Connect with us

Published

on

A man who killed two Nottingham University students and a school caretaker in a knife and van rampage was told he “remains dangerous” as he was sentenced to be detained at a high-security hospital.

Valdo Calocane, 32, repeatedly stabbed 19-year-olds Barnaby Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar with a dagger as they walked home after a night out to celebrate the end of their exams.

He also knifed school caretaker Ian Coates, 65, to death as he made his way to work at Huntingdon Academy in the early hours of 13 June last year.

During sentencing, he was told he would be detained “very probably for the rest of your life”.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

‘Justice has not been served’

But speaking outside court, the victims’ families criticised the police, prosecutors and the NHS.

“This man made a mockery of the system and he has got away with murder,” said Mr Coates’ son James Coates.

Mr Webber’s mother Emma said “true justice has not been served today” and that her “devastated” family had been “let down”.

“We trusted in our system, foolishly as it turned out,” she said, telling the assistant chief constable of Nottinghamshire Police Rob Griffin: “You have blood on you hands.

“If you had just done your job properly, there’s a very good chance my beautiful boy would be alive today.”

Timeline of missed opportunities to stop Valdo Calocane

Prosecutors accepted Calocane’s guilty pleas to their manslaughter, not murder, on the basis of diminished responsibility. He also admitted three counts of attempted murder after hitting three pedestrians in a van he stole from Mr Coates.

Nottingham Crown Court heard Calocane, who suffered from paranoid schizophrenia, had previously been detained in hospital four times under mental health laws and had a history of refusing to take his medication.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Hospital detention for fatal attacker

On Thursday, Mr Justice Turner said the injuries inflicted on the students were “unsurvivable”, and referring to the attack on Mr Coates, he told Calocane: “You stabbed him to death with the same merciless ferocity.”

He said Calocane’s “sickening” crimes shocked the nation and “wrecked” the lives of his victims and their families.

Nottingham killer sentencing – as it happened

The judge went on to individually list family members whose lives had been devastated by the attacks.

“I pay tribute to the extraordinary dignity and strength they have shown,” he said.

Addressing Calocane, Mr Justice Turner said there was “never any doubt” that it was him “who committed these appalling crimes”, and added: “None of the evidence relating to your mental state detracts from the horror of your actions.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

New footage shows Calocane’s arrest

However, he said one of the expert reports revealed Calocane, who was “clearly an intelligent man” having taken a degree in mechanical engineering at Nottingham University, had an established diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia and that he would never be cured.

He said another expert agreed that “the basis of his behaviour is very likely to have been a psychosis” and added: “You were and remain dangerous.”

Before the sentencing began, one of Mr’s Coates’s sons got up to speak to the families of Grace O’Malley-Kumar and Barnaby Webber.

Lee Coates said “our family are here for you always”, which was echoed with “yes” from the other families and followed by a round of applause.

“I am so sorry we have had to go through this and this is how we’ve met,” Mr Coates added.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

CCTV shows final moments of teens before stabbing

Barnaby Webber, Grace O'Malley-Kumar, Ian Coates
Image:
School caretaker Ian Coates, and students Barnaby Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar, were stabbed to death. Pic: Family handouts

Police: ‘We should have done more’

Calocane, who graduated from Nottingham University in June 2022 with a degree in mechanical engineering, was born in Guinea-Bissau in West Africa, and came to the UK aged 16 with his family.

Also known as Adam Mendes, he had a history of mental illness, and even once tried to hand himself into the MI5 headquarters in London, believing the British security services were controlling him.

Mr Griffin, said the force “engaged” with the attacker “mostly while supporting our colleagues in the NHS on a number of occasions between 2020 and 2022”.

He was arrested in September 2021 for assaulting a police officer and Mr Griffin said “we should have done more to arrest him” after he failed to attend court, but said it was highly unlikely he would have been jailed.

“Of course, an arrest might have triggered a route back into mental health services, but as we have seen from his previous encounters with those services, it seems unlikely that he would have engaged in this process,” he added.

Calocane was also involved in incidents of criminal damage and an alleged assault on two colleagues while working in a warehouse a month before the killings.

But Mr Griffin said he didn’t have any previous convictions, cautions or reprimands and said there wasn’t anything “obvious” to suggest he would launch the Nottingham attacks.

