Connect with us

Published

on

A court has been told Scottish sub-postmasters who were given a criminal record as a result of the Post Office scandal have been placed in an “intolerable” position by politicians promising to pardon victims.

Around 100 Scots were criminalised due to the faulty computer system but only four have so far been successful in overturning their convictions.

In England and Wales, the Post Office acted as a private prosecutor in all cases but the legal system in Scotland is different. Scotland’s public prosecution service, the Crown Office, oversaw cases.

It has emerged the Crown Office first became aware of issues linked to the Horizon system in 2013. It stopped pursuing new cases in 2015.

Officials have been so far unable to answer any questions publicly on the scandal.

The Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh is currently dealing with a case involving several sub-postmasters sent by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission (SCCRC).

The body investigates potential miscarriages of justice, and it is believed that issues surrounding six sub-postmasters should be looked at by appeal judges.

The six were entitled to appeal against the convictions for crimes of dishonesty arising from their roles as sub-postmasters at the Post Office.

The SCCRC referred the cases of Aleid Kloosterhuis, 64; William Quarm, who has died; Susan Sinclair, 57; Colin Smith, 62; Judith Smith, 60; and Rab Thomson, 64, to the appeal court in Scotland.

Read more stories from victims of the scandal

The SCCRC concluded that the five who pleaded guilty over apparent shortfalls in the Horizon system did so in circumstances that were, or could be said to be, clearly prejudicial to them.

Advocate Fred Mackintosh KC told the appeal court on Friday that he is concerned his client Ms Kloosterhuis may have to abandon her formal bid to have her name cleared.

He said he didn’t have enough information on UK and Scottish government proposals to pardon postmasters who were convicted of wrongdoing based on evidence provided by the Horizon computer system.

Mr Mackintosh said he believed the proposed pardon scheme might exclude those postmasters who have failed to clear their names through established legal routes.

He told the court he may have to advise Ms Kloosterhuis that she may have to abandon her appeal. This was because that if she were to lose her appeal, she would be excluded from the newly announced system by Prime Minister Rishi Sunak.

He said: “The government still does not know what to do with existing appeals and it has placed sub-postmasters in an intolerable position of whether to abandon appeals now or run the risk of losing and being totally excluded from the scheme.

“It would be of great assistance if the Crown – or indeed the government – could articulate some clarity as to what the scheme entails.

“Otherwise, we are in the position where we have to tell clients that we may have to abandon the appeals.”

Read more:
What is the Post Office scandal?
Investigators ‘offered bonuses’ to prosecute sub-postmasters

Earlier this week, first minister Humza Yousaf said everyone convicted in Scotland because of Horizon should be pardoned.

He spoke after Mr Sunak announced plans to introduce a new law that will quash convictions in England and Wales.

The legislation would not normally affect Scotland, but Mr Yousaf said he was open to using a Legislative Consent Motion that would allow it to also apply north of the border.

Mr Yousaf added that those affected “can be absolutely assured” they will be pardoned.

On Friday, a lawyer representing one victim said the court was being placed under “unconscionable pressure” by the statements made in recent days by the politicians.

He wanted a delay in proceedings so he could find out more information about the proposed political solutions.

But Lady Dorrian interrupted his submission and said: “The court will be not affected by that.”

Rab Thomson pleaded guilty in 2004 at Alloa Sheriff Court, to one charge of embezzlement.

On Thursday, he told Sky News he had tried to take his own life after living with the nightmare for decades.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

‘I got sectioned because of scandal’

The father-of-two’s advocate Wendy Culross told the court it was approaching the 20th anniversary of her client being accused of wrongdoing.

She said she had consulted with him, and he wanted to press on with his appeal.

Ms Culross added: “He advises me that his solely focused on clearing his name rather than being a part of any compensation claim.

“He is very clear on that. All he wants to do is clear his name.”

After Friday’s developments, an emotional Mr Thomson told Sky News the pressure is mounting, and his mental health is suffering the longer the agony is prolonged.

His appeal will finally be heard on 1 February.

