
A big bullpen bust in L.A.? Is Soto unlucky? Are the O’s cooked? An early verdict on 2025 disappointments
More Videos
Published
2 months agoon
By
admin-
David SchoenfieldJun 4, 2025, 07:00 AM ET
Close- Covers MLB for ESPN.com
- Former deputy editor of Page 2
- Been with ESPN.com since 1995
It’s early June, meaning we’re more than a month away from the All-Star break and still have the dog days of August ahead of us. Even though that serves as a reminder that the 162-game baseball campaign is a long grind, we’re still more than a third of the way through the season.
With enough of a sample size now under our belt, it’s fair to ask: What’s going on with some of MLB’s biggest early disappointments?
Though there’s still time to turn things around, let’s dig into some of the teams and stars that have struggled so far in 2025. For each one, we’ll make a statement derived from their performance the first two months of the season — and determine whether it’s real or not real.
Players
Juan Soto isn’t the $765 million star the New York Mets had hoped he’d be
The right fielder is hitting .233/.361/.438 with 11 home runs and 30 RBIs in 60 games, decent enough numbers if you were Jay Bruce or Marlon Byrd or Ryan Church, to name a few 21st century Mets right fielders. But Soto isn’t getting paid to be decent, and while Mets fans had shown a lot of patience with him, he did finally start receiving a few boos. He homered a couple times against the lowly Colorado Rockies last weekend to snap a 17-game skid where he hit .143 with no home runs — and homered off of Clayton Kershaw on Tuesday for his fifth straight game with an extra-base hit.
Now, there has been some talk about Soto just hitting into bad luck. Statcast tracks the exit velocity and launch angle of each batted ball to project expected results based on similar balls in play — and Soto’s numbers are way below where they “should” be:
2025 expected average: .299
2025 actual average: .233
2024 average: .288
2025 expected slugging: .590
2025 actual slugging: .438
2024 slugging: .569
His expected numbers look a lot more like his actual numbers from 2024 — but, of course, he’s getting paid to produce real results, not theoretical ones.
Has it just been bad luck though?
Here’s a quick rundown of 15 of his hardest-hit balls that weren’t ground balls and resulted in outs:
April 30: 112.7 mph, 16-degree launch angle, expected batting average of .750
Result: Lineout to deep right-center — right fielder Corbin Carroll shaded way over in the gap.
April 13: 112.4 mph, 11-degree LA, expected BA of .910
Result: Lineout to shortstop — the ball bounced off the top off the glove of a leaping Jacob Wilson and he caught the deflection.
May 7: 110.2 mph, 15-degree LA, expected BA of .840
Result: Lineout right to Arizona Diamondbacks center fielder Alek Thomas.
May 27: 109.9 mph, 19-degree LA, expected BA of .840
Result: Chicago White Sox outfielder Michael Taylor made a spectacular diving catch in right-center field.
May 9: 106.5 mph, 17-degree LA, expected BA of .910
Result: Chicago Cubs left fielder Ian Happ made a leaping grab.
April 30: 106 mph, 45-degree LA, expected BA of .190
Result: Towering routing fly ball to left field.
May 4: 105.9 mph, 31-degree LA, expected BA of .890
Result: St. Louis Cardinals center fielder Victor Scott robs a home run.
April 1: 104.8 mph, 18-degree LA, expected BA of .550
Result: Lineout right to the center fielder.
May 21: 104.7 mph, 30-degree LA, expected BA of .850
Result: Fly out to the warning track in deep left-center at Fenway.
April 29: 104 mph, 17-degree LA, expected BA of .470.
Result: Another lineout right to Alek Thomas in center field.
April 6: 103.2 mph, 19-degree LA, expected BA of .450.
Result: Easy catch for Toronto Blue Jays right fielder George Springer.
May 24: 102.5 mph, 28-degree LA, expected BA of .790
Result: Caught on the warning track by the center fielder.
May 4: 102 mph, 30-degree LA, expected BA of .690
Result: Fly out to the warning track in left field.
May 4: 99.7 mph, 35-degree LA, expected BA of .350
Result: Caught at the fence by the right fielder.
There were only three robberies that would easily classify as bad: Taylor’s amazing catch in which it almost appeared he trapped the ball, Scott’s leaping grab to rob Soto of a home run, and Wilson managing to corral Soto’s low liner up the middle. He had a few liners hit right to fielders, but every hitter registers some of those throughout a season.
