data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/664e4/664e428a1ce0eb9e782b9b1607821126836bf858" alt="College football's most intriguing September games, coaches under pressure and exciting newcomers College football's most intriguing September games, coaches under pressure and exciting newcomers"
College football’s most intriguing September games, coaches under pressure and exciting newcomers
More Videos
Published
2 years agoon
By
adminWe’re less than 100 days away from the start of the 2023 college football season, and the full September schedule is being released. So we’re gearing up for what the first month of the campaign will have to offer.
Our reporters break down must-see games for September, identify newcomers to watch and address questions that are still lingering. Plus, Adam Rittenberg lists coaches who are already on the hot seat, and Heather Dinich breaks down how September will impact the College Football Playoff picture.
Jump to: September’s must-see games | Playoff | Under pressure
Newcomers | Unanswered questions | Teams in new places
Most intriguing September games
LSU vs. Florida State (7:30 p.m. ET, Sept. 3 on ABC/ESPN App). The 2022 season opener between these two teams delivered a wild, heart-stopping, back-and-forth game that ended up being one of the most memorable of the campaign. But the stakes for both teams are vastly different headed into their season opener this year, this time in Orlando. Florida State used the win over LSU last year to help propel the program to its first 10-win season since 2016, and with the vast majority of its team returning, the expectation is for the Seminoles to be big-time contenders this year. Meanwhile, LSU also goes into this season with huge expectations in Year 2 under Brian Kelly, coming off an unexpected 10 wins of its own. There is already talk this game could have College Football Playoff implications. At the very least, we will get a sense of whether these teams are for real in 2023. Get your popcorn ready. — Andrea Adelson
Texas at Alabama (7 p.m. ET, Sept. 9 on ESPN/ESPN App). The dynamics for both teams entering this year’s matchup in Tuscaloosa are fascinating. Alabama needs to catch Georgia and reclaim its spot atop the college football kingdom, while sorting out a quarterback situation that added a layer with Tyler Buchner‘s transfer from Notre Dame. Texas enters its final year in the Big 12 without any CFP appearances and no conference titles since 2009. Coach Steve Sarkisian needs to deliver the results that match his playcalling and recruiting prowess. Texas largely outplayed Alabama last year before Crimson Tide quarterback Bryce Young saved the day. A road win for the Longhorns would put them squarely on the CFP radar and create more angst around Nick Saban and Alabama. A convincing Alabama win would propel the team into SEC play, where the home schedule (Ole Miss, Arkansas, Tennessee, LSU) favors the Tide. — Adam Rittenberg
Ohio State at Notre Dame (Sept. 23, time and network TBD): A season-opening victory over Notre Dame in Columbus helped furnish Ohio State‘s résumé last year — in light of a second straight defeat to Michigan — on its way to reaching the College Football Playoff. By the time Ohio State touches down at Notre Dame Stadium in South Bend, Indiana, for the first time since 1996, whoever wins the QB competition between Kyle McCord and Devin Brown to succeed C.J. Stroud will have had a road trip to the Indiana Hoosiers under their belt. But Marcus Freeman’s team will offer a stiffer test, especially with Wake Forest import Sam Hartman under center. — Blake Baumgartner
Tennessee at Florida (Sept. 16, time and network TBD): Tennessee won for only the second time in the schools’ past 18 meetings a season ago, fueling the Vols to their first 11-win campaign since 2001. Josh Heupel was able to break through in only his second year as Tennessee’s coach. The venue shifts to the Swamp on Sept. 16. Billy Napier, entering his second year as Florida‘s coach, gets a chance in front of the home folks to show he has the Gators heading in the right direction after their 6-7 finish in 2022. The obvious question: If Heupel could do it in two years (especially in the shadow of an NCAA investigation), why can’t Napier? Each team will have a new starting quarterback. And the Gators will be facing their second preseason top-15 team in the first three weeks of the season; they open at Utah on Aug. 31. — Chris Low
Pitt at West Virginia (Sept. 16, time and network TBD). This isn’t going to be the most talented matchup you’ll see in September, but it will be the most hate-filled. The Backyard Brawl ended an 11-year hiatus last season at Acrisure Stadium in Pittsburgh, with the Panthers coming out on top 38-31. While the revival last year was great for the teams and for college football, many in the rivalry would tell you it is different when it’s played in Morgantown, with stories of Mountaineers fans throwing anything they can find at the Pitt bus as it rolls up to the stadium. Pitt hasn’t won in Morgantown since 2007, when it spoiled the Mountaineers’ BCS title hopes with a 13-9 decision. The energy of the feud didn’t go away despite the long pause, and it will be nothing less than at its peak in Morgantown. — Harry Lyles Jr.
South Carolina at Georgia (Sept. 16, 3:30 p.m., CBS): All due respect to UT Martin and Ball State, but this will be Georgia‘s first real test of the 2023 season. The Bulldogs, fresh off back-to-back national championships, have some questions to answer. Chief among them: Who will start at quarterback now that Stetson Bennett is gone? Will it be Carson Beck or Brock Vandagriff? Neither has much experience. And what about the defense now that Jalen Carter, Chris Smith and Kelee Ringo have left? This team has recruited at an elite level since Kirby Smart arrived in 2015, but don’t lose sight of those 25 NFL draft picks over the past two seasons. That’s a lot of talent to replace. Meanwhile, South Carolina has Spencer Rattler back at quarterback and is riding a wave of momentum, after beating top-10 teams Tennessee and Clemson to close out the 2022 regular season and losing a close game to Notre Dame in the TaxSlayer Gator Bowl. — Alex Scarborough
USC at Colorado (Sept. 30, time and network TBD): For the past several seasons, this matchup has had no real consequence or fanfare. This year, that changes with the arrival of Deion Sanders in Boulder. If we’re being honest, every Colorado game will have some level of noteworthiness or excitement surrounding it. But this one, in particular, sticks out due to the parallel nature of the teams. Lincoln Riley was the newcomer last season, and he proceeded to take USC from a 4-8 squad to a team that was one win away from the College Football Playoff. That kind of leap isn’t expected of Sanders, but with the hype still very much present around him, the matchup with Riley will be an attention grabber, nonetheless. Plus, this will be an entertaining duel that we might get only once given USC is headed to the Big Ten after this season. — Paolo Uggetti
What we’ll learn about the playoff in September
Hey Texas, are you back?! No really … for real this time?
A win at Alabama on Sept. 9 will help answer that, and it would legitimize Texas as an early College Football Playoff contender. According to the Allstate Playoff Predictor, Texas at Alabama will have the biggest impact on the playoff race of any of the September nonconference games, and it’s one of the eight most impactful games of the regular season.
It’s certainly possible for Alabama and Texas to finish in the top four together — especially if they win their respective leagues — but if they are competing for a top-four spot with similar records, the selection committee could use the head-to-head result as one of the tiebreakers.
Texas could ultimately have a win over the SEC champion — and not win the Big 12. That’s a scenario that could mirror what happened to Ohio State this past season, which might not have finished in the top four last fall without its season-opening win against Notre Dame.
But in a four-team CFP, it is more complicated than just winning; that win needs to continue to resonate. For Ohio State last season, the Fighting Irish finished as a top-25 team, bolstering the Buckeyes’ final résumé and helping Ohio State compensate for not winning the Big Ten East division. The same scenario could unfold this year, with Ohio State at Notre Dame on Sept. 23. The winner of that game will earn instant credibility among CFP committee members, while the loser will be under tremendous pressure for the rest of the season.
Bottom line: For September games to continue to matter, both teams have to stay relevant. That wasn’t the case for Florida State last year, which eked out a one-point win over eventual SEC West champion LSU but couldn’t do anything with it because the Seminoles lost three straight to Wake Forest, NC State and Clemson. Expectations are higher in Tallahassee, and a convincing win in Week 1 against an even better LSU team would validate that.
