Sir Keir Starmer has backed his under-fire safeguarding minister to continue leading the government’s efforts to set up a national inquiry into grooming gangs after four survivors demanded her resignation.
The prime minister said on Thursday that Jess Phillips has “devoted vast parts of her life and career” to tackling violence against women and girls, and has “confidence in her”, despite the turmoil that has beset the process.
All four survivors who quit the government’s grooming gangs inquiry panel said they will consider returning to the process if Ms Phillips resigns.
However, five other survivors on the panel have written to Sir Keir to say they will only stay if Ms Phillips remains.
They said she had remained impartial, had listened to feedback and her previous experience to reduce violence against women and girls and her “clear passion and commitment is important to us”.
In contrast to the four who have quit, who accused Ms Phillips of trying to expand the inquiry’s scope beyond grooming gangs, the five said it needs to be widened to focus on child sexual exploitation as a whole to ensure survivors who do not fit “the generalised stereotype” are not excluded.
More on Grooming Gangs
Related Topics:
In response to the demand for Ms Phillips to quit, Sir Keir said: “The safeguarding minister has huge experience in issues relating to violence against women and girls. She’s devoted vast parts of her life and career to that, and so I do have confidence in her and Louise Casey in leading this project.”
Speaking to ITV Meridian, the prime minister also sought to reassure the victims of grooming, saying: “It’s really important that the national inquiry gets to the truth. All survivors deserve answers to their questions.”
“It is very important that I say to all survivors that I give my personal assurance that this inquiry will go wherever it needs to go, the scope will not be changed.”
It is understood Downing Street has reached out to the four survivors who quit the government’s process this week.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
2:14
Starmer defended Phillips at PMQs on Wednesday
Samantha, one of the survivors who wrote the letter saying they would only stay if Ms Phillips remains, told Sky News: “We shouldn’t be falling apart right now, we should be working together.
“Jess has only ever been fair and honest with us, she’s told us as much as she possibly can within her capacity.
“She’s provided a lot of support over the phone and in-person to a lot of us survivors behind the scenes, which people don’t see about Jess.
“So I do still want her to be part of this inquiry up until the end.”
A government source told Sky News the government will be talking to all survivors on the panel about their concerns and opinions on the type of person they want to chair the inquiry, after the leading candidate dropped out following concerns from survivors over his background as a police officer.
The government will move as fast as possible, they said, but it will likely take months to appoint the right chair.
Why four survivors quit the inquiry
The four women who resigned this week expressed concerns about how the process of selecting a chair and setting the terms of reference of the national inquiry into grooming gangs is being run.
They wrote on Wednesday to Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, calling for Ms Phillips to step down and all survivors to be consulted on appointing a senior judge as chair with no major conflicts of interest.
Ms Phillips told parliament on Tuesday that suggestions that the scope of the inquiry was to be expanded from just grooming gangs were “categorically untrue”.
But leaked consultation documents and texts between the safeguarding minister and survivor Fiona Goddard show the survivors’ concerns that the scope would be expanded were valid.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
10:14
Shadow Housing Secretary Sir James Cleverly told Sky News that he can’t see how Jess Phillips can stay in post
The survivors’ letter says: “Being publicly contradicted and dismissed by a government minister when you are a survivor telling the truth takes you right back to that feeling of not being believed all over again.
“It is a betrayal that has destroyed what little trust remained.”
They have demanded that the scope of the inquiry remain “laser-focused” on grooming gangs and called for victims to be free to speak to support networks without fear of reprisal.
Image: Fiona Goddard and Kemi Badenoch speaking during a press conference earlier this year
Pic PA
The letter to Ms Mahmood says: “Her [Ms Phillips’] conduct over the last week has shown she is unfit to oversee a process that requires survivors to trust the government. Her departure would signal you are serious about accountability and changing direction.”
