Two men have been found guilty of cutting down the famous Sycamore Gap tree that stood for more than 150 years.
Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers were convicted of causing more than £620,000 worth of damage to the tree and more than £1,000 worth of damage to Hadrian’s Wall in Northumberland.
On 27 September 2023, the pair drove 30 miles through a storm to Northumberland from Cumbria, where they both lived, before felling the tree overnight in a matter of minutes.
Image: The Sycamore Gap tree before it was cut down. Pic: CPS
The pair each denied two counts of criminal damage to the sycamore and to Hadrian’s Wall, which was damaged when the tree fell on it, but were convicted by a jury at Newcastle Crown Court on Friday.
The Sycamore Gap tree sat in a dip in the landscape and held a place in pop culture, featuring in the 1991 Kevin Costner film Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves.
It also formed part of people’s personal lives, as the scene of wedding proposals, ashes being scattered and countless photographs.
Image: Adam Carruthers. Pic: Northumbria Police/PA
In the clip, the sound of a chainsaw can be heard, and the silhouette of a person can be seen, before the trunk eventually tumbled.
The footage was shot on Graham’s iPhone 13, with the metadata providing the coordinates of the tree.
Part of tree kept as ‘trophy’
Over the course of the trial, the pair blamed one another, but the prosecution argued they were both responsible for what the court heard was a “mindless act of vandalism”.
As well as the video footage of the felling, an image of a piece of wood and a chainsaw was found on Graham’s phone.
Image: Adam Carruthers (R) and Daniel Graham (L) worked together felling trees. Pic: CPS/PA
Image: An image of a piece of wood and a chainsaw was found on Graham’s phone. Pic: PA
Richard Wright KC, prosecuting, told the court: “This was perhaps a trophy taken from the scene to remind them of their actions, actions that they appear to have been revelling in.”
Voice notes played in court
The jury was also played voice notes the pair had sent one another, commenting on the media coverage the incident was receiving.
In one of them, Graham, 39, said to 32-year-old Carruthers: “Someone there has tagged like ITV News, BBC News, Sky News, like News News News”, before adding: “I think it’s going to go wild.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:34
Sycamore Gap seeds saved
Another piece of evidence was a photo of the defendants felling a different tree, about a month before the Sycamore Gap was cut down.
The prosecution said Graham, who owned a groundworks company and Carruthers, who worked in property management and mechanics, were “friends with knowledge and experience in chainsaws and tree felling”.
From the beginning, much of the trial focused on the significance of the tree, with Judge Mrs Justice Lambert telling the jury to put their “emotion to one side” before proceedings began.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
0:42
Voicenotes from Sycamore Gap tree trial
‘Mindless acts of violence’
Northumberland Superintendent Kevin Waring, of Northumbria Police, said: “We often hear references made to mindless acts of vandalism – but that term has never been more relevant than today in describing the actions of those individuals”.
Graham and Carruthers gave no explanation for why they targeted the tree, he said, “and there never could be a justifiable one”.
Northumbria Police and Crime Commissioner, Susan Dungworth, called the felling of the tree “unfathomable” and said, although “there was no remorse [from the defendants], there was compelling evidence, and now there will be justice”.
Gale Gilchrist, chief crown prosecutor for CPS North East, said Graham and Carruthers took “under three minutes” to bring down the “iconic landmark” in a “deliberate and mindless act of destruction”.
She said she hoped the community “can take some measure of comfort in seeing those responsible convicted”.
‘Enormity of the loss’
Reflecting on the verdict and the actions of the pair, Tony Gates, chief executive of Northumberland National Parks Authority, said: “It just took a few days to sink in – I think because of the enormity of the loss.
“We knew how important that location was for many people at an emotional level, almost at a spiritual level in terms of people’s connection to this case.”
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
The tree’s stump still sits by Hadrian’s Wall, where new shoots have been emerging.
Its largest remaining section will go on display at the National Landscape Discovery Centre in the Northumberland National Park later this year.
The effort to preserve the tree’s legacy also goes beyond the region where it stood.
Forty-nine saplings taken from the tree have been conserved by the National Trust. They will be planted in accessible public spaces across the country as “trees of hope”, which will allow parts of the Sycamore Gap to live on.
The defendants, who didn’t react when the verdicts were delivered, will be sentenced in July.
We’re sat in a silent, empty, cardiac treatment room – on the other side of the door, you can hear the bustle of the largest A&E and major trauma ward in Devon.
Ambulances arrive, patients are wheeled on stretchers, families wait pensively.
Consultant Dr Anne Hicks, from Derriford Hospital in Plymouth, is with me – she’s worked in emergency care for more than 30 years.
There is a long pause when I ask what the hardest part of her job is.
“I don’t think it’s looking after the trauma patients,” she says.
“The toughest part is talking to the relatives. I get huge satisfaction from doing it well – but I can remember the face of every relative I think I’ve ever spoken to.”