September also can have a negative impact on contenders’ playoff hopes. Once again, Michigan has a weak nonconference lineup, starting September against East Carolina, UNLV and Bowling Green — teams that each finished with at least five losses last season. It would only be a factor if Michigan doesn’t win the Big Ten again. If the Wolverines lose to either Ohio State or Penn State, they’d likely have only one statement win — and no conference title — for the committee to consider.
— Heather Dinich
Coaches who need to get off to a hot start
The 2023 college coaching hot seat doesn’t have the same sense of inevitable doom as last season’s.
Unlike in 2022, when four coaches — Nebraska‘s Scott Frost, Arizona State‘s Herm Edwards, Georgia Tech‘s Geoff Collins and Auburn‘s Bryan Harsin — began the season with little to no chance of making it through, those currently feeling the heat still have a chance to change course. West Virginia‘s Neal Brown, who survived a tumultuous season while the athletic director who hired him (Shane Lyons) did not, might be the only major conference coach who needs a quick start to avoid the increasingly popular early-season to midseason dismissal. The Mountaineers will face Penn State, Pitt, Texas Tech and TCU — all in September — in a stiff challenge for Brown, who enters his fifth season at 22-25.
Other than Brown, few notable coaches are squarely on the hot seat. Syracuse‘s Dino Babers likely needs a solid September after a poor finish to the 2022 season. Justin Wilcox can’t fall further behind in an improving Pac-12, although Cal‘s financial and administrative challenges could save him. Jimbo Fisher’s situation will be hotly debated if Texas A&M stumbles early, but his bloated contract makes a dismissal expensive, if not impossible. Coach-friendly contracts also favor Northwestern‘s Pat Fitzgerald, Indiana‘s Tom Allen and others who have endured recent struggles. Still, they could benefit from strong starts, as could Missouri‘s Eliah Drinkwitz and a host of Group of 5 coaches, including Memphis‘ Ryan Silverfield and Arkansas State‘s Butch Jones.
The upcoming coaching cycle could be on the lighter side, possibly a residual effect of the historic 2021 carousel and last year’s, which featured 24 total changes and surprise moves at Wisconsin, Stanford and Louisville. But the carousel only needs an A-list job or two to open, either through firing, retirement or NFL exit, for things to become wild again.
What could those jobs be? Texas A&M certainly will be watched. Florida coach Billy Napier deserves more time to implement a layered plan, but what if the team endures a losing season? Jim Harbaugh’s NFL discussions have become an annual annoyance for Michigan, but what if a pro squad gives him the opportunity he seems to covet? Harbaugh’s teams have become more than an annoyance for Ohio State coach Ryan Day, who tries to avoid a third loss to the Wolverines. The job pressure around Day is fan-created, but continued struggles against Michigan could nudge one of the nation’s top quarterback coaches closer to the NFL.
Several prominent coaches will be on the annual retirement radar, with none more significant than Alabama’s Nick Saban, who turns 72 on Halloween. Others being watched include North Carolina‘s Mack Brown (turns 72 on Aug. 27), Iowa‘s Kirk Ferentz (turns 68 on Aug. 1) and Utah‘s Kyle Whittingham (turns 64 on Nov. 21).
Calling for a coaching cycle to be light or dull essentially guarantees chaos, but don’t expect the run of early firings like in 2022. When November rolls around, though, all bets are off.
— Rittenberg
Newcomers we’re most excited to see
Clemson DL Peter Woods. Much has been made of Woods’ exceptional play as an early enrollee this spring, which has everybody in the Clemson fan base excited to see what happens when the season opens. Clemson spent nearly all of last season banged up along its defensive line, but with veterans Xavier Thomas, Tyler Davis and Ruke Orhorhoro returning, integrating Woods into the lineup should be seamless. During the spring game broadcast, coach Dabo Swinney described him as “like a Halley’s comet. Every now and then you get a guy that physically and mentally and maturity and all the intangibles, he’s just ready.” — Adelson
A new-look Colorado. There are two surefire ways to create excitement: Do something no one’s ever seen before, or turn into a complete train wreck. It’s entirely possible Deion Sanders will do both at Colorado this season, and there’s no storyline more intriguing in all of college sports. Coach Prime has completely turned over his roster. He’s installed his son, Shedeur Sanders, at quarterback. He’s backed up an 18-wheeler to the entrance to the transfer portal and announced, “All aboard!” He’s landed some extremely interesting prospects like Travis Hunter, Jimmy Horn Jr. and Tar’Varish Dawson Jr., but how much chemistry can a team have when 80% of the roster is brand new? Is Sanders writing a new script for how to win or just scripting college football’s most chaotic reality show? Honestly, there’s no outcome that seems entirely out of the question. — David Hale
New faces for Alabama: Not that Alabama has ever lacked for talent under Nick Saban, but there will be three new faces this fall who Tide fans will want to keep their eyes on. Let’s start on offense with massive true freshman Kadyn Proctor. At 6-foot-7, 354 pounds, he will be hard to miss (literally) and was impressive enough in the spring that he could be Alabama’s starting left tackle by the opener, or at the very least, a few games into the season. Junior college receiver Malik Benson will provide an immediate boost to the receiving corps with his explosive playmaking ability, and freshman safety Caleb Downs might have been the best of the bunch in the spring. Alabama needed some help in the secondary, and Downs looks game-ready. Even Saban had trouble finding flaws in Downs’ game. — Low
Freshman RBs for the Tide: To piggyback off Low here, keep an eye on Alabama’s two freshman running backs: Richard Young and Justice Haynes. They were ESPN’s No. 1- and No. 2-ranked backs in the 2023 class, respectively. We’ve already gotten a sneak peak at Haynes, who enrolled early and scored three touchdowns during Alabama’s spring game in April. He has the power and speed to be a top back in the SEC. Paired with Young, Alabama could have a special backfield for the next three-plus years. And they should get plenty of opportunities as the Tide look to make more of a commitment to the running game under new offensive coordinator Tommy Rees. — Scarborough
UCLA QB Dante Moore. Five-star quarterback Moore’s decision to flip from Oregon to UCLA in the days before the December signing period was one of the biggest takeaways and a boon for Chip Kelly in the post-Dorian Thompson-Robinson era. Kelly did secure former Kent State QB Collin Schlee through the portal to join sophomore Ethan Garbers in the QB room. But convincing Moore, who threw for 2,392 yards and 32 TDs as a senior for Martin Luther King High School (Michigan), to make the move from Detroit to Pasadena could be the perfect way for the Bruins to keep the offensive momentum going after finishing third in the Pac-12 in total offense (503.5 YPG) last season. — Baumgartner
Oklahoma S Peyton Bowen: Bowen’s recruitment became one of the wilder stories heading into the December signing period. The five-star safety from Texas (ESPN’s No. 17 overall prospect) initially committed to Notre Dame for a year before flipping to Oregon and then Oklahoma during a furious 24 hours. He joins quarterback Jackson Arnold, his high school teammate and ESPN’s No. 3 overall prospect, in Norman. Bowen and five-star defensive end Adepoju Adebawore are the types of defensive recruits Oklahoma hired coach Brent Venables to sign, especially with the SEC transition on the horizon in 2024. They should see the field this fall, and their performances could open eyes of similar defensive prospects toward OU and the chance to play for Venables. Bowen is Oklahoma’s highest-rated defensive recruit since ESPN launched its rankings. — Rittenberg