Some of the balls in play had surprisingly high expected batting averages given the rather routine nature of the actual contact. For instance, the high fly ball at Fenway on May 21, just to the left of center field, went an estimated 376 feet. Statcast says it wouldn’t have been a home run in any of the 30 major league parks and it was an easy catch for Red Sox center fielder Ceddanne Rafaela, yet Statcast gave it an expected batting average of .850. My guess is most balls hit that hard at that launch angle (30 degrees) are pulled, creating a higher home run expectancy than a ball hit to center. (The wind was blowing in from right that night, although at just 3 mph, so that was only a small effect.) Soto had a couple of similar balls to left field that were also routine plays yet registered a high expected batting average.
Indeed, what we’ve seen here is hard contact — but a mix of low line drives or towering fly balls. Soto ranks in just the 23rd percentile in launch angle sweet spot (balls hit between 8 and 32 degrees), although his overall rate of 30.6% isn’t too much lower than last year’s 35.4% rate.
Is it possible the issue might be bad luck on grounders? Nope. He’s hitting .366 on hard-hit grounders (95-plus mph) compared to .293 in 2024 (and .187 on all grounders compared to .199 in 2024).
In the end, the difference is in fly ball production, according to TruMedia data:
2024: .405 average, 1.373 slugging
2025: .317 average, 1.098 slugging
(Soto actually has a slightly higher rate of hard-hit fly balls this season, 72.7% to 68.8%.)
One thing worth noting is that Soto’s expected numbers have been better than his actual numbers each of the past three seasons:
2024: .316 xBA, .646 xSLG (.288/.569 actual)
2023: .284 xBA, .538 xSLG (.275/.519 actual)
2022: .266 xBA, .501 xSLG (.242/.452 actual)
Verdict: Not Real
Look, we can debate the merits of the contract considering Soto’s lack of defensive and baserunning value. But the Mets aren’t paying him for those things, they’re paying him to hit — and he’ll be fine, even if it feels a little lazy to just call his start “bad luck.” He has hit a few extra grounders, a few extra balls to the left side instead of his pull side and, yes, has had a few hits stolen from him. Soto should put up big numbers the rest of the way and, luckily, the Mets have played well despite his slow start. This could be a really scary lineup when he heats up.
Soto was ESPN’s top free agent this past offseason, of course, and he’s not the only big free agent who has struggled so far (just the highest paid). Others have battled injuries (Blake Snell, Sean Manaea, Tyler O’Neill), control problems (Roki Sasaki, Yusei Kikuchi), PED suspensions (Jurickson Profar) or just recently went down after hot starts (Corbin Burnes, Alex Bregman).
Then we have Adames and Santander. Adames, who was No. 4 in ESPN’s free agent rankings, signed a seven-year, $182 million contract with the San Francisco Giants and is hitting .203/.293/.320 with five home runs and minus-0.2 WAR. Santander, who signed a five-year, $92.5 million deal with the Blue Jays, is hitting .179/.273/.304 with six home runs and minus-0.9 WAR.
Those two had similar profiles: low-average sluggers with some volatility to their offensive profiles plus concerns about their defense over the life of their contracts. Adames might already be playing himself off shortstop in just the first year of a seven-year deal, which doesn’t bode well for Buster Posey’s first big move as chief executive, especially with Matt Chapman locked into third base. Adames ranks in the 11th percentile in outs above average and last among shortstops with minus-7 defensive runs saved (and he wasn’t good in this category last season either). The Giants would live with below-average defense if Adames hit 32 home runs the way he did last season with the Milwaukee Brewers, but the offense hasn’t been there either.
Santander had 44 homers in 2024 with the Baltimore Orioles, but that felt like a career season for a player who doesn’t have elite exit velocity. Indeed, Santander’s hard-hit rate has fallen from the 77th percentile in 2023, to 60th in 2024, to 41st in 2025. He has made more starts at designated hitter than the outfield, which tells us what the Blue Jays think of his defense. And now he’s on the injured list because of shoulder inflammation and could sit out the rest of the month.
Verdict: Not Real
It’s too soon to write off either as a bust, but these contracts do look very shaky. In Santander’s case, we have to consider that shoulder and hip issues have affected his production. Adames was already a long-term risk to stay at shortstop and that concern has only been amplified. Let’s give him more time, but for a guy who turns 30 in September and appears to have declining range plus a high strikeout total, the initial returns aren’t good.
Tanner Scott is no longer one of the best relievers in baseball
Scott looked like one of the safer bets in free agency this past winter, coming off two dominant relief seasons in which he posted a 2.04 ERA with 188 strikeouts in 150 innings and gave up only six home runs. The Los Angeles Dodgers gave the left-hander a four-year, $72 million contract — a big deal for a reliever, but one that most agreed just added even more firepower to an already loaded bullpen.
