Connect with us

Published

on

The artist who created a sculpture which has been called “disturbing” and “shocking” says he’s been “surprised” at the backlash but welcomes difficult conversations it might inspire.

Jason deCaires Taylor told Sky News: “I don’t strive of my artwork to divide people or cause upset. But I do try to talk about issues that are pertinent and relevant to our current times.”

Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor
Image:
Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor

The 50-year-old artist has a history of producing political work but says this one contained “no political intentions at all” and is based on the painting which inspired Shakespeare‘s tragic heroine Ophelia.

The Alluvia – which is made from recycled glass and steel and features LEDs which light up at night – was installed in the River Stour, in Taylor’s hometown of Canterbury in Kent around a week ago.

However, comments posted on Canterbury City Council’s official Facebook page have included accusations that the work is “tone-deaf” and “offensive”.

One wrote: “I can’t be the only person who finds this deeply offensive. She looks like a drowned woman. How did the council not see the link to women as victims of crime or the sad fact so many drown off the Kent coast as refugees.”

Another said: “I find this sculpture absolutely appalling. It’s not just offensive, it’s downright disturbing. The imagery of a submerged figure, reminiscent of a drowning victim, is both morbid and utterly tone-deaf given the tragic drownings that occur along our coastlines. What on earth were the council thinking?”

Others stood up for the work, with one commenting: “More people seem to be “disturbed”, “offended” and “shocked” by this than they do by images of actual drownings which are happening daily along our coasts. Rather than wasting your hate on an artwork that is designed to provoke, why not put some of that energy into something constructive?”

Another wrote: “It’s a beautiful piece of art and nowhere near as disturbing as the previous sculptures that it has replaced. What kind of world do we live in when anything that offends or “triggers” someone, must be removed??”

The Alluvia on the bed of the river Stour near the Westgate bridge in Canterbury, Kent. Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor
Image:
Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor

The Alluvia on the bed of the river Stour near the Westgate bridge in Canterbury, Kent. Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor
Image:
The Alluvia on the bed of the river Stour near the Westgate bridge in Canterbury, Kent. Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor

The sculpture had replaced two similar female forms, also created by Taylor, which had been in the water since 2008 but which had been damaged due to dredging.

‘If it fosters care and sympathy, that’s good’

Taylor told Sky News: “I was surprised… 99.9% of all the feedback that I’ve received has been very positive… But at the same time, I appreciate everybody takes something different from everything they see.”

While he says there is “no connection” between the work and the ongoing migrant crisis taking place further along the Kent coast, he hopes it could inspire empathy for what’s happening out in the Channel.

Follow Sky News on WhatsApp
Follow Sky News on WhatsApp

Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Sky News

Tap here

He said: “It’s an extremely tragic situation, and I don’t think ignoring it is the solution. If [this work] can foster any kind of care and sympathy for that situation, then I think that’s a good thing.”

More than 21,000 people arrived in the UK in small boats between January and September, according to government figures, with at least 45 people dying in Channel crossings this year.

Taylor also said the fact the subject is a young woman is because it draws reference from Sir John Everett Millais’s celebrated painting, on display at Tate Britain.

The Alluvia on the bed of the river Stour near the Westgate bridge in Canterbury, Kent. Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor
Image:
Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor

‘Art without questions is pointless’

Some of Taylor’s past sculptures have raised issues around the climate crisis, Brexit and the plight of those risking their lives on the perilous migration route from West Africa to Spain.

Taylor says: “Art should ask questions. They should make people think about things that should elicit emotions, that’s really critical.

“If things were ignored and if you tried to please everybody with all your artwork, I think you’d make something very benign and quite frankly, pretty pointless.”

He also feels our age of information overload could be part of the reason for the negative feedback.

“We’re so inundated with images and media, with having our phones interrupting us and screens everywhere we look that people look for divisiveness and things that cause clickbait. I think there is an element of people sort of seeking out controversy.”

Taylor said the majority of negative comments online had come from people who had not been to Canterbury and seen the work in real life, with one call for the statue’s removal coming all the way from Orkney.

Responding directly to calls for his work to be taken out of the river, he said: “People are perfectly in their rights to have [an] opinion. But I would urge them to go and see it first.”

