Connect with us

Published

on

“Removing the right to trial by jury” and “intermediate courts” may be the only way to clear the crown court backlog in England and Wales, the chief inspector of the Crown Prosecution Service Inspectorate has said.

Speaking exclusively to Sky News, Anthony Rogers says “radical action” is needed urgently.

“The number of cases waiting to be heard in the crown courts is the highest it’s ever been.

“It’s bringing significant pressure into the whole system. Those we inspect, the Crown Prosecution Service, are under the greatest pressure I’ve ever seen in 25 years of the existence of the inspectorate.

“The thing that worries me more is I can’t see an end to it. I can only see an increasing backlog.”

There are 73,105 outstanding criminal cases waiting to be dealt with in the crown courts, according to the Ministry of Justice.

Mr Rogers says: “If you’re going to fix a problem on this scale, it needs a radical solution.

More on Crime

“It could be anything from removing the right of election to jury trial.

“It could be looking at an intermediate court between the magistrates court and the crown court, radical could literally mean changing the way that we look at the criminal justice system.”

The Chief Inspector of the Crown Prosecution Service Inspectorate Anthony Rogers speaks to Sky's Ashna Hurynag
Image:
Anthony Rogers, the chief inspector of the Crown Prosecution Service Inspectorate, speaks to Sky’s Ashna Hurynag

Both suggestions are being considered under a ‘once-in-a-generation’ independent review announced by the government last week.

Former High Court judge Sir Brian Leveson is leading the major justice review in an effort to tackle the delays.

The government says “nothing is off the table” as jury trials could be scrapped for some offences and “intermediate” middle-tier courts, made up of a judge and two magistrates, are being looked at.

Both are suggestions Mr Rogers says he would support.

“If you did that you would take 20,000 or 30,000 cases out of the backlog.

“You could start by having the simplest cases in the magistrate court, the more serious cases with probably a judge and two lay members in an intermediate court and then have the crown court reserved for the most serious offences like rape, murder, manslaughter, terrorism for example. That is radical, that would solve the problem.”

‘It was like the court was a circus and he was the ringmaster’

It’s a problem Vicki Crawford knows all too well.

Ms Crawford reported historic sexual abuse to the police in 2018. She reached out to Sky News after she waited five years and eight months for her trial to go ahead.

A gruelling wait, she bravely opened up about it.

“With every hearing and every court date, I was nervous and anxious. I had a headache, I felt sick, I couldn’t sleep. The run up to it was awful. I had nightmares. In the middle of the night, I would wake up having panic attacks. I just couldn’t eat, I just felt awful.”

Vicki Crawford has waived her right to anonymity
Image:
Vicki Crawford, who has waived her right to anonymity, says her case took almost six years from reporting to sentencing

Ms Crawford’s abuser was jailed for seven years after the trial eventually went ahead in March this year.

She explained to Sky News it felt like he was profiting from the constant adjournments, while she was being tortured by it.

“It was like the court was a circus and he was the ringmaster.”

On at least one occasion the trial was adjourned because her perpetrator claimed to be unwell.

“For me, it felt like he had a lot of control over what was going on during the court process. And it was quite frustrating to watch somebody consistently say I can’t come to court today. For such a serious load of charges, I couldn’t quite understand how he was allowed to get away with that, like so many times.”

👉 Click to listen to the Sky News Daily wherever you get your podcasts 👈

Read more:
Inside the UK’s ‘wild west’ court system

Lawyers warn against more powers for magistrates
Backlog of rape and sexual offences in courts ‘totally unacceptable’

As a survivor of sexual abuse, Ms Crawford is entitled to anonymity for life but told us her reason for waiving it.

“The reason I’m waiving my anonymity is because there are thousands of people just like me, look like me, talk like me, think like me, have the same experiences that I’m having in the court system. And nobody puts a face to those people, so, this is me.”

Watchdog warned of delays since 2019

Mr Rogers told Sky News that inspectors have been warning about delays since 2019.

The crisis in the criminal justice system is mirrored in almost every crown court in England and Wales.

In Leicester, Sky News spent time with barristers and court staff and observed delay after delay.

We heard from a judge so exasperated at cases being pushed back to 2026, witnessed crumbling court infrastructure, spoke to barristers fed up with constant adjournments and spoke to victims stuck in the middle.