The Uigaleileis in Oregon. The Uiagalelei family has made Oregon their home. Between DJ‘s transfer to Oregon State and his brother, five-star freshman defensive end Matayo, committing to Oregon, the two will be spotlighted plenty come the start of the season in the Pacific Northwest. Matayo, in particular, will be a fun one to watch in Dan Lanning’s defense. While it remains unclear how big of a role the freshman will have in next year’s team, there’s an expectation he’ll get plenty of snaps due to his athleticism and size already at such a young age. — Uggetti
Unanswered questions for September
Alabama’s QB situation. The default opinion on Alabama’s QB situation is that, “Hey, it’s Alabama. It’ll get figured out.” Indeed, Nick Saban has won a lot of games even when he hasn’t had a future first-rounder at QB, and in the seven previous instances in which Saban lacked a clear-cut incumbent at Alabama, the eventual starters in those seasons completed 67% of their throws, accounted for 192 touchdowns and just 53 turnovers and posted a combined 79-4 record, with the Tide winning four national championships. And yet … when Tommy Rees is recruiting the guy who just lost Notre Dame’s QB battle to come to Alabama, it has the feel of a red flag. Every dynasty comes to an end eventually. You’d be a fool to assume Alabama’s best days are behind it just because of a little QB controversy now, but it’s just as hard to feel like the Tide have a good answer at the most important position on the field, too. — Hale
Can Payton Thorne succeed in the SEC? Thorne, if he’s healthy, will provide Hugh Freeze and Auburn an experienced signal-caller to try to navigate the SEC. Thorne’s 3,233 passing yards and 27 touchdowns in Michigan State’s 11-win season in 2021 proved he’s capable of playing at a high level. The Tigers’ first three conference games — at Texas A&M, Georgia and at LSU — will see Auburn thrown into the fire early. A two-year starter in Thorne may give Freeze the best chance to improve an offensive attack that finished 10th in total yards (378.5 YPG) and last in passing yards (172.7 YPG) in the SEC last year. — Baumgartner
How will Garrett Riley impact Cade Klubnik’s play? Give Dabo Swinney credit. He hasn’t been one to make many changes on his staff at Clemson, but he saw a chance to go out and get one of the brightest offensive minds in the game in Garrett Riley and brought him in to run a Clemson offense that had finished outside the top five nationally in scoring offense for two straight seasons. The passing game had really suffered, and Clemson fans are anxious to see what the offense looks like with Riley and sophomore quarterback Cade Klubnik stepping into their new roles together. Klubnik spent most of last season as the backup to DJ Uiagalelei (who’s since transferred to Oregon State) before coming off the bench to replace him in the ACC championship game and then starting in the Orange Bowl loss to Tennessee. Riley has been outstanding at molding his offenses around his quarterback. Max Duggan is a great example at TCU. We’ll see if he can have that same success with Klubnik at Clemson. — Low
What exactly is going on at Texas A&M? Last season was an abject failure, as the Aggies finished 5-7 and sixth in the SEC West. But then some two dozen players started making their way to the transfer portal. And then Jimbo Fisher hired one of the most polarizing coaches in college football in Bobby Petrino to be his offensive coordinator. Given Fisher’s hesitancy to give up playcalling, that could turn into a combustible situation if things go sideways. The early part of the schedule seems manageable (September will feature New Mexico, Miami, Louisiana Monroe, Auburn and Arkansas), but remember this is a team that lost to Appalachian State last year. A rocky start could place Fisher and his $95 million contract squarely on the hot seat. — Scarborough
UCLA’s quarterback battle? Situation? Whatever you (or Chip Kelly) wants to call it, I’m fascinated by the rise of Dante Moore and whether Kelly pulls the trigger and starts the five-star freshman from the get-go instead of going for the more conservative route such as Ethan Garbers or Kent State transfer Collin Schlee. As Blake outlined above, Moore is a star in the making, and his statistics and accolades make him as much of a foolproof prospect as you can have in the sport. In spring camp this year, Moore impressed as well, turning what could have been a development year sitting on the bench into a real chance to start come the fall. Whether Kelly opts for Moore to be the replacement for the departing Dorian Thompson-Robinson in Week 1 remains to be seen. But one thing is for sure: If Moore starts on the bench, he won’t be there for long. — Uggetti
Teams in new places
Three FBS conferences will have a new look this season. A snapshot of who’s coming and going in the American, Big 12 and Conference USA in 2023:
AAC
Additions: Charlotte, FAU, North Texas, Rice, UAB, UTSA
Losses: Cincinnati, Houston, UCF
Big 12
Additions: BYU, Cincinnati, Houston, UCF
Conference USA
Additions: Jacksonville State (FCS), Liberty, New Mexico State, Sam Houston (FCS)
Losses: Charlotte, FAU, North Texas, Rice, UAB, UTSA
You may like
Sports
Spring football preview: Carson Beck, Bill Belichick add intrigue to ACC
Published
9 hours agoon
March 3, 2025By
admindata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d2b4f/d2b4ffddf01ec7060ee600d575f96a2764d7f85c" alt="Spring football preview: Carson Beck, Bill Belichick add intrigue to ACC Spring football preview: Carson Beck, Bill Belichick add intrigue to ACC"
-
Andrea Adelson
CloseAndrea Adelson
ESPN Senior Writer
- ACC reporter.
- Joined ESPN.com in 2010.
- Graduate of the University of Florida.
-
David Hale
CloseDavid Hale
ESPN Staff Writer
- College football reporter.
- Joined ESPN in 2012.
- Graduate of the University of Delaware.
Mar 3, 2025, 09:20 AM ET
March is a busy month on the sports calendar, with college basketball jumping headlong into tournament season, the NBA and NHL hitting their playoff pushes and baseball getting ready for Opening Day.
It also provides college football coaches, players and fans with their first look at what could be in store for the 2025 season as teams conduct spring practices.
We begin our power conference spring previews with the ACC, which has no shortage of compelling storylines.
How will Georgia transfer Carson Beck fare at Miami as Cam Ward’s replacement as the Canes’ starting quarterback? Can Clemson’s defense deliver as the Tigers seem poised for big things? What does SMU do for an encore after ripping through the ACC unbeaten in its first season in the conference? How does Florida State pick up the pieces from a 2-10 campaign in 2024?
And then there’s North Carolina, which opens camp with Bill Belichick in charge after one of the most shocking coaching hires in recent memory.
Here’s a look at the top storyline, a position of intrigue and player to watch for every ACC team as spring camps get underway.
2024 record: 7-6 (4-4 ACC)
Spring storyline: Who’s the starting QB? In 2023, BC named a starter, then made a switch by Week 2. In 2024, BC again benched its starter, Thomas Castellanos, during the season, which led to his transfer. Now the Eagles enter spring with Grayson James as the incumbent but a big-name transfer in Dylan Lonergan pushing for the job. Getting this decision right the first time might be critical if the Eagles want to finally get over that seven-win hump.
Position of intrigue: The offensive line has long been a position of strength for BC, including on last year’s group, which featured an All-ACC season from Ozzy Trapilo. He’s gone, as is stalwart center Drew Kendall, and the Eagles are looking to rebuild with some veteran talent from the FCS ranks, including Amir Johnson (Merrimack) and Tommy Matheson (Princeton).
Player to watch: Linebacker Bryce Steele took a redshirt year in 2024 while recovering from cancer. He saw serious action in BC’s bowl game, however, and he hopes to be back to full strength for 2025, where he’ll compete for a starting job in hopes of regaining the reputation he held as a blue-chip recruit.
