Connect with us

Published

on

Allegedly defective tools and hardware from a China-based seller on Amazon have been linked to two deaths and at least one serious injury — the latest in an alarming spike in product liability lawsuits against the Seattle-based e-tailing giant, The Post has learned.

On March 25, 2024, Jacob “Jake” Todd — 30-year-old father of three in Menifee, Calif. — was working under his Toyota Tacoma when a car jack hed bought on Amazon from Vevor, a Shanghai-based third-party seller, buckled and broke.

The grisly mishap caused fatal blunt force trauma,” according to a January lawsuit filed on behalf of his sons in California state court in Riverside County.

In February, an Alabama truck driver, James Ryan Stokes, was using a Vevor “chain load binder” to tie down items on his flatbed truck when the chain broke, sending him violently backwards and fatally breaking his neck, according to William Poole, a lawyer hired by Stokes family. 

The 49-year-old trucker left a wife and six children who are preparing a lawsuit against Amazon, Vevor and Austal USA, a ship manufacturer in Mobile, Ala. where the accident happened, according to Poole. 

It was the first time he was using the Vevor product, Poole added.

Vevor which has previously drawn whistleblower complaints to US agencies about allegedly fake reviews on Amazon, as reported by The Post also has amassed 1,430 Better Business Bureau complaints over allegedly faulty products and poor customer service.

Meanwhile, the number of overall product liability cases against Amazon has spiked between 2020 and 2024, when the lawsuits more than doubled to 84 in federal court alone, according to Lex Machina, a LexisNexis company that provides legal data analytics.

“Although the number of federal cases are small compared to Amazon’s [size] the trend shows an identifiable, steady increase of product liability cases that could be reflected in state court as well where the majority of these cases are filed,” Ron Porter, Lex Machina’s legal data expert for product liability told The Post.

Most of the 84 cases have either been settled or dismissed on procedural grounds, although the breakdown isn’t clear, Porter added.

Amazons liability over defective third-party products has become a thorny question, with laws and legal outcomes varying from state to state. The company has typically argued that it is not directly responsible for products sold on its site that are manufactured by outside firms.  

In 2020, a California state appeals court ruled that Amazon was liable for injuries caused to Angela Bolger, who suffered severe burns from an exploding laptop battery from a third-party Chinese seller called Lenoge Technology. Lenoge, which was named as a defendant, did not appear in court.

Whatever term we use to describe Amazons role, be it retailer, distributor, or merely facilitator, it was pivotal in bringing the product here to the consumer, the appeals court ruled at the time. 

While other states have sided with Amazon in similar cases, the Bolger case is a favorable precedent for plaintiffs especially where they seek restitution from a third-party seller based in China or another country overseas, according to Keith Hylton, a law professor at Boston University.

If I had to make a prediction, I would guess the Bolger case will be accepted in most jurisdictions, Hylton said in an interview.

I dont think courts will accept an outcome where Amazon sells dangerously defective products made by foreigners in places where Americans have no legal recourse and escapes liability, Hylton added. Holding Amazon liable will force it to do some monitoring, or at least to charge a price that will cover the costs Amazon will bear in compensating injured consumers.

Amazon did not respond to multiple requests for comment for this story.

As recently as May 28, Amazon was still listing the Vevor products that were involved in the two deaths. That’s despite customer reviews that have flagged safety issues — including one purporting to be from a friend of Todd.

“A very good friend of mine died using one of these vevor stands,” the reviewer wrote. “Got crushed when one of the legs failed and what he was welding fell on him, total weight was like 3000lbs supported by 2 of these. RIP jake.”

Vevor, for its part, denies all the allegations in the car jack complaint and declined to comment on the Alabama case as it has not yet been filed, according to a statement from its attorney, Alan Tan.

“As regards [to] the larger question of quality,” Tan added, “we must say that the existence of the above lawsuit against us does not imply in any manner that products sold by us are quality inferior.”

Tan pointed to a return and refund rate in the US of 3% as evidence of the quality of Vevor’s products.

Tan addressed the California wrongful death case in a March 25 letter to a do-it-yourself influencer on YouTube Jeff King of Den of Tools. King recently posted Tan’s letter on YouTube in which Tan responded to a previous Den of Tools post about Vevors products causing deaths and injuries.

