Connect with us

Published

on

Meta CEO, Mark Zuckerberg and Tesla and SpaceX CEO, Elon Musk

Manuel Orbegozo | Chip Somodevilla | Reuters

After news broke on the last day of January that Meta might follow Elon Musk’s lead in exiting Delaware to incorporate in another state, Democratic Governor Matt Meyer sprung into action.

Delaware has long been the dominant state for U.S. companies to incorporate due to its flexible corporate code and expert judiciary. More than 20% of the state’s tax revenue, amounting to more than $1 billion a year, has historically come from corporate franchise fees, so state lawmakers can ill afford to preside over a mass exodus, or what’s been dubbed a “DExit.”

On Saturday, Feb. 1, a day after the Wall Street Journal published its story on Meta considering a Delaware departure, Gov. Meyer, who was brand new to the job, convened an online meeting with attorneys from law firms that have represented Meta, Musk, Tesla and others in shareholder disputes in the state, according to public records obtained by CNBC. Other attendees included members of the Delaware legislature.

The purpose of the meeting was to have a “Discussion re: Corporate Franchise,” one memo said.

The following day, records show, Meyer invited a second group to meet with him and new Secretary of State Charuni Patibanda-Sanchez. That invitation went to Kate Kelly, Meta’s corporate secretary, and to Dan Sachs, the company’s senior national director of state and local policy.

The invite also went to James Honaker, an attorney with Morris Nichols, a firm that’s represented Meta in federal court in Delaware, and to William Chandler, former chancellor of the Delaware Court of Chancery, who is now part of Wilson Sonsini’s Delaware litigation practice.

Roughly two weeks later, Delaware lawmakers were being asked to vote on a a bill, known as SB 21, that, if enacted, would overhaul the state’s corporate law in a manner that could favor Musk, Zuckerberg and other controlling shareholders of large companies.

Read more CNBC tech news

Among other things, SB21 would alter how companies can use independent directors to ensure the deals they’ve made will not be subject to court scrutiny, and would limit the records that shareholders can obtain from companies when investigating possible breaches of fiduciary duty.

Late last week, the state Senate voted to pass an amended version of SB 21. If Delaware’s House of Representatives follows suit, in a vote expected as soon as Thursday, the bill would head to the governor’s desk to be signed into law.

That could remove a major overhang for Zuckerberg and Meta.

Meta has been the subject of “books and records” investigations in Delaware in recent months, according to two people directly involved in the matter who asked not to be named in order to discuss non-public investigations. Under current law, shareholders behind those probes could file cases alleging that Zuckerberg or other Meta directors caused billions of dollars in damages, according to the people and Delaware records viewed by CNBC.

Delaware Gov. Matt Meyer: The idea that the state is losing its corporate brand isn't accurate

If SB 21 passes, any claims filed after Feb. 17, the day the bill was brought to the assembly, would be considered under the new law. That means shareholders wouldn’t have the benefit of the current law, and investor protections that come with it, when their new claims are considered in Delaware court.

A Meta spokesperson declined to comment.

Mila Myles, a spokeswoman for Gov. Meyer, said in a statement that the governor has spent his first few weeks on the job meeting with “plaintiffs attorneys, Delaware corporate attorneys and countless Delaware incorporated companies,” adding that he is not “doing the bidding of any billionaire.”

Cozying up to Trump

Musk drew national attention to Delaware’s corporate law in 2024 after a judge there ruled that his $56 billion Tesla pay package from 2018 was illegally granted and should be rescinded. He wrote on X, “Never incorporate your company in the state of Delaware,” and subsequently moved Tesla to Texas while accusing the judge behind the ruling of “absolute corruption.

Musk also became a top donor to Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, and is now a lead adviser to his White House, running the so-called Department of Government Efficiency.

Zuckerberg, who had a notably rocky relationship with Trump during the president’s first term, has been publicly currying favor this go-round. He’s taken measures like ending Meta’s diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) programs, getting rid of third-party factcheckers in favor of a “Community Notes” model used by Musk’s X platform, and adding Dana White, CEO of the Ultimate Fighting Championship and a longtime friend of Trump, to his company’s board weeks before the new administration began.