The Alluvia on the bed of the river Stour near the Westgate bridge in Canterbury, Kent. Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor
Image:
Pic: Jason deCaires Taylor

‘A dead body doesn’t light up at night’

Chair of Canterbury Commemoration Society Stewart Ross, the charity that commissioned the work, told Sky News: “Some people find it offensive and shocking, we have no objection to that. All public art is open to discussion”.

Comparing calls for the work to be removed to the destruction of art during the Reformation, he said: “I feel strongly about this [call for censorship]. It’s what the Taliban do. If you don’t like it, don’t look.”

Follow Sky News on WhatsApp
Follow Sky News on WhatsApp

Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Sky News

Tap here

Mr Ross said the “confected anger” around the sculpture was “unnecessary” and that the charity was simply “trying to do its best,” adding: “People have been comparing it to a dead body, but I have yet to meet a dead body that lights up in the night”.

Taylor, who has been working as an artist for over 25 years, has sculptures in marine locations around the world including Australia, Mexico, Grenada and Norway. Prices for his sculptures start at around £1,300.

He first donated the two original Alluvia figures to the city of Canterbury in 2008.

Continue Reading

Entertainment

‘An enigma’ to the end: John le Carré’s son on his father – and how his legacy lives on

Published

on

By

'An enigma' to the end: John le Carré's son on his father - and how his legacy lives on

Writing 26 books and a memoir in his lifetime, John le Carré is widely considered to be one of the best spy novelists of all time.

His son, Simon Cornwell, told Sky News: “I think there was only one thing that was more important to him than his family and that was his writing.”

Rory Keenand and Mat Betteridge in The Spy Who Came In From The Cold. Pic: Johan Persson
Image:
Rory Keenand and Mat Betteridge in The Spy Who Came In From The Cold. Pic: Johan Persson

Tom Hiddleston returns in season two of The Night Manager. Pic: BBC/Ink Factory/Des Willie
Image:
Tom Hiddleston returns in season two of The Night Manager. Pic: BBC/Ink Factory/Des Willie

First gaining attention in 1963 with his breakout novel, The Spy Who Came In From The Cold, cementing his reputation 10 years later with Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, his work is now enjoying a resurgence.

The Spy Who Came In From The Cold has been adapted for the stage for the first time, with confirmation of a TV series to follow, while another of his works, The Night Manager, premieres its second season starring Tom Hiddleston in the new year.

There are further productions waiting in the wings, plus an unfinished le Carré play with the potential to be developed.

And archives of le Carré’s work – containing over 1,200 boxes of material – have gone on display at the Bodleian Libraries at the University of Oxford.

Writing under a pen name, le Carré, who was born David Cornwell, died in December 2020.

More on Tom Hiddleston

His elder sons, Simon and Stephen, now manage the film, TV and stage rights of his work through their studio The Ink Factory, while his youngest son, Nick, expands the George Smiley universe.

(R-L) Nick Harkaway, John Le Carré, and Simon, Stephen and Tim Cornwell. Pic: Clare Cornwell
Image:
(R-L) Nick Harkaway, John Le Carré, and Simon, Stephen and Tim Cornwell. Pic: Clare Cornwell

Smiley’s continuation ‘could have gone horribly wrong’

One of le Carré’s most well-known creations, Smiley was the antidote to James Bond – bespectacled, balding and a little out of shape – and a recurring character in le Carré’s books.

Simon says Nick, who has two more Smiley books in the pipeline, was “taking on a big risk” developing the character, but insists, “he is the only person who could have done it and done it that well”.

He goes on: “He could find my father’s voice… he grew up talking every day to my dad, as we did, and he just knows at an instinctive level what’s important…

“There are so many ways in which it could have gone horribly wrong, and it went brilliantly right.”

Nick Harkaway with his first Smiley continuation novel, Karla's Choice. Pic: AP
Image:
Nick Harkaway with his first Smiley continuation novel, Karla’s Choice. Pic: AP

‘A family enterprise’

Explaining how they all work together – calling it a “family enterprise in the best of ways” – Simon explains: “A lot of authors, when they die, they leave very strict instructions to their children, their estate as to how things should be managed and lots of rules and restrictions and everything else. My dad didn’t do that.”

