Connect with us

Published

on

MPs will today debate a change in the law proposed by a bereaved mother who believes social media may hold crucial clues to her son’s death.

Jools Sweeney was 14 when he was found unconscious at home in April 2022.

His parents and friends who saw him earlier that day say there were no signs he was depressed.

A coroner found he took his own life, but that he probably did not intend to, as he was unable to confirm he was in a suicidal mood.

His mother Ellen Roome suspects he may have taken part in an online challenge.

She has spent two years trying to get access to his social media accounts but says the tech companies have made it “very difficult”.

Her petition to allow bereaved parents or guardians to access a child’s full social media history attracted 126,000 signatures, known as Jools Law, and will be debated in parliament later.

More on Houses Of Parliament

“Earlier in the day he was playing football with a group of friends,” she said.

“You can see on our security camera he said goodbye to his friend, all chirpy, an hour and a half before I got home.

“We can’t have all, his parents, friends, teachers, grandparents, missed depression. And so we’re left with these huge question marks,” she said.

“The pain in my heart of not knowing what happened that night or why is incredibly hard. I don’t want another family to go through it.”

‘It’s my gut feeling and I just want to know’

Jools Sweeney and Ellen Roome. Pic: Supplied
Image:
MPs are to debate Ellen Roome’s suggestions

Ms Roome, 48 from Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, fears her son may have taken part in an online challenge which led to his death.

The police and coroner did not gather forensic data from his phone.

With help from her son’s friends, Ellen has been able to unlock his phone and access some of his accounts, but some material has been deleted.

She says the tech companies have not given her full access to what Jools was looking at before his death.

“I have always said I don’t know it’s social media but that’s always been my gut feeling and I just want to know – it’s the missing piece of the jigsaw,” she said.

“He did an awful lot of challenges, like standing on his hands putting a t-shirt on upside down. I thought they were fun, viral challenges. I never knew about some of the more dangerous ones.

“The police didn’t ask for the data from social media companies. The detective didn’t even find out he had more than one TikTok and Instagram account.”

She says the social media companies have not given her all his messages and browsing history.

“They could say ‘here it is, I hope you get some answers’. They could redact the details of other children.”

Jools died a week after 12-year-old Archie Battersbee from Southend-on-Sea, Essex, was left brain-damaged by what a coroner concluded was an online prank and later died.

Sky News has contacted Meta, which owns Instagram, as well as TikTok and Snapchat. None provided an on-the-record statement, but they are understood to have been in contact with Ms Roome.

social media ban
Image:
Ms Roome wants access to her late son’s social media

Police ‘supporting’ family

A spokesperson for Gloucestershire Constabulary said they were limited in what they could request because it was not a criminal case.

“We cannot fathom how upsetting it must be for the family to not have answers after Jools took his own life.

“We supported the Sweeney family and coroner’s office throughout an investigation into the cause of his death.

“As part of this Jools’s phone was given to police and a review of the contents took place, as well as the manual review of a TikTok account. Nothing was found as part of these searches to provide any answers.

“Police are limited in what lines of enquiry can be taken to access private social media accounts hosted by private companies due to legislation, which states that you have to be proving or disproving an indictable offence, which is not applicable in this case and therefore there was no legal basis to apply for a production order.

“We know this sadly doesn’t help Jools’ family get the answers they are searching for, and we continue to support them with their own application for access to his social media accounts.”

A TikTok representative held a meeting with Ms Roome last year and explained that the law requires companies to delete people’s personal data – unless there is a police request for it.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

May 2024: ‘I have no idea why he isn’t here’

Read more:
Social media failing to remove dangerous content
Tech bosses threatened with jail over child protection
Everything ‘on the table’ in debate

‘I don’t want any other family in my position’

In April 2024, new powers allowing coroners to require the production of social media evidence were introduced. Jools’s inquest was by then closed.

Ms Roome is preparing a case to go to the High Court to get a fresh inquest and is crowdfunding the £86,000 cost to find answers.

The government issued a response to Ms Roome’s petition, saying that tech companies should respond to requests from bereaved parents in a “humane and transparent way”.

A new Digital Information and Data Bill, to be passed this year, would compel social media companies to retain data in cases where a child has died, so a coroner can request it.

But Ms Roome is worried it would not compel coroners and police to request the data.

Science, Innovation and Technology Secretary Peter Kyle arrives in Downing Street.
Pic: PA
Image:
Peter Kyle has said he will be looking ‘very, very closely’ at the issue. Pic: PA

“I don’t want any other family to be in the position I am two-and-a-half years after my son’s death. It should be automatic,” she said.

Her lawyer Merry Varney, partner at Leigh Day, also represented the family of Molly Russell who fought for months to access what she saw online.

‘It’s left to parents to fill the gaps’

Ms Varney told Sky News: “Getting that information is incredibly difficult, it’s a moving target. You’ve got the posters of the content, they control whether it’s deleted or made private.

