Connect with us

Published

on

The founder of the popular photoblog Humans of New York has hit out at an Indian version of his concept – Humans of Bombay – as it becomes embroiled in a copyright battle.

Humans of Bombay, which follows a similar format to Humans of New York (HONY), has filed a copyright infringement lawsuit against a rival platform.

Weighing in on the dispute, Humans of New York founder Brandon Stanton slammed Humans of Bombay, accusing it of appropriating his own work first.

“I’ve stayed quiet on the appropriation of my work because I think @HumansOfBombay shares important stories, even if they’ve monetized far past anything I’d ever feel comfortable doing on HONY.

“But you can’t be suing people for what I’ve forgiven you for.”

HONY features portraits of New Yorkers alongside quotes or short stories from their lives.

It became an online sensation after it launched in 2010, claiming to provide a “worldwide audience with daily glimpses into the lives of strangers on the streets of New York City”.

The photoblog now boasts an online following of over 20 million.

Read more:
Deaths from 9/11-related illnesses reaches ‘sombre milestone’
New York’s mayor says migration crisis may ‘destroy’ city

Humans of Bombay was launched four years later in 2014 by founder Karishma Mehta. It has since amassed some 3.2 million followers.

Like Humans of New York it accompanies portraits of “strangers” with quotes and stories with the stated aim of telling “inspirational and relatable stories of individuals from all walks of life”.

‘We tried to address the issue amicably’

MUMBAI, INDIA - MAY 3: (EDITOR’S NOTE: This is an exclusive shoot of Hindustan Times) Karishma Mehta, photographer, documentarian and founder of the Facebook page ‘Humans of Bombay’ that chronicles the stories of Mumbaikars during an exclusive interview with ht48hours-Hindustan Times, on May 3, 2016 in Mumbai, India. Karishma Mehta discovered the page in 2013, while studying economics and business in Nottingham, UK. Mehta has been walking the streets of Mumbai documenting stories of random stran
Image:
Karishma Mehta founded Humans of Bombay in 2014

In its lawsuit it is now alleging that People of India (POI) – another India-based storytelling account – has not only replicated its style, but has also been passing off its material as their own.

Responding to Mr Stanton’s accusation, Humans of Bombay said the lawsuit wasn’t just a matter of storytelling.

“We are grateful to HONY & Brandon for starting this storytelling movement. The suit is related to the IP in our posts & not about storytelling at all.

“We tried to address the issue amicably before approaching the court, as we believe in protecting our team’s hard work.”

A back and forth between the two on X, formerly known as Twitter, has since ensued, with Mr Stanton accusing Humans of Bombay of monetising his concept.

Claiming he hadn’t profited from a single story told on Humans of New York, he wrote “when art begins with a profit motive, it ceases to become art”.

He pointed people to the @HumansofAdam – a similar concept running in the Netherlands – as an example of a “true artist who had done beautiful things”.

A ‘cryptic assault on our efforts’

Once again Humans of Bombay hit back, this time accusing Stanton of “jumping the gun” in issuing a “cryptic assault on our efforts”.

Mr Stanton’s photoblog features stories from over 20 different countries. His portraits are also the subject of two bestselling books.

He is known for using his work to fundraise for some of the subjects he features.

In December 2013, he was named one of Time magazine’s “30 Under 30 People Changing The World”.

Continue Reading

US

Trump’s two-week timeline: What next for Iran?

Published

on

By

Trump's two-week timeline: What next for Iran?

👉 Follow Trump100 on your podcast app 👈

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt has said Donald Trump will make a decision on whether to militarily strike Iran in the next two weeks. That’s as diplomatic talks between Western governments and the Iranians ramp up.

In today’s episode, US correspondents Mark Stone and Martha Kelner unpick why the delay might be, and the competing voices in the ears of the president.

If you’ve got a question you’d like the Trump100 team to answer, you can email it to trump100@sky.uk.

Don’t forget, you can also watch all episodes on our YouTube channel.

Continue Reading

US

Trump’s update on Iran timeline is significant – but it still keeps everyone guessing

Published

on

By

Donald Trump weighing up many risks before possible US strike on Iran

This is the most significant statement from the US president in days, though it still keeps everyone guessing.

In a message conveyed through his press secretary, he is giving diplomacy up to two weeks to work.

“Based on the fact that there’s a substantial chance of negotiations that may or may not take place with Iran in the near future, I will make my decision whether or not to go within the next two weeks,” Karoline Leavitt quoted him as saying.

It is not clear what “whether or not to go” entails.

Israel-Iran conflict: Latest updates

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Trump: Iran ‘weeks away’ from nuclear weapon

We know that he has been given a spectrum of different military options by his generals and we know that the Israelis are pressuring him to use American B2 bombers with their bunker-busting bombs to destroy Iran’s nuclear facility at Fodow.

