Robert De Niro’s company has been ordered to pay more than $1.2m (£982,000) to his former personal assistant after it was found to have engaged in gender discrimination and retaliation – but a jury found the star was not personally liable for the abuse.
A judge ordered De Niro’s company, Canal Productions, to make two payments of $632,143 to his long-time personal assistant Graham Chase Robinson.
De Niro, 80, who spent three days at the two-week trial, including two in the witness box, has been ensnared in duelling lawsuits with Ms Robinson since she quit in April 2019.
Image: De Niro arrives at court. Pic: AP
Ms Robinson, 41, said De Niro and his girlfriend Tiffany Chen teamed up against her to turn a job she once loved into a nightmare.
De Niro and Ms Chen each said during evidence that Ms Robinson became the problem when her aspirations to move beyond Canal Productions led her to make escalating demands to remain in the job.
In two days in the witness box the actor told jurors he boosted Ms Robinson’s salary from less than $100,000 (£82,000) annually to $300,000 (£245,000) and elevated her title to vice president of production and finance at her request – despite her responsibilities remaining largely the same.
De Niro said when she quit Ms Robinson stole about $85,000 (£70,000) in airline miles from him, betrayed his trust and violated his unwritten rules to use common sense and always do the right thing.
At times De Niro acknowledged from the witness box many of the claims Ms Robinson made to support her $12m (£10m) gender discrimination and retaliation lawsuit.
He agreed he had asked her to scratch his back on at least two occasions, dismissing a question about it with: “Ok, twice? You got me!”
Advertisement
He admitted he had berated her, though he disputed ever aiming a profanity her way, saying: “I was never abusive, ever.”
He also denied ever yelling at her, saying every little thing she was trying to catch him with was nonsense and that, at most, he had raised his voice in her presence but never with disrespect.
Then, he looked at her sitting between her lawyers in the courtroom and shouted: “Shame on you, Chase Robinson!”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:35
April 2022: De Niro on political ‘big untruths’
‘Emotional and mental breakdown’
Ms Robinson said she quit her job during an “emotional and mental breakdown” that left her overwhelmed and feeling like she had “hit rock bottom”.
She said she has since suffered from anxiety and depression and has not worked in four years despite applying for 638 jobs.
“I don’t have a social life,” she said. “I’m so humiliated and embarrassed and feel so judged. I feel so damaged in a way. … I lost my life. Lost my career. Lost my financial independence. I lost everything.”
‘Acivil rights trial’
De Niro’s lawyers sued Ms Robinson for breach of loyalty and fiduciary duty even before her lawsuit was filed against him in 2019.
They sought $6m (£5m) in damages, including a return of the five million airline miles.
In a closing argument on Wednesday, De Niro’s lawyer Richard Schoenstein said the miles that were taken were worth about $85,000. He said jurors could order Ms Robinson to return some of her salary, but, he added: “We’re not looking for you to punish her.”
In his closing, Ms Robinson’s lawyer Brent Hannafan called the two weeks of court proceedings a civil rights trial and urged jurors to return a verdict “not just for Ms Robinson, but for all civil rights litigants”.
De Niro has won two Oscars and is currently starring in the Martin Scorsese film Killers Of The Flower Moon.
US president Donald Trump told Fox News the suspect was in custody on Friday, adding “somebody that was very close to him turned him in”.
Officials have now revealed further details about the suspect, including what a family member said about him and messages he sent a friend about his alleged plot.
Here’s what we know about the suspect so far:
How was the suspect caught?
Mr Trump told Fox News that a person “very close” with the suspect went to “the father”, who then went to a US Marshal.
“The father convinced the son,” he said, adding that they then “drove into the police headquarters, and he’s there now”.
He added that he may need to be corrected and that he was “talking based on what I’m hearing”.
In a news conference later, Utah Governor Spencer Cox said a member of Robinson’s family reached out to a family friend, who then contacted the Washington County Sheriff’s Office with information that Robinson “had confessed to them or implied that he had committed the incident”.
NBC news reports that the family member is his father – and that the father then went to a church minister he knew, who contacted a local sheriff.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:55
Utah Governor: ‘We got him’
He said the family member told the FBI that Robinson “had become more political in recent years” and that, at a dinner prior to the shooting, he had mentioned Mr Kirk’s upcoming visit to Utah Valley University.
Mr Cox said they had “talked about why they didn’t like him and the viewpoints that he had” and that “the family member also stated Kirk was full of hate and spreading hate”.
He went on to say that messages between Tyler Robinson and his roommate revealed details about the alleged plot.
