The father of a six-year-old girl who was operated on by former surgeon Dr Yaser Jabbar multiple times over 15 months is among the first to be told she suffered harm during her care.
Dean Stalham’s daughter Bunty was born with the rare bone condition neurofibromatosis.
It means she has been in and out of hospital since she was 18 months old but was placed under the care of the former consultant orthopaedic surgeon in 2018.
During her time in Dr Jabbar’s care at Great Ormond Street Hospital, her family say she underwent multiple “unsuccessful and painful” procedures which ultimately led to her leg being amputated below the knee.
The hospital is reviewing the care of hundreds of children seen by Dr Jabbar.
Some 700 cases are being investigated in total and a select number of families have heard back already, including Bunty’s.
More on Health
Related Topics:
The review of her care – shown to Sky News – revealed that she had suffered moderate physical and mild psychological harm.
Speaking to Sky News, her father Dean Stalham said: “He [Dr Jabbar] was trying to save a leg that couldn’t be saved.
Advertisement
“He took it upon himself to be the almighty saviour of the leg, as it were, and it proves that they were all unnecessary because they all failed – and what it says in the report is that there’s no benefit, not one operation was of any benefit to Bunty whatsoever.”
Mr Stalham added: “He was all smiles and success – coming in and saying I’ve lengthened her leg, it’s great, it’s longer than the other one, it was all a big major success and then out of the blue – actually no it hasn’t worked.”
Dr Jabbar no longer works at the hospital and has not had a licence to practise medicine in the UK since January.
Image: Dean Stalham and Bunty
Bunty’s leg was eventually amputated in 2022. Her father says it should have happened sooner and saved her from prolonged pain.
“We think that she thought her leg was going to grow back, in her head, because she was told it was a healthy bone… she thought her leg was going to regrow. He sold her a dream.
“After the eventual amputation, he came out of that operation and said right I’ve left a three-inch piece of lovely, healthy bone hanging from her knee, it will mean she will have mobility. Then two weeks later, the bone’s veering off to the left.”
An external report – commissioned by Great Ormond Street – into Dr Jabbar’s practices and the wider department, is due to be sent to the families of those affected who wish to see it.
They have been told it will be redacted in places.
Caroline Murgatroyd, from Hudgell Solicitors, is representing some of them.
“Bunty’s case has similarities to others we have seen – which is a pattern of poor decision making, failure to consider alternatives to the surgery and failure to discuss with parents the risks and benefits to different treatment options and whether any particular treatment is really in the patient’s best interest.”
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children said in a statement: “We wish to say we are deeply sorry to Bunty and her family, and all the families impacted by the review of care given by a Lower Limb Orthopaedic surgeon. This is not what they should expect from any service at our hospital.
“Within 18 working days of concerns being raised to senior leaders about the Lower Limb Lengthening and Reconstruction Service, we asked the Royal College of Surgeons to carry out a review into our Paediatric Orthopaedic service in July 2022.
“We are now ensuring that all the findings are addressed at pace.”
Dr Jabbar has since been working in Dubai, but Sky News understands he has been suspended.
In a statement shared with Sky News, a spokesperson from CMC Hospital Dubai said: “We have been made aware of recent reports concerning allegations of misconduct and malpractice involving a physician employed at our hospital.
“We took immediate action to suspend the physician. We are awaiting the relevant authorities’ decisions on the matter.”
British Transport Police held an emergency exercise for press officers in March, which ironically involved a stabbing on a train travelling south near Huntingdon.
In the training drill, the train stopped immediately between stations when a passenger pulled the emergency cord.
It took police 25 minutes to reach the train and casualties, far longer than the eight minutes in which Cambridgeshire firearms officers reached the scene at Huntingdon station.
Chris Webb, a crisis communications expert who helped run the exercise, said: “People think if you pull the emergency cord on a train it stops immediately, but that’s not what happens these days.
“As soon as the driver knows there is a problem, he or she radios the line operator HQ and they discuss where to stop.
“The decision last night was to keep going to Huntingdon station, where it was much easier for armed police to get on.”
More from UK
Image: Forensic investigators at Huntingdon train station in Cambridgeshire
He added: “It must have been awful for passengers when the train kept going for another ten minutes or so.
“It’s always a balance. It might have prolonged the attack, but stopping in the middle of nowhere can mean the attack stops but it’s much more difficult for the emergency services to get there.”
Mr Webb, former head of news at Scotland Yard, said such exercises are held regularly by train operators.
A similar drill was carried out on the London Underground weeks before the 7/7 bombings in 2005.
“There are always lessons to learn but you cannot guard against everything.”
In the training exercise in March the suspect was a white man with mental health issues. He was shot dead by police.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
Police triggered the Plato code to all emergency services in their initial response to the Huntingdon train stabbing, but that did not label it a terrorist attack.