Vevor hired a local California litigator who is “working together with the lawyer hired by Amazon to proactively prepare filing answer against the complaint,” according to Tan’s letter.

The letter caught the attention of the Todd family’s lawyer, Vanessa Pena.

It raises questions that they contacted Amazons attorneys to work directly with them,” Pena told The Post.

She added that Vevor reached out to Amazon before it responded to the wrongful death lawsuit on April 10. “It infers me to me that they have a relationship with Amazons attorneys.”

The letter from Tan also claims that Vevor is being unfairly attacked with litigation in the US, where it’s facing at least a half-dozen patent and trademark cases alleging that it’s selling knockoffs.

You correctly pointed out that companies doing business in the US get sued because Americans like to sue no matter who you are or how well you behave, Tan wrote to King.

Colby Lord of Huntsville, Texas fell more than 40 feet when the “Vevor half body safety harness he had purchased on Amazon fell apart while he was trimming a tree. He fractured both ankles, his back and left hand, according to his lawyer, Sam Palermo, a partner in the Sorrels personal injury law firm.

Lord’s fall resulted in serious and lasting injuries, according to a complaint filed against Vevor and several affiliated companies in federal court in Houston, Texas in October.

Amazon is not a defendant in that case. In 2021, Texas’ highest court ruled that Amazon cannot be held liable for injuries caused by a third-party seller’s product that the e-commerce giant shipped from its warehouse.

Continue Reading

UK

Why many victims will welcome a national inquiry into grooming gangs

Published

on

By

Why many victims will welcome a national inquiry into grooming gangs

In 2019, nine men were jailed for raping and abusing two teenage girls living in a children’s home in Bradford.

One of the victims, Fiona Goddard, says more than 50 men raped her.

When the government began to talk about offering councils money for local inquiries, Fiona hoped Bradford would be one of the first to take up the offer. But there didn’t seem to be much enthusiasm.

The council was quick to point out that there had already been an independent case review into Fiona’s case, along with four other victims.

This, then, was Fiona’s first reasoning for wanting a national inquiry: The council felt it had done all that needed to be done. Fiona didn’t.

The Independent review, published in July 2021, found that while in the children’s home, Fiona “went missing almost on a daily basis”. The police attitude was that she could look after herself – she was “street-wise”.

There was “agreement by all agencies that Fiona was either at risk of Child Sexual Exploitation (CSE) or actively being sexually abused and exploited”. But “this was not addressed by any single agency”.

And “when Fiona became pregnant at the age of 15, there was little curiosity or enquiry who the father was”.

So, obvious failings were discovered.

The predictable response was that lessons had been learned and new processes put in place. But no one seemed to be held accountable.

Grooming gangs timeline: What happened, what inquiries there were and how Starmer was involved

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Grooming gangs: What happened?

Ms Goddard told Sky News: “In my serious case review she [Jane Booth, the independent chair] found seven incidences at least, in them records that she found, of them not reporting sexual abuse or rape or assault, from as young as eight years old, and one of the incidences I literally turned up covered in blood and they didn’t report it.

“That is not just misunderstanding a crime, that is making intentional decisions not to report the sexual abuse of a child.”

She adds: “Let’s not forget, these people still work within social services and the police force.”

Not only did this Independent review not satisfy Fiona, but it also didn’t begin to reflect the levels and scale of abuse Fiona had experienced outside of Bradford.

Fiona Goddard, who says more than 50 men raped her in Bradford
Image:
‘I literally turned up covered in blood and they didn’t report it,’ Fiona says

Asked where she was trafficked to, Fiona rattles off a list of cities.

“Blackburn, Rotherham, Rochdale, Birmingham, Edinburgh, Oldham – never Telford, I’d never even heard of Telford until it all came out if I’m honest – Nottingham, Oxford.”

Then she remembers she didn’t go to Oxford – men from Oxford came to her – but the point is made.

Local enquiries can’t possibly begin to explore the networks of men who traffic women, often down routes of drug trafficking being done by the same gangs.

Bradford Council told Sky News it contributed to the national Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) and published more than 70 reports where child sexual exploitation was discussed and has implemented findings from the independent local review which included Fiona’s case.

Fiona believes there are numerous connections leading back to Bradford – but victims from each city often believe their abusers are at the centre of it.