Le Carré’s fourth son, Tim, sadly died aged 59 in 2022, shortly after editing a collection of his father’s letters, titled A Private Spy.

Le Carré is by no means the only author whose legacy lives on via others.

Announcing a staggered retirement, Lee Child passed his hit creation Jack Reacher on to his younger brother Andrew in 2020.

PG Wodehouse’s much-loved Jeeves and Wooster stories have been rewritten this Christmas by celebrity fans including Frank Skinner and Alan Titchmarsh, half a century after his death.

Daniel Craig at the No Time To Die world premiere in 2021. Pic: Reuters
Image:
Daniel Craig at the No Time To Die world premiere in 2021. Pic: Reuters

Staying part of the conversation is key

While Ian Fleming’s James Bond has been continued by 15 authors so far, and spilling into the young adult genre, capturing a whole new generation of readers.

Mark Edlitz, intellectual expert and author of The Many Lives Of James Bond, told Sky News such continuations are essential to the survival of the work.

Author Mark Edlitz has written about the Bond continuation novels
Image:
Author Mark Edlitz has written about the Bond continuation novels

“We have seen all these detectives and spies who don’t have a movie series or a TV series to bolster their eyeballs, and then they fade from public view.

“These books and movies help keep the author’s work present and viable and part of the public conversation.”

Sarah Baxter, senior contracts advisor for The Society of Authors, says remaining relevant and visible has another big benefit too.

“That kind of partnership can go on to give a whole new lease of life to works that may have been written many, many years ago, and it can go on to generate a lot of income for a literary estate.”

Le Carré - an enigma, even to his family, to the end. Pic: AP
Image:
Le Carré – an enigma, even to his family, to the end. Pic: AP

‘An enigma’

More than 60 million copies of Le Carré’s books have been sold worldwide, with new adaptations likely to boost those sales further.

But Simon Cornwell says the investment in his father’s work is about more than just profits.

“We became very, very close as a family because he was very keen to be a proper dad and we were working with him and his material as well, so it was particularly towards the end of his life. It was a beautiful, thrilling thing.”

A master storyteller, the moral ambiguity of the fictional world he constructed reflected back on to its creator.

Simon says: “He remained an enigma. I think in some ways he was probably an enigma to himself…

“He was an extraordinary man to be close with, but do you ever understand somebody like that? Probably not.”

His work more widespread than ever, but the man himself – still a mystery.

The Spy Who Came In From The Cold is at @sohoplace in London’s West End to 21 February before embarking on a UK Tour.

John le Carré: Tradecraft is at the Bodleian Libraries at the University of Oxford until 6 April.

Continue Reading

Entertainment

Primal Scream says video with alleged antisemitic imagery shown at gig was meant to provoke debate

Published

on

By

Primal Scream says video with alleged antisemitic imagery shown at gig was meant to provoke debate

Primal Scream have said a video containing alleged antisemitic imagery was a “piece of art” and was intended to “provoke debate, not hate”.

Warning: This article contains alleged antisemitic imagery.

The Scottish rock band have been reported to the Metropolitan Police for showing a film at their Roundhouse concert in Camden, London on Monday which appeared to include imagery of the Star of David entwined with a swastika.

The force is now assessing the report.

‘Film is a piece of art’

Primal Scream said in a statement on Instagram: “The film is a piece of art. It clearly draws from history to question where the actions of current world governments sit in that context. It is meant to provoke debate, not hate.

“In a free, pluralistic and liberal society freedom of expression is a right which we choose to exercise.”

More on London

Primal Scream, founded by frontman Bobby Gillespie in 1982, were playing a 25-year anniversary show for their album XTRMNTR.

As the group performed Swastika Eyes, pictures of political figures including Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appeared behind them, showing what appeared to be the Star of David combined with a swastika in their eyes.

The video from the gig that sparked the report to police
Image:
The video from the gig that sparked the report to police

Venue ‘appalled’

The Roundhouse has apologised, saying it was “appalled” that “antisemitic imagery was displayed”, adding it was done entirely without its knowledge.

