The furore surrounding Michael Matheson’s near £11,000 iPad data roaming bill was “completely blown out of all proportion”, according to the shamed MSP.
The Falkirk West MSP had initially billed taxpayers before U-turning, claiming the device had only been used for parliamentary work during a family holiday to Morocco.
It later emerged his teenage sons had been using the work iPad as a hotspot to stream football while on the trip.
Mr Matheson, who was first elected as an MSP in 1999, was questioned about his ministerial career during an interview with the Institute for Government (IFG) think tank as part of its Ministers Reflect series.
During the talk, held in October last year but published on Friday, he said his opponents had sought to take “political advantage” of the situation.
More on Snp
Related Topics:
Mr Matheson said: “I think the thing that you need to realise is that when you become a minister, if you do make a mistake, you can end up in the eye of a political storm.
“The thing that acted as a big catalyst for me was that, as soon as the general election was called, everything was put on steroids.
“It became a massive issue because folk saw a political advantage they could get from it. It just got completely blown out of all proportion, in my view.”
Mr Matheson was the net zero, energy and transport secretary in Nicola Sturgeon’s government at the time of the family holiday around Christmas in 2022.
Ahead of the trip he failed to replace an outdated SIM card, which led to increased data use costs.
Mr Matheson, who was later appointed health secretary in March 2023 under then first minister Humza Yousaf, told Holyrood he was unaware that his sons had used the iPad as a hotspot when he initially submitted the bill.
Following his wife’s admission, Mr Matheson initially failed to publicly mention his sons’ involvement.
Instead, he continued to insist the iPad was only used for parliamentary work and blamed the outdated SIM card for the excessive bill.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:15
Mr Matheson’s sons racked up the near £11,000 iPad bill streaming football abroad
When questioned by journalists days after he knew the truth, he continued to deny the iPad was used for personal use until he made a statement to Holyrood.
Mr Matheson quit as health secretary ahead of the conclusion of a probe by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB), which ruled he had breached the MSP code of conduct.
When asked if there were any lessons to be learned for other ministers, he told the IFG: “If I look back, the lesson I would say is recognising how unforgiving the political space is that you’re operating in.
“In the end, it was my desire to try and avoid the press knowing about what my son had done.
“It was completely unforgiving, despite the fact that when you offer it up, then they say you’re using it as a cover. Actually, no, I’m not, but I’m telling you that’s what’s happened.
“So, I think what I would say to ministers is that it is quite unforgiving at times when something like that happens, despite what your background is and how long you’ve been in government and how you’ve always tried to avoid getting the government into any difficult positions.”
He added: “When you’re a backbencher, if you do make an error, it’s not the same.
“But when you’re a minister and you’re a senior minister, you’re going to get chased down and you quite literally get chased down.”
Mr Matheson said a number of people reached out in support during the scandal.
He also said the scrutiny had a “significant impact” on his family, which included taking his teenage sons out of school and his wife becoming “unwell with stress”.
He added: “It’s in the public record that our house got broken into.”
When questioned about Mr Matheson’s latest comments, First Minister John Swinney said: “The parliament’s worked its way through all of these issues and it’s come to its conclusions and those conclusions stand.
“We just have to consider that as the conclusion that parliament has arrived at.”
The Scottish Conservatives criticised Mr Matheson’s remarks.
MSP Rachael Hamilton, the party’s deputy leader, said: “Taxpayers will be outraged that Michael Matheson is trying to downplay the scandal that ultimately forced him to resign in disgrace.
“The public were rightly furious that the then SNP health secretary thought it acceptable to ask them to foot the bill for his [iPad] expenses.
“He then repeatedly lied to them and parliament and refused to say sorry for what he had done.
“No wonder Scots are so disillusioned with senior SNP figures at Holyrood when they continue to hold voters in such contempt.”
Singer and actress Marianne Faithfull has died at the age of 78.
A spokesperson for her music promotion company Republic Media said: “It is with deep sadness that we announce the death of the singer, songwriter and actress Marianne Faithfull.
“Marianne passed away peacefully in London today, in the company of her loving family.
“She will be dearly missed.”
Faithfull was best known for her 1964 hit As Tears Go By, written by Sir Mick Jagger, with whom she had a well-publicised relationship, and fellow Rolling Stones star Keith Richards.
She also starred in films including The Girl On A Motorcycle and 2007’s Irina Palm, for which she was nominated for a European Film Award for Best Actress.
In recent years, she provided voice work for the 2021 remake of Dune and 2023’s Wild Summon.
Instagram
This content is provided by Instagram, which may be using cookies and other technologies.
To show you this content, we need your permission to use cookies.
You can use the buttons below to amend your preferences to enable Instagram cookies or to allow those cookies just once.
You can change your settings at any time via the Privacy Options.
Unfortunately we have been unable to verify if you have consented to Instagram cookies.
To view this content you can use the button below to allow Instagram cookies for this session only.
She and Sir Mick began seeing each other in 1966 and became one of the most glamorous couples of Swinging London.
He paid tribute to his “wonderful friend and beautiful singer and a great actress”, and said he was “so saddened” by her death, as “she was so much part of my life for so long”.
Next to a picture of the pair arm in arm on Instagram, Sir Mick said Faithfull “will always be remembered”.
His Stones bandmates Ronnie Wood and Keith Richards also paid tribute, with Richards posting on Instagram that he was “so sad and will miss her.”
His post was accompanied by a picture of the pair enjoying a drink together.
Wood wrote on Jagger’s post: “Farewell dear Marianne.”
Instagram
This content is provided by Instagram, which may be using cookies and other technologies.
To show you this content, we need your permission to use cookies.
You can use the buttons below to amend your preferences to enable Instagram cookies or to allow those cookies just once.
You can change your settings at any time via the Privacy Options.
