A man has pleaded guilty to murdering the wife and two daughters of racing commentator John Hunt in a crossbow attack.
Kyle Clifford, 26, from Enfield, was accused of stabbing Carol Hunt, 61, to death and fatally shooting Louise, 25, and Hannah Hunt, 28, with a crossbow at their family home in Bushey, Hertfordshire, on 9 July last year.
He pleaded guilty to two counts of possession of an offensive weapon, alongside the murder charges. He denied one count of rape and will face a trial for this charge later in the year.
Clifford had tied the arms and ankles of his former partner, Louise, with duct tape before he shot her through the chest with a crossbow bolt.
Her sister, Hannah, was found in the main doorway of the house with a crossbow bolt to the chest. She was still alive when police arrived at the property, having managed to call the emergency services, telling officers she feared she was going to die.
Their mother, Carol, sustained significant stab wounds to her knee, hands, back and torso after Clifford attacked her with a 10in butcher’s knife.
Following the deaths, Sky Sports and BBC racing commentator Mr Hunt said the devastation he and his surviving daughter Amy feel “cannot be put into words”.
Image: Kyle Clifford was discovered by police in Lavender Hill cemetery in Enfield, north London, following a large manhunt
Following the attacks, the Home Office said Home Secretary Yvette Cooper was urgently considering whether tougher crossbow laws were needed. But in the King’s Speech, which took place just days later, no proposal for action on the weapon was mentioned.
The previous government looked at bringing in firearms licensing-style rules in the wake of an attempt to kill the late Queen with a crossbow.
Image: Carol Hunt pictured with her husband John Hunt. Pic: Facebook
There is currently no registration system for owning a crossbow, but it is illegal for anyone under 18 to buy or own one, and carrying one in public without reasonable excuse can be punished by up to four years in prison.
A teenager who was planning a mass shooting at his old primary school has been jailed for life with a minimum term of 49 years for murdering his family.
Nicholas Prosper, from Luton, pleaded guilty to the murder of his mother, Juliana Falcon, 48, and his siblings, Kyle Prosper, 16, and 13-year-old Giselle Prosper at Luton Crown Court in February.
In sentencing, the judge said the words “heartless and brutal” were insufficient to describe the horror of the last moments suffered by his victims.
Their bodies were found at their flat in the town in September last year.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:44
Prosper, who was planning a mass shooting at his former primary school, was arrested after the phone call.
The 19-year-old planned to carry out a mass shooting at St Joseph’s Catholic Primary School, where Prosper and his siblings had been pupils, he admitted to police.
The court heard his aim was to be known as “the world’s most famous school shooter of the 21st century”.
Image: Giselle Prosper (left), Juliana Prosper (centre), Kyle Prosper (right) found dead in a flat in Luton, Leabank, on Friday 13 September 2024. Pic: family pics issued via Bedfordshire police
Police believe he killed his family when his mother found a shotgun he had bought using a fake certificate and confronted him.
His scheme was eventually foiled by officers who spotted him in the street immediately after the murders and arrested him.
The loaded shotgun was found hidden in bushes nearby, along with more than 30 cartridges.
Image: Nicholas Prosper holding a plank of wood as a mock firearm.
Pic: Bedfordshire Police/PA
Image: Prosper obtained the shotgun by deception. Pic: Bedfordshire Police
As his sentencing started on Tuesday, the court heard that “his planning was cold, deliberate and without sympathy or emotion towards the actual victims or potential victims”.
Judge Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said the details of Prosper’s case were “chilling”, and that he had wanted to emulate and outdo the US school massacres at Sandy Hook in 2012 and Virginia Tech in 2007.
His “main wish”, according to the prosecution, was notoriety, telling a prison nurse “I wish I had killed more”.
Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said Prosper had not hated his mother or siblings and had “had a good life with them”, but that his intention had been to kill them in their sleep and rape his sister.
“Each victim suffered the anguish of anticipating or being aware of the deaths of others,” she said.
In explaining why she had opted not to impose a whole-life sentence, the judge said: “A minimum term does not in any way equate to the value of the life of a murder victim, still less three such victims.”
She acknowledged that Prosper had autism spectrum disorder, but said she was satisfied that it did not affect his decision-making enough to be the primary reason why he carried out the killings.
“A murder spree with the sole aim of glorifying the name of the perpetrator in the history of mass killers is what you intended,” she said.
“You have also expressed no remorse and no sorrow. Indeed, when asked by the psychiatrist if you would try to commit another massacre, you replied: ‘Well, that’s their job to stop me getting the weapons if I get released’.“
Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb added: “Your plans were intelligent, calculated and unselfish. Your ambition was notoriety. You wanted to be known posthumously as the world’s most famous school shooter of the 21st century.
“Words such as heartless and brutal are insufficient to describe the horror of those last moments of the people who were closest to you.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
3:00
Officer DCI Sam Khanna says the Nicholos Prosper case is the most ‘distressing’ he’s ever worked on.