The Israelis are encouraging no delay. But against that, he is weighing up many risks, both military and political.

More on Donald Trump

Militarily, it is not clear how successful a bunker-busting strike on Fordow would be.

Experts have suggested it would require several of the massive bombs, which have never been used in combat before, to be dropped on the site.

It is not as simple as one clean strike and job done.

Politically, the president is under significant pressure domestically not to get involved in Iran.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

MAGA civil war breaks out over Iran

Within his own MAGA coalition – influencers, politicians and media personalities are lining up in criticism of involvement in the conflict.

One of those leading the criticism, his former chief strategist Steve Bannon, who maintains huge influence, was seen entering the White House on Thursday.

His press secretary reiterated to us that the president always wants to give diplomacy a chance and she confirmed that his Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff has spoken to the Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi.

Steve Bannon speaks at a conservative conference in Maryland earlier this month. Pic: AP
Image:
Steve Bannon, seen recently at a conservative event in Maryland, is against US involvement in Iran. Pic: AP

European leaders, including the UK foreign secretary David Lammy, who is in Washington, are meeting Mr Araghchi in Geneva on Friday.

The two-week window – assuming it lasts that long – also gives space to better prepare for any strike and mitigate against some of the other risks of US involvement.

Read more from Sky News:
Is Trump losing his MAGA support?
Gantz defends conflict with Iran
‘Love Trump’ says Israeli minister

There are 40,000 troops in bases across the Middle East. It takes time to increase security at these bases or to move non-essential personnel out. It also takes time to move strategic military assets into the region.

The USS Nimitz aircraft carrier and its support vessels were redeployed from the Indo-Pacific on Monday. Their last known position was the Strait of Malacca two days ago.

The Nimitz Carrier Group will overlap with the USS Carl Vinson group which was deployed to the Middle East in March.

The potential two-week window also allows for more time for a ‘day after’ plan, given that the Israeli strategy appears to be regime change from within.

Since the Israeli action in Iran began last week, the worst-case scenario of mass casualties in Israel from Iranian attacks has not materialised.

The president is said to be surprised and encouraged by this. “Israel has exceeded a lot of people’s expectations in their abilities,” press secretary Karoline Leavitt said.

The Israeli success, the absence of a mass casualty event in Israel, and the lack of any sustained counterattack by Iranian proxies in the region remove reservations that previous presidents have had about taking on Iran.

That said, sources have told Sky News that the president is determined that the diplomatic solution should be given a chance despite current pessimism over the chances of success.

A critical two weeks ahead.

Continue Reading

US

SpaceX rocket being tested explodes into giant fireball before launch in Texas

Published

on

By

SpaceX rocket being tested explodes into giant fireball before launch in Texas

A SpaceX rocket has exploded before launch – sending a dramatic fireball high into the sky.

Starship 36 was preparing for its 10th test flight at Starbase – SpaceX’s launch site at the southern tip of Texas – when the incident occurred on Wednesday evening.

During take off procedures just after 11pm local time, the rocket exploded into a giant fireball.

The company described the incident as a “major anomaly”.

A screenshot of the moment a SpaceX rocket Starship 36 exploded in Starbase, Texas. Pic: NASASpaceFlight
Image:
Starship 36 was preparing for its 10th test flight. Pic: NASASpaceFlight

A screenshot of the moment a SpaceX rocket Starship 36 exploded in Starbase, Texas. Pic: NASASpaceFlight
Image:
The test flight failed at Starbase – SpaceX’s launch site. Pic: NASASpaceFlight

In a statement, it added: “A safety clear area around the site was maintained throughout the operation and all personnel are safe and accounted for.

“Our Starbase team is actively working to safe the test site and the immediate surrounding area in conjunction with local officials.

“There are no hazards to residents in surrounding communities, and we ask that individuals do not attempt to approach the area while safing operations continue.”

Read more from Sky News:
Trump: I ‘may or may not’ strike Iran
Elon Musk posts ‘drug test results’

It marks the latest failure for the space flight company, which hopes that Starship will one day be used to ferry people and cargo to Mars.

Last month, a Starship test flight began spinning out of control about 30 minutes after its launch because of fuel leaks – meaning it broke up on re-entry into the Earth’s atmosphere.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

May: SpaceX rocket spins out of control

That followed explosive past failures in January, where a rocket blew up about eight minutes after take-off, and March, which forced flights in Florida to be temporarily grounded.

SpaceX CEO Elon Musk said in May that despite the rocket failure, the test flight was a “big improvement”.

A day later, he said he wants to send a spacecraft crewed by humanoid robots on a voyage to Mars by the end of 2026.

Continue Reading

Trending