Unfortunately we have been unable to verify if you have consented to Instagram cookies.
To view this content you can use the button below to allow Instagram cookies for this session only.
Born in 1946, Faithfull started her singing career in 1964 after being discovered by the Stones’ manager Andrew Loog Oldham.
Her self-titled debut album was released a year later, with As Tears Go By reaching number nine on the UK singles chart.
She went on to have a string of successful singles, including Come And Stay With Me, This Little Bird, and Summer Nights, and famously dated Sir Mick from 1966 to 1970.
Faithfull was prolific throughout the 60s, releasing six albums – some only in the UK and some for the US – as well as contributing backing vocals to the Beatles’ Yellow Submarine and inspiring the Stones’ Sympathy For The Devil.
That decade also saw her star in films like 1967’s I’ll Never Forget What’s’isname – where she was one of the first people to say f*** in a mainstream studio film – 1968’s The Girl On A Motorcycle, and Tony Richardson’s 1969 adaptation of Hamlet.
Her affair with Sir Mick was notorious, with the couple being arrested in 1968 for possession of cannabis.
She was also infamously found by police wearing only a bear skin rug when they arrived for a drugs raid at Richards’ home in 1967.
After breaking up with the Stones frontman, Faithfull spent two years homeless in Soho while suffering from anorexia and heroin addiction, before she started living in a squat.
She wrote in her 1994 autobiography: “For me, being a junkie was an admirable life. It was total anonymity, something I hadn’t known since I was 17.
“As a street addict in London, I finally found it. I had no telephone, no address.”
In 1979, following success in Ireland with the country-themed Dreamin’ My Dreams, Faithfull released the Grammy-nominated Broken English – widely considered her best album.
She later achieved critical acclaim as a jazz and blues singer with 1987’s Strange Weather and went to rehab that same decade.
Faithfull released a total of 21 solo albums throughout her career. Her most recent was the spoken word album She Walks In Beauty from 2021, which saw her work with frequent Nick Cave collaborator Warren Ellis.
She made a full recovery from breast cancer in 2006.
The Home Office’s efforts to address violence against women and girls have not yet improved outcomes for victims, according to the public spending watchdog.
Described as a “significant and growing problem”, the National Audit Office (NAO) says one in 12 women can expect to experience some form of gender-based violence each year.
Around one in four women will be a victim of sexual or attempted assault in their lifetime.
Louise*, whose identity we have protected, says she suffered sexual and violent abuse at the hands of her former partner for seven years.
“He was a very jealous and controlling man,” she says.
The abuse would come in “different forms”, Louise explained. “Sometimes it was straight beatings. Other times it would be restraining and threatening with knives etc. And of course, there was the mental abuse.”
It’s been a few decades since her traumatising experience, and she says: “It’s incredibly depressing to hear things haven’t changed or moved on. I find that shocking.”
She now has three children who have more awareness about gender-based abuse and “understand things like gaslighting and coercive control”.
But she says now the culture has shifted, action needs to be implemented.
“Stop doing more research or yet another report which never gets acted on… We want action. My advice is you need to talk to victims, you need a victim-led solution,” Louise says.
Home Office did not lead ‘effective cross-government response’
After multiple high-profile cases of women and girls who died at the hands of abusers, the previous Conservative government introduced the Tackling Violence Against Women and Girls Strategy in 2021 and the Domestic Abuse Plan in 2022, both led by the Home Office.
However, a report by the NAO says the department did not lead an “effective cross-government response”.
Caroline Harper, who led the report, says this is partly due to the fact the Home Office “struggled to get other government departments on board”.
“There hasn’t been sufficient focus on prevention,” she adds.
She says while “supporting victims is really, really important, it would be much better if they didn’t become victims in the first place”.
Ministerial oversight group ‘only met four times in three years’
The report highlights a ministerial oversight group responsible for setting out the strategy “only met four times in three years”.
The prevalence of sexual assault against women aged 16 to 59 in England and Wales was 4.3% in 2023-24, up from 3.4% in 2009-10, the NAO said.
In that same period, incidents of rape and sexual assault against women and girls recorded by police rose from 34,000 to 123,000, although the NAO said this could partly be explained by improved recording of such crimes.
Past focus ‘not on measuring outcomes’
Isabelle Younane, head of external affairs at the Women’s Aid charity, says: “We really do welcome the intention of government and the strategy of ensuring a strong focus is on prevention and cross-government working.”
However, she adds: “We have not yet seen this translate into meaningful outcomes for women and girls on the ground.”
Ms Younane says in the past the focus has been on “measuring activities and whether those activities had been completed, not on measuring outcomes”.
A Home Office spokesperson highlighted that the NAO report looked at the “previous government’s work” and its “failure to deliver systemic change to deal with these devastating crimes”.
“We are delivering a step-change in the government’s response, as we work to deliver our unprecedented manifesto commitment to halve violence against women and girls in a decade,” they added.
Net Zero Secretary Ed Miliband will find the government’s support for a third Heathrow runway “uncomfortable” but he won’t cause any “disruption”, Harriet Harman has said.
Baroness Harman was a cabinet minister alongside Mr Miliband in Gordon Brown’s government when they approved an expansion in 2009, saying it was needed for economic reasons.
Mr Miliband had threatened to resign as energy and climate secretary over the plans but, in the end, he did not do so.
She added Mr Miliband “actually brought Keir Starmer into politics” and supported him for the leadership.
He will find the support for a third runway “uncomfortable”, Baroness Harman said.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:24
Government backs Heathrow expansion
“But he will be saying ‘if you’re going to do Heathrow, we better flipping well actually improve a lot of the other green things we’re doing and bring them forward’,” she added.
“So, I think he will stay in government, play a very important role for the green agenda, and I don’t think there will be a disruption.”