An overhaul of the criminal justice system is coming – and for many, it can’t come soon enough.

Continue Reading

UK

Police condemn ‘intolerable abuse’ at Palestine Action protest – as more than 425 arrests made

Published

on

By

Police condemn 'intolerable abuse' at Palestine Action protest - as more than 425 arrests made

The Metropolitan Police has condemned the “intolerable” abuse allegedly suffered by officers who were “kicked and spat on” as they arrested more than 400 people at a protest against the banning of Palestine Action as a terror group.

The arrests were made on Saturday at a protest in London against the banning of the proscribed terror group.

Deputy Assistant Commissioner Claire Smart, who led the policing operation, said: “In carrying out their duties today, our officers have been punched, kicked, spat on and had objects thrown at them by protesters.

“It is intolerable that those whose job it is to enforce the law and keep people safe – in this case arresting individuals committing offences under the Terrorism Act – should be subject to this level of abuse.”

Pic: PA
Image:
Pic: PA

The force added some protesters had been both physically and verbally abusive in a “coordinated effort to prevent officers carrying out their duties”, and that more than 25 of the arrests were made for assault.

A spokesperson for Defend Our Juries claimed the rally had been “the picture of peaceful protest” and that the Met Police’s statement about its officers being abused was an “astonishing claim”.

“I’ve been here all day and I haven’t seen any violence or aggression from anyone,” they said. “I’ve only seen aggression and violence from the police.”

More on Palestine Action

It comes as the number of those arrested at the protest rose to more than 425 by around 9pm on Saturday, the Met said, but more arrests were expected.

Officers were seen drawing their batons while demonstrators took action in support of the proscribed terror organisation.

One man was seen with blood streaming down his face behind a barrier after being arrested, while the crowd was heard chanting “shame on you” and “you’re supporting genocide”.

Tense scenes on the western side of Parliament Square saw several protesters fall over in a crush while water was thrown at officers.

Pic: PA
Image:
Pic: PA

Deputy Assistant Commissioner Smart said the majority of protests, including the Palestine Coalition march, attended by around 20,000 people, “passed with very few arrests”.

But “this was not the case at the protest organised by Defend Our Juries in support of the proscribed terrorist organisation Palestine Action”.

“The tactics deployed by supporters of Palestine Action in their attempt to overwhelm the justice system, as well as the level of violence seen in the crowd, required significant resource which took officers out of neighbourhoods to the detriment of the Londoners who rely on them,” she said.

Sky News’ Laura Bundock was at the protest.

She said: “There are hundreds of people here holding their placards proclaiming support for Palestine Action, they know that in itself is a criminal offence and so they are sat around, lying around, waiting to be arrested but with so many people here, it’s taking a long time.”

She added: “Protesters are now appealing to the new home secretary, they don’t see this activism as terrorism and vow they will never back down.”

A protester is carried away by police in Parliament Square. Pic: PA
Image:
A protester is carried away by police in Parliament Square. Pic: PA

First arrest after just 12 minutes

The Met announced the first arrests of the day on X just 12 minutes after the protest’s official start time.

The protest’s organiser, Defend Our Juries, said it estimated 1,500 had gathered for the rally, where many of them held signs saying: “I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action.”

In an update early on Saturday evening, the Met said: “Any assaults against officers will not be tolerated and arrests have already been made. We will identify all those responsible and prosecute to the full extent of the law.”

It had warned before the protest that “expressing support for a proscribed organisation is a criminal offence under the Terrorism Act”.

“Where our officers see offences, we will make arrests,” it said.

Pic: PA
Image:
Pic: PA

Palestine Action has been banned as a terror group since 5 July after MPs voted overwhelmingly in favour of the move proposed by then-home secretary Yvette Cooper, making it illegal to express support for the group.

Read more:
Farage wants to deport women asylum seekers back to Taliban
Israel warns Gaza City residents to flee south to ‘humanitarian area’

Police and demonstrators in Westminster. Pic: PA
Image:
Police and demonstrators in Westminster. Pic: PA

The ban on the group came shortly after two Voyager aircraft suffered around £7m worth of damage at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire on 20 June.

The Home Office is set to appeal against the High Court ruling allowing Palestine Action’s co-founder, Huda Ammori, to proceed with a legal challenge against the government over the group’s ban.

Continue Reading

UK

Cabinet reshuffle: Who’s on Keir Starmer’s new team and who’s out?