“The content of these messages included messages affiliated with the contact ‘Tyler’ stating a need to retrieve a rifle from a drop point, leaving the rifle in a bush, messages related to visually watching the area where a rifle was left, and a message referring to having left the rifle wrapped in a towel,” he said.
Image: Where the shooting took place and where Tyler Robinson was eventually arrested
Mr Cox added that there was no evidence to suggest anyone else was involved, but that the investigation was ongoing.
He said the suspect was taken into custody in Washington County, in southern Utah, around a three to four hour drive from Orem, where his family lived.
Pictures and footage released by the FBI
Image: Photos released of the suspect. Pic: Utah Public Safety
Mr Cox also said that the suspect changed clothes on campus.
He said footage “first spotted” him with one outfit on, which he allegedly changed while on the roof of one building.
Mr Cox said he then “changed back into that clothing at some point” – meaning the first outfit.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
2:19
Moment suspect flees after Charlie Kirk shooting
All this meant, the governor said, that when he was arrested, the suspect was wearing the same clothes he had on before the shooting.
Earlier, Mr Trump had said the suspect was “28 or 29”, but caveated that his facts were “subject to be corrected” and “based on what I’m hearing”.
Before news of his capture came in, the FBI had released images of a “person of interest” in the shooting, later revealed to be Robinson, showing him wearing a hat, sunglasses, and a backpack.
They also released video footage of him fleeing after the incident, where he could be seen walking on the roof of the building from where the fatal shot was fired.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:33
Suspected Charlie Kirk shooter seen on roof
He was then seen climbing down and heading toward a wooded area, where police say he abandoned his rifle.
The first description of the suspect came from a police officer on her radio shortly after the shooting, who said he was “wearing jeans, black shirt, black mask, long rifle”.
Beau Mason, commissioner of the Department of Public Safety, later said he “appears to be of college age” and that he “blended in well with a college institution”.
What else do we know about Robinson?
Sky News have now verified what appear to be school records posted in 2020 by his mother which show a 4.0 average – a very high score, akin to straight As in the UK.
“This boy is a genius,” she added.
Robinson expected to be charged with aggravated murder
The suspect is expected to be charged with aggravated murder, felony discharge of a firearm causing serious bodily injury and obstruction of justice, according to a probable cause affidavit.
The offences are all state charges.
Mr Cox said that under Utah law, they have three days to file charging documents, and that it should come “early next week.”
Utah officials previously said they were going to seek the death penalty for Charlie Kirk’s suspected shooter.
What weapon did the shooter use?
The weapon was found after the shooting in a wooded area where the shooter had fled, according to FBI agent Robert Bohls.
He described the gun as a “high-powered bolt action rifle”.
Investigators collected a footwear impression, a palm print, and forearm imprints for analysis.
Firearms consultant David Dyson told Sky News that, based on the range from where they are believed to have fired, the gunman would likely need to be a somewhat skilled target shooter.
But he suggested that while the shot may be difficult for anyone without experience, it’s “not a great range” for someone with practice.
Charlie Kirk – the leading youth right-wing influencer is assassinated while giving a talk at a university. The assassin is still on the run. James Matthews is in Utah at the scene of the crime.
And Lord Mandelson, the ambassador to the US, is given his marching orders. Less than 24 hours after the PM backed him, he sacked him. What next?
Chaos broke out at Utah Valley University when prominent right-wing influencer Charlie Kirk was shot dead in front of thousands of people.
Mr Kirk, 31, was speaking to students about mass shootings on Wednesday when he was shot in the neck, leading students to flee and a manhunt for the killer beginning.
Many questions remain, with differing accounts and multiple videos across social media.
The Sky News Data and Forensic team has tracked and mapped the events before, during and after the killing to find out as much as possible about what happened.
When and where did the shooting happen?
Mr Kirk was speaking to around 3,000 people from under a small white tent on the campus when he was shot.
The event was part of his “prove me wrong” series, which saw the right-wing influencer visit campuses across the country and debate contentious subjects like gun control, free speech, LGBTQ+ rights and abortion rights with left-wing students.
The event began at roughly 12pm local time.
Mr Kirk was taking questions about mass shootings and gun violence when, at roughly 12.20pm, he was shot.
It was a single shot that struck him in the neck, a university spokesman confirmed.
Image: Charlie Kirk at a university event before he was fatally shot. Pic: Reuters/Trent Nelson/The Salt Lake Tribune
Madison Lattin, who was standing only a few dozen feet to the left of Mr Kirk when he was shot, said: “Blood is falling and dripping down, and you’re just like so scared, not just for him but your own safety.”
Footage from the scene showed Mr Kirk being carried away within seconds of the shooting.
Where did the shot come from?