“The social media companies take this line ‘it’s not for us, it’s not our responsibility’, which makes for a very challenging set of circumstances – and it’s not right.

“There’s a lot the social media and tech platforms say about wanting to help, to be seen to be doing the right thing. But are they transparent about the gaps? No.

“It’s left to the parents to fill the gaps themselves and it can be costly and difficult.”

👉 Listen above then tap here to follow the Sky News Daily wherever you get your podcasts 👈

Technology Secretary Peter Kyle spoke to Sky News in November. He said: “Coroners have the power now to compel the release of that data so it can be looked at.

“I’m going to be looking very, very closely at how those powers are used, that all coroners know that they have those powers and then if there’s any additional powers that are needed going forward, then, of course, you know, I’m all ears to see how that could work.”

Anyone feeling emotionally distressed or suicidal can call Samaritans for help on 116 123 or email jo@samaritans.org in the UK. In the US, call the Samaritans branch in your area or 1 (800) 273-TALK

Continue Reading

UK

As hate crimes against Muslims rise, govt urged to adopt new definition of Islamophobia in full

Published

on

By

As hate crimes against Muslims rise, govt urged to adopt new definition of Islamophobia in full

A long-awaited definition of Islamophobia is expected within weeks – and a former faith minister is urging the government to adopt it in full.

It is expected that the government will move away from the word “Islamophobia”, instead replacing it with “anti-Muslim hostility”.

But Lord Khan, who oversaw the start of the review into the definition, told Sky News the government must adopt the full new definition to tackle hate against Muslims.

Lord Khan. Pic: PA
Image:
Lord Khan. Pic: PA

The Labour peer, who was faith minister until the September reshuffle, told Sky News: “I hope it’s a clear definition which reflects the terms of reference which protects people, and it’s clear.

“There’s so many definitions out there, this is an opportunity to address the big problem in our communities.

“I would request and urge the government to adopt the definition which fits within the terms of reference on what we wanted to do when we embarked on the process.

“It’s a strong message to our communities that the work that should be done isn’t being done – these are lived experiences and I am one of those people who has suffered.”

More from Politics

There was a suspected arson attack at a mosque in East Sussex earlier this month. Pic: Eddie Mitchell
Image:
There was a suspected arson attack at a mosque in East Sussex earlier this month. Pic: Eddie Mitchell

Chaired by former Conservative minister Dominic Grieve, an independent working group has been looking at whether to produce a new definition of Islamophobia since February as part of a government bid to tackle the rise in hate crimes towards British Muslims.

Its aim was to “define unacceptable treatment, prejudice, discrimination and hate targeting Muslims or anyone who is perceived to be Muslim”.

From the beginning, ministers have insisted that any new definition would not infringe on freedom of speech, that it would protect the right to criticise, express dislike of, or insult religions and it would not pave the way for blasphemy laws to pass “through the back door”.

In 2021, Labour adopted a working definition of Islamophobia from a cross-party group supported by Wes Streeting, which said: “Islamophobia is rooted in racism and is a type of racism that targets expressions of Muslimness or perceived Muslimness.”

This old definition has formed the basis of the Conservatives’ concern with the government’s policy on this new one.

Read more: ‘Most dangerous’ time to be Muslim in UK, monitor says

Tory shadow equalities minister Claire Coutinho told Sky News: “I think we all need to be equal in the law and there is already protection in the law – if you are a victim of violence or harassment based on your religion – those protections are already in place.

“What I deeply worry about is putting one group on a pedestal and giving them special protections because that will only breed resentment.”

When pressed on why other protected groups should have a definition, she said: “With the antisemitism definition, there was an international consensus and it was combating a specific thing, which was Holocaust denial.

“If you look at this definition, it’s based on an earlier version and one of the things it said in 2018 was that even talking about the grooming gangs was a form of anti-Muslim hatred.”

Claire Coutinho. Pic: PA
Image:
Claire Coutinho. Pic: PA

British Muslims say they still face discrimination – and without a specific definition of Islamophobia, crimes can often go underreported. According to multiple monitoring groups, hate crimes have gone up significantly, with Home Office data showing a surge of 20% last year, making Muslims the target in nearly half of religion-based offences.

However, policy groups say the result of adopting a definition could be a “fundamental social and structural change” by the back door, without democratic consent.

The Policy Exchange thinktank claimed that if the government adopts a fixed definition, activists will use it to challenge counter-terrorism laws and undermine the Prevent programme, which aims to steer people away from extremism.

Ministers are set to decide in the coming weeks on what they will adopt in the report and whether it will be published, with Communities Secretary Steve Reed formally making the announcement when that decision is made.

A Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government spokesperson said: “We do not comment on leaks. The department is carefully considering the independent Working Group’s advice on a definition of anti-Muslim hatred/Islamophobia, and no government decisions have been made.

“We will always defend freedom of speech, including fiercely protecting the right to criticise, express dislike of, or insult religions and the beliefs and practices of those who follow them. This will remain at the front of our minds as we review the definition.”