Meta also agreed in January to pay $25 million to settle a four-year-old lawsuit over the company’s decision to suspend Trump’s accounts after the Jan. 6 Capitol riot.

News that Zuckerberg was considering a move out of Delaware landed a little over a week after President Donald Trump’s inauguration, which the Meta CEO attended along with other tech leaders.

Mark Zuckerberg arrives before the inauguration of Donald Trump as the 47th president of the United States takes place inside the Capitol Rotunda of the U.S. Capitol building in Washington, D.C., Monday, Jan. 20, 2025.

Kenny Holston | Via Reuters

Meta hasn’t publicly commented on whether it plans to reincorporate outside of the state.

As CNBC previously reported, authors of SB 21 included Richards, Layton & Finger, a corporate defense firm that counts Musk and Tesla as clients. It was co-written by Delaware Law School professor Lawrence Hamermesh, as well as Chandler, the ex-chancellor, and former Delaware Supreme Court Justice Leo Strine. 

Strine works for Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen and Katz, which is representing Zuckerberg in a separate matter tied to the company’s involvement in the 2018 Cambridge Analytica scandal. In 2019, Meta agreed to pay a $5 billion fine to settle related charges with the FTC.

SB 21 was introduced to Delaware’s General Assembly on Feb. 17, by Senate Majority Leader Bryan Townsend, who had attended the first of the two meetings held by Gov. Meyer. The process of drafting the bill didn’t follow Delaware’s traditional practice of changing corporate law, which typically involves writing and review by the state’s bar association, and a committee within it called the Corporation Law Council.

Reforms outlined in SB 21 have been supported by corporate defense firms and attorneys, including those who helped draft the bill. They’ve been vociferously opposed by shareholders’ attorneys and investment groups, including CalPERS and ICGN, who say they want to ensure that controlling shareholders don’t make self-interested deals or decisions that go against the wishes and rights of the broader investor base.

On Feb. 2, Myles from the governor’s communications office shared a memo with legislators and attorneys who had attended the weekend meetings. It included a list of talking points in defense of SB21.

The memo, obtained by CNBC, said Delaware prides itself on serving as “home to the world’s leading companies,” having the “best law and jurisprudence” for businesses, and remains the “premier destination in America for business formation.”

“Whenever an entity — regardless of size — exits Delaware for one of our sister jurisdictions, our goal is to earn their business back,” the memo said. “In many cases, companies that reincorporate out of Delaware return to Delaware.”

Read the public records here:

Ron Baron on Elon Musk: I'd hope that he would be 'a little less visible'

Continue Reading

Technology

Google, Apple hit with EU antitrust actions under cloud of Trump tariff threats

Published

on

By

Google, Apple hit with EU antitrust actions under cloud of Trump tariff threats

A man holds an Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max ahead of the launch of sales of the new iPhone 16 series smartphones in a store in Moscow, Russia September 20, 2024. 

Evgenia Novozhenina | Reuters

European Union regulators are taking steps to rein in Google and Apple on antitrust charges, even as U.S. President Donald Trump threatens to hit the bloc with tariffs for alleged “overseas extortion” of America’s tech giants.

This breaking news story is being updated.

Continue Reading

Technology

XRP surges after Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse says SEC is dropping its lawsuit against the company

Published

on

By

XRP surges after Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse says SEC is dropping its lawsuit against the company

A visual representation of the digital cryptocurrency, XRP.

S3studio | Getty Images

XRP surged after Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse said the Securities and Exchange Commission is no longer pursuing its appeal in the case against the payments company.

The price of XRP was last higher by nearly 14% at $2.57.

“It’s been almost four years and about three months since the SEC originally sued us, certainly a painful journey in lots of ways,” Garlinghouse said at the Digital Assets Summit in New York Wednesday morning. “I really deeply believed that we were going to be on the right side of the law and on the right side of history.”