In a statement on Thursday, the FBI said they had tracked the gunman’s movements onto the campus, “through the stairwells, up to the roof, across the roof, to a shooting location”.
They said they first tracked his movements from 11.52am, when they said he arrived on campus.
Videos from the event show the gunman was on top of the Losee Centre building – just over 130m away from where Kirk was speaking, according to an online measuring tool.
Two videos show a figure on the roof before and immediately after a shot is fired.
The first video shows what appears to be someone lying down. The person filming says “he just ran from over there” – pointing in the direction of a stairwell coming up the roof.
The second video is filmed in the moments after the shot is fired. You see a silhouette that appears to stand and move away from the roof’s edge.
Using videos taken near the stage, Sky News was able to confirm that this position has a direct line of sight to where Kirk was sitting at the time of the attack.
Audio analyst Rob Maher has estimated the distance the shot travelled, reaching a similar conclusion to Sky News’ analysis.
“The time gap between the crack sound and the pop sound in the recordings close to the podium is about 240 milliseconds,” he told Sky News.
“Since the exact trajectory of the bullet and the bullet’s speed is not known, I have to make an assumption that the bullet speed was likely about 800 meters per second. With that assumption, the time gap indicates that the firearm was likely about 140m from the podium”.
Image: Pic: Rob Maher
What weapon was used?
The weapon suspected of being used in the shooting has been found, according to FBI agent Robert Bohls, who told a news briefing in Orem, Utah, that it was a “high-powered, bolt-action rifle”.
“That rifle was recovered in a wooded area where the shooter had fled,” he said. “The FBI laboratory will be analysing this weapon.”
Mr Bohls added that they also found an “impression of a palm print and forearm imprints for analysis”; however the shooter remained at large.
Firearms consultant David Dyson told Sky News that, based on the range from where they are believed to have fired, the gunman would likely need to be a somewhat skilled target shooter.
But he suggested that while the shot may be difficult for anyone without experience, it’s “not a great range” for someone with practice.
“There’s target disciplines, for instance, [at] 800m. So you can shoot quite accurately at far greater distances than 150 yards,” he said.
“If we’re in that sort of ballpark, then you’re not looking at somebody with phenomenal skill,” he added.
What do we know about the shooter?
A manhunt is under way for the killer, which began on the university campus but has now extended beyond.
Police radio recordings show the first mention of the incident at 12.26pm, about six minutes after the shooting occurred.
Officers were on the scene within minutes, with one officer describing the suspect at 12.35pm as “wearing jeans, black shirt, black mask, long rifle”.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:17
Audio recording of police response after Charlie Kirk shot
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:56
Police audio after the incident
By 12.58pm, 32 mins after the shooting, armed officers could be seen checking the perimeter of the Losee building.
In an update on Thursday, authorities offered a few more details about the shooter, who they referred to as a male.
Beau Mason, commissioner of the Department of Public Safety, said he “appears to be of college age” and that he “blended in well with a college institution”.
The authorities added they were “doing everything we can to find him” but that “we’re not sure how far he has gone yet”.
Image: The person of interest the FBI is looking for. Pics: FBI Salt Lake City/X
The FBI later released images of a “person of interest” in the shooting.
Two people were arrested after the shooting, but neither was determined to have any connection with the shooting and were later released.
What sort of security was on site?
Witnesses have spoken about a supposed lack of security checkpoints, with people being able to walk into the event with backpacks without being searched.
“Anybody in the world could park anywhere around the university and walk right in,” one witness told Sky News affiliate NBC news.
The UVU website states that “generally, anyone is allowed to enter areas that are open to the public” but non-public areas are restricted by “access cards, locked doors, or monitored entryways”.
A 2012 drone video shows the area around the shooter’s location on the 4th floor. A metal railing encloses an accessible balcony area which means that to reach the roof where the shot was taken, they could have climbed or jumped over the railing.
Image: Pic: Eric Fowkes
Extra security measures were put in place for the event. UVU Police Chief Jeff Long said six police officers were there as well as plainclothes police officers in the crowd.
Chief Long confirmed that Mr Kirk also had a security team, which travels with him, and said he coordinated with Mr Kirk’s lead security officer.
Analysis of the videos from the event show at least four men, who appear to be Kirk’s security team, surrounding the stage.
“We train for these things, and you think you have these things covered,” Chief Jeff Long said in his statement last night.
“You try to get your bases covered and unfortunately today we didn’t”.
The Data and Forensics team is a multi-skilled unit dedicated to providing transparent journalism from Sky News. We gather, analyse and visualise data to tell data-driven stories. We combine traditional reporting skills with advanced analysis of satellite images, social media and other open source information. Through multimedia storytelling we aim to better explain the world while also showing how our journalism is done.