Scott, who picked up his first win on Tuesday night, is 1-2 with a 4.55 ERA and has allowed hitters a .260 average and .727 OPS — compared to a .186 average and .528 OPS over the past two seasons. He had given up 10 earned runs in six innings over his past seven outings, suffering two losses and two blown saves, before Tuesday’s two-strikeout, no-run, one-inning outing.
“I’m just not hitting my locations,” Scott said after Monday’s loss to the Mets, “and it’s costing us.”
His fastball velocity is down 1 mph and his whiff rate on it has dropped from 29% last season to 20% in 2025. Scott mentioned not hitting locations, but his walk rate is actually way down to just 1.3 per nine innings compared to 4.5 in 2024. Maybe he needs to revert to more of an “effectively wild” approach that has worked in the past.
Verdict: Real
Relievers run hot and cold and can suffer a high burnout rate after just a couple of dominant seasons. Scott’s strikeout rate had already dipped slightly last season from 2023 and the four-seamer is showing a little less life this season. He’s still a good reliever and the ERA should drop moving forward, but he simply hasn’t been at the same dominant level we saw him at with the Miami Marlins and San Diego Padres.
Sandy Alcantara is going to be the star of this trade deadline
It’s important to remember that the right-hander is returning from Tommy John surgery after not playing the 2024 season, but his 7.89 ERA and minus-1.4 WAR are hard to ignore. His stuff and velocity have been good, but the command has not been (4.7 walks per nine) and he has especially struggled against left-handers, who are hitting .270/.397/.480 off him with more walks than strikeouts. He hasn’t pitched as badly as the ERA suggests with a 5.04 FIP, but he has somehow allowed a .438 average with runners in scoring position.
At this rate, he could become the first pitcher since Jeff Fassero in 1999 to pitch at least 150 innings with an ERA over 7.00. (Jose Lima, believe it or not, twice had ERAs over 6.50 in the early 2000s while pitching at least 150 innings. Yes, that era was fun.)
Verdict: Not Real
Alcantara’s struggles are particularly damaging to Miami because, at the start of the season, he projected as perhaps the top trade target come July — and a chance for the Marlins to infuse some much-needed prospect help into their rebuild. A trade could still happen as teams will note his 97-mph fastball and 50% groundball rate, but he’ll need to roll out a string of great starts before the end of July for the Marlins to get any value in return. And right now, until he figures out how to get out left-handed batters, that isn’t happening.
Teams
The 2025 Baltimore Orioles are cooked
The Orioles’ struggles have been well documented: an injury-depleted starting rotation that has struggled with an ERA over 5.00, key hitters such as Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman who have underperformed, and a bullpen that hasn’t picked up the slack. It led to manager Brandon Hyde getting fired in mid-May even if, as the title of the old Jim Bouton book “I Managed Good, But Boy Did They Play Bad” might suggest, Hyde was simply the fall guy for a rookie owner surprised that his pitching staff fell apart after refusing to make any major upgrades in the offseason.
Coming off 101 wins in 2023 and 91 wins in 2024, a season approaching 100 losses would certainly qualify as one of the most disappointing in recent years. Looking back at FanGraphs’ preseason projected win totals, here are the top disappointments in win differential since 2021 for teams expected to finish over .500 (FanGraphs projected the Orioles to win 83 games in 2025, while ESPN projected 88 wins):
2023 Cardinals: minus-17 (projected 87, actual 71)
2021 Padres: minus-16 (projected 95, actual 79)
2023 Mets: minus-15 (projected 90, actual 75)
2021 Mets: minus-15 (projected 92, actual 77)
2021 Twins: minus-15 (projected 88, actual 73)
Verdict: Real
It’s probably too late for the Orioles to turn things around. Sweeping the White Sox this past weekend is a start, but they began the week with playoff odds under 2%. Last year, it took 86 wins to win a wild card in the American League. The Orioles will have to play at a 100-win pace the rest of the way just to get to 86. The lack of pitching depth suggests that is unlikely to happen, even if Henderson and Rutschman — and the rest of the offense — come to life.
The Texas Rangers and Atlanta Braves offenses will keep them from playing in October
In 2023, the Braves led the majors with a robust 5.85 runs per game while the Rangers ranked third at 5.44 (and then averaged 5.71 in the playoffs on their way to a World Series title). Both lineups fell off in 2024, although Atlanta’s pitching was good enough to help the Braves secure the final wild-card spot. In 2025? It has been more like last season so far, as the Braves are averaging just 4.05 runs and the Rangers are scuffling at just 3.36.
Both teams are under .500 and have wasted good pitching in the process, especially the Rangers, who rank second in the majors behind only the Mets in runs allowed per game. The Rangers’ top three of Nathan Eovaldi, Tyler Mahle and Jacob deGrom have crushed it, combining for a 1.97 ERA. Eovaldi just landed on the IL because of triceps tendinitis, although it’s expected to be the minimum stay.
