Connect with us

Published

on

The leader of Burnley Council and 10 other councillors have resigned from the Labour Party over Sir Keir Starmer’s decision not to push for a ceasefire in Gaza, Sky News understands.

Afrasiab Anwar, who has been in the party for 10 years, said it had been a “really difficult decision” to leave Labour.

He was among those calling for Sir Keir to step down on Thursday.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

‘Is ceasefire issue tearing Labour apart?’

The 11 councillors described their memberships as “untenable” given the leadership’s refusal to demand a ceasefire in the Middle East.

In a statement, they said Sir Keir had indicated he “does not value the voice of the grassroots of the party” – citing remarks the opposition leader made following a speech on Friday in the North East.

Sir Keir, who has come under internal pressure for Labour to demand a cessation of hostilities, told reporters his focus was on stopping the suffering in Gaza, not on the “individual positions” of party members.

Labour has backed the UK government’s stance of calling for a pause in the fighting to allow humanitarian aid and medical treatments to reach Palestinians in Gaza.

Analysis: Sir Keir’s attempts to draw a line under the ceasefire row are backfiring


Amanda Akass is a politics and business correspondent

Amanda Akass

Political correspondent

@amandaakass

Sir Keir Starmer has spent weeks trying to downplay his party’s divisions over the question of a ceasefire in Gaza – but the row continues to escalate.

On Friday he claimed Labour was “united” on the issue because everyone is motivated by the same desire to alleviate human suffering there – and that he just isn’t concerned about the individual positions of party members.

But this attempt to paper over the cracks with optimistic descriptions just isn’t cutting it with many of those members, who feel he’s just not listening.

Now the leader of Burnley Council, one of two Labour council leaders who called on Sir Keir to resign over the issue last week, has himself announced he’s stepping down from the party, along with 10 other councillors.

Cllr Afrasiab Anwar claims the views of grassroots members are being ignored. Some in the party are worried about the kind of exodus of Muslim support seen in the wake of the Iraq war.

It brings the number of councillors to have resigned from Labour to 50 – alongside the many big names who have overstepped the party line in calling for a ceasefire, including the mayors Sadiq Khan, Andy Burnham and the Scottish Labour Leader Anas Sarwar.

Last week Sir Keir attempted to draw a line under the row with a big speech and a number of interviews clarifying his position, arguing that he shares people’s “human emotion” in response to what’s happening, but that humanitarian pauses are the most practical way to alleviate the suffering of the people of Gaza.

He pointed out that demanding a ceasefire would negate Israel’s right to defend itself – both positions which are in line with the government.

He’s hoping the wider electorate will sympathise with his arguments and the desire to stand up for Israel after the horrors of 7 October, particularly given the antisemitism allegations which have haunted his party in the past.

The big risk for him is if this rebellion amongst councillors spreads to the parliamentary party.

There’s talk of left wing MPs attempting to force a vote on the issue this week, perhaps in league with the SNP, to expose the scale of opposition to his position.

Many MPs are under real pressure from their constituents – loyal shadow leader of the Commons Lucy Powell told Sky’s Kay Burley this morning she’s had protests outside her office and it’s “a difficult one for all of us to look at”.

The real challenge to Sir Keir’s leadership would be if any of those shadow frontbenchers who’ve publicly defied the party line and called for a ceasefire decide to take it further – and step down.

However, Mr Anwar said the position was “nonsensical” and did not capture the strength of feeling in his Lancashire town, along with communities elsewhere in Britain, about the war.

“We just can’t stand by watching and being part of a party that is not speaking out, or at the very least calling for a ceasefire,” Mr Anwar said.

“Instead of talking of peace – all of our world leaders, including the leader of the Labour Party, are talking about humanitarian pauses. It’s just nonsensical.

“I just don’t think the message is getting through in terms of how our communities, right across the board, are feeling about this.”

He said the group had tried “everything we could by working within the party”.

Mr Anwar added he wanted Labour to “come back to its core values of fighting for social justice”.

Analysis: Starmer’s attempts to draw a line under Gaza ceasefire row ‘aren’t cutting it’

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Protesters shut down central London

In a statement on Sunday, the group said: “It has become apparent that Keir Starmer and the leadership either cannot or will not heed our concerns or acknowledge the sentiments within our communities.”

