The police watchdog has started an investigation into the way detectives handled complaints made by the legal team of a man wrongfully convicted of rape.
The complaints relate to an allegation regarding the failure to retain items of evidence and the failure to reveal information relating to two witnesses who gave evidence to the trial, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) said.
It said its casework team “highlighted significant issues” with Greater Manchester Police’s investigation into the complaints and “identified several outstanding lines of inquiry”.
IOPC director of operations Amanda Rowe said: “Given our concerns over Greater Manchester Police’s handling of the complaints – and the significant public interest in a case that led to a man spending 17 years in jail for a crime he didn’t commit – our involvement will ensure there is thorough scrutiny of the actions of police involved.
“Our investigation, which will be carried out independently of the police, will focus on the specific allegations raised in Mr Malkinson’s complaints.
“We are not reviewing the original criminal investigation, nor do we have the power to do so.
“We are in contact with the government about its broader inquiry into the wrongful conviction. We will continue to work with the chair and inquiry team so that our work and theirs is aligned to ensure that the actions of GMP are fully examined.”
While it is independent, it is not statutory and therefore is not able to compel people to come before it.
Greater Manchester Police, the Crown Prosecution Service and the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) will all have their roles in Mr Malkinson’s conviction and imprisonment reviewed.
At the time Mr Malkinson said: “I spent over 17 years wrongly imprisoned and so I hope that my lawyers and I will be given the opportunity to feed into the inquiry’s terms of reference.
“I had to take the police to court twice to force them to hand over evidence.
“The CCRC has so far refused to apologise and take accountability. So, naturally, I am concerned that witnesses from these agencies may not cooperate and hand over all the evidence.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
2:50
Malkinson: Wrongly imprisoned for rape
He added: “If there is any obstruction by the agencies involved, then the inquiry needs to be made statutory so that they can be compelled to hand over evidence.
“I want to see serious, profound changes in our justice system coming out of this. My case shows that the police cannot be trusted to investigate impartially or act as faithful gatekeepers to the evidence.”
Labour’s post-election honeymoon looks to be over as it faces pressure this week over winter fuel payments, releasing prisoners early, and the state of the NHS.
Two months after winning a historic majority, Sir Keir Starmer and his ministers have a busy week as they face pressure not just from other parties, but their own MPs.
A vote on winter fuel payments, the prime minister speaking at the TUC conference, prisoners being released early, the publication of a report into the NHS and Sir Keir’s trip to the US are all on the cards this week.
Monday will see Chancellor Rachel Reeves addressing Labour MPs at a Parliamentary Labour Party meeting, where she is expected to face concerns about removing the winter fuel payment from 10 million pensioners.
MPs will vote on Tuesday on whether to limit the winter fuel payment to those on pension credit, after the government announced its intention at the end of July.
Labour MPs will be told they must vote with the government, however several, particularly on the left of the party, have voiced their opposition to the cut.
It is understood they may abstain instead of voting against the government, after Sir Keir set a clear precedent by suspending seven MPs from Labour after they rebelled over the decision to keep the two-child benefit cap.
Sir Keir would not say if he would again suspend MPs for voting against the government, telling the BBC on Sunday: “That will be a matter for the chief whip.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:40
‘Not remotely happy’ about cutting winter fuel
The prime minister will also address the Trades Union Congress (TUC) conference on Tuesday, where he is set to be questioned about the winter fuel payment cut and workers’ rights.
Advertisement
Sharon Graham, head of the Unite union, told Sky News on Sunday that they want the government to “think again” and called for a wealth tax instead.
She said: “We are in crisis. The Tories left a mess. No one’s denying that. Labour is right about that, but the choices they make to clear it up are really important.
“If we said the top 50 families in Britain are worth £500 billion, why aren’t they being looked at?
“Why are you looking at pensioners who really don’t have any sort of type of money? That’s the wrong choice to make.”
In a packed day for the government, Tuesday is also when the first tranche of prisoners will be released early under the Labour government as it tries to alleviate overpopulated prisons.
The Ministry of Justice admitted this week some serious offenders will be released early if they are serving a sentence for a lesser crime, having completed a sentence for a serious crime.
Reports on Saturday also claimed those serving time for common assault for being violent towards a partner would not be flagged as domestic abusers, so could be released early.
Sir Keir blamed the Conservative government for not building enough prisons, saying he was “forced into this”.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:21
Government ‘picking the pockets of pensioners’
Thursday will see the publication of a report into the state of the NHS by Lord Darzi, an eminent cancer surgeon and former Labour health minister.
The report has already had some sections released in summary, with children’s health and the progression of heart and circulatory diseases heavily criticised.
Sir Keir said the report showed the NHS was “broken” as he again hit out at the Conservatives’ “unforgivable” reforms.
To end the week, the prime minister will head to Washington DC for his second meeting with President Joe Biden since becoming prime minister.
