As the second day of court proceedings in London’s High Court were concluding, a judge 3,000 miles away in a US Federal Court was also talking about the Duke of Sussex.
It was certainly an unusual stroke of legal coincidence.
In courtroom number 17 of the E Barrett Prettyman US Courthouse in Washington DC, Judge Carl Nichols was hearing the opening arguments of a curious case which Prince Harry finds himself embroiled in.
It hinges around the duke’s US visa application and specifically two questions within that application which he would have been required to answer (under oath) when he applied for the visa to move to America in 2020.
The first of the key questions, in America’s Department for Homeland Security DH160 visa form, asks: “Have you ever been a drug abuser or addict?”
The second asks: “Have you ever violated, or engaged in a conspiracy to violate, any law relating to controlled substances?”
But why is this case being heard? Well, it was brought by the Heritage Foundation, a conservative US-based think tank which likes to hold the centre-left administration of President Joe Biden to account.
For some time it’s been examining the role of the Department for Homeland Security (DHS) and specifically immigration issues.
One angle it’s spent time on is the consistency with which the DHS applies its own policies when granting visas to visitors.
Advertisement
Their allegation is that the DHS operates double standards and preferential treatment from time to time.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:01
Why is Prince Harry’s US visa under scrutiny?
Prince Harry is the perfect case study
Enter Prince Harry. He is, for the Heritage Foundation, the perfect case study. He has publicly admitted taking drugs (in his book, Spare) and he was granted a visa.
The Heritage Foundation failed to obtain the visa application through a freedom of information request. The US government and the DHS cited the prince’s privacy.
So, they went to court and want a judge to instruct the DHS to unseal Prince Harry’s visa application, or at least, the relevant parts of it – those two questions.
Either the prince answered truthfully, prompting the question – why was he granted a visa without further interrogation as is standard procedure? Or, he lied and said he hadn’t taken drugs which would put him in very hot water with the US authorities – perjury.
The Heritage Foundation’s central protagonist is Nile Gardiner, a former aide to Margaret Thatcher and a man who has been, publicly, deeply critical of the prince and his wife – “greedy narcissists pursuing a disastrous vendetta”.
He and his lawyer insist this case isn’t really about them. “This is about the Duke of Sussex…” the Heritage Foundation’s lawyer said in court, “… but truly, it’s about the DHS.”
Inescapably though, Prince Harry is a neatly convenient case study for an organisation which has issues with the Biden administration and with the duke.
A curious case, then, which will be the subject of much more legal argument before a judge decides whether or not it is in the public interest to release the prince’s visa application for all to see.
A gunman who murdered four people in a New York office building before taking his own life had CTE, a degenerative brain disease which has been linked to playing American football.
The 27-year-old, who played high school football, had “unambiguous diagnostic evidence” of low-stage CTE, or chronic traumatic encephalopathy, the New York City medical examiner said.
In a three-page note discovered by police after the mass shooting, Tamura made repeated references to CTE.
Image: Shane Tamura. Pic: AP
In his note, which was written on notepad paper and using a variety of ink, Tamura wrote “CTE study my brain please. I’m sorry.” And again: “Please study brain for CTE. I’m sorry.”
He also specifically refers to Terry Long, a former NFL player who starred for the Pittsburgh Steelers. Long was diagnosed with CTE after drinking antifreeze to take his own life 20 years ago. CTE can only be diagnosed after death via post mortem.
In a statement, the NFL said: “We continue to grieve the senseless loss of lives, and our hearts remain with the victims’ families and our dedicated employees.
“There is no justification for the horrific acts that took place. As the medical examiner notes ‘the science around this condition continues to evolve, and the physical and mental manifestations of CTE remain under study’.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
3:19
July: New York shooter’s note: ‘CTE study my brain please’
We looked at the case of former high school football player Noah Green. He was 25 when he crashed into a security cordon protecting the capitol building in Washington DC and stabbed police officer William Evans to death, before he too was shot dead by responding police.
Green’s mother, Mazie, told me she believes his crime was caused by brain injuries sustained on the American football field. He also had CTE.
The theory of a link between CTE and violent crime is increasingly cited in the courtroom.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:58
At least four dead in New York shooting
Kellen Winslow, a former NFL player, argued for his sentence for multiple rapes to be reduced because of head trauma suffered on the football field.
Former San Francisco 49ers star Phillip Adams shocked the country when he shot dead six people, including grandparents and their two grandchildren, then himself in 2021. He had severe CTE.
Elon Musk’s name has appeared in files relating to Jeffrey Epstein, with a reference made to the world’s richest man potentially visiting the paedophile’s island.
The Duke of York is also named as a passenger on the sex offender’s private jet in documents released by Democrats on the House Oversight Committee in the US.
They show Musk as a potential visitor to Epstein‘s island, Little St James, on 6 December 2014 – six years after Epstein became a listed sex offender.