2024 record: 6-7 (2-6)
Spring storyline: Coach Justin Wilcox overhauled his offensive staff after the Bears lost four games by 5 points or fewer in their ACC debut, culminating with yet another season with more frustration than joy. Wilcox hired former Boise State and Auburn coach Bryan Harsin as offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach, while also bringing in new assistants to coach the offensive line, receivers and running backs. He also hired former Washington State coach Nick Rolovich as a senior offensive assistant. Meanwhile, defensive coordinator Peter Sirmon is reportedly moving on to the New Orleans Saints, which means this staff will look almost entirely different when spring kicks off.
Position of intrigue: Fernando Mendoza transferred to Indiana, leaving an open quarterback competition behind. Ohio State transfer Devin Brown is expected to compete with true freshman Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele, who transferred to the Bears a month after signing with Oregon. Sagapolutele had flipped to Oregon after initially committing to Cal, but after joining the Ducks for their Rose Bowl prep, he changed his mind and decided he wanted to come to Cal after all.
Player to watch: Cal got huge news when running back Jaydn Ott decided to return for one more year after an ankle injury hindered him for most of 2024. With Ott and Jaivian Thomas returning, Cal has one of the best running back duos in the ACC.
2024 record: 10-4 (7-1)
Spring storyline: There’s a new sheriff on D, as Clemson parted ways with Wes Goodwin in favor of former Penn State coordinator Tom Allen. The goal is to rejuvenate a pass rush that has floundered in recent years, and fresh off a dominant season coaching the likes of Abdul Carter, Allen should have plenty to work with, including T.J. Parker and Peter Woods, on the line of scrimmage.
Position of intrigue: The Tigers were stymied by a late-season injury to Phil Mafah, and they struggled to get the running game going down the stretch. This spring, Clemson will be looking to iron out a backfield that has ample options but no lead rusher. Former blue-chip receiver Adam Randall is making the full-time switch to tailback, and he’ll get plenty of run alongside David Eziomume, but the biggest name to watch might be freshman Gideon Davidson, whom Dabo Swinney believes could be the best first-year back in the country.
Player to watch: In what might have been the biggest shocker of the offseason, Clemson took a big name from the transfer portal for the first time, landing former Purdue edge rusher Will Heldt. That he’s Swinney’s first big signing in the portal means Heldt will undoubtedly be an object of fascination around Death Valley, but the bigger story is that Clemson is desperate for a big impact off the edge — something that was sorely lacking at times in 2024.
2024 record: 9-4 (5-3)
Spring storyline: Is Duke ready to push into the ACC’s upper echelon? Here’s a fun fact: The only teams with more conference wins in the past three years than Duke (14) are Clemson and Louisville. After last season’s surprising 9-4 finish, Duke spent big to land transfer Darian Mensah at QB, and expectations are incredibly high in Durham for the first time in — well, it’s been a while.
Position of intrigue: Mensah was the big offseason splash, but there remains a question as to who he’ll be throwing the ball to. The Blue Devils’ top two receivers and their leading pass catcher at tight end from 2024 are all gone. In their wake, Duke will rely on third-year option Que’Sean Brown, who emerged late in the season, and a pair of transfers in Andrel Anthony (from Oklahoma) and Cooper Barkate (from Princeton).
Player to watch: Jaquez Moore was supposed to be a centerpiece to Duke’s offense in 2024, but an early injury upended his season, and he finished with just 32 carries. He’s healthy again, and if he can get back into the form he showed as an all-around playmaker in 2022 and 2023, the Blue Devils should have a nicely balanced attack.
2024 record: 2-10 (1-7)
Spring storyline: Can Will Smith or Tommy Lee Jones show up on day one and zap away all memories of 2024? If so, that’d be a good start for Florida State, a team that went from the penthouse (13-0, ACC title before a bowl blowout in 2023) to the outhouse (2-10 and a big part of the coaching staff fired in 2024). The Seminoles are looking to find their footing again. Mike Norvell said he has invested in the right guys — attitude, work ethic, character — in the transfer portal, but there’s a lot of work to be done to move past a disastrous 2024 campaign.
Position of intrigue: Take your pick. At virtually every spot, Florida State has a big question after last year’s debacle. QB certainly fits the bill as “intriguing,” but BC transfer Thomas Castellanos isn’t likely to change a lot of hearts and minds this spring by himself. The bigger issue might be getting the O-line in order after an unmitigated disaster last season. If FSU can’t block, it won’t matter who’s in the backfield.
Player to watch: The defense is getting a fresh start under new coordinator Tony White, and he brings two transfers with him from Nebraska — edge rusher James Williams and linebacker Stefon Thompson. Williams arrives with his share of hype, and if FSU is going to regain some semblance of its 2023 magic, finding a pass rusher in the mold of Jermaine Johnson or Jared Verse will be critical.
2024 record: 7-6 (5-3)
Spring storyline: Georgia Tech ended last season with a good bit of buzz, and the Yellow Jackets return one of the most productive QBs in the ACC in Haynes King. Will all of that add up to a breakthrough season? There’s a lot to like on this team, but the story of coach Brent Key’s first few years in Atlanta has been the Jackets’ ability to play their best in big games then stub their toes against teams they should beat. Key is a ferocious competitor, and this spring seems like it should be a turning point when he pushes Tech from surprising upstart to a real contender.
Position of intrigue: The wide receiver room will look a lot different this spring. Three of the five wideouts with at least 100 receiving yards last season are gone, including star Eric Singleton, who exited via the portal for Auburn. Malik Rutherford is back, and he’ll be joined by a pair of FIU transfers in Eric Rivers and Dean Patterson, who combined for 112 catches and 19 touchdowns last year, as well as freshman Jamari Bruce.
Player to watch: Key is a former offensive lineman, and he believes championship teams are built in the trenches. Enter Josh Petty, a five-star recruit and arguably the most talented O-lineman the Jackets have landed in decades (and their first five-star signee since Calvin Johnson). Petty will need to work his way into the starting five, which already features talented veterans in Joe Fusile and Keylan Rutledge, but that doesn’t mean all eyes won’t be on the talented freshman this spring to see just how much bang Georgia Tech is getting for its buck.
2024 record: 9-4 (5-3)
Spring storyline: Just how good can this offense be? In his first year, Jeff Brohm made the most of veteran QB Jack Plummer. Last season, Tyler Shough developed into one of the most productive QBs in the country. Now Brohm turns to USC transfer Miller Moss, perhaps the most talented QB he has had at Louisville, and the Cards will surround Moss with a host of ubertalented skill players, including Caullin Lacy and Isaac Brown. Brohm’s offenses are always explosive, but this Cardinals squad has a chance to be one of the most terrifying units in America.
Position of intrigue: The secondary is littered with transfers — no shocker at Louisville — including the two corner positions, where Jabari Mack (Jacksonville State), Rodney Johnson (Southern) and Justin Agu (Louisiana) will be in the mix for playing time. There’s a big void in the secondary, after Louisville said goodbye to a host of veterans, including Quincy Riley. How this new unit jells will be crucial for a Louisville D that was far too susceptible to the big play in 2024.
Player to watch: Here’s a fun scenario: Isaac Brown was among the most prolific freshmen in the country last season, racking up 1,527 all-purpose yards. And yet, it’s another rising sophomore — Duke Watson — who might be the more explosive player. Watson got just 67 carries last season but averaged nearly 9 yards per rush and scored seven times. His role will grow alongside Brown in 2025, giving Louisville arguably the best 1-2 punch at tailback of any squad since last season’s Ohio State national champs.
2024 record: 10-3 (6-2)
Spring storyline: Can the defense get turned around? Miami parted ways with Lance Guidry after the D let the Canes down in 2024, and new coordinator Corey Hetherman is taking over with sights set on a far more dominant unit. Getting star defensive lineman Rueben Bain healthy will be a big first step, but figuring out a game plan for a beleaguered secondary will be even more significant.
