Connect with us

Published

on

SPENCER RATTLER IS not done yet. He’s closing in on an hour for this afternoon’s throwing session, but he’s just sniffed out a challenge. The road to the NFL draft is a slog — the self-seriousness of the combine, the forensic analysis of testing numbers, the sheer quantity of questions asked and answered, then asked and answered again. (“The Patriots f—ing grilled me,” he says in between passing drills.) But for this one moment in late March, one month before some team in the NFL calls his name early in the draft — or not; he’s one of the draft’s most intriguing riddles — Rattler’s just a kid with a ball and the chance to one-up his buddy. He tells Mike Giovando, his longtime personal coach and the man at the helm of today’s training, he’s not ready to call it quits right now.

“I think my arm’s got one more,” he yells out.

He and Jalen Daniels, who spent time at South Carolina and is one of his training partners for the day, have been heaving long balls down the sideline, trying — and so far failing — to overthrow the speedy wide receiver Giovando has enlisted for today’s prep work. “He’s like Flash Gordon!” Giovando raves.

Daniels has just given it his best, but the receiver screams out a taunt from far downfield: “I had to slow down to catch it!”

Rattler, as he often does, has thoughts: “Watch this,” he says, ribbing Daniels. “Let me show you how to throw it to a fast guy.”

On cue, Shawn Charles, said fast guy, streaks down the right sideline. He’s a blur, like when the road, from a distance, goes wavy on a hot day. Rattler plants his right foot square on the 20-yard line, dances for a few steps, then launches one last moon shot.

The throw is hardly out of his hands before Giovando hollers his approval. “That’s it, right there!” The rest of the group — Daniels; an old teammate of Rattler’s from his high school days in Phoenix; and a hotshot quarterback in the Phoenix prep scene — lets out a collective gasp. This particular moon shot is easily 65 yards (70? 75? It all seems plausible) and Charles catches it over his shoulder, in the nick of time.

“He had to accelerate,” Giovando says, laughing, giddy from Rattler’s arm strength. The preposterousness of it. “He had to accelerate to it!”

Rattler is 23 years old, and it feels like he’s been a part of the public discourse for just as long. In that time, he’s been: the prodigy; the punk; the Heisman favorite; the flameout; the presumptive No. 1 NFL draft pick; the draft’s dead-man-walking; the comeback hero. But it’s this, right here — sublime, tantalizing arm talent — that keeps people coming back for more. It is tough to quit Spencer Rattler, even when it’s not quite clear who Spencer Rattler is. Or who he’ll be next.


IN THE SHADOW of some rolling Arizona mountains, Rattler ponders the climb before him.

He’s worked out with teams (Falcons, Broncos) and interviewed with teams (Seahawks, Patriots) and trotted out his best sales pitch for why all these prospective employers ought to hire him. But here, miles away on a high school football field in Scottsdale, it’s Denver that gnaws at him. He’s tossing a football to himself, waiting for the day’s throwing session to get in full swing, daydreaming aloud.

“They’d be smart to take me over Nix,” he says to his coach. Bo Nix, he means, the quarterback from Oregon. If Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye are this draft’s holy triumvirate of passers, with J.J. McCarthy right on their heels, Nix and Michael Penix Jr. are the quarterbacks most often coupled with Rattler. The next-best tier. The could-be-a-starter-one-day tier.

“They’re not getting you in the third,” Giovando says.

The Broncos, who are in the quarterback market this draft, have the 12th overall pick but none in the second round, so they’re all dabbling in a bit of NFL draft game theory at the moment.

“Hope not,” Rattler says.

Three years ago, a conversation like this would’ve been unfathomable. The notion of Spencer Rattler trying to separate himself from the pack? At odds with logic. He was the pack. Lincoln Riley had assembled a revolving door of Heisman quarterbacks at Oklahoma — Baker Mayfield (winner), Kyler Murray (winner), Jalen Hurts (finalist). Rattler was the next man up, except he’d be homegrown in Norman, not a transfer finishing out his college football string there, like his three predecessors. In the early days of Rattler’s recruitment, when Giovando first got on the phone with Riley, he told the Oklahoma coach at the time: “This guy is going to be like those guys.”

“This kid’s special,” Riley concurred. “I see it.”