Continue Reading

UK

The groundbreaking breeding programme that’s reducing methane in cow burps

Published

on

By

The groundbreaking breeding programme that's reducing methane in cow burps

Cows bred to produce less methane in their burps could prove to be an important ally in the fight against climate change, scientists have told Sky News.

A groundbreaking breeding programme in Scotland is proving so successful that the amount of the greenhouse gas produced by cattle when they belch or break wind could fall by 40% in just 20 years.

Cows and other farm animals produce at least 12% of global methane emissions, according to the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations.

But reducing levels could have a significant impact on global warming.

The gas traps 80 times more heat in the atmosphere than carbon dioxide in the first two decades after it’s released. But it breaks down after only 12 years – so reducing emissions would have rapid results.

Professor Mike Coffey, from Scotland’s Rural College, said calves born in the Cool Cows breeding programme produce 2% less methane than their parents.

“It’s permanent and cumulative. So once you’ve got an animal that produces less methane, she produces less for life,” he explained.

More on Climate Change

“When you mate her to a lower methane-producing bull her offspring produce even less than she did.

“And you just keep going on and on. Over 20 years, you can reduce it by 40%.”

Methane is produced from cows, sheep and other ruminant animals when microbes in their guts digest grass and other feed.

The amount of the gas released by animals varies, partly because of the number and type of bugs in their stomach. And that’s influenced by inherited genetic factors in the cattle.

A new DNA test made by the company Semex can predict which animals will produce less methane, allowing scientists to match up bulls and cows for the breeding programme.

IVF techniques are then used to produce five or six calves in surrogate mothers each year, rather than the one that would normally be possible.

It means scientists can pick the best animal to breed from, leading to more rapid methane reductions without any genetic modification.

‘Entirely vegan world not feasible’

Agriculture currently accounts for 10% of the UK’s greenhouse gas emissions, with the country’s nine million cows and calves a significant contributor.

The National Farmers’ Union has set a target of reducing greenhouse gas emissions to net zero by 2040.

Food sustainability experts say breeding cattle that produce less methane is a significant advance, but not enough.

Emma Garnett, from the University of Oxford, said livestock still produce large amounts of manure that also releases greenhouse gases.

“Yes, let’s make things more efficient if we can, because I don’t think an entirely vegan world is a feasible,” she said.

“But it must not be used as a smoke screen for not shifting to more plant-based diets. The most effective way to reduce methane from cows is to farm fewer cows.”

Read more from Sky News:
The beef market is in turmoil – and inflation is spiralling

Parkinson’s patient plays clarinet during brain surgery

Beef consumption has already fallen by 62% since 1980, according to recent government figures.

Much of that has been because of concerns over health and animal welfare, but in recent years the climate impacts of cattle farming have become more widely known.

However, cheese consumption is increasing.

Professor Coffey said: “If you choose to eat meat or dairy, we are trying to produce it with lower impact.

“Just like if you chose to drive a car, you can choose to drive a car that has less emissions or you can choose to go on the bus.

“What we are doing here is providing consumers a choice and farmers the tools to enable that choice to be made.”

Continue Reading

UK

UK weather: Four Met Office warnings in place as Storm Benjamin hits

Published

on

By

UK weather: Four Met Office warnings in place as Storm Benjamin hits

Yellow weather warnings for strong winds and heavy rain have been issued overnight – as Storm Benjamin sweeps through the UK.

The Met Office has issued four alerts – and has warned flooding, power cuts and travel disruption are possible.

Forecasters say damage to buildings is possible, with “a small chance of injuries and danger to life being caused by large waves” as the storm moves from the English Channel to the North Sea.

Britons who live in coastal areas are being urged to check their properties and “consider preparing a flood plan”.

Check the weather forecast where you are

The morning commute, for some, may be tricky. Filepic: PA
Image:
The morning commute, for some, may be tricky. Filepic: PA

A yellow warning for rain covering most of southern England, the East Midlands, parts of Wales and Yorkshire came into force at midnight and will expire at 6pm tonight.

Up to 30mm of rain is expected quite widely – rising to 50mm in some places, and even 90mm in isolated areas.

More on Weather

An additional alert covering East Anglia and Lincolnshire expires at 9pm.

Large parts of southeast England are also under a yellow warning for wind from 3am until midnight – with gusts of 50mph to 60mph widely possible, potentially rising to 70mph near coasts.

A final warning for wind applies in Cornwall, Devon and the west coast of Wales from 6am until 3pm.

Read more from Sky News:
Trump imposes sanctions on Russian oil firms
Nicolas Sarkozy targeted with death threats in prison

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Is UK ready for more extreme weather?

Chief meteorologist Rebekah Hicks said: “It is worth noting that there is a greater than usual uncertainty surrounding the track and intensity of this low pressure system.

“The public should stay up to date with the latest forecasts and warnings as the situation evolves, with adjustments to the forecasts likely at short notice.”

Storm Benjamin was named by Meteo France, the French national meteorological service.

Continue Reading

Trending