It added: “In response to our calls for him to resign he responded that the individual concerns of members are not his focus, further illustrating that he does not value the voice of the grassroots of the party.”

The leader of Pendle Council, which is also in Lancashire, also called on Sir Keir to resign on Thursday.

It came after senior Labour figures also broke ranks to challenge Sir Keir’s stance – including London mayor Sadiq Khan, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar, and Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham.

Read more:
Sue Gray’s baptism of fire trying to fix Starmer’s ceasefire crisis
Labour rebels try to secure divisive Commons vote on Gaza

A Labour spokesman said: “Labour fully understands calls for a ceasefire.

“Everybody wants to see an end to this cycle of violence and suffering, we need to see hostages released and aid getting to those most in need.

“But a ceasefire now will only freeze this conflict and would leave hostages in Gaza and Hamas with the infrastructure and capability to carry out the sort of attack we saw on October 7.

“International law must be followed at all times and innocent civilians must be protected.

“Labour is calling for humanitarian pauses in the fighting.

“This is the best and most realistic way to address the humanitarian emergency in Gaza and is a position shared by our major allies, in the US and the EU.”

Continue Reading

Politics

PM won’t discipline chancellor despite ‘regrettable’ email oversight in rental licence row

Published

on

By

PM won't discipline chancellor despite 'regrettable' email oversight in rental licence row

Sir Keir Starmer has said Rachel Reeves will face no further action over her “inadvertent failure” to obtain a rental licence for her south London home.

The chancellor had come under pressure to explain whether she had broken housing law by not getting the licence for the property when she moved into Number 11 Downing Street last year.

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch called for her to resign or be sacked.

But in a letter published on Thursday night, the prime minister said correspondence shared by Ms Reeves shows her husband had been assured by the couple’s estate agents “that they would apply for a licence on his behalf”.

Sir Keir said it was “regrettable” he had not been made aware of the correspondence sooner, with an initial letter the chancellor sent him on Wednesday having suggested she was “not aware that a licence was necessary”.

A second letter from Ms Reeves on Thursday informed the prime minister that she had found correspondence between the letting agent and her husband about applying for the licence on their behalf.

Sir Keir said in his reply: “I understand that the relevant emails were only unearthed by your husband this morning, and that you have updated me as soon as possible.”

More on Rachel Reeves

The PM labelled the incident “an inadvertent failure” and said he sees “no need” for further action.

Lettings agency apologises

Number 10 also published advice given to the PM by his independent ethics adviser, Sir Laurie Magnus, saying he’d found “no evidence of bad faith”.

The owner of lettings agency Harvey and Wheeler has released an apology to the chancellor.

Gareth Martin confirmed a member of his staff said they would apply for the licence – but this was never done, as the person “suddenly resigned” prior to the start of the tenancy.

He said: “We deeply regret the issue caused to our clients as they would have been under the impression that a licence had been applied for.”

Read more:
Badenoch hacking ‘not the same’ as Reeves ‘law break’

Sam Coates: Rental row raises questions that cut deeper

The housing row had loomed over Rachel Reeves. Pic: PA
Image:
The housing row had loomed over Rachel Reeves. Pic: PA

Ms Reeves had immediately faced calls to leave her post after a report in the Daily Mail, which saw her admit to mistakenly breaching local council housing rules by failing to secure the licence.

The newspaper reported Ms Reeves had failed to pay for a “selective” licence when renting out her family home in Dulwich, south London, which she has left while living in Downing Street as chancellor.

The Housing Act 2004 gives councils the power to make landlords accredit themselves in certain areas.

What are rental licensing laws?

Under the Housing Act 2004, introduced by Labour, councils can decide to introduce selective licensing, where residential landlords in specified areas must have a licence.

Landlords must adhere to certain requirements to obtain a licence, including gas certificates, working carbon monoxide alarms and fire safety regulations for furnishings.

They must secure a licence within 28 days of renting out a home.

Southwark Council, where Rachel Reeves’ house is, charges £900 for a licence, which lasts five years.

Failure to secure a selective licence can result in a penalty of up to £30,000 or an unlimited fine from a court upon conviction.

Landlords can also be made to repay up to 12 months’ rent to the tenant or they can be prevented from renting out the property.

Serious and repeat offenders can be prosecuted, with a sentence of up to five years or an uncapped fine, and they can be put on a rogue landlords database.

