrs Leigh Wilson, Mrs Dunville wanted her son Albie to go to a special school, but she had to wait more than a year for an assessment with an education psychologist to contribute to the council’s decision, which meant she missed the deadline for an EHCP.

“The people making these decisions just don’t see that all children with Down’s syndrome are totally different and can’t be seen as the same.”

The guidelines are that if there are not enough local authority-employed education psychologists they should seek a private assessment, but her local authority did not do that.

Mrs Dunville said her son has been “segregated” in a mainstream school, where they are “trying their best” but “it’s just not the right setting”.

Continue Reading

UK

Man arrested after woman in her 80s killed in Christmas Day motorway crash

Published

on

By

Man arrested after woman in her 80s killed in Christmas Day motorway crash

A man has been arrested after a woman in her 80s was killed in a Christmas Day motorway crash.

A white Ford Fiesta and a black Volkswagen Tiguan collided on the A1(M) near Darlington just after 8.30pm, North Yorkshire Police said.

The passenger of the Ford Fiesta, a woman in her 80s from the Durham area, suffered serious injuries and died at the scene.

The car’s driver, a man in his 80s from the Durham area, was taken to hospital in a serious but stable condition.

The driver of the Volkswagen, a man in his 20s from the Durham area, was arrested on suspicion of causing death by dangerous driving.

He has now been released under investigation.

More on North Yorkshire

The motorway was closed until around 8am on Boxing Day for collision investigators and National Highways to assess the road surface.

It is now open in both directions but with a lane closure still in place as of 9.30am.

Police have appealed for witnesses and dashcam footage of the crash, which happened on the northbound carriageway between Junction 57 (A66(M) junction) and Junction 58 (Merrybent).

The force also thanked members of the public who assisted at the scene.

Continue Reading

UK

Two women and dog killed after Christmas Day ‘stabbing’ at flat in Milton Keynes

Published

on

By

Two women and dog killed after Christmas Day 'stabbing' at flat in Milton Keynes

Two women have died following reports of a stabbing in Milton Keynes on Christmas Day, police have said.

A dog injured in the incident in Bletchley also died after being taken to the vets.

A man and a teenage boy suffered serious injuries.

A 49-year-old man from Milton Keynes has been arrested on suspicion of murder and attempted murder and remains in custody.

A police forensic officer at the scene near an apartment block on Santa Cruz Avenue in Newton Leys, near Bletchley.
Pic: PA
Forensic officers at the scene near an apartment block on Santa Cruz Avenue in Newton Leys, near Bletchley.
Pic: PA
Image:
Forensic officers at the scene. Pics: PA

Officers were called to a block of apartments in Santa Cruz Avenue just after 6.30pm on Christmas Day following reports of a stabbing.

The two women, aged 38 and 24, died at the scene, Thames Valley Police said. Their next of kin have been informed.

The injured man and teenage boy were taken to hospital and are both in a stable condition.

Police said the parties are known to each other.

Senior investigating officer Detective Chief Inspector Stuart Brangwin said: “Firstly I would like to extend my deepest condolences to the families of the women who have tragically died in this shocking incident.

“We have launched a double murder investigation, which may be concerning to the wider public; however, we have made an arrest and are not looking for anyone else in connection with this incident and the parties are known to each other.”

Continue Reading

Trending