She, like many of her colleagues, has had to tell the parents of teenagers killed in car crashes the worst news.
“The tragedy is nothing to what that parent feels when you tell them their child has gone. That their child has died.”
Image: Consultant Dr Anne Hicks
This is the so-called ripple effect – so many lives impacted by deaths on our roads, beyond the immediate family.
Sky News has spent the last year reporting on a long-running campaign – led by grieving families – to get the government to toughen rules on new young drivers within its Road Safety Strategy, which is set to be announced soon.
But as well as relatives, there is a whole other group impacted by deaths on Britain’s roads.
Emergency service workers are often the first to arrive at some of the most horrific and distressing scenes.
We’ve been given access inside Derriford Hospital in Plymouth and Devon Air Ambulance – to understand how frontline workers deal with such trauma.
Grant Thompson is a paramedic with the air ambulance team based at Exeter Airport. We’re inside the medical stockroom, used to refill the chopper after each callout.
He remembers a callout last summer.
‘A shock to the system’
Image: Grant Thompson, a paramedic with the air ambulance team based at Exeter Airport
“It was one of those jobs when you’re not expecting, I suppose, what you’re going to see,” he says.
“We started realising this was going to be a bad job. You started thinking, ‘how are we going to split up as a team?’We got there reasonably quickly and three of these young people actually died at the scene, which was quite difficult.
“It was trying to give the best care you can for everybody – they were quite severely injured. It’s always a shock to the system when you get to those jobs. It can be tricky. It can be tricky.”
Those three young deaths were among more than 1,600 on Britain’s roads last year – with nearly 130,000 injured.
Some 22% of those fatalities involved a young person behind the wheel.
New data released by the Department for Transport also shows male drivers aged 17-24 are four times more likely to be killed or seriously injured than all drivers aged over 25.
Death is one thing, life-changing injuries another.
Inside the major trauma unit at Derriford, ward manager Larissa Heard says she’s seen the “whole scale” of reaction.
“Some patients are amazingly resilient and take it really well – for others it is absolutely life-changing, and they are hysterical,” she says.
“This could be the first time that they’re actually seeing their injuries in full light. It might be the first time that they’re actually aware they’ve had an amputation or are actually paralysed.
“So having to manage that for us can be really hard.”
Image: Devon air ambulance workers
‘It’s only afterwards the impact hits you’
As we chat, an 18-year-old who has lost a leg in a car crash pushes himself past us; staff say there are always victims of RTCs on the ward.
Treating the physical and mental scars of collisions is, of course, their job.
Like all those in the NHS, that responsibility comes first.
“I don’t think you feel it until you get the lovely thank-you cards at the end, and you find out the patients you looked after knew your name,” says Catie Crisp, a trainee advanced clinical practitioner.
“It’s only afterwards the impact hits you: ‘I can take a deep breath now, that was really hard, that was really emotional.'”
Image: Catie Crisp, a trainee advanced clinical practitioner
A possible solution?
Like the families who lost children, emergency workers would welcome any measure that could reduce the number of young people injured and killed.
Graduated driving licences (GDLs) place restrictions on new young drivers in the first few months of driving, such as a ban on driving late at night and with a car full of people – factors so often part of fatal accidents.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
2:18
What are graduated driving licences?
In Canada, one of the first countries to introduce GDLs, it takes at least 20 months to gain a full driving licence, with learners earning certain freedoms in stages. Deaths among young drivers are down 83% in the five years to 2022, compared to the same period before GDLs were brought in.
For emergency consultant Dr Tim Nutbeam, introducing a similar scheme would be a step in the right direction:
“I believe in evidence informed practice and for me the evidence from Canada, from other parts of the world is really strong. I believe GDL saves lives.
“I’ve got four children. One of them in a couple of years will be driving. I as a parent will be making sure a similar structure to GDL is in place to try to keep her safe.”
Image: Dr Tim Nutbeam
But the Department for Transport says it is not considering them.
A spokesperson told Sky News: “Every death on our roads is a tragedy and our thoughts are with everyone who has lost a loved one in this way.
“Whilst we are not considering graduated driving licences, we absolutely recognise that young people are disproportionately victims of tragic incidents on our roads and continue to tackle this through our THINK! campaign.
“We are considering other measures to address this problem and protect young drivers, as part of our upcoming strategy for road safety – the first in over a decade.”
‘They need to reconsider’
For those representing emergency service workers, the government’s position must change.
“In my view, the evidence is overwhelming that they need to reconsider it,” says Philip Secombe – the joint lead on road safety for the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners.
“We need to look at not restricting our young drivers, but actually safeguarding them, and their passengers and other road users.”
Back at the Devon Air Ambulance base, Grant explains how the ripple effect can spread far and wide.
