Pope Francis condemned for urging Ukraine to negotiate peace with Russia

Published

1 year ago

March 10, 2024

admin

The Pope has been criticised for urging Ukraine to negotiate an end to the war against Russia, with a leading Ukrainian cleric and a senior Polish politician among those condemning his remarks.

The head of the Catholic Church called on Ukraine to have “the courage of the white flag”, adding “I think that the strongest one is the one who looks at the situation, thinks about the people, has the courage of the white flag, and negotiates.”

In an interview with Swiss broadcaster RSI, he said Kyiv, shouldn’t be ashamed to talk to Vladimir Putin’s regime, “before things get worse”, as “the word negotiate is a courageous word”.

“When you see that you are defeated, that things are not going well, you have to have the courage to negotiate. Negotiations are never a surrender,” he added.

Radek Sikorski, foreign minister of Poland, a staunch and vocal Ukraine ally, responded on X: “How about, for balance, encouraging Putin to have the courage to withdraw his army from Ukraine? Peace would immediately ensue without the need for negotiations.”

Mr Sikorski drew parallels between those calling for negotiations while “denying [Ukraine] the means to defend itself” and European leaders’ “appeasement” of Adolf Hitler just before the Second World War.

Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk, the head of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, responded, too, saying surrender is not on the minds of Ukrainians.

While meeting some Ukrainians in New York, he said: “Ukraine is wounded, but unconquered! Ukraine is exhausted, but it stands and will endure. Believe me, it never crosses anyone’s mind to surrender.”

Andrii Yurash, Ukraine’s ambassador to the Holy See, in a post on X, appeared to compare the pope’s comments to calls for “talking with Hitler” while raising “a white flag to satisfy him”.

Click to subscribe to the Sky News Daily wherever you get your podcasts

A Vatican spokesman later clarified that the Pope supported “a stop to hostilities [and] a truce achieved with the courage of negotiations”, rather than an outright Ukrainian surrender.

The term “white flag”, was used by the interviewer, and repeated by the Pope.

Negotiating peace would represent a huge change for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who remains firm on not engaging directly with Moscow on peace talks.

With the war in its third year, Russia’s massive advantage in resources has begun to tell through progress on the battlefield, while Ukraine is running low on ammunition and some of its Western allies are starting to discuss sending troops to the conflict.

Throughout the war, the Pope has tried to maintain the Vatican’s traditional diplomatic neutrality, but that has often been accompanied by apparent sympathy with the Russian rationale for invading Ukraine.

In May 2022, three months after the invasion began, he said that NATO was “barking at Russia’s door” with its eastward expansion.

During the Angelus prayer on Sunday from the window overlooking St Peter’s Square in Rome, the Pope said he was praying “for peace in the tormented Ukraine and in the Holy Land”.

“Let the hostilities which cause immense suffering among the civilian population cease as soon as possible.”

World

Thousands of Ukrainian civilians lost in hellish archipelago of Russian jails

Published

2 hours ago

May 16, 2025

admin

Thousands of Ukrainian civilians lost in hellish archipelago of Russian jails

In all the horrors of this war, the plight of thousands of civilians abducted by Russia is one of the worst, but is in danger of being overlooked.

Warning: This report contains details of torture and sexual abuse

Their fate is not mentioned for instance in Donald Trump’s peace plan currently being wrestled over, let alone any demands they are released by Russia.

But their plight is truly horrific. Ukraine has identified almost 16,000 names of people lost in a gulag of 180 prisons in Russian-held Ukraine and in Russia itself, as far away as Siberia.

It is a war crime to take civilians hostage during a conflict but that has not deterred Vladimir Putin’s regime.

Worse, there is abundant evidence they are being tortured, sexually abused and killed in custody.

Oleksandra Matviichuk, a Nobel Prize-winning Ukrainian human rights lawyer, said: “I interviewed hundreds of people who survived Russian captivity, men and women, mostly civilians, and they told me how they were beaten, raped, smashed into wooden boxes.