A statement from the family of the victims was read outside the court.
It said they now understood the deaths had “much more meaning and importance” because they “stopped any other family in the community going through the pain we have suffered”.
“For now, we would ask people to remember Juliana, Kyle and Giselle for the people they were. Julie was a strong, loving mother to her four children, who were her absolute world.
“Kyle was a kind and funny young man who loved football and boxing. He was a big talent with massive potential. Giselle was a beautiful soul and caring young girl with an infectious smile. She was also an exceptional pupil at school and was loved dearly by her friends.”
The final act of Juliana Falcon’s life, in the minutes before she was shot dead by her son, potentially saved dozens of others.
Realising the unthinkable about her child, her intervention was crucial in preventing him from carrying out what could have been one of the worst mass killings ever to happen in the UK.
Police believe Juliana spotted the shotgun and confronted her son about what he was up to, and there was a struggle as he began attacking his mother.
Her intervention changed everything.
Image: Giselle and Kyle Prosper (below) were both killed by their older brother. Pics: Bedfordshire Police
Prosper, 18, shot his mother dead with the firearm he had bought illegally less than 24 hours earlier.
Over the next few hours in the family’s eighth-floor flat in Luton, he also shot dead his 13-year-old sister, Giselle, and shot and repeatedly stabbed his 16-year-old brother, Kyle.
The noise of the killings alerted neighbours and meant police would be on their way, so Prosper’s plan had to be brought forward.
“My f****** mum messed it up,” he wrote down while in custody. “My mother is a f****** stupid cow.”
A plan for ‘notoriety’
Image: Prosper has admitted killing his family
Prosper left the flat at 5.30am on 13 September last year, hours before the school would open.
He had meticulously researched school massacres, was fascinated by violence and led a dysfunctional life online. He craved notoriety.
He took with him more than 30 shotgun cartridges which, he had calculated, would enable him to kill more children than any other school attack.
When he was arrested, he was on his way to his old primary school to target the youngest children there, aged just four and five.
Image: Prosper deceived a seller to obtain the shotgun. Pics: Bedfordshire Police
In a note he later wrote in prison, he confessed he “wanted to cause the biggest [school] massacre in the 21st century and be more famous than Sandy Hook”.
A total of 26 children were killed at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut, USA in 2012. The killer there had shot dead his own mother at home before going to the school.
Prosper’s mother’s actions in Luton, disturbing his plan early, denied him that appalling place in history.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
3:03
Killer ‘seemed really calm’ – neighbour
Senior investigating officer Detective Chief Inspector Sam Khanna, of Bedfordshire Police, told Sky News that Prosper’s ambition “was most definitely notoriety… to be known as being responsible for the biggest school shooting on record.”
He had researched in detail every shooting school shooting across the world “within the last 15, 20 years,” he said.
“He’d done his sums, and he wanted to be responsible for the most amount [of deaths]. Killing his family was the first part of it. But then going to a school and killing numerous children, teachers, then finally himself.”
Concerns raised
Image: St Joseph’s Catholic Primary, Prosper’s former school, was the intended target
Prosper was raised in Luton and had attended St Joseph’s Catholic Primary School, where he planned to carry out an attack three-quarters of a mile from his home.
Growing up, teachers thought he was a quiet, introverted boy, with a small group of friends who were interested in computers.
When he went to sixth form aged 16, staff noticed he had become more withdrawn.
The school raised concerns that he could be on the autism spectrum, but he refused to see a GP or accept any help.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:24
Prosper pretends plank of wood is a gun
DCI Khanna said “very little” was known of Prosper, and “there was certainly no Prevent referral”.
Prevent is the UK’s counter-terrorism programme designed to identify and stop young people being radicalised.
Both of Prosper’s parents “had expressed concerns to the school”, the detective said.
The school had shared those concerns, he said, “but because of his unwillingness to engage with mental health professionals, it didn’t go any further”.
A consultant forensic psychiatrist concluded the teenager shows “all the symptoms of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)” but that it was undiagnosed at the time of the killings. He said Prosper has “an extreme lack of empathy with others and an extreme lack of remorse”.
Image: Prosper was filmed buying the firearm. Pic: Bedfordshire Police
So how was an 18-year-old able to source a shotgun? The answer is by deception.
Prosper convinced a legitimate seller, who had only previously sold to registered firearms dealers, to deliver the weapon to him.
The teenager produced a convincing but fake shotgun certificate and paid the seller £650 in cash and an extra £30 petrol money to bring the gun and 100 shotgun cartridges to Luton the day before the killings.
Bedfordshire Police investigated and concluded the seller would not face criminal charges. He had been duped by Prosper.
DCI Khanna said Prosper “went to great lengths, looking at templates, looking at prototypes, getting police force logos, signatures, and having copies of genuine certificates, so he could produce what he thought would be good enough to enable him to obtain that shotgun – even down to the printing of the paper with watermarks”.