Position of intrigue: Did we mention the secondary? Yes, breakout freshman OJ Frederique returns, but most of the rest of the DB room gets a fresh start with transfers Ethan O’Connor (Washington State), Charles Brantley (Michigan State), Zechariah Poyser (Jacksonville State) and Xavier Lucas (Wisconsin) arriving with ample hype, alongside blue-chip freshman Bryce Fitzgerald, among others. Miami’s DBs were a mess down the stretch last season — in part due to talent, in part due to injuries — so this spring is about breaking in the new faces and developing some depth at key spots.
Player to watch: How do you follow a season with Cam Ward at QB? By landing the best transfer available in former Georgia star Carson Beck. Once considered a potential No. 1 NFL draft pick, Beck saw his stock slip a bit last season, but with more playmakers at his disposal in 2025, he could be in for a huge final season.
2024 record: 6-7 (3-5)
Spring storyline: Last year, NC State hit the portal hard — and with ample hype — only to see its season dissolve behind an injured QB and an underperforming supporting cast. Dave Doeren learned some lessons from all that, and he insists the focus this year is on chemistry and continuity, starting with a hefty investment in building around QB CJ Bailey, who flashed signs of stardom as a freshman but still has much to learn before he’s ready to take the Wolfpack to the next level.
Position of intrigue: NC State needs far more from its O-line that it got last season — or really, at almost any time in the past few seasons. With that in mind, the Wolfpack added some experienced toughness up front with transfers Teague Andersen (Utah State), Brock Stukes (North Carolina A&T) and Jalen Grant (Purdue). The run game improved as last season progressed, but with Hollywood Smothers and Kendrick Raphael looking like potential stars, NC State must find a combination up front that can run block with some consistency. NC State hasn’t finished in the top eight in the ACC in rush yards per game since 2017.
Player to watch: Bailey might be the key to NC State’s 2025 campaign. He was forced into action last season before he was ready but put together some solid numbers — 22 touchdowns, 10 interceptions, 8 yards per pass — but he was wildly inconsistent. With a chance for him to get a full offseason under his belt and some gaps in his foundation filled in, the expectations go way up. NC State promoted QB coach Kurt Roper to offensive coordinator, a move made as much to help Bailey as anything.
2024 record: 6-7 (3-5)
Spring storyline: Oh, there’s not really much to talk about at North Carolina this spring. Just a normal offseason in which … a six-time Super Bowl-winning head coach took over the program. That’s right, Bill Belichick is in Chapel Hill now, and he will undoubtedly be one of the biggest storylines in the country. How will the Heels look under a head coach with six rings but no college experience? It’s anyone’s guess. The move will either be a stroke of genius or a source of endless second guessing. Either way, it’s bound to be fun.
Position of intrigue: Tom Brady ain’t walking through that door, as they say, but UNC’s QB room could sure use him. The Heels saw two of the three quarterbacks to start for them last season leave via transfer, while the third, Max Johnson, is still rehabbing a bad leg injury suffered in the season opener. Belichick has put his faith (so far, at least) in Purdue transfer Ryan Browne and freshman Bryce Baker and — well, much like hiring Belichick in the first place, this seems like a big gamble. Of course, Belichick knows a thing or two about finding a good QB, so if he doesn’t see a gem this spring, he might be able to upgrade in the next portal window.
Player to watch: Belichick spent last season as an advisor at Washington, where his son Steve was defensive coordinator. Both are at UNC now, and they brought some talent with them, including corner Thaddeus Dixon and safety Peyton Waters, who will try to lock down a Tar Heels secondary that looked a mess at times in 2024.
2024 record: 7-6 (3-5)
Spring storyline: Pitt got off to an unexpected 7-0 start last season, only to finish on an equally unexpected six-game losing streak. After winning 20 games between 2021 and 2022, Pitt has struggled to find the same winning consistency the past two seasons. The hope is that the return of quarterback Eli Holstein and all-everything back Desmond Reid, plus a healthier offensive line, in Year 2 under offensive coordinator Kade Bell will allow the Panthers to find the rhythm and consistency to win.
Position of intrigue: Pitt struggled on the offensive line last season for a variety of reasons, including injuries that hindered the overall cohesion of the group. The Panthers put an emphasis on this position group in the portal, particularly offensive tackle, signing transfers Jeff Persi (Michigan) and Kendall Stanley (Charlotte). Stanley played 706 offensive snaps, all at right tackle, this past season, while the 6-foot-8, 310-pound Persi brings an imposing presence — though he has spent the majority of his career as a backup.
Player to watch: Pitt does a terrific job developing defensive backs, and safety Cruce Brookins could be next in line. With All-ACC safety Donovan McMillon gone to the NFL, Brookins has drawn praise for his striking ability and ball skills (two interceptions in reserve duty last season, including one against West Virginia).
2024 record: 11-3 (8-0)
Spring storyline: SMU did the unprecedented last year, rolling to an ACC championship game appearance in its first year in a power conference. Despite the success the Mustangs had in their inaugural ACC season, they lost to Clemson in the ACC title game and then lost to Penn State in the first round of the College Football Playoff. While Year 1 should be considered a success, all eyes will be on SMU to see whether it is able to sustain its momentum and position near the top of the conference.
Position of intrigue: Brashard Smith emerged last season as a dynamic playmaker for the Mustangs, gaining a school-record 1,977 all-purpose yards; now they have to find a way to replace his production. SMU signed Miami transfer Chris Johnson Jr., hoping he can follow in the footsteps of Smith, also a Miami transfer. Johnson joins returning players LJ Johnson and Derrick McFall, who showed playmaking ability as a true freshman last season in the handful of games he played.
Player to watch: The biggest question here is how quarterback Kevin Jennings responds after throwing three interceptions — two that were returned for touchdowns — in the CFP loss to Penn State. Jennings was so good for SMU the bulk of the season; how he responds to the adversity from that game will be telling.
2024 record: 3-9 (2-6)
Spring storyline: It was more of the same for Stanford in Year 1 in the ACC — a fourth straight 3-9 campaign that has increased the sense of urgency for Troy Taylor headed into his third season as Cardinal coach. Stanford was active in the transfer portal to fill key holes at receiver, offensive line and defensive back, so how those players mesh with the young talent Taylor has recruited to The Farm will ultimately determine how well Stanford does this season.
Position of intrigue: With Ashton Daniels and Justin Lamson gone, former four-star recruit Elijah Brown is expected to enter spring as the starter at quarterback, and with good reason. Brown came into Stanford last year as an ESPN 300 prospect, immediately boosting hopes he could help the Cardinal win again. An injury limited him last season, so 2025 is his chance to prove he has what it takes to lead this team.
Player to watch: The new receivers are all intriguing, as Stanford looks to replace Elic Ayomanor and several others who transferred. Three are enrolled for spring: Caden High (South Carolina State), Jordan Onovughe (Colorado) and CJ Williams (Wisconsin).
2024 record: 10-3 (5-3)
Spring storyline: Fran Brown surprised and impressed in Year 1, leading Syracuse to its first 10-win season since 2018, including a regular-season finale victory over Miami that kept the Hurricanes out of the ACC title game. But this will be a very different team on offense this spring with Kyle McCord, LeQuint Allen and Oronde Gadsden all gone to the NFL draft. Indeed, the biggest questions this spring surround how the Orange are going to replace all that production.
Position of intrigue: Replacing McCord is at the top of the list. Syracuse signed transfer Rickie Collins from LSU and returns backup Michael Johnson Jr. and redshirt freshman Jakhari Williams. In addition, the Orange signed two freshmen quarterbacks in Luke Carney and Rich Belin. Offensive coordinator Jeff Nixon said Syracuse will have an open quarterback competition this spring. Though the room is missing the veteran presence McCord brought last season, Nixon said he is pleased with the depth he has among his quarterbacks.