Published

on

By

Cabinet reshuffle: Who's on Keir Starmer's new team and who's out?

Sir Keir Starmer has reshuffled his cabinet following Angela Rayner’s resignation after admitting she had not paid enough stamp duty on the purchase of a new home.

The prime minister’s former right-hand woman stepped down as deputy prime minister, housing secretary and deputy leader of the Labour Party after standards adviser Sir Laurie Magnus found she had breached the ministerial code.

Politics latest: Reshuffle after Rayner quits

She paid standard stamp duty on a flat she bought in Hove, East Sussex, in May after taking advice that it counted as her only home due to her disabled son’s trust owning the family home in Ashton-under-Lyne – but it was established she should have paid more.

Her resignation has left a hole around the cabinet table, which Sir Keir is now filling.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The rise and fall of Angela Rayner

It was stressed early on Chancellor Rachel Reeves would remain as chancellor, in an attempt to stop the markets moving.

Read more: The working class mum who left school at 16 and became deputy PM

This is who is moving and where to:

David Lammy – foreign secretary to justice secretary and deputy PM

After flexing his diplomatic muscles with Donald Trump and his deputy JD Vance over the past year, Mr Lammy will now move to the justice brief.

The move is likely to be a blow as the PM had promised, most recently in November, he would be foreign secretary for the whole parliament until 2029.

Although he is no longer holding one of the four great offices of state, he has also been made deputy prime minister, presumably to soften the blow.

Mr Lammy is close to Sir Keir, both as a friend and in his next door constituency, and was seen grinning as he went into Number 10 after being appointed.

Yvette Cooper – home secretary to foreign secretary

The Labour stalwart had made tackling illegal migration a priority, so the move could be seen as a disappointment for her.

However, she remains in one of the four great offices of state – PM, chancellor, foreign and home.

Shabana Mahmood – justice secretary to home secretary

A big promotion, the straight-talking Labour MP will be tasked with tackling the small boats crisis and asylum seeker hotel protests.

She is no stranger to making difficult decisions, deciding to free criminals early to reduce prison overcrowding as justice secretary.

Her move makes it the first time all three great offices of state, after the prime minister, are held by women.

Pat McFadden – chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and intergovernmental minister to work and pensions secretary and head of “super ministry”

Often seen as Sir Keir’s “number two”, Mr McFadden will take over a newly formed “super ministry”.

It will include the department for work and pensions and the skills remit of the department for education – taking a large part of Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson’s brief and taking over from Liz Kendall as work and pensions secretary.

While it is not a promotion at first glance, it is a much wider role than he has had as chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster – the highest-ranking Cabinet Office minister after the PM.

Darren Jones – chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster

It is the second new job in the space of one week for the new chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster. The close ally of the prime minister was promoted from chief secretary to the Treasury on Monday to chief secretary to the prime minister. And now he gets another new job.

Steve Reed – environment secretary to housing secretary

A promotion for the man who has consistently defended the government lifting inheritance tax relief on farmers.

He takes over one of the two major vacancies left by Ms Rayner and will have the massive task of building 1.5 million new homes during this parliament, as promised by the government.

Jonathan Reynolds – business and trade secretary to chief whip

A slightly odd move for the MP seen as a steady pair of hands in his business secretary role.

He takes over from Sir Alan Campbell and will now have to hustle Labour MPs to vote with the government – something that has sometimes proved difficult with the current cohort.

Mr Reynolds will also attend cabinet, as is necessary so he can liaise between the party and No 10.

Peter Kyle – science secretary to business and trade secretary

A promotion for Mr Kyle, who is taking over from Jonathan Reynolds.

He is seen as a rising star and impressed Labour MPs when he refused to stand down after suggesting Nigel Farage was on the side of people like Jimmy Savile by opposing the government’s online safety law.

Mr Kyle will be in charge of getting trade deals with other countries over the line.

Emma Reynolds – economic secretary to the Treasury to environment secretary

Probably the biggest promotion of the reshuffle, Ms Reynolds is taking on Mr Reed’s role after serving as a junior minister in the Treasury.

She will have to take on farmers and deal with the water companies – a big undertaking.

Liz Kendall – work and pensions secretary to science, innovation and technology secretary

Pat McFadden has taken her role as work and pensions secretary, while Ms Kendall takes over Peter Kyle’s brief.