The Rangers acquired Jake Burger and Joc Pederson in the offseason to bolster the offense, but Burger has a .250 OBP and Pederson has hit .131 with a .269 OBP. Marcus Semien isn’t driving the ball, hitting .199 with only six extra-base hits — he had 73 in the World Series season — while Adolis Garcia‘s offense continues to stagnate with a .258 OBP. The lineup has been so bad that manager Bruce Bochy recently had Triple-A journeyman Sam Haggerty batting leadoff for an entire week.
The Braves have been marginally better and Ronald Acuña Jr.’s return will help boost the meager production from their outfielders, but this clearly isn’t the feared lineup of 2023 that became the first team to slug .500 as a team. Indeed, the only player aside from Acuña slugging .500 is rookie part-time catcher Drake Baldwin, who’s sitting at .518.
Verdict: Real
The Rangers are likely to see some regression from their pitching — Eovaldi and Mahle have been almost impossibly good and the bullpen still looks shaky on paper — so even though the AL is wide open, it has been two years of bad offense. OBP is life in baseball — and the Rangers simply don’t have it.
FanGraphs still pegs the Braves’ playoff odds near 50%, projecting them as the second-best team in the NL the rest of the way behind only the Dodgers. Of course, Atlanta also has Spencer Strider back now, but we need to see a good outing before we assume it’s the 2022-23 version of Strider — indeed, he allowed three home runs on Tuesday and dropped to 0-4. Raisel Iglesias‘ struggles are another big problem. In a top-heavy NL, the Braves have dug themselves a hole and I don’t see the offense suddenly starting to light up the scoreboard.
The Diamondbacks’ pitching will turn itself around after brutal start
The Diamondbacks once again have one of the best offenses in the majors, but they’re looking up at the Dodgers, Padres and Giants in the NL West because the pitching has struggled — and the rotation now has to find ways to win without Burnes.
Zac Gallen is 4-7 with a 5.13 ERA and leads the National League in walks. Eduardo Rodriguez — a big free agent a year ago — is 1-3 with a 7.05 ERA and is now 4-7 with a 5.99 ERA in his Diamondbacks career, apparently another example of the risk in signing free agent starters. Brandon Pfaadt does have seven wins, but is averaging just 7.1 strikeouts per nine and has a 5.05 ERA. He also just had one of the worst starts in major league history, facing eight batters, not getting any of them out, and seeing all eight score. The bullpen, meanwhile, ranks 26th in ERA and 29th in win probability.
Verdict: Not Real
I might have been inclined to say “Real” until Burnes landed on the IL. For now, the Diamondbacks are saying elbow inflammation, so at least it’s not Tommy John surgery. If he’s out for a lengthy period, it might be tough to overcome. Remember, Jordan Montgomery is already out because of Tommy John surgery.
The bullpen has its own problems: Kevin Ginkel was just sent down to the minors with a 12.60 ERA, Joe Mantiply was released and A.J. Puk remains on the 60-day IL.
You may like
Sports
After suffering a catastrophic injury, can UNC quarterback Max Johnson get his career back on track?
Published
3 hours agoon
August 14, 2025By
admin
-
Andrea AdelsonAug 13, 2025, 07:00 AM ET
Close- ACC reporter.
- Joined ESPN.com in 2010.
- Graduate of the University of Florida.
CHAPEL HILL, N.C. — Max Johnson seethed as he stared at the clock on the wall in his hospital room. He could not move his right leg, bandaged from hip to foot after surgery to fix a broken femur. He smelled like days-old sweat. Though his foot felt numb, the pain up and down his leg sometimes brought him to tears.
He always had been a guy who relied on his faith, but this injury was testing him. Johnson had transferred to North Carolina for what he thought would be a fifth and final college season. He’d hoped for a relatively straightforward time in Chapel Hill: a solid year that would lead him seamlessly into the NFL, just like Drake Maye and Sam Howell — the quarterbacks who preceded him at UNC.
Instead, three quarters into the opener at Minnesota in 2024, Johnson had been carted off the field while he held his bones in place. He could not get past all the questions swirling in his head as he listened to the second hand on the clock tick.
Why me?
Tick.
Why now?
Tick.
What next?
Tick.
Every second in that bed meant no football, and no football meant no NFL, the only dream he’d ever had. Even as he laid there, having suffered an injury on the football field most commonly seen after high-speed car wrecks, the draft was a first-level concern. That was nothing new. Max’s dad, former NFL quarterback Brad Johnson, remembers driving a young Max and two friends when they started talking about what they wanted to be as grown-ups.
Max turned to his friends and said, “I’m No. 14. I’m going to be like my dad.”
