The Isle of Arran’s majestic scenery masks a national scandal it has been the victim of for almost a decade.
Two new ferries were ordered in 2015 to replace a fleet of failing vessels that have been serving Scotland’s remote islands every single day for 40 years. Construction began eight years ago.
The elephant in the room is that they have not carried a single passenger so far. Not one.
A botched design process plagued the original 2018 delivery date resulting in the shipyard collapsing into administration.
It was bought by the Scottish government which has been lumbered with obscene cost overruns ever since.
The original contract, which was accused of being rigged, was supposed to cost £97m but mismanagement and a string of blunders, including installing the wrong cables on an entire vessel, means the final costs are likely to rob the public purse of £400m.
The cash-cow project has been described as one of the biggest procurement disasters in the history of Scottish devolution.
More on Scotland
Related Topics:
Islanders live in dread of their ageing ferries breaking down or being unable to cope with regular bouts of poor weather.
‘Our whole life is just worrying about the ferry’
Advertisement
Pensioners Ena and Raymond Burke have lived on Arran for nearly 40 years.
Raymond, 78, is battling an aggressive form of cancer and has to travel to hospital in Glasgow for specialist treatment.
The couple have told Sky News the unreliable service means they are being forced to leave the island up to four days before each appointment to avoid problems.
Ena believes the “constant worry” about the ferries is making Raymond’s medical ordeal worse.
She told Sky News: “When you live on an island the ferry rules your life. It puts huge pressure on us.
“You find yourself sitting there crying, thinking I can’t go through this anymore. I can’t face this journey across. I can’t face the fact I don’t know whether the boat is going to sail.
“Our whole life is just worrying about the ferry.”
‘We are counting the cost financially and mentally’
David Henderson has been a farmer on Arran for 49 years.
He is in the middle of lambing season and complains that delays to the new ferries are leaving him out of pocket.
He said: “When we are trying to get cattle to the market [on the mainland], you are constantly worried about whether the ferries are going to set sail.
“It’s a constant topic of conversation. We are working with a boat that is 40 years old and they are just not reliable enough.
“If we’d got the new boats when they were supposed to come, hopefully they’d have been a better boat. We are counting the cost financially and mentally.”
Follow Sky News on WhatsApp
Keep up with all the latest news from the UK and around the world by following Sky News
Former first minister Nicola Sturgeon repeatedly defended the decision to take the yard into public ownership, insisting it saved jobs and safeguarded shipbuilding on the Clydeside from wipe-out.
But the ferries saga has plagued the SNPpolitically for years.
The second of the two under-fire ferries, named the MV Glen Rosa, entered the water for the first time in recent days but it will be late 2025 before it is likely to be in service.
At its launch on Tuesday, Sky News questioned Scottish government minister Mairi McAllan.
She said: “There is no doubt the projects have been beset with some difficulties and legacy challenges. The launch of the Glen Rosa is an important part of our plan to deliver six new ferries by 2026.
“I understand the challenge with the resilience of the network but nonetheless we are celebrating with the workforce of Ferugson Marine shipyard and the community about this majestic boat.”
Meanwhile, the head of a Scottish government ferry company has told Sky News he will not quit despite the price tag bulging to four times the original cost.
Caledonian Maritime Assets LTD (CMAL) owns the ferries, ports and harbours as well as being responsible for procuring new vessels.
‘We are where we are,’ admits ferry chief
Kevin Hobbs, managing director, told Sky News: “This has not been the best procurement the company has ever been involved in. However, we are where we are and the main focus now is to get both of these ferries into service.”
Asked if he should be considering his position given his own role in the debacle, he said: “No I don’t think so. This contract was signed before I even started. I inherited it.”
Four other ferries have been ordered by the Scottish government to replace other ageing vessels. They are being built in Turkey and being delivered on time and on budget.
The question is whether the long-term casualty of this chaos could be the future of the once world-renowned Scottish shipyards.