He has made AI a major facet of his role so we will wait to see which direction Ms Kendall takes the job in.

Douglas Alexander – trade policy minister to Scotland secretary

A promotion for the Blair/Brown minister who returned to politics last year after being ousted in 2015 by then 20-year-old SNP MP Mhairi Black.

He takes over from Ian Murray, who has been removed from the cabinet.

Sir Alan Campbell – Chief whip to Lord President of the Council and leader of the House of Commons

An MP since 1997 and part of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown’s frontbench, Sir Alan is taking over Lucy Powell’s role.

He will be in charge of organising government business in the Commons – a sizeable job.

Anna Turley MP is now Minister of State in the Cabinet Office (Minister without Portfolio). She will attend Cabinet

The Home Office

Sir Keir has also announced big changes at the Home Office, as the government works to get a grip of illegal migration to the UK.

Dame Angela Eagle, who was border security and asylum minister, has been moved to the environment department.

Dame Diana Johnson, who was policing and crime minister, has been moved to the Department for Work and Pensions.

Dan Jarvis has been given a role in the Cabinet Office, in addition to his post as security minister in the Home Office.

And Sarah Jones, who was industry minister, has been moved to the Home Office.

Ministerial changes

As well as making sweeping changes to the cabinet, Starmer has also been making changes to the ministerial team.

These changes include…

Jason Stockwood as Minister of State (Minister for Investment) jointly in the Department for Business and Trade and HM Treasury;

Dan Jarvis as Minister of State in the Cabinet Office. He will remain Minister of State for the Home Department;

Rt Hon Baroness Smith of Malvern as Minister of State (Minister for Skills) in the Department for Work and Pensions. She will remain Minister of State (Minister for Skills and Minister for Women and Equalities) in the Department for Education.

Lord Vallance KCB as Minister of State in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. He will remain Minister of State in the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology.

Michael Shanks as Minister of State jointly in the Department for Business and Trade and Department for Energy Security and Net Zero.

Alison McGovern as Minister of State in the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government.

Dame Angela Eagle as Minister of State in the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.

Rt Hon Dame Diana Johnson as Minister of State in the Department for Work and Pensions.

Sarah Jones as Minister of State for the Home Department.

Who is out?

Lucy Powell has been sacked as leader of the House of Commons.

Ian Murray has been sacked as Scotland secretary.

Justin Madders is no longer minister for employment rights.

Not out – but

Bridget Phillipson remains as education secretary but her brief has narrowed as Mr McFadden has taken over the skills part of her job.

Continue Reading

UK

Resident of Epping asylum hotel assaulted, say police, after reports of people throwing flares

Published

on

By

Resident of Epping asylum hotel assaulted, say police, after reports of people throwing flares

A resident of a hotel housing asylum seekers has been assaulted, police say, after they responded to reports of people throwing firecrackers and flares outside the property.

Officers were called to the Bell Hotel on Friday evening, where people were throwing smoke bombs.

Essex Police said the antisocial behaviour was not carried out by legitimate protesters and was a “change from the peaceful protect we saw on Thursday and on many occasions before”.

Police also received reports a resident of the hotel was assaulted, and arrested a 49-year-old man from Harlow in connection with this.

He remains in custody.

One man was also issued with a Section 42 Notice yesterday evening, under the Criminal Justice and Police Act 2001. This is a legal power that allows police to direct someone to leave the area if their presence is believed to be causing alarm or distress.

Chief Superintendent Simon Anslow said: “I have seen reports that those living at the hotel were throwing flares – I have watched footage of the events yesterday and can say that this is categorically untrue. This is flagrant disinformation, the likes of which we have seen before, designed to cause trouble.

“In fact, flares were being lit and thrown by those purporting to protest, but there is a stark difference between criminal behaviour and those seeking to genuinely exercise their right to protest.”

He continued: “Flares, firecrackers and smoke bombs are not peaceful. Assaulting those living at the hotel is not peaceful. Surrounding and intimidating people living in the hotel is not peaceful.”

The Bell Hotel has been the site of protests in recent weeks. Pic: AP
Image:
The Bell Hotel has been the site of protests in recent weeks. Pic: AP

A dispersal order was put in place on Friday evening, which gives officers the power to disperse anyone suspected of anti-social behaviour.

Continue Reading

Trending