Player to watch: Syracuse was not nearly as aggressive in the transfer portal as it was a year ago, but landing defensive lineman Chris Thomas Jr. from Marshall should help shore up a run defense that was inconsistent for most of last season.
2024 record: 5-7 (3-5)
Spring storyline: Virginia hit the transfer portal hard to boost its roster, signing 16 players in hopes of putting the Cavaliers in position to make a bowl game for the first time since 2021. While the program has made some strides since Tony Elliott was hired in 2022, he also knows this has to be the year in which significant progress is shown. His players have already spoken confidently about putting Virginia in a spot where it can compete for championships. We will get our first glimpse at the possibility this spring.
Position of intrigue: Virginia lost quarterbacks Anthony Colandrea (portal) and Tony Muskett (final season) and went into the portal to find their replacements. The headliner is Chandler Morris, now at his fourth school after spending last season at North Texas. Virginia also signed Daniel Kaelin from Nebraska as the potential quarterback of the future with four years of eligibility remaining. Look for Morris to take the reins giving his experience.
Player to watch: Linebacker Fisher Camac, a transfer from UNLV, has the ability to make the type of plays that set the tone on defense. Last season, he had 15 tackles for loss, 7.5 sacks, 5 pass breakups, 3 QB hurries and a forced fumble.
2024 record: 6-7 (4-4)
Spring storyline: Last season was supposed to be a breakout year for Virginia Tech. Instead, the Hokies struggled to a 6-7 record, lost 24 players to the transfer portal and saw some of their best players move on to the NFL draft. Though the Hokies bring back veteran quarterback Kyron Drones, there will a lot of changes, not only from a personnel perspective but among its coaching staff, with new offensive (Philip Montgomery) and defensive coordinators (Sam Siefkes).
Position of intrigue: The Hokies have holes to fill across the board, given the roster turnover. But let’s stick with offense and look at the running back room, where leading rusher Bhayshul Tuten is off to the NFL and backup Malachi Thomas transferred. Virginia Tech signed three transfer backs: Terion Stewart (Bowling Green), Braydon Bennett (Coastal Carolina) and Marcellous Hawkins (Central Missouri State) to fill the void.
Player to watch: Wide receiver Donavon Greene, a Wake Forest transfer, brings much needed experience and a veteran presence to the young, unproven Virginia Tech receiver group. Greene has been limited by injuries over the past few seasons, so staying healthy is imperative.
2024 record: 4-8 (2-6)
Spring storyline: New coach Jake Dickert replaces Dave Clawson, who stepped down after 11 seasons and one of the most successful tenures in Wake Forest football history. Dickert spent the past four seasons at Washington State, and though he has spent the majority of his career outside the Eastern time zone, he has found success at schools similar in stature to the Demon Deacons. Much will be different this spring beyond the head coach. Wake Forest will feature a new offensive scheme for the first time in 12 years.
Position of intrigue: Wake Forest goes into spring practice with a three-way competition at quarterback, a position the Demon Deacons have struggled with since Sam Hartman departed in 2022. Sophomore Jeremy Hecklinski returns, but Wake added two transfers: Robby Ashford from South Carolina and Deshawn Purdie, who played at Charlotte last season as a freshman before briefly signing with Florida in December, then opting to leave in January.
Player to watch: Running back Demond Claiborne is one of the most under-the-radar players in the country, so keeping him in the mix is huge for Wake Forest. As their leading rusher and a dynamic kickoff returner, Claiborne ranked No. 11 in the nation in all-purpose yards in 2024 with 131.7 per game.
Sports
The Playbook, Inning 9: Mastering the 2025 fantasy baseball player pool
Published
12 hours agoon
March 3, 2025By
admindata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/561f5/561f51e72fae3927e8db23de93cdce522264b3f6" alt="The Playbook, Inning 9: Mastering the 2025 fantasy baseball player pool The Playbook, Inning 9: Mastering the 2025 fantasy baseball player pool"
-
Tristan H. Cockcroft
Mar 3, 2025, 06:44 AM ET
(The full, nine-inning Playbook was originally published during the spring of 2020. The following 2025 analysis is new.)
We’ve gone through the basics of fantasy baseball, discussed salary cap strategy and how to build a cheat sheet. We’ve also provided in-season trade and free agency tips, dug deep into the advanced stats (including those provided by Statcast) and examined the latest trends around the league.
Still, even with all those tools at your disposal, there’s no greater truth to fantasy baseball success than this: The key ingredient to winning a championship is an extensive knowledge of the player pool itself.
This final edition of the Playbook takes you through my own playbook — a file I compile and maintain annually containing notes on hundreds of players, where I’ll jot down any sort of injury report, statistical nugget or neat fact that might help in the decision-making process. It’s from this file that I craft my player rankings and ultimately create my own cheat sheets.
They’re things you might consider when drafting any of the listed names, though my rankings ultimately provide you my best estimate of each player’s current-season worth.
With that in mind, here are a few of those players who have sprung to the front of my mind as we get ready for the spring action to come:
To illustrate how truly special a talent Bobby Witt Jr. is, Statcast’s Barrel and sprint-speed metrics paint quite the picture. He is the only player in the 10-year history for which we have that data to have managed at least 10% Barrel and 30% sprint-speed rates. He placed in the 92nd percentile in the former, the 100th in the latter and is baseball’s first player with multiple 30/30 seasons before turning 25 years old.
Aaron Judge might be coming off one of the best hitting seasons in baseball history as his 223 OPS-plus was sixth-best among batting title-eligibles during the Integration Era, and he scored 630 fantasy points. However, historic campaigns often coax us to overlook the effects of regression or a player’s past injury history.
Consider that, from 2000-23, there were 39 instances of a hitter scoring 600-plus fantasy points. Over each player’s following season, that group averaged 21.4 fewer games and only 507.4 points. One-third of those players scored fewer than 500 fantasy points — including Judge himself, who missed 54 days and 42 team games with a 2023 toe injury suffered when he crashed into an outfield wall at Dodger Stadium (as well as another 11 days and 10 team games with a hip issue earlier in the year). He finished 2023 with only 106 games played and 340 fantasy points, sixth-worst among those 39 “follow-up” campaigns.
I’m as big a Judge fan as anyone, but if he’s going to cost a hefty, almost Shohei Ohtani-like premium in drafts, I’m passing on him for 2025.
A first-round pick last year, Corbin Carroll began 2024 as one of its biggest disappointments, in large part due to his struggles adapting to some swing changes he had made last winter. Carroll straightened things out shortly thereafter — something I examined in this June column — batting .256/.348/.522 with 20 home runs, 26 stolen bases and a seventh-best-among-hitters 331 fantasy points. That’s a much better representation of what should be expected from him going forward than his ghastly numbers over 2024’s first 10 weeks.
Kyle Tucker‘s injury last season — a small fracture in his shin suffered on June 3 during an at-bat — was more of a fluke than a long-term concern. Keep that in mind when evaluating him entering what is his walk year, as well as his first with the Chicago Cubs. Tucker had scored the third-most fantasy points at the time of his injury (222), and he was comparably excellent after his return, ranking 21st with 58 points from Sept. 6 until the end of the regular season. At the time he got hurt, he was on track for a third consecutive 25/25 (HR/SB) campaign, something that has been done by only nine players in history.
