Rebekah Vardy loses appeal after claiming Coleen Rooney’s lawyers ‘deliberately’ understated costs during libel case
Rebekah Vardy has lost an appeal after claiming Coleen Rooney’s lawyers “deliberately” understated some of their client’s costs during the “Wagatha Christie” libel case.
The high-profile court case took place after Mrs Rooney, wife of former Man Utd striker Wayne Rooney, accused Mrs Vardy on social media in 2019 of leaking her private information to the press.
Mrs Vardy, wife of Leicester City striker Jamie Vardy, unsuccessfully tried to sue Mrs Rooney in a libel battle in 2022 that captivated some areas of the public and was later dramatised for TV.
The judge ordered Mrs Vardy to pay 90% of Mrs Rooney’s costs, including an initial payment of £800,000.
Both women are now in a further dispute over how much Mrs Vardy should pay in legal costs as a result.
In October last year, a specialist costs judge ruled Mrs Rooney’s lawyers did not commit misconduct after they were accused by Mrs Vardy’s legal team of understating some of her costs.
Mrs Vardy appealed against the decision last month while Mrs Rooney’s lawyers claimed the challenge was “misconceived”.
In a ruling on Thursday, High Court judge Mr Justice Cavanagh dismissed the appeal.
He said: “The appeal must fail on the basis that the judge was entitled to reach the conclusion that he came to.”
A hearing last October was told that Mrs Rooney’s claimed legal bill – £1,833,906.89 – was more than three times her “agreed costs budget of £540,779.07”.
Jamie Carpenter KC, for Mrs Vardy, said that this was “disproportionate”, and that the earlier “understatement” of some costs was “improper and unreasonable” and used to “attack the other party’s costs”.
However, Senior Costs Judge Andrew Gordon-Saker said that while there was a “failure to be transparent” by Mrs Rooney’s legal team, he found “on balance and, I have to say, only just” that they had not committed wrongdoing.
In written submissions for the appeal against the decision last month, Mr Carpenter said Mrs Rooney “very substantially understated” her costs by around 40% in her budget, known as a “precedent H”, in 2021, and that the amount Mrs Vardy should pay should therefore be reduced.
Benjamin Williams KC, for Mrs Rooney, said in his written submissions that her budget was “properly and correctly completed” and there was “no tenable case” of misconduct.
In a separate ruling on Thursday, Mrs Vardy largely lost a bid for access to more documents in relation to costs.
Her lawyers asked the court in February to order Mrs Rooney’s team to hand over “privileged” documents, details about her claim for VAT, and further information about retainers between Mrs Rooney and her solicitors.
Mrs Rooney’s lawyers resisted the bid, describing it as a “fishing expedition”.
Read more from Sky News:
Inside missile defence base protecting Europe
Striking bin workers urged to accept deal
Over 1,000 Cabinet Office jobs to be axed
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
From 2022: The Wagatha Christie trial – explained
On Thursday, Senior Costs Judge Mark Whalan said he was “not persuaded” Mrs Vardy’s lawyers should be allowed to inspect VAT documents, or other privileged material.
But he ruled they should be allowed to see a redacted retainer between Mrs Rooney and her solicitors.
Judge Whalan also ordered Mrs Vardy to pay almost £11,000 of costs of the application, stating that he must “conclude realistically” that it “is the defendant and not the claimant” who had been successful.
After the rulings, a spokesperson for Mrs Vardy said: “In terms of the two judgments today, we are gratified disclosure has been obliged in one ruling whilst being respectfully disappointed that, in the other judgment, our appeal was not successful.
“Now we just wish to move on and look to the future. We will be making no further comment at this time.”
A woman who was stabbed to death in north London has been named by police – as a man was arrested on suspicion of murder.
Pamela Munro, 45, was found with a stab wound and died at the scene in Ayley Croft, Enfield, on Saturday evening, the Metropolitan Police said.
A 29-year-old man was arrested on suspicion of murder on Monday and is in custody, the force added.
Detective Chief Inspector Neil John said: “Investigating officers have worked relentlessly across the weekend to investigate the circumstances around Pamela’s death.
“We continue to support her family who are understandably devastated.”
Police at the scene at Ayley Croft in Enfield
Read more from Sky News:
Fresh appeal over student’s murder
100 firefighters battle flats blaze
The Met Police has asked anyone with information or who was driving through Ayley Court between 6.30pm and 7.30pm on Saturday and may have dashcam footage to contact the force.
-
Sports2 years ago‘Storybook stuff’: Inside the night Bryce Harper sent the Phillies to the World Series
-
Sports1 year agoStory injured on diving stop, exits Red Sox game
-
Sports1 year agoGame 1 of WS least-watched in recorded history
-
Sports2 years agoMLB Rank 2023: Ranking baseball’s top 100 players
-
Sports4 years ago
Team Europe easily wins 4th straight Laver Cup
-
Environment2 years agoJapan and South Korea have a lot at stake in a free and open South China Sea
-
Environment2 years agoGame-changing Lectric XPedition launched as affordable electric cargo bike
-
Business3 years agoBank of England’s extraordinary response to government policy is almost unthinkable | Ed Conway