Anyone feeling emotionally distressed or suicidal can call Samaritans for help on 116 123 or email jo@samaritans.org in the UK. In the US, call the Samaritans branch in your area or 1 (800) 273-TALK

Continue Reading

UK

Man and boy arrested on suspicion of arson after restaurant fire leaves two in critical condition

Published

on

By

Man and boy arrested on suspicion of arson after restaurant fire leaves two in critical condition

A 54-year-old man and a 15-year-old boy have been arrested on suspicion of arson with intent to endanger life after a restaurant fire in east London on Friday.

Three people were taken to hospital in a life-threatening condition after the fire at the Indian Aroma in Ilford.

Two remained in a critical condition on Sunday morning, according to the Metropolitan Police.

The restaurant suffered extensive damage in the blaze.

Two further victims are thought to have left the scene before officers arrived, Scotland Yard said.

Woodford Avenue from above. Pic: UK News and Pictures
Image:
Woodford Avenue from above. Pic: UK News and Pictures

Police are still trying to identify them.

CCTV footage seen by the PA news agency appears to show a group of people wearing face coverings walk into the restaurant and pour liquid on the floor.

More from UK

Seconds later, the inside of the restaurant is engulfed in flames.

“While we have made two arrests, our investigation continues at pace so we can piece together what happened on Friday evening,” said the Met Police’s DCI Mark Rogers.

“I know the community [is] concerned and shocked by this incident.

The moment the fire broke out.
Image:
The moment the fire broke out.

“I would urge anyone with any information or concerns to come forward and speak to police.”

Hospital porter Edward Thawe went to help after hearing screams from his nearby home.

He described the scene as “horrible” and “more than scary and the sort of thing that you don’t want to look at twice.”

He said: “I heard screaming and people saying they had called the police.”

Read more from Sky News:
Pro-Palestine Australians protest after week of tension with Israel
‘I’m deprived of my UK citizenship but I’m not a convicted terrorist’
Ghislaine Maxwell was given ‘platform to rewrite history’

The 43-year-old said he saw a woman and a severely burned man who may have been customers.

Another witness, who did not want to be named, said he saw three “severely burned” people being doused by the emergency services and given oxygen.

“I can only imagine the pain they were going through,” he said.

On Saturday, the London Ambulance Service told Sky News: “We sent resources to the scene, including ambulance crews, an advanced paramedic, an incident response officer and paramedics from our hazardous area response team.

“We treated five people for burns and smoke inhalation. We took two patients to a major trauma centre and three others to local hospitals.”

The police investigation is continuing.

Continue Reading

UK

Fast-track asylum appeals process to be introduced – as average time for decisions is more than one year

Published

on

By

Fast-track asylum appeals process to be introduced - as average time for decisions is more than one year

A new fast-track asylum appeals process will be introduced to speed up the process of deporting people without a right to remain in the UK, the home secretary has said.

As it currently takes, on average, more than a year to reach a decision on asylum appeals, the government plans to set up a new independent panel focused on asylum appeals to help reduce the backlog.

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said “completely unacceptable” delays in the appeals process left failed asylum seekers in the system for years.

There are about 51,000 asylum appeals waiting to be heard.

The new independent body will use professionally-trained adjudicators, rather than relying on judges.

Ministers are introducing a new 24-week deadline for the first-tier tribunal to determine asylum appeals by those receiving accommodation support and appeals by foreign offenders.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Police clash with protesters in Bristol

But they believe the current tribunal system, which covers a wide range of different cases, is still failing to ensure failed asylum seekers can be returned as swiftly as possible, nor can it accommodate a fast-track system for safe countries.

More on Asylum

It comes amid protests about the use of hotel accommodation for migrants.

The home secretary said the overhaul would result in a system which is “swift, fair and independent, with high standards in place”.

Read more from Sky News:
UK set to bask in 30C sunshine over bank holiday weekend
Coca-Cola brews up sale of high street coffee giant Costa

She said: “We inherited an asylum system in complete chaos with a soaring backlog of asylum cases and a broken appeals system with thousands of people in the system for years on end.

“That is why we are taking practical steps to fix the foundations and restore control and order to the system.