Although Julio Rodriguez endured a disappointing, injury-marred 2024, he still managed a third consecutive 20/20 campaign to begin his MLB career. He’s only 24 years old, and he finished last season on a high note. He hit .295/.345/.486 with nine home runs and six stolen bases over his final 43 games, during which time he had comparable Statcast average exit velocity (92.3 mph), hard-hit (50.4%) and Barrel rates (11.3%) to his numbers from 2022-23 combined (92.4, 51.7% and 12.4%). Rodriguez’s free-swinging nature continues to make him more of a premium pick in rotisserie leagues than he is in ESPN’s points-based standard, but there’s an excellent chance he’s aligned for 2025 results closer to those of 2022 or 2023.
Combining the past three seasons, only two hitters have had at least a 15% Statcast Barrel and at most a 17.5% strikeout rate: Juan Soto and Yordan Alvarez. We all think of Soto as one of the best all-around hitters, with elite raw power and contact ability, but do we regard Alvarez the same? Probably not … but we should.
It’s a shame that the San Diego Padres couldn’t have claimed they played in the AL just so that Jackson Merrill could have snagged a Rookie of the Year Award in a season in which he was plenty deserving of the honor. That’s not to criticize Paul Skenes, who was every bit as worthy (and my personal pick for the award), but Merrill set a record for a player 21 years or younger with five game-tying or go-ahead home runs in the ninth inning or later. It underscored the Padres slugger’s rapidly growing raw power skills, which were most evident from June 12 onward, when he hit .304/.336/.596 with 21 home runs over 89 games. During that time, Merrill’s 14.8% Statcast Barrel rate ranked 14th, and his 38.1% fly-ball rate sat third among hitters with at least 250 plate appearances.
Let’s set aside shortened MLB seasons — the COVID-shortened 2020, in this example — for a moment. If we do that, Manny Machado would have nine consecutive complete MLB seasons with at least 28 home runs. That would make him one of only 16 players in baseball history with a streak of at least that length, underscoring his consistently excellent production even as he enters his age-32 season.
Few 2024-ending injuries warrant as close attention this spring than Rafael Devers‘ shoulder issue, which cost him 11 of the Boston Red Sox‘s final 31 games and caused him to hit only .164 with one extra-base hit, a double, in the other 20. To further illustrate the effects of the shoulder injury on his production, he had 46.0% hard-hit and 39.0% whiff rates, the former 8% beneath his rate up to that point in 2024, the latter more than 9% greater than his early-season exploits.
Statcast estimated that Anthony Santander should have been expected to hit only 36.6 home runs last season, (awfully close to the 33.3 he had in that category in the two previous seasons) and within range of the 33 (2022) and 28 (2023) he actually hit. He ended up with 44. When figuring out a three-year average to help project his 2025 potential HR output, it’s probably much wiser to chip 8-10 homers off last season’s total. Set a number around 32 as your baseline for his 2025 expectations.
Adley Rutschman was struck on the hand by a foul tip in a June 27 game, missing the Baltimore Orioles‘ next contest but no additional time. After that point, however, he managed to hit only .189/.279/.280 with four home runs over 71 games — a surefire signal that the injury took a toll on his production. Rutschman is another player whose health warrants monitoring during Grapefruit League action, as from the date of his MLB debut (5/21/22) until the date of that injury, his 214 fantasy points led all catchers and were tied for 17th-best among hitters.
Although his 2024 U.S. debut didn’t go quite as well as many hoped, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, at times, still flashed the top-shelf stuff that should quickly make him one of fantasy’s best starting pitchers. After surrendering five runs in the first inning of the season’s opening game in Japan, he posted the majors’ ninth-best ERA (2.34), 11th-best strikeout rate (28.1%) and 11th-best K/BB ratio (5.13) until he got hurt in a June 15 start. During that span, only 14 starting pitchers averaged better than his 15.3 fantasy points per start.
If rationales for Jarren Duran‘s breakthrough 2024 are what you seek, his defensive improvements rank high on that list. A liability in the field in his early MLB days, Duran was worth 11 runs defensively last season, tied for eighth-most among outfielders, and his 10 Statcast Outs Above Average between left and center field were tied for 12th-best among outfielders. That’s the kind of defensive skill that earns a player a fantasy-beneficial everyday role, as Duran played in 160 games and had a league-leading 735 plate appearances. Expect more of the same in 2025, despite Boston’s crowded roster.
Speaking of playing time benefits, Jurickson Profar‘s career bests of 158 games and 668 plate appearances had a lot to do with his 2024 rebound — one you can term a breakthrough if you weren’t wowed by his 2018. It probably also helped that he had a full spring training this time around. You may recall that after signing late in 2023, he had a miserable season. Regression nevertheless appears likely to have an effect on his 2025, especially as he hit .235/.345/.409 over his final 66 games last season.
Devin Williams‘ back injury, which cost him the first four months of the 2024 season, didn’t seem to have any adverse impact upon his performance after his activation. Among pitchers with at least 20 innings pitched from the date of his July 28 activation onward, his 43.2% strikeout rate ranked second, his 14 saves tied for fourth and his .133 BAA ranked 10th.
Keep tabs on the Texas Rangers‘ lineup plans during spring training, as Marcus Semien‘s status as the team’s leadoff hitter has a good amount of say in his fantasy value. He leads the majors with 2,919 plate appearances across the past four seasons, resulting in his scoring 1,841 fantasy points, seventh-best among hitters. Going by his per-game average, however, his 2.86 ranked only 15th among hitters (minimum 400 games), and he’s coming off what was a down year as a 33-year-old in 2024. Fortunately, Semien has remained in the leadoff spot in early spring games, but any change would deepen his downside.
Matt Olson has hit 74 home runs after the All-Star break over the last four years combined, second-most in baseball to Judge’s 89. Olson has also averaged 0.49 fantasy points per game more after the break compared to his pre-break numbers over this stretch. Keep that in mind when you’re evaluating an aggressive bid for him at the draft table, relative to letting him go and instead trying to make an in-season trade for him.
George Kirby has quickly become one of my favorite high-floor fantasy pitching targets, thanks to his pinpoint control and elite stuff. In both 2023 and 2024, he pitched at least 190 innings with a sub-3% walk rate, accounting for two of the only 12 such seasons this century. Kirby, however, is one of only three different pitchers to have done that while also sporting at least a 7.5 K/BB ratio in the same year, joining Greg Maddux (1995, 1997), Cliff Lee (2010) and Phil Hughes (2014). Though Hughes is the outlier on that list, Kirby is in some impressive company with Maddux and Lee, and he’ll play this season at only 27 years old.
Only two qualified hitters last season managed at least a 45% Statcast hard-hit rate but also no greater than a 15% whiff rate on all swings last season: Yandy Diaz and Vinnie Pasquantino. Both players’ elite skills with the bat make them undervalued players, particularly Pasquantino, who hit 24 homers in the minors in 2022 and 28 combined between the majors and minors in 2023.
Willy Adames‘ 224 plate appearances with runners in scoring position last season was an MLB-leading total, as well as the most by any player since Hunter Pence in 2012. Adames drove in a league-best 93 runners in the process, something that he’ll be hard-pressed to repeat in 2025. He also stole 21 bases, almost double his previous career high for stolen base attempts (11, in 2018 and 2022). Adames remains a very good, top 10-capable fantasy shortstop, but he’s bound to regress in both the RBI and SB categories in 2025.
Over the last four seasons, Isaac Paredes has pulled 71 home runs and Christian Walker 70, the 10th- and 11th-most by any right-handed batter during that time span. That’s important, considering both players are now with the Houston Astros, where their home ballpark, Daikin Park, has the Crawford Boxes in closer-than-league-average proximity to home plate in left field.