His name appears on what appears to be Epstein’s daily schedule, with the entry reading: “Reminder: Elon Musk to island Dec.6 (is this still happening?)”
Image: Jeffrey Epstein. File pic: New York State Sex Offender Registry via AP
In June, Musk claimed Donald Trump appeared in files relating to the disgraced financier and alleged his administration was concealing information about the US president’s association with Epstein.
He gave no evidence for the claim, which he made on X, and later appeared to have deleted the posts.
Sky News has approached Musk for comment.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:47
Watch: Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein together in 1992
Prince Andrew named as passenger on Epstein jet
The documents also show Prince Andrew as a listed passenger on a flight on Epstein’s jet from Teterboro, New Jersey, to Palm Beach, Florida, on 12 May 2000.
He is named alongside Epstein, his then-girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell, who is now a convicted sex trafficker, and two names that have been redacted.
Details of the duke travelling on Epstein’s jet have previously been heard in court in Maxwell’s trial. One of her accusers, who was 14 at the time, recalled she had travelled on a flight with Andrew.
The duke strenuously denies any wrongdoing.
In addition to Musk and the duke, the records also show he was in contact with Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, PayPal founder Peter Thiel and Steve Bannon, who was Mr Trump’s chief strategist during his first term.
Image: A passenger manifest for a flight involving Jeffrey Epstein and Maxwell, and Prince Andrew. Pic: Oversight Dems
Image: New documents from Epstein’s estate. Pic: Oversight Dems
Image: Pic: Oversight Dems
Image: Pic: Oversight Dems
The names of victims in the records are redacted and the committee said it plans to release more files once they are redacted as well.
Duchess of York dropped by charities over Epstein email
The release comes days after an email surfaced from Sarah, Duchess of York, to Epstein, in which she apologised to him for disowning him in the media.
In the letter, the duchess, Prince Andrew’s ex-wife, called the sex offender a “supreme friend”.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:45
Duchess of York explains message to Epstein
Her spokesperson said the message was written because he had threatened to sue her for defamation.
Earlier this month, Peter Mandelson, the British ambassador to the US, was sacked by Sir Keir Starmerafter it was discovered he had also sent messages to Epstein, calling him “my best pal”, after he was jailed awaiting sex trafficking charges.
Epstein was found dead in his cell at a federal jail in Manhattan in August 2019 while he was awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges. The death was ruled a suicide.
Ex-FBI director James Comey has been charged with making a false statement and obstruction in a criminal case.
Comey was fired months into Donald Trump‘s first presidency, in the middle of an investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election.
Fellow former FBI chief Robert Mueller took over the investigation, which found numerous contacts between Mr Trump’s 2016 campaign and Russian officials, but concluded that there was not enough evidence to establish a criminal conspiracy.
Mr Trump and his supporters labelled the investigation a “hoax” and a “witch hunt” used to undermine Mr Trump’s first administration – despite several government reviews showing that Moscow interfered on behalf of the Republican’s campaign.
Image: Donald Trump (pictured today in the White House) hailed the charges as “JUSTICE IN AMERICA” on Truth Social. Pic: Reuters
The charges come days after the US president appeared to chide his attorney general, Pam Bondi, for not bringing criminal charges against Comey and other perceived political enemies quickly enough.
“We can’t delay any longer, it’s killing our reputation and credibility,” Mr Trump wrote, referencing the fact that he himself had been indicted and impeached multiple times. “JUSTICE MUST BE SERVED, NOW!!!”
When she announced the charges, Ms Bondi said: “No one is above the law. Today’s indictment reflects this Department of Justice’s commitment to holding those who abuse positions of power accountable for misleading the American people.”
More on James Comey
Related Topics:
Mr Trump celebrated the charges as “JUSTICE IN AMERICA” in a Truth Social post, adding that Comey “was indicted by a Grand Jury on two felony counts for various illegal and unlawful acts”.
After he was fired, Comey became a prominent critic of the president, calling him “morally unfit” for office.
The criminal case against Comey, who served as FBI director from 2013 to 2017, does not concern the substance of the Russia investigation.
Instead, it accuses him of having lied to Congress in 2020 when he said he never authorised anyone to serve as an anonymous source to a reporter about the investigation.
Image: James Comey testified remotely before the Senate Judiciary Committee in September 2020. Pic: AP/Ken Cedeno/UPI
An internal watchdog for the US Justice Department found evidence of numerous errors but no political bias concerning the FBI’s opening of the investigation into Russian election interference.
In a 2019 report, the watchdog faulted Comey for asking a friend to give memos detailing Comey’s one-on-one interactions with Mr Trump to the New York Times.
During Mr Trump’s first term, the Justice Department declined to pursue criminal charges against Comey.
The case against Comey is the starkest example of the Trump administration using law enforcement to target a critic, following the president’s promise of retribution against the former FBI chief during his 2024 election campaign.
If Comey is convicted of making a false statement and obstruction, he faces up to five years in prison.