“We are determined to substantially reduce the number of people in the asylum system as part of our plan to end asylum hotels.

“Already since the election, we have reduced the backlog of people waiting for initial decisions by 24% and increased failed asylum returns by 30%.

“But we cannot carry on with these completely unacceptable delays in appeals as a result of the system we have inherited which mean that failed asylum seekers stay in the system for years on end at huge cost to the taxpayer.”

Official figures released earlier this month showed a total of 111,084 people applied for asylum in the UK in the year to June 2025, the highest number for any 12-month period since current records began in 2001.

‘Waving immigrants through even faster will not fix the problem’

Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, said: “I think this goes nowhere near far enough.

“The underlying rights, which allows most illegal immigrants to stay here, are not changing. Simply waving illegal immigrants through even faster to full housing and welfare rights will not fix the problem.”

Chris Philp
Image:
Chris Philp

He added: “Immigration judges will still apply ever expanding common-sense defying definitions of ECHR rights to allow foreign criminals and illegal immigrants to stay here.”

But the Liberal Democrats have been more positive in their response, with shadow attorney general, Ben Maguire, saying: “A faster application process would mean that those with no right to be here are sent back swiftly and those who do have a valid claim can get a job, integrate and contribute to the community.”

Asked for his thoughts on the policy, immigration lawyer Harjap Singh Bhangal told Sky News that it “definitely sounds like some sort of solution”.

He pointed that the backlog of asylum seekers waiting for a decision is “huge”, around 51,000 people – and that during this time, they are not allowed to work.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

A new fast-track asylum appeals process will be introduced to speed up the process of deporting people without a right to remain in the UK.

He said: “The equivalent would be saying that imagine if A-level students this year sat the exams and were told ‘well, hold on, you’re not going to get your results for two years’ time. But in the meantime, you can’t go to university.’

“You’d have mayhem, and it’d be pandemonium in the street. You’d have broken people idle with nothing to do. Essentially, this is what’s happening to asylum seekers.”

He added that one of the reasons it takes so long for cases to be heard is because asylum seekers have to represent themselves in court, which can mean upwards of half a day is spent translating and explaining everything to them.

Mr Bhangal also said the immigration system is “broken”, because “they take ages to make a decision which could be made in one week”.

Continue Reading

UK

Family pay tribute to ‘beloved’ man who died in ‘accident while working on fairground ride’

Published

on

By

Family pay tribute to 'beloved' man who died in 'accident while working on fairground ride'

A man who died after suffering “serious head injuries” while “working on a fairground ride” has been named as Corrie Lee Stavers.

Emergency services were called to the Spanish City Summer Funfair in Whitley Bay in North Tyneside after reports that a man, in his 20s, had been injured around 2.15pm on Saturday, police said.

Mr Stavers, 28, was treated at the scene but was declared dead a short time later.

In a statement issued by the police, his family said: “It’s with broken hearts that we share the devastating news that our beloved Corrie has passed away.

“He was tragically taken from us in an accident while working on a fairground ride. None of us were prepared for this, and the pain of losing him so suddenly is impossible to put into words.

“Our lives will never be the same without him, but his memory will live on in our hearts forever.

“We love you endlessly Corrie, and we miss you more than words can ever say.

More from UK

“You’re with our mam now – rest in peace Corrie.”

The funfair, which is in Whitley Bay’s Spanish City Plaza area, has been shut “until further notice” and the Health and Safety Executive has been informed.

The annual funfair had opened on Thursday and had been due to run until Bank Holiday Monday.

Read more from Sky News:
Man and boy arrested after restaurant fire
Fast-track asylum appeals process to be introduced

A Northumbria Police spokesman said: “Emergency services attended and a man in his 20s was found to have suffered serious head injuries.

“Despite the best efforts of medical staff, a short time later the man was sadly declared dead.

“His next of kin have been contacted and are being supported by specialist officers.”

The spokesman added: “Our thoughts are with the man’s family at this extremely difficult time.

“We have contacted the Health and Safety Executive and are working with them to establish exactly what happened.

“The fair has been closed to the public and will remain closed until further notice.”

Continue Reading

Trending