“The system just feels broken. That we had to fight this fight for the industry and you had an SEC attacking the industry, particularly the Ripple case,” he continued. “There were no victims, there was no investor loss. They were just not acting in good faith.”

In 2020, the SEC sued Ripple for breaching U.S. securities laws by selling XRP without first registering it with the agency. The company scored a partial victory in 2023 when SEC. U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres handed down the decision, which was hailed as a landmark win for the crypto industry. Still, while XRP at that point was not considered a security when sold to retail investors on exchanges, it was considered an unregistered security offering if sold to institutional investors.

The development comes as the SEC moves quickly to reverse much of the damage in the crypto industry left by the previous administration. Last month the agency ended its enforcement case against Coinbase; closed its investigations into Robinhood’s crypto unit, Uniswap, Gemini and Consensys with no enforcement action; scaled back its crypto enforcement unit; and clarified that meme coins are not securities.

This week, the newly formed SEC crypto task force will kick off a roundtable series focused on defining the security status of digital assets.

XRP was created by the founders of Ripple in 2012. It is the native token of the open source XRP Ledger, which Ripple uses in its cross-border payments business – about 95% of which takes place outside the U.S. Ripple is the largest holder of XRP coins.

The coin was the biggest beneficiary of the post-election Trump trade. It’s up more than 400% since then and up 22% this year.

Don’t miss these cryptocurrency insights from CNBC Pro:

Continue Reading

Technology

Tencent fourth-quarter profit surges 90% on gaming and advertising boost

Published

on

By

Tencent fourth-quarter profit surges 90% on gaming and advertising boost

Chinese tech company Tencent is a gaming giant and the parent company of WeChat, the ubiquitous social messaging app in China.

Cheng Xin | Getty Images News | Getty Images

Tencent on Wednesday posted a fourth-quarter beat on top and bottom line driven by a surge in gaming and advertising revenue.

Here’s how Tencent did in the fourth quarter of 2024 versus Refinitiv estimates:

  • Revenue: 172.4 billion Chinese yuan ($23.9 billion), versus 168.9 billion yuan expected.
  • Profit attributable to equity holders of the company: 51.3 billion yuan, compared with 46.03 billion yuan expected.

Revenue rose 11% year-on-year while profit was up 90% versus the same period in 2023.

Tencent is known as one of the world’s biggest gaming firms. Domestic games revenue in China rose 23% year-on-year to 33.2 billion yuan in the fourth quarter. Tencent said this hike was due to a low base in the prior year’s period, as well as growth in some of its hit games, including Honour of Kings and Peacekeeper Elite.

The annual growth rate for domestic games accelerated in the December quarter, compared with the previous three-month period.

International games revenue jumped 15% year-on-year to 16 billion. Over the past few years, Tencent has stepped up efforts overseas with games like PUBG Mobile, as the domestic games market slowed amid macroeconomic and regulatory headwinds.

While Tencent is one of the world’s biggest gaming companies, the tech giant has also placed a large focus on becoming a key artificial intelligence player in China over the last two years, putting out various AI models.

On Tuesday, the company launched its Hunyuan3D-2.0 model which can turn text or images into 3D graphics. In February, Tencent had unveiled Turbo S, an AI model designed to answer user queries as quickly as possible.

Investors are still watching as to how Tencent plans to monetize its AI investments.

The Shenzhen-headquartered firm’s AI push is emblematic of the current state of competition among China’s tech giants, which has been spurred on by startup DeepSeek and its highly efficient artificial intelligence model that was released earlier this year.

AI updates have been released thick and fast from companies including Alibaba and Baidu.

Last week, Alibaba launched a new version of its AI assistant app that will be powered by its own Qwen AI reasoning model. Baidu on Sunday released two new models including a new reasoning model.

Tencent is working with its own AI models as well as those of rivals. The company has its in-house AI chatbot called Yuanbao, which is based on its own Hunyuan foundational model as well as DeepSeek’s R1. Tencent has also sought to integrate DeepSeek’s technology across some of its other products, including WeChat’s search features in China.

This breaking news story is being updated.

Continue Reading

Trending