“Their fingers were cut, their nails were torn away, their nails were drilled. There were electrical shocks through their genitalia. One woman told me how her eye was dug out with a spoon.”

When the Russians took territory north of Kyiv at the start of their illegal invasion, they came for the men, among them Dmytro Khilyuk.

Apart from a short letter sent from captivity a few months later, his elderly parents have not seen him since.

‘I just can’t take it anymore’

“We’re old and we’re sick,” his mother Halyna, bedridden after a stroke, told us.

“We’ve been without our only child for four years now, not knowing anything, where he is, how he is.”

She wept as she told us of the agony of living with the uncertainty about their son.

“I just can’t take it anymore. Why is my child suffering like this? It’s been four years. All we get are endless talks, talks, and more talks. And nothing changes. I could die any day… and never see my child again.”

Khilyuk has lost half his weight and most of his teeth

A year ago a fellow prisoner who had shared a cell with Mr Khilyuk was released. He said Mr Khilyuk had lost half his weight and most of his teeth.

Fellow journalist and friend of Mr Khilyuk, Stas Kozluk, told us he was worried about his state of mind.

“We just can’t imagine what can happen with the mind of a human being that’s captured and spends three years in that condition. To be honest, I don’t know how to help him. And that’s the most terrifying thing,” he said.

Russia releases no information

Ukrainian authorities can only piece together information about the abducted civilians. Mr Kozluk told us those who’ve been detained learn the phone numbers and names of relatives of others they are held with.

Those who are released pass on what information they can.

Russia releases no information about those civilians it is holding illegally, against the rules of war.

‘The world doesn’t understand’

Thousands of innocent civilians are lost in a hellish archipelago of Russian jails notorious for their evil regime of abuse.

And the world, says Oleksandra Matviichuk, is in danger of forgetting about them.

“I think the world doesn’t understand, first, the cruelty and unhuman conditions in which Ukrainians are held in Russian captivity,” she says.

“Second, they don’t understand that Russia detained not just military, but civilians. And according to the Geneva Convention, they have to be released immediately without any exchanges, without any conditions.”

Diplomatic efforts to end this war grind on fitfully. But there has been very little pressure on Russia to end its illegal abduction of thousands of innocents.

World

US ‘doesn’t have high expectations’ for Ukraine-Russia negotiations, Marco Rubio admits

Published

5 hours ago

May 16, 2025

admin

US 'doesn't have high expectations' for Ukraine-Russia negotiations, Marco Rubio admits

The United States “doesn’t have high expectations” for negotiations in Turkey between Russia and Ukraine to end the war, America’s top diplomat has admitted.

US secretary of state Marco Rubio said he did not think there would be a “breakthrough” in discussions until Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin meet to discuss it directly.

Russia and Ukraine are preparing to hold their first direct peace talks in three years, but the negotiations will take place in the aftermath of Mr Putin declining Volodymyr Zelenskyy‘s offer of an in-person meeting.

It came after Mr Putin proposed direct negotiations with Ukraine over the war “without any preconditions” after the “coalition of the willing” countries threatened Russia with fresh sanctions if it failed to take part in a 30-day ceasefire beginning on Monday. In response Mr Zelenskyy had called on Mr Putin to meet him in Istanbul.

Ukraine war latest: Trump teases ‘destination unknown’

The Ukrainian president said he was sending a team headed by his defence minister, from the Turkish capital Ankara to Istanbul, to meet the Ukrainian delegation, though he said Moscow’s team did not include “anyone who actually makes decisions”.

Mr Zelenskyy accused Moscow of not taking efforts to end the conflict seriously by sending a low-level negotiating team he described as “a theatre prop”.

Russian presidential aide Vladimir Medinsky, who is heading Moscow’s delegation, said: “The task of these direct negotiations with Ukraine is to establish long-term peace sooner or later by eliminating the root causes of this conflict.”

He later said he expected Ukraine’s representatives to turn up for the beginning of discussions on Friday morning.