Ms Reeves has apologised over the incident, and for the delay in clarifying what advice her husband had received from the estate agent.

“I am sorry about this matter and accept full responsibility for it,” she told the PM.

Number 10 has consistently backed Ms Reeves ahead of her delivering the budget on 26 November.

Continue Reading

Politics

Government warned against ‘deplorable’ budget strategy

Published

on

By

Government warned against 'deplorable' budget strategy

The government hinting at a rise in income tax at the budget only to not go through with it in a bid to win over voters would be “deplorable”, according to Labour peer Harriet Harman.

Reports are swirling that the chancellor is considering a manifesto-breaking hike when she delivers her crucial fiscal statement next month – and Sir Keir Starmer failed to rule it out at PMQs this week.

The Daily Telegraph says Rachel Reeves is considering a proposal by the Resolution Foundation think tank to cut national insurance by 2p and add it to income tax – protecting workers while hitting pensioners and landlords.

But Baroness Harman warned ministers against “manipulative” briefing to the media ahead of the budget, as the constant speculation “will only make people anxious”.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Could Labour break its manifesto in the budget?

She told Sky’s political editor Beth Rigby on the Electoral Dysfunction podcast that it would be the “worst sort of briefing and political games playing”.

“I hope they’re not seeding the idea there’s going to be an increase in income tax announced at the budget so they can get credit for not announcing it, because I just think that’s manipulative of public opinion,” she said.

Baroness Harman added: “If they’re thinking about it, that’s one thing – but if they’re putting it out when they actually know they’re not going to do it, I just think that’s deplorable.”

👉Tap here to listen to Electoral Dysfunction on your podcast app 👈

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Ex-Bank governor warns of tough budget

Baroness Harman said Ms Reeves has three options to deal with the gap in the public finances: cutting spending, increasing borrowing or raising tax revenue.

She said spending cuts are problematic as departments like health, education, transport, and councils need more investment – and will likely be voted down by Labour MPs.

Increasing borrowing would mean paying more interest, she said, and that would risk being seen as breaching a manifesto commitment on the chancellor’s fiscal rules.

Read more:
What tax rises could Reeves announce?

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The ‘problem’ Rachel Reeves faces

Raising income tax, national insurance or VAT would also breach the manifesto, which Baroness Harman said would raise questions about everything Labour said had promised.

“What does it mean about what you meant at the time?” she said.

“Did you not mean it at the time? Were you just saying it to get people’s votes, or did you say it unwisely because you didn’t realise what your scope was going to be?

“Either is really bad.”

Ms Reeves will deliver the budget on 26 November.

Continue Reading

Politics

‘Manufactured panic’: Immigration not near top of most people’s concerns, poll suggests

Published

on

By

'Manufactured panic': Immigration not near top of most people's concerns, poll suggests

Only a quarter of people think immigration is an important issue locally – and concern about it is “a manufactured panic,” it has been claimed.

A YouGov poll found only 26% of people said immigration and asylum was one of the three most important issues facing their community.

This was half the 52% who said it was one of the biggest problems facing the country as a whole, and put immigration seventh on the list of important local problems behind issues like cost of living, health, crime, and housing.

Saeema Syeda, of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI), said the poll “proves what we’ve been saying all along – there is no immigration crisis”.

She said: “It’s a manufactured panic, pushed by some politicians and parts of the media to distract from what actually matters to people.

“Across our communities, we share the same priorities – making ends meet, accessing healthcare, decent schools and secure homes. We need to end scapegoating and look for solutions.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Have billions been wasted on housing migrants?

The poll, which was commissioned by campaign group Best for Britain, found the cost of living was the top issue for people both nationally and locally.

But while immigration was the second most important issue for people nationally, health was ranked second locally, followed by the economy, crime, housing, and jobs.

Read more:
Huge rise in immigration raids on salons and takeaways
Military barracks used to house asylum seekers

Among those who voted Labour at the last general election, 56% of people mentioned the cost of living as a major national issue and 39% mentioned the economy, compared with 34% who said immigration was a major problem.

Best for Britain said the findings showed that “for most people, including those vital to Labour’s electoral coalition, concerns around immigration are not based on personal experience”.

The YouGov poll surveyed 4,368 British adults between September 5 and 10.

Continue Reading

Trending