Autumn statement: Public have ‘duty’ to work, says minister – as benefits shake-up looms

Published

2 years ago

November 21, 2023

admin

There is a “duty on citizens” to work if they are able to, a government minister has said.

Chief secretary to the Treasury, Laura Trott, told Sky News the Conservatives believe “if you can work, as a principle, you should work”, saying the tenet is “the thrust of all our policies”.

Her remarks came ahead of the autumn statement on Wednesday, where the government is expected to announce plans to force those with mental health or mobility problems to find work they can do from home, or risk losing their welfare payments.

Government sources have told Sky News there is a concern a large number of people are currently “written off” and there will be measures in the speech to address that.

Politics live: Whitty to face questions at COVID inquiry

Chancellor Jeremy Hunt is said to be considering a big squeeze on benefits in order to make savings for the public purse.

Over the weekend, he said ministers needed to “take difficult decisions to reform the welfare state”, and he has not ruled out a change in the way the government increases benefits – perhaps using October’s lower inflation figure of 4.6% for the rise, rather than September’s higher number of 6.7%.

Economists said this would equate to a £3bn spending cut, largely impacting households receiving means-tested or disability benefits.

Charities and opposition MPs have appealed to the government not to make the move, saying it would hit the poorest hardest as the cost of living crisis continues to bite.

Currently, around two million working age people are not employed – something Rishi Sunak dubbed a “national scandal” on Monday, claiming it was “not sustainable for the country”.

Asked by Sky News’ Kay Burley if the reports around the welfare shake-up were “uncaring”, Ms Trott said: “I think that if you can work, as a principle, you should work, and that is what the government believes, that’s been the thrust of all of our policies.

“Of course, there should be support for people to help them into work or to help them with issues that they’re facing.

“But ultimately there is a duty on citizens that if they are able to go out to work, that’s what they should do.”

She added that the Department for Work and Pensions – where she was formally a minister was “working very hard to make sure our welfare system is supporting those who need support”.

But, she said: “Those who can work, can contribute, should contribute. And that is the principle that we must keep throughout all of this.”

Shadow work and pensions secretary, Liz Kendall, told Sky News said she was a “big supporter of flexible working and working from home”.

But she blamed the government’s lack of support for those with disabilities and mental health conditions for the number of those out of work.

Ms Kendall said: “It’s very interesting to see Rishi Sunak railing against the fact millions of people are out of work due to long-term sickness, saying it’s a scandal they’ve been written off. Well, who’s done that?”

The Labour MP added: “What those people want is access to the talking therapies they need to deal with anxiety and depression.

“They need adaptations at work or at home if they have a disability, and we are seeing huge waits for people to get adaptations – both at home and in the work place.

“We strongly believe in work. But the government has failed to achieve that and instead of railing against the problems that they themselves have created, we need to see a proper plan.”

Politics

Labour dealt historic loss in Caerphilly by-election – as Plaid Cymru win seat

Published

1 hour ago

October 24, 2025

admin

Labour dealt historic loss in Caerphilly by-election - as Plaid Cymru win seat

Plaid Cymru have won the by-election in the Senedd seat of Caerphilly for the first time.

The Welsh nationalist party secured 15,960 votes – and candidate Lindsay Whittle cried as the result was announced.

Mr Whittle is 72 years old and had stood as a Plaid candidate 13 times since 1983. He will now hold the seat until the Senedd elections next year.

This by-election was widely regarded as a two-horse race between Plaid Cymru and Reform UK, and the result marks a considerable blow for Nigel Farage.

Analysis: Reform candidate looked neglected and dejected

Jon Craig

Chief political correspondent

@joncraig

In a by-election in the birthplace of the comedian Tommy Cooper, it was Plaid Cymru that had the last laugh.

During the campaign, Nigel Farage and Reform UK’s candidate Llyr Powell had posed for photos in front of the statue of the legendary comic in Caerphilly.

But when the result was declared at 2.10am at the count in the town’s leisure centre, Mr Farage – who’d been campaigning for Mr Powell on polling day – was nowhere to be seen.