Mason Miller became only the third rookie reliever to manage at least 25 saves, 100 strikeouts and a sub-2.50 ERA, joining Terry Forster (1972) and Craig Kimbrel (2011), which is why I was shocked to see him place only fourth in the wide-open AL Rookie of the Year balloting. Perhaps that will help him sneak relatively beneath the radar when compared to other top closers, but he has the raw stuff that compares to anyone’s. Miller led all pitchers (minimum 50 IP) in strikeout rate (41.8%), average fastball velocity (100.9 mph) and Statcast’s expected ERA (1.77).
At the age of 34 and in his 13th season in the majors, Sonny Gray enjoyed what could by many measures have been regarded a career year in 2024. If you’re worried about his ability to maintain his performance at his age, consider what he just accomplished. His 5.8% walk rate was a personal best, and last season represented the first time in his career that he has had three pitches that he threw at least 10% of the time generate at least a 30% whiff rate (sweeper, cutter and curveball).
It’s easy to underrate closers who only recently moved into their jobs, such as the Ryan Walker of the San Francisco Giants. He notched his first save last season on Aug. 10. From that date forward, his 122 fantasy points were seventh-best among relief pitchers. Among those with at least 15 appearances during that time span, his 37.3% strikeout rate tied for ninth-best, his 26.8% hard-hit rate allowed ranked 11th-best, and his 1.91 FIP was 15th-best. Walker has the ability to be a top-10 fantasy closer in 2025.
To give you a sense of what a healthy Hunter Greene can do, consider that he stayed mostly injury-free between Aug. 20, 2023, and Aug. 13, 2024 (other than a 10-day IL stint in September 2023) spanning 158 Cincinnati Reds games. Even accounting for that brief absence, he scored 416 fantasy points, a total exceeded by only 10 other starting pitchers over that time. Additionally, in that same time span, only seven qualified starting pitchers had better than his 29.3% whiff rate.
Brandon Pfaadt had a 1.11 differential between his ERA (4.71) and FIP (3.61) last season, the third-widest in that direction among qualified pitchers. It was only the 10th time this century that a qualified pitcher had an ERA more than a run higher than his FIP, as well as a sub-four FIP, signaling a high degree of unluckiness for the Arizona Diamondbacks starter. Pfaadt is a potential bargain this season.
Yes, Jacob deGrom is one of baseball’s greatest injury risks, but he has been consistently excellent around his absences. In the last five seasons alone, coming off what were back-to-back NL Cy Young Award campaigns for the right-hander, 91.5% of his starts resulted in double-digit fantasy points, the best rate in baseball among pitchers with at least five starts. That included two of his three starts fresh off Tommy John surgery in 2024, when he was limited in terms of pitch count. Additionally, 51.1% of deGrom’s starts in that same five-year span were worth at least 20 fantasy points, also an MLB-leading rate.
If there’s any time to take a chance on deGrom, it’s now, with him fully recovered from his most recent surgery and having shown a high level of skill in his brief return.
Elly De La Cruz did have an MLB-leading 218 strikeouts during his breakthrough 2024, but don’t let that scare you about his potential growth entering his third big-league season. That he incrementally improved his selectivity at the plate last season bodes well. In 2023, De La Cruz chased a non-strike 29.2% of the time while in Triple-A ball, and 32.8% of the time with the Reds. Last season, he cut that rate down to 26.9%.
Mind Spencer Schwellenbach‘s workload increased last season, as it’s probably the best argument against his potential to advance into the top-10 fantasy starting pitchers in 2025. He was one of 16 pitchers in professional ball to experience at least a 100-inning boost, accounting for work at all pro levels and in foreign leagues, and he was the youngest pitcher among that group.
For those curious about the other pitchers under the age of 30 who were also on that list: Aaron Ashby, Shane Baz, Garrett Crochet, Davis Daniel, Ryan Feltner, Luis Gil, J.T. Ginn, Max Meyer, Casey Mize, Carlos Rodon, Yariel Rodriguez and Trevor Rogers.
The Astros seemed to crack the Yusei Kikuchi code, following their acquisition of the left-hander at the trade deadline. They coaxed him to decrease his four-seam fastball usage while leaning much more heavily upon his slider. In fact, last August and September were two of the only four months in which he has thrown fewer than 50% four-seamers and 30%-plus sliders across the past three seasons.
In those four months, he averaged 12.3 fantasy points per appearance. In the other 14 months, he averaged just 7.9 points per outing. Kikuchi’s time with the Astros represented two of his seven best-scoring months from 2021-23. Here’s hoping the Los Angeles Angels, his new team, have him continue with similar pitch selection.
James Wood does need to get more lift on the ball before he’ll truly break out at the MLB level, but to give you an idea of how much offensive potential he’d have once he does, consider his contact quality of 2024. His 59.1% Statcast hard-hit rate while at Triple-A Rochester led that level (among hitters with at least 100 plate appearances), while his 52.0% rate in his 79 games while with the Washington Nationals placed in the 96th percentile among hitters with at least 150 batted balls. Keep an eye out for any shifts in Wood’s swing path this spring.
Only two players had at least 150 plate appearances in each of the past three seasons, while improving their in-zone contact rate in both of the past two years: Shea Langeliers and Michael Massey. In Langeliers’ case, he’s a potential bargain backstop, and bear in mind that his 534 plate appearances last season were seventh-most among catchers.
Sports
Yelich makes return to field: ‘Cool to be out there’
Published
12 hours agoon
March 3, 2025By
admindata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/43eb4/43eb4cad6e2155e06cd3ddd693dc3048dd816a6f" alt="Yelich makes return to field: 'Cool to be out there' Yelich makes return to field: 'Cool to be out there'"
-
Associated Press
Mar 1, 2025, 06:25 PM ET
PHOENIX — Milwaukee Brewers outfielder Christian Yelich took a step forward Saturday in his return from back surgery by playing in a game for the first time since July.
Yelich was the designated hitter for the Brewers’ 9-4 Cactus League victory over the Texas Rangers. The 2018 NL MVP went 0-for-3 with two strikeouts and an RBI.
“It was just cool to be out there, honestly, because it’s a long road from the last time I did it,” Yelich said. “Honestly, that was a victory in itself for me today.”
The 33-year-old Yelich had last played in a game July 23. He went on the injured list later that month and underwent a diskectomy in August to remove the damaged part of a disk in the spine.
His back issues ended a season in which Yelich earned his third All-Star Game selection. Yelich batted .315 with a .406 on-base percentage, .504 slugging percentage, 11 homers, 42 RBIs and 21 steals in 73 games. He was leading the National League in batting average and on-base percentage at the time of his injury.
The Brewers could use a big season from Yelich as they adjust to the loss of shortstop Willy Adames, who signed a seven-year, $182 million contract with the San Francisco Giants after hitting 32 homers and driving in 112 runs for Milwaukee in 2024.
Yelich expects to be available for the start of the season. His presence in Saturday’s lineup was a step in the right direction.
“I honestly didn’t care what the results were at all,” Yelich said. “Just find out where you’re at and go from there. I thought there were some good things, some things that weren’t too good. But it was basically how I expected it to be, and my body felt good. That was pretty much the biggest concern of the day.”
Trending
-
Sports2 years ago
‘Storybook stuff’: Inside the night Bryce Harper sent the Phillies to the World Series
-
Sports11 months ago
Story injured on diving stop, exits Red Sox game
-
Sports1 year ago
Game 1 of WS least-watched in recorded history
-
Sports2 years ago
MLB Rank 2023: Ranking baseball’s top 100 players
-
Sports3 years ago
Team Europe easily wins 4th straight Laver Cup
-
Environment2 years ago
Japan and South Korea have a lot at stake in a free and open South China Sea
-
Environment2 years ago
Game-changing Lectric XPedition launched as affordable electric cargo bike
-
Business2 years ago
Bank of England’s extraordinary response to government policy is almost unthinkable | Ed Conway