On Sunday, Sir Keir denied the US was angry at the UK for suspending some arms sale licences to Israel and said they had spoken before and after the decision.
He said discussions with Mr Biden will focus on the next few months in Ukraine and the Middle East.
The health secretary has said he is “not remotely happy” about having to vote to cut the winter fuel allowance for some pensioners.
Wes Streeting said he has apologised to his elderly constituents who it will affect, but said cutting the payment from those not on pension credit is essential to balance public finances.
He told Sky News’ Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips: “I think it is a tough choice, and we’ve had plenty of political criticism for it, I think, which demonstrates the political pain of it.
“I’m not remotely happy about it, and I’m not remotely happy about having to say to some of my constituents, ‘I’m sorry that I’m going into work this week to vote for something that will take money away from you’.”
MPs will vote on Tuesday on whether to cut the winter fuel payment after the government announced its intention at the end of July.
Mr Streeting echoed Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s sentiment that it was a “tough choice” but is needed to get the economy back on a stable footing.
The health secretary added: “I think there are lots of people out there, actually, particularly pensioners, who’ve seen governments come and go, and have seen what happens when politicians duck the difficult decisions, who, even if they don’t agree with this choice, I hope will take some reassurance that this isn’t a government that ducks difficult decisions or pretends you can spend money you don’t have, or pretends that the stability of the public finances is not an essential ingredient for the future growth, prosperity and success of our country.”
Labour MPs will be told they must vote with the government on Tuesday to cut the payment, however several, particularly on the left of the party, have voiced their opposition to the cut.
It is understood they may abstain instead of voting against the government after Sir Keir suspended seven MPs from Labour when they voted against the government shortly after winning the election.
Sir Keir would not confirm or deny if he would do the same this time.
“That will be a matter for the chief whip,” he told the BBC.
“We’re going into a vote. I’m glad we’re having a vote, because I think it’s very important for parliament to speak on this.
“But every Labour MP was elected in on the same mandate as I was, which was to deliver the change that we need for the country over the time we’ve got in office.
“I’m absolutely convinced that we will only deliver that change, I’m absolutely determined we will, if we do the difficult things.
“Now, I know they’re unpopular, I know they’re difficult. Of course they’re tough choices.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:48
Minister’s plan to cut NHS waiting list
In a busy week for the prime minister, following the vote on Tuesday, Sir Keir will head to the US on Friday for his second trip to the White House since becoming PM in July.
Ahead of the meeting with Joe Biden, Sir Keir denied the US was angry at the UK for suspending some arms sale licences to Israel.
“We have been talking to the US beforehand and afterwards,” he told the BBC.
“They are very clear that they have got a different legal system and they understand the decision that we have taken.”
He said discussions with the president would be focused on a “strategic discussion” about the next few months in Ukraine and the Middle East.
The health secretary has said NHS waiting lists need to be “millions lower” by the next general election in 2029.
Wes Streeting told Sky News’ Sunday Morning with Trevor Phillips he is willing to do whatever it takes to ensure waiting lists are brought down, including using the private sector.
He said the “NHS waiting list will need to be millions lower by the end of this parliament”.
Mr Streeting said he wants to end the “two-tier system” where those who can afford it go private “and those who can’t are being left behind”.
However, he said where there is spare capacity in the private sector the NHS should use that to get waiting lists down.
“Rebuilding that [the NHS] takes time,” he said.
“So in the meantime, I’m looking to pull every single lever I can to make sure that people get treated as fast as possible and as safely as possible.
More from Politics
“And you can get those waiting lists down, get people back to health, back to work, or back to enjoying their lives in retirement.”
Mr Streeting said his centre-left principles mean he cannot leave “working class people waiting longer even where there is spare capacity in the private sector that we could use via the NHS to get those people treated faster”.
Advertisement
Questioned on whether GPs will get the 11% pay rise they are asking for, after Labour gave other public sector workers their requested increases, Mr Streeting would not confirm they will.
Instead, he said he has been in negotiations with the British Medical Association (BMA) GP committee and met them “many times” since becoming health secretary.
However, he said said he did want to “set expectations in the wrong places” as he cited cutting the winter fuel allowance for pensioners not claiming pension credit.
“There are difficult balances to strike in the public finances,” he said.
An investigation into the state of the NHS, ordered by the government in July, has been undertaken by Lord Darzi, an eminent surgeon and former Labour health minister, and will be published on Thursday.
Shadow health secretary Victoria Atkins said she was concerned by Lord Darzi’s links to the Labour party as she said the NHS situation in Wales, which has been under Labour control for more than 100 years, is “lamentable”.
“This report, I fear, is cover for the Labour Party to raise our taxes in the budget in October and they are laying the groundwork for this,” she said.
“They weren’t straight with us about wind fuel payments. They’re not being straight with us about taxes. And we need to have a grown up conversation about the NHS, but this is not the way to go about it.”