In fact, the joke among Plaid supporters at the count was that long before the declaration Mr Farage was halfway down the M4 on his way back to London.

Read Jon’s full analysis here.

His candidate Llyr Powell received 12,113 votes – denying a victory that would have strengthened claims that Reform can convert a large lead in opinion polls into election wins.

Nonetheless, the party’s performance is a marked improvement on 2021, when it received just 495 votes.

More than anything, the result is a humiliating and historic defeat for Labour, who had held Caerphilly at every Senedd election since it was created in 1999 – as well as the Westminster seat for over a century.

Its candidate Richard Tunnicliffe secured 3,713 votes and finished in third place, with Welsh Labour describing it as a “by-election in the toughest of circumstances, and in the midst of difficult headwinds nationally”.

Turnout overall stood at 50.43% – considerably higher than during the last ballot back in 2021.

Giving his acceptance speech after the result was confirmed, Mr Whittle described how he had been “absolutely heartened” by how many young people were involved in the by-election – and said the result sends a clear message.

He said: “Listen now Cardiff and listen Westminster – this is Caerphilly and Wales telling you we want a better deal for every corner of Wales. The big parties need to sit up and take notice.

“Wales, we are at the dawn of new leadership, we are at the dawn of a new beginning – and I look forward to playing my part for a new Wales, and in particular, for the people of the Caerphilly constituency. I thank you with all my heart.”

Mr Whittle quipped Plaid’s victory “was better than scoring the winning try for Wales in the Rugby World Cup”.

And looking ahead to the next year’s elections, he added: “[This] result shows what’s possible when people come together to back practical solutions and protect what matters most.

“We’ve beaten billionaire-backed Reform and, with the same determination, we can do it again in May 2026. Caerphilly has shown the way – now Wales must follow.”

Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth told Sky News his party’s victory is the “start of a reset of politics in Wales”.

He said Plaid’s goal is to take over the Senedd for the first time in May next year.

“I want to see that through now. I’ve made it clear, said it in my conference speech a couple of weeks ago, we have to replace Labour,” he said.

“And it’s not just for its own sake, it’s so we get better outcomes for Wales. That’s what Plaid Cymru’s always about.”

Labour minister labels result ‘disappointing’

Cabinet Office minister Nick Thomas-Symonds told Sky News that “frustrations” with the “pace of change” led to Labour’s loss.

“I’m not shying away from, how disappointing the result is,” he said.

“What I found on the doorsteps was a real desire for more change, a frustration about the pace of change. That was coming through to me very strongly when I was speaking to people, I think that’s been reflected in the result.”

Labour’s deputy first minister in the Senedd, Huw Irranca-Davies, said the prime minister must “get back to bread and butter things” such as the cost of living, instead of focussing on immigration.

“We’ve got to get better,” he said.

“If it turns out as we think, as the polls have shown tonight, after a really good campaign with a really good Labour candidate in Richard, then we’ve got to talk about how do we get back to bread and butter things: cost of living, the state of the local community, the high street, the green spaces, the money in people’s pockets.

“And that’s a task for both Welsh Labour and UK Labour as well.”

First Minister Eluned Morgan congratulated Mr Whittle on his return to the Senedd and said: “We take our share of the responsibility for this result. We are listening, we are learning the lessons, and we will be come back stronger.”

Reform’s chair David Bull suggested the party’s strong performance in the polls cost them the by-election to Plaid Cymru.

“I actually think the problem for us was the MRP poll, which was released two or three days ago,” he told Sky News.

“It showed us on 42%, Plaid on 38%, and it changed some people’s minds. I’ve heard tales from Lib Dem supporters, even Tories, actually voting tactically for Plaid to keep us out.”

Nigel Farage added that Reform’s candidate lost to “a party that people know well and to a popular local politician”.

“The Senedd elections next year are a two-horse race between Reform UK and Plaid Cymru,” he said.

The Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats were among the parties that lost their deposits.