Read more:
‘Heroic’ Grace tried to save friend, family reveals
Barnaby’s mother misses his ‘beaming smile’
How the families paid tribute to ‘beloved’ victims

‘She tried her best to save her friend’

Prosecutor Karim Khalil KC said medical student Ms O’Malley-Kumar showed “incredible bravery” as she tried to protect Mr Webber, who was studying history, and her family hailed her as a “hero”.

“Grace’s last moments were in pain and that’s something that really hurts me to think about and she was a hero, that was her character,” her brother, James, 17, told Sky News.

“She tried her best to save her friend. That was how Grace lost her life in the most vulnerable manner. She would never leave a friend, never, and that was very evident from her last moments. She passed fighting.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Killer ‘ruined my life’

Her father, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, a primary care physician who has worked in the NHS for 30 years, accused Calocane of deceiving psychiatrists and called for the “despicable” killer to be “removed from society altogether and forever”.

Her mother, consultant anaesthetist Sinead O’Malley, addressed the killer of her “darling girl” in court, telling him: “You understood right from wrong. You have violence in your soul.

“You are medically non-compliant and are never to be trusted. You remain a danger to society and the wider public.”

Grace O'Malley- Kumar's father, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, and brother, James O'Malley- Kumar
Image:
Grace O’Malley- Kumar’s father, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, and brother, James O’Malley- Kumar

Mr Webber’s mother Emma called Calocane a “monstrous individual”, while his father David called him a “monster”.

His younger brother Charlie Webber said he was his “hero” and he was proud he “stood his ground” before his death.

Mr Coates’ son, James, said his father was just five months away from retirement before he was killed, adding: “He didn’t get the chance because a selfish monster decided to go on a spree killing.”

Continue Reading

UK

Head of Southport attacker’s former school tells inquiry he was ‘building up to something’

Published

on

By

Head of Southport attacker's former school tells inquiry he was 'building up to something'

The head teacher of the Southport attacker’s former school has told a public inquiry she felt like he was “building up to something”.

Joanne Hodson, head of The Acorns School in Ormskirk, said she had a “visceral sense of dread” that he would do something.

“I felt like something was going to happen and there was a level of agitation with direct challenges to staff, the way he was with other pupils. I felt like every day it was building and building and building,” she told the inquiry at Liverpool Town Hall.

Axel Rudakubana, then aged 17, killed six-year-old Bebe King, seven-year-old Elsie Dot Stancombe, and nine-year-old Alice da Silva Aguiar and attempted to murder 10 others at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport on 29 July last year.

He was later jailed for a minimum of 52 years.

Families of the victims with their legal team arrive at Liverpool Town Hall for the Southport Inquiry.
Pic: PA
Image:
Families of the victims with their legal team arrive at Liverpool Town Hall for the Southport Inquiry.
Pic: PA

Rudakubana, referred to during the public inquiry as AR, came to Ms Hodson’s school after he was permanently excluded from the Range High School, in Formby, due to taking knives to school in October 2019.

‘Devoid of any remorse’

Ms Hodson said she first met Rudakubana at his admissions meeting for the Acorns, when she asked him why he had taken a knife to his former school.

“He looked me in the eyes and said ‘to use it’. This is the only time in my career that a pupil has said this to me or behaved in a manner so devoid of any remorse,” she said.

“What also surprised me was that AR’s parents did not flinch at this comment.”

She said the parents saw Rudakubana “as the victim” and believed he had taken the knife to school as a response to being bullied.

His parents thought he was a “good boy” who never did anything wrong and that “any issues were someone else’s fault”, according to Ms Hodson.

Members of the public leave flowers at a memorial site for the victims of the Southport stabbings. File pic
Image:
Members of the public leave flowers at a memorial site for the victims of the Southport stabbings. File pic

Ms Hodson said she had feared Rudakubana was going to “bring something” to the Acorns.

Instead, he returned to the Range in December 2019 to assault another student with a hockey stick while carrying a knife in his bag.

‘Sinister undertone’

Ms Hodson described Rudakubana as the “most unusual” pupil she had experienced during her career, adding in a statement: “There was a sinister undertone and it was difficult to build rapport.

“He had no respect for authority and generally a lack of respect of other pupils and staff. He was insistent that his views alone were correct and everyone else was wrong. There was never any sense of remorse or accountability for his actions.”

In his education, health and care plan, it was noted there were concerns that Rudakubana said or did things which had been described as “sinister”, the inquiry heard.