So, despite the anger, frustration and disappointment, despite the months of excruciating surgeries and rehab ahead of him, he knew, in that hospital bed, that his dreams had not changed. He was no quitter.
NEVER QUITTING IS part of the Johnson family mythology. Brad began his college career as a third-string quarterback at Florida State before working his way up the depth chart to start. The Vikings drafted him in the ninth round in 1992. Again, he was buried on the depth chart. But he played 17 seasons in the NFL and won a Super Bowl with Tampa Bay. There is a photo from the postgame celebration: Johnson has his back to the camera, holding his 18-month-old son. Max looks into the camera, a slight smile forming, as a crowd envelops them.
Everybody in the family is athletic and competitive. Nikki Johnson, Max’s mom, played volleyball at South Florida and set school records for kills, digs and hitting percentage. Her sister also played volleyball, and her brother, Mark Richt, played quarterback at Miami before eventually coaching at Georgia and Miami.
Max has always held onto hope. Brad tells a story to that point. Max was in sixth grade; Brad was his coach. They were down 16 points with 12 seconds to go. Brad was ready to run out the clock, but Max would not have it.
“I swear he yelled at me because the game wasn’t over,” Brad says. “He’s that kid that believes the game is not over until the clock hits double zero.”
Max grew into an elite quarterback prospect in the class of 2020, signing with LSU out of high school. He played in six games as a true freshman and made two starts, then started all 12 games in 2021. But then-coach Ed Orgeron was fired, and Johnson transferred to Texas A&M to play for then-coach Jimbo Fisher. But multiple injuries marred his two seasons with the Aggies, and Fisher was fired there, too, leaving Johnson with another decision after the 2023 season. North Carolina under then-coach Mack Brown seemed the best choice for him to get to the NFL.
“I think it was really big for me to watch Sam and Drake over the last few years under Coach Brown light it up, make plays with their legs, and I feel like that could do that,” Max Johnson says. “I wanted to play one year and go pro. That was my plan.
“Then the injury happened.”
THIRD-AND-10 FROM THE North Carolina 33, late third quarter. North Carolina trails Minnesota 14-10. Johnson drops back to throw a backside curl route. As he releases the ball, Minnesota cornerback Justin Walley hits him on a blitz and starts to take him down to the ground. As Johnson begins to land awkwardly on his right leg, pinned under Walley, Darnell Jefferies hits him high.
Johnson says he remembers being on the ground, staring at the dark night sky. He felt indescribable pain. It was hard to breathe. Then and there, he knew his season was over. He said he believed he had torn a knee ligament.
Frustration and anger set in. Trainers asked if he could get up. Johnson said no. When they picked him up to assist him off the field, Johnson felt his femur shift out of place and his foot dangle. He knew then his leg was broken.
Johnson made it to the sideline, but the pain was too intense to make it to the locker room. The cart came out, and all Johnson remembers is the pain. Teammates came over to give him words of encouragement. His brother, Jake, a tight end on the team, told Max he loved him.
As he made his way off the field, Johnson thought about giving a thumbs-up to show he was OK. But he was not OK. Brad and Nikki, watching from the stands, had no idea how badly Max was hurt. But they knew something was terribly wrong when the cart came out and they began to make their way down to the tunnel to find him.
Trainers tried to put on an air cast, but the pain was too intense. They gave Johnson morphine, but he still felt pain every time the broken bone shifted inside his leg, a sensation Johnson described as “flopping back and forth.” The ride to the hospital was horrible, every bump more painful than the last.
Once he arrived, he was placed on a hospital bed. He couldn’t help but ask for the score of the game. Backup Conner Harrell had led North Carolina to a 19-17 victory.
The doctors told Johnson, still in his football gear, that they needed to take him back for an X-ray. They cut off his uniform, pads and all. Johnson sat there in his underwear, sweaty and bloody, crying, in a daze.
The X-ray confirmed the broken leg. He also had to hold his bones in place during that process. You can see his right hand in the image, holding just underneath the bone.
By this time, his parents had arrived at the hospital from the game. UNC trainer David Mincberg was there as well. Jake also asked to go to the hospital, but his parents told him it would be best to go back with the team to Chapel Hill.
Because it was so late in the evening, Johnson would have to wait until morning for surgery. To help keep the bone in place through the night, Johnson had a hole drilled through his tibia, where doctors inserted a string and attached a five-pound weight, which hung off the side of the bed. Max’s parents and Mincberg slept in chairs in his room, refusing to leave him alone.
Dr. David Templeman, who performed the surgery at Hennepin County Medical Center, said he had never seen an in-game injury like that to an athlete. During surgery, Templeman inserted a metal rod that ran from Johnson’s hip to his knee to stabilize the injury.