“The loss of any life is tragic and affects a lot of people and clinicians as well, but I think when there’s a young person who survives as well, they’ve got to walk with that for the rest of their lives, 60 odd years or whatever it’ll be, that you’ve got to carry that with you – and more than likely it’d be one of your friends.
“I just hope that shapes people’s attitudes to save driving. You know, these are my mates, my best mates in the world, in my car, I need to adapt my driving to come out safe of this.”
Sir Keir Starmer says AI will improve public services, put money in your pocket, create jobs and improve your children’s future.
Politicians are betting the house on it – but how much are they actually spending? And on what?
Sky News asked consultancy Tussell, which analyses government contracts and spending, to help find out.
Image: AI is kind of a big deal for the prime minister. Pic: PA
Over £3.35bn is the overall spend by government departments on AI contracts, infrastructure and services, since the technology first really appeared on the scene in about 2018. The number of contracts has been going up each year.
The biggest by far is a 2021 contract by the Met Office with Microsoft to build the world’s most powerful weather and climate forecasting supercomputer, plus a few small contracts for departments to use its Copilot AI.
It’s worth more than £1bn overall.
Another big contract is for Init – the German public transport technology company – with Transport for London, worth £259m.
But this might be surprising: one of the smallest recipients is Alphabet.
The company behind Google, and a massive AI investor, has just two contracts with the Cabinet Office and the Ministry of Justice, worth £2.5m.
Fellow US firm Palantir has lots of smaller value contracts – 25 in total, worth £376m.
Its UK boss, Louis Mosley told Sky News that Palantir is helping junior doctors draft discharge summaries. And in defence, it helps intelligence officers collate information and process it more quickly.
Asked whether people were right to be concerned about big AI companies coming in and using their data, he replied: “Those are very legitimate concerns, and they’re right to interrogate this, but Palantir is actually the answer to those problems. We are the way you keep data secure, and we are the way you make AI transparent and auditable”.
‘Ministers need to be brave’
However, Mr Mosley said the government could go further.
“What they’re saying publicly is what they’re saying privately, but the challenge is always a fear of change,” he said.
“And in this case, you’ve got to embrace change. And ministers need to be brave. They need to take on the system and tell them this is the way things need to work today.
“There is a lot of fear that tomorrow I’m going to have to do a different thing to what I was doing yesterday.”
Who’s spending the most?
Sky News also looked at which departments have the biggest spending on AI. They are science and technology, which has the Met Office contract, and transport with the Init deal.
But the biggest, most data-intensive departments feature low down the table.
The Treasury, which encompasses the taxman, and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), which handles benefits, are in the bottom three.
The DWP has an annual IT budget of over a billion pounds a year, yet has spent less than £100m cumulatively since 2018 on AI.
Industry insiders blame a short-term government mindset, lack of IT expertise and backwards technology – up to 60% of some bits of government are running on legacy, older versions, of IT.
The areas of government where a revolution could save us the most money appear largely as yet unexplored. The AI journey has barely begun.
Prince William has talked about the need for more good leaders, as well as putting on a display of his less serious side, on the first day of his tour to Brazil.
William, who is in the country all week for both his annual Earthshot Awards on Wednesday and COP30, the UN’s climate conference, started his trip with a penalty shootout at the iconic Maracana Stadium in Rio, before heading to Copacabana Beach to kick off his shoes and take part in a volleyball game.
Image: Pics: PA
On Tuesday, he will focus more heavily on his environmental work with a series of visits.
On Monday morning, he was welcomed to Rio with an honour reserved for the carnival king – the keys to the city.
Standing on top of Sugarloaf Mountain with a bird’s eye view of the city and the iconic Christ the Redeemer statue, he was greeted by the mayor of Rio, Eduardo Paes.
Speaking about the significance of the key ceremony, he joked, “So he’s got the keys, he can do whatever he wants in the next 72 hours. The city belongs to Prince William. I’m still the king, but it will belong to him!”
William’s legacy goals
Ticking off some of the city’s most iconic locations, he met with Brazilian football legend Cafu at the Maracana.
Image: Pic: PA
He enlisted his help to highlight his Earthshot Awards, as they joined an event for young environmental campaigners and entrepreneurs.
Speaking to one group, William talked about the need for more good leaders, saying: “I need to work out how do I speed that up, but you guys are my hope, you’ve got the passion, the ambition that’s what this needs.”
He added: “That’s what I hope my legacy will be, in a few years time you’re kind of household names.”
Image: Pic: PA
William then went pitch side and met children learning about the environment and climate change through the sport-based organisation Terra FC.
The prince ended his football drills by taking a penalty against keeper Pedro Enrique, 14, and was mobbed by youngsters wanting a high-five after he scored.
Pedro said afterwards: “I was scared and nervous but very excited as he was most the famous person to take a penalty kick. I didn’t let him score. It was a good penalty.”