More from the inquiry:
Rudakubana judged as posing no risk to others
His parents struggled to deal with outbursts

Taxi driver waited 50 minutes to call 999
The missed chances to stop Rudakubana

A three-minute silence was held in Town Hall Gardens, Southport, marking one year since the attack. File pic: PA
Image:
A three-minute silence was held in Town Hall Gardens, Southport, marking one year since the attack. File pic: PA

Ms Hodson said she was asking other agencies for help, but the word “sinister” was crossed out in the report and changed to “inappropriate” after professional views were submitted by the child and adolescent mental health service (CAMHS).

“I was challenged quite heavily and told no child should ever be described as sinister and as a professional I should not be using those words,” she said.

‘Let down’ by Prevent

Ms Hodson said school staff were concerned about Rudakubana attacking his peers and made three referrals about him to the government’s anti-terror programme Prevent.

The head teacher said staff felt “let down” after their third referral caused in the school’s relationship with Rudakubana and his father, but was not acted on by Prevent.

When Rudakubana made comments thought to be antisemitic in school in January 2022, teachers did not make another referral to Prevent, with Ms Hodson telling the inquiry: “On reflection, whilst I regret not submitting further Prevent referrals in 2022, I think by this point Acorns had lost faith that anything would be done.”

She said staff were concerned about Rudakubana being radicalised, but “he was so socially isolated that I could not conceive of the idea that he might attack a group of strangers, let alone young children”.

“The tragic events are so far removed from what I would have associated AR with in terms of risk,” Ms Hodson said.

The inquiry was adjourned until Monday.

Continue Reading

UK

Post Office compensation ‘worse than original injustice’, victims’ commissioner says

Published

on

By

Post Office compensation 'worse than original injustice', victims' commissioner says

A leaked letter, seen by Sky News, warns government that victims of the Post Office scandal find compensation schemes “worse than the original injustice”.

The letter was written by victims’ commissioner Baroness Newlove and sent to the Post Office minister Blair McDougall earlier this month.

“Far from offering catharsis,” she writes, “the compensation process was seen to be as bad as or even worse an experience than the initial investigation, prosecution and injustice itself.”

She adds that “hearing this from victims, time and again, shocked me”.

Victims told her that initial offers were “insultingly low” and that constant delays and requests for decades-old paperwork had left them offended and “distressed”.

Some described the process as “adversarial”, with Baroness Newlove comparing it to fighting an insurance company rather than receiving justice from the state.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

‘Unbearable’ wait to clear names for Post Office victims

The letter urges the government to abandon “commercial tactics” such as making low initial offers – approaches the Commissioner says are “not appropriate when dealing with traumatised victims”.

More on Post Office Scandal

“It might be better to come back with a request for more information, rather than make an offer that is guaranteed to offend the victim,” she said.

The letter was sent on 3 October, shortly before the government outlined its official response to part one of the Horizon inquiry report.

It announced that it would accept most of the recommendations, including on redress, put forward by the chair of the inquiry Sir Wyn Williams.

In her four-page letter, Baroness Newlove also welcomes access to “free legal advice” to help victims with claims but calls for earlier cases to be reviewed.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Minister: No deadline on Horizon scandal compensation

She explains that where advice had not been available, some victims “might have been disadvantaged as a result”.

“Is it possible these early cases can be reviewed to ensure everyone has been treated fairly and equally?” she asks.

The letter also raises concerns that some current serving sub postmasters feel “under pressure” from managers not to pursue claims, urging the department to ensure this “is not the case”.

Baroness Newlove also relays victims’ frustration that Fujitsu, the company behind the faulty Horizon system, continues to work with the government and asks whether this is “an issue the government is looking to address”.

Post Office Minister Blair McDougall said in response to the letter: “We pay tribute to all the postmasters who have suffered from the Horizon scandal, which is why we have increased the total amount paid to postmasters fivefold to over £1 billion as part of our ongoing commitment to deliver justice to victims as swiftly as possible.

“Since this letter was sent we set out our response to Sir Wyn Williams’ inquiry proposals, which will help us further speed up claims, and which offers legal advice to sub postmasters.

“I look forward to working with postmasters in making further improvements to the redress schemes so that they get the compensation they deserve.”

