Connect with us

Published

on

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe says former prime minister Liz Truss looked at her situation “from a different angle” because she was a mother.

Mrs Zaghari-Ratcliffe was freed from prison in Iran in March 2022 after six years.

There were five foreign secretaries during the course of her imprisonment – Philip Hammond, Boris Johnson, Jeremy Hunt, Dominic Raab and Liz Truss.

Mrs Zaghari-Ratcliffe is critical of the length of time it took the government to pay a £400m debt to Iran which helped secure her release.

Speaking to delegates at the Labour women’s conference in Liverpool today, she was asked by Shadow International Development Secretary Lisa Nandy “whether it’s significant that there was a long line of male foreign secretaries who didn’t secure your release, and then we had a female foreign secretary who within a few weeks had managed to do it?”

“I come from a country where women have almost no role in politics, I was a victim of that male led politics,” replied Ms Zaghari-Ratcliffe.

“The people who decided my future – apart from Liz Truss – were all men. I have a feeling that Liz Truss looked at my problem in a different way.

More from Politics

“Having said that we have got some very principled politicians – Jeremy Hunt was great, he was the one who gave me diplomatic protection, and who first acknowledged I was innocent. We also had Alastair Burt [a junior Foreign Office minister], who was an amazing politician.

“But then we had Liz Truss, she was a mother with two kids. Of course her decision was based on years of discussions and political communication, it didn’t happen all of a sudden – but I think she looked at my problem from a different angle that the male politicians hadn’t.”

She also said she regrets the tone she took with Ms Truss when she spoke to her on the phone before her release.

Read more:
Liz Truss told family of Morad Tahbaz he was not her ‘problem’ anymore
UK sanctions 30 more individuals and entities for corruption and human rights abuses

“I talked to Liz Truss in a very, very angry manner. She called me on my birthday three months before I came home, and I was not kind on the phone. But that’s because I’d had so much of ‘we’re doing all we can’ with the previous ministers that I felt this is the same thing. I felt bad after.”

Asked what it was that kept her going during her time in prison, Mrs Zaghari-Ratcliffe said it was the solidarity among female prisoners she lived with after being released from nine months in solitary confinement. She described how seeing women able to laugh and socialise who had been detained for much longer periods gave her strength to get through her ordeal.

“In prison, all of us were in it together,” she said. “All of us had 10 minutes of phone calls every other day, all of us had the same rations, all of us had to clean the ward. We had the same rights, we ate together, we cooked together, we sat together. We helped each other.

“Also – I have a young child, and she was the source of inspiration for me every day, and I had to be a sane strong mother for her.”

She also described finding out about the scale of the campaign to secure her release giving her “power and strength”.

Her nine-year old daughter Gabrielle and husband Richard Ratcliffe, who campaigned tirelessly for her release, sat watching in the auditorium.

Ms Zaghari-Ratcliffe also described Labour’s pledge to stand up for British nationals detained abroad protection as “very promising”.

“It’s very important to know you are going to be protected outside the borders of the UK,” argued Mrs Zaghari-Ratcliffe, who has campaigned for more to be done to secure the release of people unfairly detained overseas. “That will be a very huge step to avoid other incidents of unfair detention, torture and being taken as a hostage.

“Obviously governments want to do deals with other countries- they don’t want to upset any other governments, they want to trade with them. I didn’t feel I was protected. I felt they resisted protecting me in a very obvious way. The first time I had a trial they refused to come to the court, the second time…they refused again, on the grounds – they said – that if we come to the court with you, that will make your situation worse. How can you put me in more trouble? The worst is that they will put me in prison, but I was already in prison. This will hopefully stop people being let down the way I felt.

“Within six months of my detention it was very clear what should be done for me to get home. But it took the government five and a half years to do what they should have done in the first place. It took them two years to recognise my rights had been violated -whereas it took the UN six months to recognise I’d been unlawfully detained.”

Shadow Foreign Secretary David Lammy is due to announce his party’s plans for a special envoy for arbitrary detention and a new legal right for consular protection during his speech to the party’s conference in Liverpool on Monday, although the pledge to create the legal right for consular protection was originally made last year.

The party is aiming to replicate the success of the American Special Envoy for Hostage Affairs, Roger Carstens, who has been credited with a significant uptick in the number of unfairly detained US citizens released since his appointment in 2020.