Plato is called for a major incident where it’s thought a suspect is on the loose and has already, or is liable to, cause serious injury.
Plato does not denote a terror attack, though it is often used in terrorist incidents.
Image: A forensic investigator on the platform by the train at Huntingdon train station in Cambridgeshire
In a Plato response paramedics, fire fighters and other first responders are sent to a safe rendezvous point while armed police go in and deal with the suspect.
Plato depicts a situation where unarmed responders are vulnerable and are kept back until it is safe to approach casualties.
There are exceptions and it’s understood the East of England Ambulance Service has a special Hazardous Area Response Team (HART) which was allowed to accompany armed police onto the platform where the two suspects were arrested last night.
Once other first responders were allowed in, Plato was called off – an important part of the operation.
Plato was called during the initial response to the Manchester Arena bomb attack in 2017, but the fire service was not told it had been called off for two hours and that meant its officers did not go in to help with the rescue.
A student has told how she thought she “was going to die” during a mass stabbing on board a high-speed train.
Amira Ostalski was travelling to London for a Saturday night out with her friend Vanessa on board the “very busy” 6.25pm Doncaster to King’s Cross LNER service.
She told Sky News correspondent Dan Whitehead they were “listening to music, just having a good time”, when “panic and chaos” broke out in her carriage, Coach G, between Peterborough and Huntingdon.
“I see five rows ahead of us a guy in a white t-shirt just jumps out of his seat,” she said. “People are screaming, ‘he’s got a knife’…. I’m guessing he stabbed the person right in front of me.”
Ms Ostalski said she came within 2m of the attacker but only caught a glimpse of him adding: “He was just a black bearded guy wearing all black and a hoody.
Image: Woman who saw attack on train at Huntingdon tells Sky News of her experience
“I didn’t see the knife he was holding. I’m guessing because it was already in the body or something.”
She said she “started running” and was “trying to calm everyone down” because there was a young boy, around six years old, who hid in the toilets with his mum.
“Everyone’s running. A guy next to me is holding his arm saying he’s been stabbed. He was running. I see people covered in blood,” she said.
“Everyone was shocked, everyone was terrified. People wanted to know what was going on, everyone’s pushing and shoving. Everyone’s getting trampled.”
Image: Woman who saw attack on train at Huntingdon tells Sky News of her experience
Ms Ostalski said she heard some people crying on the phone “in tears and in shock, thinking they’re going to be stabbed”.
“It was horrific, it was really horrific because we had no idea where he was and the conductor who tried to stop him, he got stabbed as well.
“We felt that we were not safe because we were trying to get the train to stop but it wasn’t stopping.”
Image: Route of the 6.25pm London North Eastern Railway (LNER) service between Doncaster and London King’s Cross
Ms Ostalski said she ran into the buffet car where she picked up a metal tray to protect herself and her friend.
“I was honestly so petrified. I thought in that moment it was the last time I was ever going to be alive. I thought I was going to die,” she said.
Ms Ostalski said she saw the attacker again when the train was stopped at Huntingdon station by the door, holding a bottle in his left hand.
“He just looked so calm and I think that was the most terrifying thing,” she said.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:34
Armed officers were seen running along the platform at Huntingdon station towards the train carriages after multiple people were stabbed on board.
Image: Moment of suspect’s arrest
Police declared a major incident and armed officers can be seen in video footage sprinting along the platform.
Ms Ostalski said she thought she and the other passengers were safe when the train was evacuated.
But when she reached the car park, she turned around and saw the attacker jump the fence and start coming towards them.
“I have to admit, the police came really quickly and managed to detain him,” she said.
“I saw them running then took the knife and he got tasered and fell right on the spot.”
Two men born in Britain have been arrested over the attack, which police do not believe was motivated by terrorism, but Ms Ostalski said she only saw one of them.
A total of 11 people have been treated in hospital for their injuries, while two people remain in a life-threatening condition.
Ms Ostalski said she finally found safety in a taxi but will remember the ordeal for the rest of her life.
“Honestly, I’m scared to sit on a train,” she added.
A passenger who witnessed a mass stabbing on board a high-speed train heading for London told Sky News he heard someone yelling: “They’ve got a knife. I’ve been stabbed.”
The witness, who gave his name as Gavin, said there were “extremely bloodied” people and police shouting “get down, get down!” as passengers scrambled to leave the train.
Image: One passenger in an emergency mediwrap blanket walks to safety. Pic: PA
Chief Superintendent Chris Casey of British Transport Police said: “This is a shocking incident and first and foremost my thoughts are with those who have been injured this evening and their families.
“We’re conducting urgent enquiries to establish what has happened, and it could take some time before we are in a position to confirm anything further.
“At this early stage, it would not be appropriate to speculate on the causes of the incident.
“Our response is ongoing at the station and will be for some time.”