After the surgery, Johnson realized his leg felt numb and started to panic. Doctors came in and started touching his feet. Johnson saw their demeanors shift from mild concern to outright worry. The initial operation had caused pressure to build up in his leg, a problem that sometimes occurs after surgery. Johnson feared amputation was a possibility, but Templeman says his team was able to react quickly enough to avoid that scenario.
To ease the pressure that had built up, doctors placed a wound vacuum in Johnson’s leg to help reduce swelling. Johnson would undergo other surgeries — he’d have five in total — to close the wound once the pressure eased. But he also had to get up and start walking to not only avoid blood clots but to start restoring the function of his leg.
Johnson initially needed multiple people to help him out of bed. His mom held the vacuum attached to his leg while Johnson held onto a walker. He took 12 steps, turned around and took 12 steps back.
“I was absolutely gassed. The most tired I’ve ever been in my life,” he said.
Johnson had already lost weight, and his hemoglobin levels had deteriorated so much that he needed a blood transfusion. Templeman told him it could take months to a year for full feeling to return in his foot. Johnson hated it when anyone touched his feet, but that was about to change.
“I’m not kidding you. I must have touched that kid’s foot 1,000 times,” Nikki Johnson said. “I know this is not scientific, but I will stick by this: Touching it and moving it and rubbing it helped those nerves regenerate. I believe there was some supernatural healing there. Maybe that’s just what I want to believe. But the doctors were amazed that his feeling and function came back so quickly.”
Max stayed in the hospital nine days. Despite the ordeal, the Johnsons asked repeatedly whether he could play football again. Templeman said, “Hopefully.” The Johnsons said they were given a recovery timeline of six months to a year.
“That’s all we needed to hear,” Nikki said.
Johnson knew injuries like this were exceedingly rare in football players, and only a handful had ever come back to play. So, obviously, he gave himself just six months to make it back.
AFTER LEAVING THE hospital, Johnson stayed in Minneapolis until doctors cleared him for air travel back to Chapel Hill. The family stayed with Brad’s friends from his time with the Vikings.
Max had yet to shower since the injury. But the shower was up the stairs, and he could not bend his bandaged leg. Max broke into a cold sweat debating whether to attempt the stairs or not. He begged his parents to help him. They relented.
He was able to make it up four steps before taking a break. Then he went up another four steps before stopping for another break. It went like this until he made it to the top … an hour and a half later. Max was wiped out.
When he finally got into the shower, he sat in a chair, his leg wrapped and sticking out the open shower door. He sat for 15 minutes, water finally washing him clean. “One of the best feelings in my life,” he says.
When he was done, he realized he now had to make his way down the stairs. It was easier to get down but still took time and an enormous amount of effort. Max needed help to do everything, from using the restroom to getting dressed and undressed every day. He felt like a child again.
Mincberg stayed the entire time, often doing shopping runs to stock up on clothes, food and other necessities for the four of them. His parents took care of him day after day, without hesitation. “They became my best friends,” Max says.
The following Saturday, he put on the UNC game against Charlotte and tried to figure out the offensive game plan just to keep his mind occupied. On Sept. 11, Johnson saw Templeman for a follow-up appointment and was cleared to return home. UNC sent a charter plane to bring Johnson, his parents and Mincberg back to Chapel Hill.
MAX GOT BACK to the apartment he shared with Jake. His parents rented one in Chapel Hill to continue to help. Nikki, Brad and Jake did whatever Max needed — from cooking to cleaning to helping him get from one appointment to the next.
Max could not drive, nor could he attend class in person because he was unable to sit in chairs. He also remained away from the team. The first few weeks home were a slog. He had trouble sleeping and would get about only two hours at a time. Sometimes he would stay awake all night.
He remembers one day he wanted to try to work out in the gym in his apartment complex, just to feel active again. He used his crutches to make it there. He picked up seven-pound weights and did curls to an overhead shoulder press. After 15 minutes, he was exhausted. It took him 25 minutes to get back to his apartment.
He still felt angry and frustrated, unable to play the sport that made him feel complete. The doubts about his future were there constantly. Max relishes his ability to run, because most people assume he’s slow. He ran a 4.6 in the 40-yard dash. Would he ever gain back that speed? And even if he did, it was a near certainty he would face another quarterback competition, just as he had every other year he spent in college.
In late September, he took out his journal and started writing, letting go of his anger. He realized the injury gave him time to slow down, rethink his values and remember why he plays. He grew stronger in his faith and his conviction he would play again.
The mindset shift did not lessen the reality of his situation. Even if Max made it all the way back to the football field, there still might not be an NFL future. He pressed on nonetheless.