He was both technician and showman, practically from the moment his father, Mike, realized his 2-year-old could skillfully throw and catch a Nerf football. “I would just look and go, ‘Wow, that’s not normal,'” he says. “And so then I knew, ‘OK, we got something going on here.'”

Rattler, the technician, perfected his back shoulder throw as an eighth-grader, according to his high school coach, Dana Zupke, which is hard enough to do as an NFL quarterback, let alone a middle-schooler still clumsy in a growing body. Rattler the showman could park himself at the 50-yard line, and sitting on the field cross-legged, throw the ball 60 yards and straight through the goalposts.

The technician: In ninth grade, he’d go to his high school field to throw alongside NFL hopefuls prepping for the combine; a nearby training facility would often have their college kids use Pinnacle High’s field. One time a college coach came over to marvel to Zupke: “Well, the best quarterback out here is your freshman.”

The showman: A few years later, he stood at the top of Tempe Butte — a literal mountain — on Arizona State’s campus, then fired footballs toward a trash can some 1,500 feet away and below, just because he thought he could. He nailed it on his eighth try.

Those who witnessed his feats say he’d preface them with a verbal wink. Watch this.

And we have. We were glued to the Spencer Rattler Experience, first for the come-up, and then when everything suddenly cratered. The only thing the masses love more than a conquering hero is to watch that hero’s downfall.


FOR A SPELL, Rattler’s story unfolded exactly as designed.

By the time he played his redshirt freshman season at Oklahoma — a COVID-shortened one in 2020 — he earned a 92.6 grade from Pro Football Focus. Only Mac Jones, Zach Wilson and Justin Fields, all top 15 quarterbacks in the 2021 draft, bested him, and the talk (and betting odds) turned loftier, inevitable. Rattler was at once the face of college football and the sport’s most formidable marketing power. The Heisman favorite. The presumptive No. 1 draft pick.

Then, in less than one year, he was not.

He was decidedly tolerable to start the 2021 season — a decent haul for touchdowns (10), probably a few too many turnovers (five interceptions) — but the offense looked disjointed and the team was winning tight games that didn’t need to be tight at all. Rattler wasn’t lighting the world on fire, but there was a quarterback waiting just behind him who might. Midseason and still undefeated, he was cast aside just before halftime of the Texas game for Williams, who’d go on to capture everything that once seemed preordained for Rattler. A Heisman (at USC, where Williams followed Riley after the 2021 season). The top overall draft pick, too (barring some sort of shift in the tectonic plates, Williams will be called first next week).

In short order, he faded to college football afterthought, relegated to national punching-bag status (Oklahoma fans once chanted midgame for Williams to take Rattler’s job), the transfer portal and the long, chastening road to starting over.

It was a dizzying paradigm shift. But for all that cratering going on around him, Rattler, himself, did not.

Just before the Texas game and the benching that ensued, his mother, Susan, was diagnosed with cancer. She underwent chemotherapy and was declared cancer-free, and when Rattler thinks about that time, he is clear on which battles were real. “That’s real-life adversity,” he says. “Having to push through that.”

He kept pushing through in football because Susan wanted him to, but he did so with a new kind of clarity. His father wanted to yank him out of OU the second he was benched; Rattler chose instead to ride out the year as a second-stringer before seeking a new homebase. The narrative imploded — Spencer Rattler, QB1 since the time he first held a football — but the story Rattler told himself did not. He was still a starter. Still a star. He was just someplace else’s starter; someone else’s star. It was simply a question of finding where, and for whom, he could “kill it.”

“I’m built different,” he says, explaining how he could lose his job but not his sure-footing. “I truly feel like that.”

He thinks of his bottoming out as something of a résumé-padder, instead. He had to learn three offenses (two of which were pro-style) at his two stops, and that counts for something. He was demoted and humbled in excruciatingly public ways. But he survived. Thrived, he’d tell you.

“I wouldn’t change a thing,” he says. “I wouldn’t change a thing because I’m more ready than ever because of the things I’ve had to go through.”

It helps, of course, that he started over — and started games again — for two years at South Carolina, where he, by and large, helped to revive the Spencer Rattler brand. He reestablished his credentials — by 2023, he was ninth among FBS quarterbacks with a 79.4% adjusted completion rate, per PFF. And at times, as he foretold, he flashed an undeniable ability to kill it. See: the November 2022 game against Tennessee, when he threw for six touchdowns and dispatched the Volunteers who, at the time, were ranked fifth in the country and generally looked like world-beaters.