It said in a statement: “We deeply regret that these highly offensive images were presented on our stage and unequivocally apologise to anyone who attended the gig and to the wider Jewish community.”

It added: “Our organisation absolutely condemns antisemitism in every form.”

Call for ‘urgent investigation’

The Community Security Trust (CST), which provides protection for Jewish communities in the UK, said it had reported the band to police and called on the venue to carry out an “urgent investigation”.

In a statement, a CST spokesperson said: “CST is appalled by the grossly antisemitic image displayed at Primal Scream. Entwining a Star of David with a swastika implies that Jews are Nazis and risks encouraging hatred of Jews.

“There needs to be an urgent investigation by the venue and the promoter about how this happened, and we have reported this to the police.”

What have police said?

Responding to that report, a Met Police spokesperson said: “On Wednesday, 10 December, we received a report in relation to a video shown on stage during a concert at the Roundhouse in Chalk Farm Road, Camden on Monday, 8 December.

“It is being assessed by officers.”

Read more from Sky News:
Man found guilty of savage train glass bottle attack
Taylor Swift breaks down in tears over Southport attacks

‘Unadulterated hatred’

The charity Campaign Against Antisemitism said: “The Nazi swastika represents the ideology that inspired people to industrially slaughter six million innocent Jewish men, women and children by bullet, gas and any other means available.

“To visually combine that with the Star of David – the pre-eminent symbol of Judaism – is absolutely sickening and totally inexcusable.

“This isn’t art. This isn’t edgy. This isn’t political statement. It is unadulterated hatred and a clear breach of the international definition of antisemitism.

“We will be writing to the Camden Roundhouse and our legal team is examining the footage to consider further steps.”

Continue Reading

Entertainment

‘Beloved and inspirational’ author Joanna Trollope dies

Published

on

By

'Beloved and inspirational' author Joanna Trollope dies

Author Joanna Trollope has died aged 82, her family has said.

Trollope was one of the nation’s most widely read authors, having published more than 30 novels during a career that began in the 1970s.

Her novels include “Aga sagas” The Rector’s Wife, Marrying The Mistress and Daughters-in-Law.

In a statement, Trollope’s daughters Antonia and Louise said: “Our beloved and inspirational mother Joanna Trollope has died peacefully at her Oxfordshire home, on December 11, aged 82.”

Trollope with Queen Elizabeth II in 2001. Pic: PA
Image:
Trollope with Queen Elizabeth II in 2001. Pic: PA

Her literary agent James Gill said: “It is with great sadness that we learn of the passing of Joanna Trollope, one of our most cherished, acclaimed and widely enjoyed novelists.

“Joanna will be mourned by her children, grandchildren, family, her countless friends and – of course – her readers.”

Trollope was born in Gloucestershire in 1943. She won a scholarship to study at the University of Oxford in the 1960s.

After graduating, she joined the Foreign Office before training as a teacher and then turning to writing full-time in 1980.

The author was best known for her novels set in rural middle England and centred around domestic life and relationships.

Her early historical romances were written under the pseudonym Caroline Harvey, before she turned to contemporary fiction.

Her work tackled a range of topics from affairs, blended families and adoption, to parenting and marital breakdown.

Trollope with shortlisted novels for the Orange Prize for Fiction. Pic: PA
Image:
Trollope with shortlisted novels for the Orange Prize for Fiction. Pic: PA

Trollope also took part in The Austen Project, which saw six of Jane Austen’s novels retold by contemporary writers.

She wrote the first book in the series, Sense & Sensibility, published in 2013.

Read more from Sky News:
Man found guilty of murdering wife in rare retrial

UK ‘rapidly developing’ plans to prepare for war

In 1996, Trollope was awarded the Order of the British Empire (OBE) for her services to literature and later made a Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) in 2019.

She won the Romantic Novel of the Year in 1980 for the book Parson Harding’s Daughter and in 2010 was given a lifetime achievement award from the Romantic Novelists’ Association (RNA) for her services to romance.

She went on to chair a number of award ceremonies, including the Costa Book Awards, formerly the Whitbread Prize, as well as the BBC National Short Story Award and the Orange Prize for Fiction.

Continue Reading

Trending