“Too often the government’s efforts to secure the release of British nationals unjustly detained abroad have been arbitrary, haphazard, uncoordinated, lacking resource and lacking transparency,” Mr Lammy is due to say.

“The joy of having Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe among us this week is profound, but it’s also a sombre reminder of other Britons still awaiting justice.

“Labour’s pledge is simple. We will legislate for a new legal right to consular assistance and appoint a special envoy for Britons wrongly detained abroad. A Labour government will never forget that our first duty is to keep our own citizens safe.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Sir Keir Starmer has kicked off Labour’s Party conference in Liverpool.

A source close to the foreign secretary questioned the efficacy of Labour’s proposals.

“We provide consular assistance around the world 24/7 so it’s hard to see how these measures would improve that, bar words. A legal right would give no cover whatsoever in jurisdictions that didn’t and won’t recognise it. It’s a hollow promise.

“This government has secured the release of a number of British nationals from Governments that neither accept dual nationality, allow consular access or recognise British laws, and done so most often when the noise around such cases was least.

“Our officials work every single day on getting British nationals held abroad either consular access or release.”

In response to the Labour announcements a spokesperson for the Foreign Office said: [We] help British Nationals abroad affected by a range of circumstances.

In any given year, we support around 20,000 to 25,000 British nationals and their families.

“British nationals must follow the law in the country they visit and consult the travel advice so they are aware of the dangers present.

“Our travel advice is constantly updated to provide the most accurate information to British nationals overseas. While we will provide consular support when requested, we cannot change or overrule the local laws Brits will be subject to when travelling out of the UK.”

Continue Reading

Politics

Homelessness minister Rushanara Ali resigns after ‘extortionate’ rent hike claims

Published

on

By

Homelessness minister Rushanara Ali resigns after 'extortionate' rent hike claims

Homelessness minister Rushanara Ali has resigned after reportedly hiking the rent on a property she owns by hundreds of pounds – something described by one of her tenants as “extortion”.

That was just weeks after the previous tenants’ contract ended, The i Paper said.

Four tenants who rented a house in east London from Ms Ali were sent an email last November saying their lease would not be renewed, and which also gave them four months’ notice to leave, the newspaper reported.

The property was then re-listed with a £700 rent increase within weeks, the publication added.

In a letter to the prime minister, Ms Ali said that remaining in her role would be a “distraction from the ambitious work of this government”.

She added: “Further to recent reporting, I wanted to make it clear that at all times I have followed all relevant legal requirements.

“I believe I took my responsibilities and duties seriously, and the facts demonstrate this.”

Laura Jackson, one of Ms Ali’s former tenants, said she and three others collectively paid £3,300 in rent.

Weeks after she and her fellow tenants had left, the self-employed restaurant owner said she saw the house re-listed with a rent of around £4,000.

“It’s an absolute joke,” she said. “Trying to get that much money from renters is extortion.”

Sir Keir Starmer said Ms Ali's work in government would leave a 'lasting legacy'. Pic: PA
Image:
Sir Keir Starmer said Ms Ali’s work in government would leave a ‘lasting legacy’. Pic: PA

Ms Ali’s house, rented on a fixed-term contract, was put up for sale while the tenants were living there, and was only relisted as a rental because it had not sold, according to The i Paper.

The government’s Renters’ Rights Bill includes measures to ban landlords who end a tenancy to sell a property from re-listing it for six months.

The Bill, which is nearing its end stages of scrutiny in Parliament, will also abolish fixed-term tenancies and ensure landlords give four months’ notice if they want to sell their property.

Something Sir Keir’s increasingly unpopular government could have done without


Jon Craig - Chief political correspondent

Jon Craig

Chief political correspondent

@joncraig

Rushanara Ali’s swift and humiliating demise is a classic example of paying the price for the politician’s crime of “Do as I say, not as I do”.

She was Labour’s minister for homelessness, for goodness’ sake, yet she ejected tenants from her near-£1m town house then hiked the rent.

A more egregious case of ministerial double standards it would be difficult to imagine. She had to go and was no doubt told by 10 Downing Street to go quickly.

MP for the East End constituency of Bethnal Green and Stepney, Ms Ali was the very model of a modern Labour minister: a degree in PPE from Oxford University.