Prosper spent a lot of time online alone in his bedroom posting troubling comments supporting sexual relationships between adults and children and expressing other extreme views.
He had also become obsessed with the Walking Dead video game, and particularly a character called Clementine who is a vulnerable young girl.
Image: Detective Chief Inspector Sam Khanna, of Bedfordshire Police
Detectives can’t say if there is a direct link between his “avid use” of the game and the school shooting plan, but it is one aspect of a complex and unhealthy life he led online.
DCI Khanna said Prosper “certainly believed that he had some form of relationship with Clementine, albeit she’s a video game character”.
Police also found indecent images of children on Prosper’s devices.
The investigator said his online research of school massacres was persistent and extremely detailed.
“There’s a lot of talk about the dark web, but this was on the surface web and sites where… you can read manifestos of people that have done horrific acts. They shouldn’t be available to be seen.”
After his arrest, Prosper told a nurse at Bedford prison about his school massacre intentions. He had also written two detailed plans of what he intended to do at the primary school he used to attend.
“We didn’t find any evidence that he had harboured any grudges towards that particular school… it was purely around his knowledge of it,” DCI Khanna said.
After killing his family, he left home “with the right amount of cartridges to complete his plan, right down to the final detail”, he added.
“Once in prison, he has openly talked about the fact that that was his plan – to go to the school and kill children and teachers before finally killing himself.”
Prosper had chosen black and yellow clothes for the attack and as he made his way towards the school in Luton he was spotted by police officers on patrol.
They thought he was acting strangely and knew three members of the same family had been shot dead nearby.
“It’s not murder,” he repeatedly told the officers as they handcuffed him by the roadside.
Months later, he pleaded guilty shortly before he was due to stand trial.
Image: Prosper pictured walking to the school on the morning of his planned attack. Pic: Bedfordshire Police
Remembering the victims
The dilemma of whether to make his school shooting plan public has been difficult for police and prosecutors.
It is clearly deeply upsetting for the school community and they are mindful that Prosper craved attention and publicity, but it is also about challenging this kind of extreme behaviour online.
DCI Khanna’s investigation team has examined this “deeply troubling” case with the victims at the forefront of their minds.
“The family has really told us what wonderful people they were,” he said.
Juliana, he said, was “a doting mum who did a lot of work for charity and [was] a very keen runner”.
He described Giselle as “so popular amongst friends, a bright girl with an infectious smile”, while Kyle was a “funny young man, really into his sports and again very popular at school with his friends”.
Now, DCI Khanna said, the focus should be on the victims – “and how much they’ll be missed”.
The mother of a young soldier who took her own life says she has “sleepless nights” knowing there are abusers still serving in the Army.
A coroner ruled that the Army’s failure to take action after 19-year-old Royal Artillery Gunner Jaysley Beck was sexually assaulted by a more senior soldier and harassed by her line manager contributed to her death at Larkhill Camp in Wiltshire in 2021.
One of the men has since left the Army but the other continues to serve.
Image: Gunner Jaysley Beck was found dead at Larkhill Camp in Wiltshire in December 2021
Jaysley Beck’s mother, Leighann McCready, believes he has been protected by the Army.
“Why should they continue to carry on serving when we’re left absolutely heartbroken? We have to deal with this for the rest of our lives and it’s not fair. It’s absolutely not fair that no action’s been taken.”
Reacting to the announcement that claims of sexual harassment in the Army will be removed from the chain of command and instead dealt with by a new, specialist taskforce, Ms McCready said it was a “step in the right direction” but added that “it should have happened a long time ago”.
One former soldier described how, after reporting an alleged rape, she discovered the officers dealing with her case had called her a whore.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:57
‘Jaysley should still be here’
Ms McCready praised the hundreds of servicewomen who have spoken out since her daughter’s death and urged the Army to root out their abusers.
“This causes me sleepless nights to know that they’re still serving. It’s heartbreaking. It’s absolutely heartbreaking to think this is still going on.
“All I want now is for action, for real action to be taken and to continue with the change and continue speaking up”.
Image: Jaysley Beck and her mother Leighann McCready
A Ministry of Defence spokesperson said “the Army and MoD have undertaken to carefully analyse and assess all of HM Coroner’s findings into the tragic death of Gunner Jaysley-Louise Beck.
“There is no place for bullying, harassment, or discrimination in the military. This government is totally committed to making the reforms that are needed to stamp out inappropriate behaviour and hold people to account.”
On Tuesday the head of the Army, General Sir Roly Walker, told MPs “I absolutely recognise that we still have work to do. There are some recurring themes which we are addressing. Self-evidently, there continues to be a prevalence of bullying, harassment, and discrimination within our ranks.
“We have to recognise that there are some cultural and structural barriers still.”