The survivors describe their demands as “the absolute bare minimum for survivors to trust that this inquiry will be different from every other process that has let us down”.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
7:02
Minister for Children and Families, Josh MacAlister told Sky News Jess Phillips will not be resigning
Frontrunner quits over ‘toxicity’
The letter was sent hours after one of the frontrunners to become chair of the inquiry withdrew, blaming “vested interests” and “political opportunism and point-scoring”.
Ex-police chief and child protection specialist Jim Gamble told the home secretary in a letter there was a “highly charged and toxic environment” around the appointment process and victims “deserve better”.
The other, Annie Hudson, a former social worker, said earlier this week she no longer wanted to be considered after intense media coverage.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
18:19
‘Everyone should park their interests’
The prime minister launched the inquiry into grooming gangs after an audit by Baroness Louise Casey showed the scale of the problem.
It is understood that the government is exploring a range of other candidates and will provide an update in due course.
A Home Office spokesperson said: “The grooming gang scandal was one of the darkest moments in this country’s history.
“That is why this government is committed to a full, statutory, national inquiry to uncover the truth. It is the very least that the victims of these hideous crimes deserve.
“We are disappointed that candidates to chair that inquiry have withdrawn. This is an extremely sensitive topic, and we have to take the time to appoint the best person suitable for the role.
“The home secretary has been clear – there will be no hiding place for those who abused the most vulnerable in our society.”
The Home Office has confirmed that hundreds of migrants will be moved to military sites as the government tries to stop the use of asylum hotels.
About 900 men will be temporarily based at Cameron Barracks in Inverness, and Crowborough Training Camp in East Sussex.
A Home Office spokesperson said: “We are furious at the level of illegal migrants and asylum hotels. This government will close every asylum hotel.
“Work is well under way, with more suitable sites being brought forward to ease pressure on communities and cut asylum costs.”
Industrial sites, temporary facilities and disused accommodation are also being considered as officials step up work to find alternatives.
The plans – first mooted by the defence secretary last month – have been confirmed ahead of the expected deportation of an asylum seeker who was accidentally released while serving a sentence for sexual offences.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
Justice Secretary David Lammy has confirmed there will be an independent investigation into what happened and said “human error” was to blame for the incident.
Pressure on jail staff ‘intolerable’
But the Prison Officers’ Association (POA) has warned it will “not accept any scapegoating of staff” – and claims it has highlighted “a severe lack of training” for at least a decade.
Mark Fairhurst, the union’s national chair, said: “The pressure on staff is intolerable, and this will inevitably lead to mistakes.
“These issues should have been addressed a long time ago, but as usual, our employer waits for a headline and then acts.”
The POA has warned this could happen again in the future because prisons are understaffed and overcrowded.
One member of staff at HMP Chelmsford has been suspended pending an investigation, with some MPs calling for the prison’s governor to step down if they are found at fault.
Kebatu was found guilty in September of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl and a woman in Epping – about a week after he arrived in the UK on a small boat.
He had been staying at The Bell Hotel, which was being used to accommodate asylum seekers, and the case sparked weeks of protests over the summer.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
2:40
Father of Kebatu victim: ‘I am broken’
‘Urgent review’ ordered
In the Commons yesterday, Mr Lammy said he was “livid” on behalf of Kebatu’s victims – and vowed he would be deported back to Ethiopia “as quickly as possible”.
He dismissed Conservative MPs who asked whether he would resign over the issue, describing this as a “ridiculous question”.
The deputy prime minister added he has ordered an “urgent review” into the checks that take place when an offender is freed, and new safeguards have been added.
But with a prison service source telling Sky’s Mollie Malone that these checks could take staff an extra 30 to 40 minutes, former governor Pia Sinha has warned: “The solution is not adding more administrative burden.”
Data shows 262 prisoners in England and Wales were released in error in the 12 months to March 2025 – a 128% increase on the previous year.
US Representative Ro Khanna is looking to introduce a bill to restrict all elected officials from trading stocks and crypto, citing conflicts of interest.