Regardless of the hard work of innocent staff, will this be the final nail in the coffin for a shipyard that has become synonymous with expensive and as-yet undelivered boats – and crucially has no more orders on its books?
He called emergency services but soon “water started seeping in”.
“I thought I’m going to have to get out, I’m going to have to smash a window,” Mr Randles said.
More on Weather
Related Topics:
He wound down his and his son’s windows, and climbed out before rescuing his son.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
1:10
‘Devastating’ flooding in Wales
“The water was chest high, I held him up as high as I could to keep him out of the water.”
Advertisement
“It wasn’t raining so heavily, I’ve driven in much worse rain,” he added.
Mr Randles, a self-employed roofer who relies on the car for work, said he remained calm during the ordeal and was helped by the fact that Luca was asleep during the rescue.
Mr Randles’ partner Paige Newsome – who was not in the car at the time – said the incident was “really scary”.
“To think I could have actually lost them both – I don’t know how I would’ve lived,” she said.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
The road has been flooding for at least two decades, the couple said.
“What is it going to take for the council to sort it out? Does a fatal incident have to happen? It’s been going on for years,” Ms Newsome said.
The couple are worried about affording another car as well as Christmas celebrations.
But Mr Randles said: “I’m grateful that we got out safely and that we can spend his first birthday and Christmas as a family.”
Storm Bert has brought more than 80% of November’s average monthly rainfall in less than 48 hours to some parts, the Met Office said.
Around 300 flood warnings and alerts are in place in England, with another 100 in Wales and nine in Scotland, as heavy rain and thawing snow bring more disruption across the UK.
A major incident was declared by Rhondda Cynon Taf County Borough Council in South Wales after homes and cars were submerged in water.
‘It is devastating’
Gareth Davies, who owns a garage in Pontypridd, a town in Rhondda Cynon Taf, told Sky’s Dan Whitehead that flooding has put his small business “back to square one”.
As the River Taff burst its banks, the majority of the vehicles in Mr Davis’s garage were so damaged he says they will have to be written off.
“I am gutted,” he said, standing in his flooded garage, most of which is also covered in oil after a drum tipped over.
“How long is it going to take to sort out? I am going to lose money either way. I can’t work on people’s cars when I am trying to sort all of this out.
“It is devastating.”
Mr Davies said he has never had an issue with water coming into his garage until now.
Pointing to one car that had been hoisted into the air before water reached it, he said: “Lucky enough, I did come in this morning just to get that car up in the air.
“I don’t know what to say, I have been working flat out for two years to build this up and something like this happens, and it just squashes it all.
“This has put me back to square one.”
At least two to three hundred properties in South Wales have been affected by flooding, Councillor Andrew Morgan, leader of Rhondda Cynon Taf Borough Council, said on Sunday.
He said the affected buildings are a mixture of residential and commercial properties, after the weather turned out to be worse than what was forecast.
The Labour MP behind the assisted dying bill said she has “no doubts” about its safeguards after a minister warned it would lead to a “slippery slope” of “death on demand”.
In a strongly worded intervention ahead of Friday’s House of Commons vote, Ms Mahmood said the state should “never offer death as a service”.
She said she was “profoundly concerned” by the legislation, not just for religious reasons, which she has previously expressed, but because it could create a “slippery slope towards death on demand”.
Asked about the criticism, Ms Leadbeater said: “I have got a huge amount of respect for Shabana. She’s a very good colleague and a good friend.
“In terms of the concept of a slippery slope, the title of the bill is very, very clear.
“It is called the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill. It cannot include anybody other than people who are terminally ill, with a number of months of their life left to live. It very clearly states that the bill will not cover anybody else other than people in that category.”
She wants people who are in immense pain to be given a choice to end their lives, and has included a provision in the legislation to make coercion a criminal offence.
Advertisement
The matter will be debated for the first time in almost 10 years on Friday, with MPs given a free vote, meaning they can side with their conscience and not party lines.
As a result, the government is meant to remain neutral, so the intervention of cabinet ministers has provoked some criticismfrom within party ranks.