In her resignation letter to Sir Keir Starmer, she said she is quitting “with a heavy heart”. Really? She presumably didn’t have a heavy heart when she ejected her four tenants.

She’d previously spoken out against “private renters being exploited” and said the government would “empower people to challenge unreasonable rent increases”.

She was charging her four former tenants £3,300 a month. Yet after they moved out, she charged her new tenants £4,000, a rent increase of more than 20%.

In an area represented by the left-wing firebrand George Galloway from 2005 to 2010, Ms Ali had a majority of under 1,700 at the election last year.

Ominously for Labour, an independent candidate was second and the Greens third. No doubt Jeremy Corbyn’s new party will also stand next time.

In her resignation letter to the PM, Ms Ali said continuing in her ministerial role would be a distraction. Too right.

A distraction Sir Keir and his increasingly unpopular government could have done without.

Responding to her resignation, shadow housing secretary Sir James Cleverly said: “I said that her actions were total hypocrisy and that she should go if the accusations were shown to be true.”

A Liberal Democrat spokesperson said: “Rushanara Ali fundamentally misunderstood her role. Her job was to tackle homelessness, not to increase it.”

Read more:
First migrants detained under returns deal with France
Tropical Storm Dexter to bring potential heatwave next week

Previously, a spokesperson for Ms Ali said the tenants “stayed for the entirety of their fixed term contract, and were informed they could stay beyond the expiration of the fixed term, while the property remained on the market, but this was not taken up, and they decided to leave the property”.

The prime minister thanked Ms Ali for her “diligent work” and for helping to “deliver this government’s ambitious agenda”.

Sir Keir Starmer said her work in putting in measures to repeal the Vagrancy Act would have a “significant impact”.

And he said she had been trying to encourage “more people to engage and participate in our democracy”, something that would leave a “lasting legacy”.

Continue Reading

Politics

Rushanara Ali: Humiliating demise for Labour minister after a most egregious case of double standards

Published

on

By

Rushanara Ali: Humiliating demise for Labour minister after a most egregious case of double standards

Rushanara Ali’s swift and humiliating demise is a classic example of paying the price for the politician’s crime of “do as I say, not as I do”.

She was Labour’s minister for homelessness, for goodness’ sake, yet she ejected tenants from her near-£1m town house and then hiked the rent.

Politics Hub: Minister’s resignation as it happened

A more egregious case of ministerial double standards it would be difficult to imagine. She had to go and was no doubt told by 10 Downing Street to go quickly.

Rushanara Ali reportedly hiked the rent on a property she owns. Pic: PA
Image:
Rushanara Ali reportedly hiked the rent on a property she owns. Pic: PA

‘A heavy heart’ – really?

MP for the East End constituency of Bethnal Green and Stepney, Ms Ali was the very model of a modern Labour minister: A degree in PPE from Oxford University.

In her resignation letter to Sir Keir Starmer, she said she is quitting “with a heavy heart”. Really? She presumably didn’t have a heavy heart when she ejected her four tenants.

She’d previously spoken out against “private renters being exploited” and said her government would “empower people to challenge unreasonable rent increases”.

The now former minister was charging her four former tenants £3,300 a month. Yet after they moved out, she charged her new tenants £4,000 – a rent increase of more than 20%.

Read more politics news:
Fact-checking Farage’s claims
Why chancellor has little to cheer

The report about the Labour MP first emerged in the i newspaper. Pic: UK Parliament
Image:
The report about the Labour MP first emerged in the i newspaper. Pic: UK Parliament

A fragile constituency for Labour?

In an area represented by the left-wing firebrand George Galloway from 2005 to 2010, Ms Ali had a majority of under 1,700 at the election last year.

Ominously for Labour, an independent candidate was second and the Greens third. No doubt Jeremy Corbyn’s new party will also stand next time.

In her resignation letter to the PM, Ms Ali said continuing in her ministerial role would be a distraction. Too right.

A distraction Sir Keir and his increasingly unpopular government could have done without.

Continue Reading

Politics

Trump picks top economic adviser to temporarily fill crucial US Fed seat

Published

on

By

Trump picks top economic adviser to temporarily fill crucial US Fed seat

Trump picks top economic adviser to temporarily fill crucial US Fed seat

Federal Reserve Board of Governors member Adriana Kugler announced her resignation on Aug. 1, paving the way for a Trump nominee at the US central bank.

Continue Reading

Trending