We’ve spoken to grooming victims across the country, and in 2022, a case was reopened in Humberside after a Sky News investigation, where we found diary entries, texts, photos, and school reports all indicating that teenage victims had been abused.

Read more on this story:
Telford child abuse victims speak out

What we know about grooming gangs, from the data
The women who blew whistle on Rotherham

One of them was “Anna”, who also wants a national inquiry. She believes there is a national pattern of police forces not believing victims or even criminalising them instead.

Obtaining her own police records using a Subject Access Request (SAR), Anna found officers’ attitudes towards her were similar to what we heard with Fiona in Bradford, blaming her abuse and injuries on “lifestyle choices of her own”.

Anna said: “Every time I look at my Subject Access Request, I still think it’s shocking.

“It was the same sort of terminology – lifestyle choices, liar, attention seeker, and the majority of it was negative.

“It was really rare that I’d come across something where they were actually listening or they were concerned.”

Humberside Police told us: “As the investigation is active, it is imperative we protect its integrity; as such are unable to comment on aspects of the investigation as this could impact or jeopardise any criminal or judicial proceedings.”

But it is years now since Anna first reported her abuse, and she believes the police have left it too late to gather evidence.

She told Sky News: “I think it’s either happening everywhere, or young people have been taken everywhere.

“I think the attitudes of the professionals, the police, social services, from what I’ve heard and seen, they seem very similar in every area.”

The government-commissioned rapid review by Baroness Casey is due to be published next week and is expected to call for a national inquiry into grooming gangs.

Like Anna and Fiona, many victims will welcome Sir Keir Starmer’s early response accepting the recommendation.

They will want the inquiry to probe into the operations of the perpetrators – who they are and how they are connected.

But they will also want clear accountability of the people and organisations who failed to act when they reported their abuse – and an understanding of why, so often, authorities fail to protect these vulnerable girls.

Continue Reading

UK

Woman, 23, dies after falling in water at beauty spot in Scottish Highlands

Published

on

By

Woman, 23, dies after falling in water at beauty spot in Scottish Highlands

A woman has died after falling into the water at a popular beauty spot in the Scottish Highlands.

The 23-year-old had fallen into the water in the Rogie Falls area of Wester Ross.

Police Scotland confirmed emergency services attended the scene after being called at 1.45pm on Saturday.

“However, [she] was pronounced dead at the scene,” a spokesperson said.

“There are no suspicious circumstances and a report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

Rogie Falls are a series of waterfalls on the Black Water, a river in Ross-shire in the Highlands of Scotland. They are a popular attraction for tourists on Scotland’s North Coast 500 road trip.

Continue Reading

UK

‘Happy Father’s Day, Papa’: Royal children share ‘before and after’ photos with Prince William

Published

on

By

'Happy Father's Day, Papa': Royal children share 'before and after' photos with Prince William

Prince George, Princess Charlotte and Prince Louis have wished their “Papa”, Prince William, a happy Father’s Day.

The post on the Prince and Princess of Wales‘s official social media pages features two photos – captioned “before and after”.

The children are seen hugging their father – and then piling on top of him.

The post reads: “Happy Father’s Day, Papa (before and after!) We love you! G, C & L.”

The two photographs of the family – one colour and one black and white – were taken earlier this year in Norfolk by photographer Josh Shinner, who also took Prince Louis’s birthday portraits earlier this year.

The post follows yesterday’s Trooping the Colour, celebrating King Charles‘s official birthday, after which the family shared a rare posed photo taken on the day of the event.

The first photo shows the Prince of Wales wearing a green woollen jumper and jeans, with his arms around George, 11, and Charlotte, 10, with Louis, seven, standing in front of him.

The second picture shows everyone in a bundle, lying on grass and daffodils, with Prince William at the centre.

The Royal family traditionally shares public wishes for Father’s Day and Mother’s Day.

Last year, the Prince of Wales shared a photo of himself playing football with the King, taken in the gardens of Kensington Palace in June 1984, just ahead of his second birthday.

This year, Buckingham Palace posted a black and white photo of Prince Philip pushing a young King Charles and Princess Anne on a swing.

A second photo showed the Queen and her father, Major Bruce Shand, taken on the day of her wedding to Charles in 2005.

The message read: “To all Dads everywhere, we wish you a happy Father’s Day today.”

Continue Reading

Trending