Eventually, he was able to go to one team meeting a week, where he had a special chair that allowed him to sit. He used FaceTime whenever he could. In October, Brad drove Max to one of his rehab appointments. He waited in the car for Max to finish and fell asleep, but then awoke to a knock on the window.
“Dad! I can walk!”
Brad got out of the car. Max took eight steps without his crutches. They cried.
Part of his initial rehab was simply focusing on bending his leg and perfecting his walking form. Max would stare at himself in the mirror, his right leg thinned out compared to his left. He had to work on making sure he was not putting too much pressure on his left leg to compensate for the injury to his right.
The bone was still broken, so he felt constant pain. But Johnson says to return to football form, he could not wait for the bone to heal completely.
“If you don’t walk on it in a certain amount of time, then the bone will never really heal back to where you want it to be,” Johnson says.
Eventually, Johnson started walking on an underwater treadmill. Around Thanksgiving, he transitioned from walking to slowly running on the same machine. There would be more challenges ahead. Brown was fired as coach before the final game of the regular season. Johnson faced the prospect of playing for a fourth head coach and sixth offensive coordinator, without knowing whether he would be healthy enough to compete for a starting job in 2025. Uncertainty filled the first weeks of December.
But Johnson remained adamant he wanted to play a sixth season, and that he wanted to stay at North Carolina.
IF YOU HAD told Max Johnson in high school that he would play for three coaches who won a national championship and one who won six Super Bowls, there is no way he would have believed you.
Transferring for a third time after the coaching change never entered his mind. The thought of playing for the coach who was with Tom Brady in New England excited Johnson. The two had an honest conversation about where Johnson stood after Belichick arrived on campus. Asked why he decided to give Johnson a chance, Belichick says simply, “Why not?”
The truth is, Belichick owes Johnson nothing. Coaches taking over programs flip rosters to fit their needs. The current Tar Heels roster features more than 40 transfers and 17 true freshmen, including ESPN300 quarterback Bryce Baker. Though Johnson was injured, he had been playing college ball for longer than every other player in the quarterbacks room and could provide valuable knowledge and steady leadership as he worked to return.
The rehab was going slower than Johnson had hoped. Initially, he wanted to be ready in time for spring football in March. But he was not fully healed and could not run and cut the way he needed to.
North Carolina had a decision to make once spring practice wrapped in April. Given the uncertainty around Johnson and the departure of quarterback Ryan Browne to Purdue, North Carolina signed quarterback Gio Lopez from South Alabama. Johnson says he understood.
“I get it. You have to go in the portal,” Johnson says. “I didn’t know if I was going to be ready. They didn’t know. They asked me those questions. I’m telling them I’m going to be ready, because I know myself. But it’s tough from their point of view because it’s like, ‘OK, we’ve got to make a business decision.'”
Johnson welcomed Lopez without reservation, helping him get up to speed with the offense.
“I transfer in, we’re both competing for the spot, and people paint this narrative like they must not like each other. Me and Max are actually great friends,” Lopez said. “He’s been super helpful with the offense. There’s no second agenda with him, where he’s trying to throw me off. He’s been great.”
Johnson worked every day, three hours a day, not only with his physical therapy but other forms of rehab, from scar tissue massage to electric stimulation.
“He never took a day off,” Jake says. “I know having a career in the NFL is his dream, and he’s not going to let [anything] stop him.”
Finally, several weeks after spring practice ended, Max was able to fully drop back with no pain. Max says that moment was “probably one of the best feelings I’ve ever felt.”
Johnson says his leg is fully healed and he is “ready to roll” for fall camp. He says he did every run and every lift with the team this summer and feels as good as he did last year. Templeman and the staff at the hospital have been amazed by his progress.
“Out of all the people I’ve taken care of in my career, he’s probably in the 100th percentile for [getting] healthy,” Templeman said. “It’s exceptional even within the realm of being an athlete.”
Now that fall camp has started, Johnson says the coaching staff told him he would be given a fair shot to win the starting job. Whether he does remains to be seen as the season opener against TCU on Labor Day inches closer.
“It’s not us picking them, it’ll be that player earning it — then we’ll decide on that,” Belichick said the day fall practice began. “If it’s clear-cut, then that player will be the player. If it’s not clear-cut, maybe the competition will continue into the early part of the season.”
Asked what he hopes for this season, Johnson says, “I want to play.”
MAX STILL KEEPS the white No. 14 Carolina jersey he wore in the opener last year, cut down the middle, as a reminder not only of how far he has come, but how much putting that jersey on means to him. There might be those who wonder why he would put himself through the agony of nearly a year of rehab without any guarantee that he would play again. Johnson has a quick retort: Nothing in life is guaranteed, so why not spend each day doing what you love?