Read more from Sky News:
Doctors in England to go on strike
Two dead and five injured after fire

A Post Office spokesperson said: “We have and continue to actively support all Post Office colleagues, but particularly those with direct contact with Postmasters, to encourage them to submit a claim to the Horizon Shortfall Scheme if they believe they suffered losses in the past.

“Our Area Managers are playing a pivotal role in guiding Postmasters on how to submit a claim and signposting where there’s additional support to do so. We have a dedicated claimant support team available on the phone to discuss options, provide support, and answer any questions a Postmaster may have so that we can begin to process their claim right away.

“We would welcome contact with the Victim Commissioner directly so that we can understand more about what they have been told and to ensure all of us work together so that current and former postmasters get their claims in as soon as possible.

“To assist this, we will shortly be launching a national advertising campaign urging any current or former Postmaster who has not submitted a claim to do so as soon as possible and by 31 January 2026.”

A Fujitsu spokesperson said in a statement: “We continue to work with government to ensure we adhere to the voluntary restrictions we put in place regarding bidding for new contracts while the Post Office Inquiry is ongoing, and we are engaged with government regarding Fujitsu’s contribution to compensation.”

Continue Reading

UK

Ringleader behind arson attack and kidnap plot was ‘groomed’ by Russian chatbot, court told

Published

on

By

Ringleader behind arson attack and kidnap plot was 'groomed' by Russian chatbot, court told

The ringleader behind an arson attack and plot to kidnap a billionaire Russian dissident had been “groomed” by a chatbot, operated by Wagner mercenaries, a court was told.

The Old Bailey heard the fire at an industrial estate in Leyton, East London, on 20 March 2024, caused an estimated £1m of damage, including to vital Starlink satellite equipment destined for Ukraine.

Dylan Earl, 21, a builder and part-time drug dealer who lived with his parents in Elmesthorpe, Leicestershire, has admitted his role in orchestrating the attack by recruiting others to carry it out.

During his trial, the court heard he also tasked two people to burn down an exclusive restaurant and wine dealership in Mayfair and to kidnap Evgeny Chichvarkin, the billionaire owner.

Two units in the Cromwell Industrial Estate were set on fire in March 2024. Pic: London Fire Brigade
Image:
Two units in the Cromwell Industrial Estate were set on fire in March 2024. Pic: London Fire Brigade

Damage to an east London warehouse that was shown to the jury at the Old Bailey.
Pic: PA
Image:
Damage to an east London warehouse that was shown to the jury at the Old Bailey.
Pic: PA

However, Paul Hynes KC, defending, told a sentencing hearing on Thursday that the Russians were “trash fishing” using a Russian language chatbot called PrivetBot on the encrypted Telegram platform and Earl was “easy meat”.

“Our prime submission is that he is, or was at the time, a sad individual who sat for lengthy periods alone in his bedroom at his parents’ house.

“His minimalist existence was taking drugs, particularly cannabis and involving himself in online gaming.

“We do not seek to characterise Dylan Earl as a victim in this case but there are vulnerable elements in him that were used by PrivetBot, acting on behalf of the Wagner Group, as a proxy for the Russian Federation.”

In April 2024, PrivetBot messaged Earl. His replies had been deleted, but the Wagner contact said: “I see that you know what you want. It’s a great happiness that you have realised so early that you are a WARRIOR. We need your connections and your capabilities.”

Mr Hynes told the judge, Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb, Earl was “very much a sad individual” who “had a certain detachment from reality” and “sought praise, importance and significance”.

“The potent effect of the messaging is shown in his desperate, pathetic and delusional responses,” he added.

Read more from Sky News:
Arsonist told to watch spy drama
Explainer: US sanctions on Russia
Fake celebrity chatbots targeting children

Earl messaged the contact, offering to recruit thousands more to join their operation and boasting of his underworld contacts.

“If you need connections with IRA, I can sort it. You want criminal connections with murderers, kidnappers, soldiers, drug dealers, fraudsters, car thieves, I can sort it all,” Earl wrote.

But the court heard Earl never left his bedroom and never met the people he recruited.

Earl and five other men are being sentenced for their part in the Russian-ordered arson attack on behalf of the Wagner Group, a Russian mercenary company, which is proscribed as a terrorist organisation in the UK.

The Kremlin denies accusations that it is involved in any such acts of sabotage.

The men will be sentenced on Friday.

Continue Reading

Trending