Mr Rubio said he will meet Ukraine’s delegation on Friday, adding: “It’s my assessment that I don’t think we’re going to have a breakthrough here until the president [Mr Trump] and President Putin interact directly on this topic.”

The team sent by Russia “does not indicate a breakthrough”, he said, before going on to say: “I hope tomorrow the news says they’ve agreed a ceasefire. But it’s not my assessment.”

He was echoing remarks made by Mr Trump earlier in the day, when he said: “Nothing’s going to happen until Putin and I get together.”

Asked if any plans were under way for a meeting between the US and Russian leaders, Mr Rubio said Mr Trump was going to make a decision once his trip to the Middle East finishes.

Tens of thousands of soldiers have been killed on both sides in the war since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, along with more than 12,000 Ukrainian civilians, according to the UN.

Russian forces are preparing for a fresh military offensive, Ukrainian government and Western military analysts have warned.

👉 Listen to Sky News Daily on your podcast app 👈

Sir Keir Starmer accused Mr Putin of “standing in the way of peace”, with the prime minister saying: “There was only one country that started this conflict – that was Russia. That was Putin. There’s only one country now standing in the way of peace – that is Russia, that is Putin.”

World

Iran ‘ready to make nuclear concessions’ – as Trump asks for Qatar’s help getting a deal

Published

23 hours ago

May 15, 2025

admin

Iran 'ready to make nuclear concessions' - as Trump asks for Qatar's help getting a deal

A top Iranian official has said the country is prepared to make a number of concessions related to its nuclear programme, in exchange for the lifting of economic sanctions.

It comes as Donald Trump, during his tour of the Middle East, urged Qatar to wield its influence over Iran to persuade it to give up its nuclear programme.

Ali Shamkhani, a top political, military and nuclear adviser to Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, spoke to Sky News’ US partner NBC News.

He said Tehran was willing to commit to never making nuclear weapons again, getting rid of its stockpiles of highly enriched uranium, which can be weaponised, agree to only enrich uranium to the lower levels needed for civilian use and allow international inspectors to supervise the process.

This was in exchange for the prospect of the immediate lifting of all economic sanctions on the country.

Asked if Iran would sign an agreement today if those conditions were met, Mr Shamkhani told NBC: “Yes.”

His comments are the clearest public indication of what Iran hopes to get out of a deal and their willingness to do one.

“It’s still possible. If the Americans act as they say, for sure we can have better relations,” Mr Shamkhani added.

However, he expressed frustration at continued threats from the US president, describing them as “all barbed wire” and no olive branch.

Similarly, he warned that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu might try to derail the deal.

Trump goes to the Middle East

Elsewhere, on the second of three stops on his tour of the Middle East, Mr Trump appealed to Qatar for help in the process.

He urged the country to use its influence over Iran to persuade its leadership to reach a deal with the US and dial back its rapidly advancing nuclear programme.

Mr Trump made the comments during a state dinner.

He said: “I hope you can help me with the Iran situation.

“It’s a perilous situation, and we want to do the right thing.”

Over the years, Qatar has played the role of intermediary between the US and Iran and its proxies – including talks with Hamas as its 19-month war with Israel grinds on.

This comes after Mr Trump told a Gulf Cooperation Council meeting in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, this week that he wants “to make a deal”.

However, he said that as part of any agreement, Iran must end its support of proxy groups throughout the Middle East.

A nuclear Iran

Mr Trump has always said Iran could not be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon.

While Iran has always denied doing so, the UN nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency, has warned that Tehran has enough enriched uranium close to weapons-grade quality for nearly six bombs.

The US and Iran reached a nuclear deal in 2015, under Barack Obama, in which Iran agreed to drastically reduce its stockpile of uranium and limit enriching up to 3.67%.

But Mr Trump scrapped that deal in his first term.

Today, Iran enriches up to 60%, a short, technical step from weapons-grade levels.

Washington and Tehran have engaged in four rounds of talks since early April.