Labour peer Charlie Falconer told Sky News Ms Mahmood’s remarks were “completely wrong” and suggested she was seeking to impose her religious beliefs on other people.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
8:51
Kevin Hollinrake says he will be in favour of the assisted dying bill
Asked about his comments, Ms Leadbeater said it was important to remain “respectful and compassionate throughout the debate” and “for the main part, that has been the case”.
She added: “The point about religion does come into this debate, we have to be honest about that. There are people who would never support a change in the law because of their religious beliefs.”
Ms Leadbeater went on to say she had “no doubts whatsoever” about the bill, which has also been objected by the likes of Health Secretary Wes Streeting and former Labour prime minister Gordon Brown.
Asked if she has ever worried about people who don’t want to die taking their own lives because of the legislation, Ms Leadbeater said: “No, I don’t have any doubts whatsoever. I wouldn’t have put the bill forward if I did.
“The safeguards in this bill will be the most robust in the world, and the layers and layers of safeguarding within the bill will make coercion a criminal offence.”
There is a lot at stake this week for Sophie Blake, a 52-year-old mother to a young adult, who was diagnosed with stage four cancer in May 2023.
As MPs vote on whether to change the law to allow assisted dying, Sophie tells Sky News of the day her life changed.
“One night I woke up and as I turned I felt a sensation of something in my breast actually move, and it was deep,” she says, speaking from her home in Brighton.
“Something fluidy, a very odd sensation. I woke up and made a doctor’s appointment.”
Sophie underwent an ultrasound followed by a biopsy before she was taken to a room in the clinic and offered water.
“They said, ‘a hundred percent, we believe you have breast cancer’.”
But it was the phone call with her mother that made it feel real.
More on Assisted Dying
Related Topics:
“My mum had been waiting at home. She phoned me and said ‘How is it darling?’ and I said ‘I’ve got breast cancer,’ and it was just that moment of having to say it out loud for the first time and that’s when that part of my life suddenly changed.”
Sophie says terminal cancers can leave patients dreading the thought of suffering at the end of their lives.
Advertisement
“What I don’t want to be is in pain,” she says. “If I am facing an earlier death than I wanted then I want to be able to take control at the end.”
Assisted dying, she believes, gives her control: “It’s an insurance policy to have that there.”
Disability rights advocate Lucy Webster warns that for people like Sophie to have that choice, others could face pressure to die.
“All around the world, if you look at places where the bill has been introduced, they’ve been broadened and broadened and broadened,” she tells Sky News.
Lucy is referring to countries like Canada and Netherlands, where eligibility for assisted deaths have widened since laws allowing it were first passed.
Lucy, who is a wheelchair user and requires a lot of care, says society still sees disabled people as burdens which places them at particular risk.
“I don’t know a single disabled person who has not at some point had a stranger come up to us and say, ‘if I were you, I’d kill myself’,” she says.
The assisted dying bill, she says, reinforces the view that disabled lives aren’t worth living.
“I’ve definitely had doctors and healthcare professionals assume that my quality of life is inherently worse than other people’s. That’s a horrible assumption to be faced with when [for example] you’ve just gone to get antibiotics for a chest infection. There are some really deep-seated medical views on disability that are wrong.”
Under the plans, a person would need to be terminally ill and in the final six months of their life, and would have to take the fatal drugs themselves.
Among the safeguards are that two independent doctors must confirm a patient is eligible for assisted dying and that a High Court judge must give their approval. But the bill does not make clear if that is a rubber-stamping exercise or if judges will have to investigate cases including risks of coercion.
Julian Hughes, honorary professor at Bristol Medical School, says there’s a very big question about whether courts have the room to take on such a task.
“At the moment in the family division I understand there are 19 judges and they supply 19,000 hours of court hearing in a year, but you’d have to have an extra 34,000,” he explains.
“We shouldn’t fool ourselves and think that there wouldn’t be some families who would be interested in getting the inheritance rather than spending the inheritance on care for their elderly family members. We could quickly become a society in which suicide becomes normalised.”