“When it’s in you and something that you enjoy, you can’t listen to the noise of what someone else thinks,” Brad says. “It has to be your passion, your dream. You have to look back on your story and have no regrets. The chance for him to have the ball in his hands, the feeling of calling the play in the huddle, the feeling of the game, it matters.”
For now, Max is not listed among the quarterbacks to watch for the 2026 NFL draft. ESPN NFL draft analyst Jordan Reid said there’s a “wait-and-see approach,” not only because of the injury but because it’s not known yet how much he will play.
But Max sees his dad as the perfect example — someone who overcame his own roller-coaster college career to not only make it in the NFL but persevere and find a way to win at the highest level.
“I want to play football,” Max says. “That’s what I want to do. I’ll never give up.”
Sports
D-backs’ DeSclafani to IL after turn as starter
Published
10 hours agoon
August 13, 2025By
admin
-
Associated Press
Aug 13, 2025, 02:34 PM ET
ARLINGTON, Texas — The Arizona Diamondbacks placed right-hander Anthony DeSclafani on the 15-day injured list Wednesday because of right thumb inflammation after he made three starts.
DeSclafani (1-2, 4.36 ERA) has been primarily a reliever for the Diamondbacks but made the starts this month after Merrill Kelly was traded to the Texas Rangers at the deadline on July 31.
Arizona made the move with DeSclafani before the series finale at Texas, when Kelly was starting for the Rangers. The Diamondbacks recalled right-hander Casey Kelly from Triple-A Reno.
“We’re hoping for the minimal time. He’s going to get some imaging just to make sure that everything’s OK,” manager Torey Lovullo said. “This is something that popped up a couple days ago. We all felt that he was going to be able to take the baseball and go out there and compete, which he did. We saw the stuff in the first couple of innings, and we decided it was time to take him off the field.”
In the three starts this month, DeSclafani is 0-1 with a 5.59 ERA, allowing six runs in 9⅔ innings. He threw three innings Tuesday night, allowing two runs in a game Arizona won 3-2 on a homer by Ketel Marte in the ninth.
Sports
Twins no longer for sale; owners eye investors
Published
10 hours agoon
August 13, 2025By
admin
-
Associated Press
Aug 13, 2025, 11:15 AM ET
MINNEAPOLIS — The Minnesota Twins are no longer for sale, executive chair Joe Pohlad announced Wednesday on behalf of his family.
After exploring a variety of options over the past 10 months, the Pohlad family will remain the principal owner of the club and add new investors instead. Carl Pohlad, a banking magnate and the late grandfather of Joe Pohlad, purchased the Twins in 1984 for $44 million.
“For more than four decades, our family has had the privilege of owning the Minnesota Twins. This franchise has become part of our family story, as it has for our employees, our players, this community, and Twins fans everywhere,” Joe Pohlad said in his announcement. “Over the past several months, we explored a wide range of potential investment and ownership opportunities. Our focus throughout has been on what’s best for the long-term future of the Twins. We have been fully open to all possibilities.”
Pohlad said the family was in the process of adding two “significant” limited partnership groups to bring in fresh ideas, bolster critical partnerships and shape the long-term vision of the franchise that relocated to Minnesota in 1961 after originating as the Washington Senators. Details about the new investors will be kept private until Major League Baseball approves of the transactions, Pohlad said.
The Twins are on track for their lowest attendance total in 16 seasons at Target Field, and an ownership-mandated payroll reduction last year, among other factors, has contributed to a dissatisfied customer base. The Twins traded 10 players off their roster leading up to the July 31 deadline, furthering the frustration. Word that the Pohlads are staying put certainly won’t help the morale of Minnesota baseball fans, who’ve been waiting for another World Series title since 1991.
“We see and hear the passion from our partners, the community, and Twins fans. That passion inspires us,” Pohlad said. “This ownership group is committed to building a winning team and culture for this region, one that Twins fans are proud to cheer for.”
Trending
-
Sports3 years ago
‘Storybook stuff’: Inside the night Bryce Harper sent the Phillies to the World Series
-
Sports1 year ago
Story injured on diving stop, exits Red Sox game
-
Sports2 years ago
Game 1 of WS least-watched in recorded history
-
Sports2 years ago
MLB Rank 2023: Ranking baseball’s top 100 players
-
Sports4 years ago
Team Europe easily wins 4th straight Laver Cup
-
Sports2 years ago
Button battles heat exhaustion in NASCAR debut
-
Environment2 years ago
Japan and South Korea have a lot at stake in a free and open South China Sea
-
Environment2 years ago
Game-changing Lectric XPedition launched as affordable electric cargo bike