South Carolina had never had a former No. 1 quarterback recruit — even a bruised and battered one — to call its own. Rattler had had masses fawning over him before, but he had lost them too, and it was a relief to feel valued again. To feel liked again, at all. At his throwing session, he pulls up to the parking lot next to the field in his G-Wagon that showcases a decal of the South Carolina emblem — a palmetto tree beneath a crescent moon. He steps out wearing a black T-shirt with the faces of Gamecocks legends — Jadeveon Clowney, Marcus Lattimore, Stephon Gilmore. Beneath that tee, he sports a Block C tattoo on his left arm, for the university that reclaimed him and that let him reclaim his place in the football world order. A different place, maybe a less exalted one than he once envisioned. But a place all the same.

“I’ve had a lot of NFL people tell me this. That’s one of the reasons they’re buying stock in Spencer Rattler,” says Jim Nagy, who oversees the Reese’s Senior Bowl, college football’s de facto all-star game and unofficial kickoff to the draft process.

“He has come out the other side.”


RATTLER’S YOUTH COACH loves to tell this one story.

Matt Frazier was unnerved, paralyzed over what play to call with six seconds left in the state championship game and his team, the Firebirds, down by five points. He called a timeout, visited the huddle — coaches were allowed in the huddle for kids that age; 9- and 10-year-olds — and looked at his quarterback. “Spence,” he said. “I want to run quarterback counter.”

They’d never run the play before, but Rattler looked at Frazier — Frazier swears this part is true — and promised him: “I got this, Coach.”

He did, in fact, have it. Rattler scored; the Firebirds won by a point.

The long span of Rattler’s career is littered with intoxicating anecdotes where he’s got this. Gauzy memories of telling his coaches, or his teammates, or strangers on the street to watch this. Take eighth grade: He’d regularly throw a pass and before the ball even got to its intended target, he’d throw up his hands. “Touchdown,” he’d say. And it would be.

“That was really the time that I got to see firsthand the moxie,” Zupke says. “OK, this kid knows he’s good. He lets everybody know he’s good. But he backs it up every time.”

Rattler is filled to bursting with moxie, Zupke will tell you. Or swagger, his friends will say. Or confidence, his father will offer. And because we’ve been exposed to him for so long, the perception of that moxie (or swagger, or confidence) has soured into something more distasteful. Arrogance. Worse, maybe. Entitlement.

He keeps a tight circle, but those inside it offer their theory of the case, and a culprit: “QB1: Beyond the Lights,” Season 3. Rattler spent his senior year of high school at Pinnacle trailed by cameras in service of the Netflix show; he was cast as the villain, and so the villain he became, to legions of people he didn’t know but who thought they knew him.

He had big dreams and was loud about them — “two Heismans,” he crowed in one episode. In another, he pointed fingers at his No. 2 quarterback, but never himself, according to that quarterback. Was he being deliberately over the top? Was it just two quarterbacks and friends bickering? It was simpler, more satisfying, to not ask those questions.

“Eyes were always on him,” Zupke says. And they weren’t just watching, he goes on. They were searching for proof of his divahood or his dearth of team spirit or some sin not yet dreamt up.

“I was like everybody else,” says Marcus Satterfield, Rattler’s offensive coordinator for his first year in Columbia. “All I could envision was the Netflix documentary, and when I met him, he was totally the opposite. Not an a–hole. He was grateful. Considerate.”

Austin Stogner started his college career at Oklahoma, transferred to South Carolina alongside Rattler, then repeatedly found himself on the receiving end of this conversation with their new teammates: He’s … awesome? I … didn’t think he would be like that?

Rattler has a mop of tightly coiled blond hair and a pair of diamond studs in both ears on any given day. A lot about him flashes, but his personality is best described quietly. He’s kind, according to most everyone around him. Thoughtful, even, which is why he does things like beeline for a South Carolina freshman running back who picked up a blitz, just to pay his respects. “It’s a little thing, but it’s a big thing too,” says Shane Beamer, his head coach at South Carolina. “We were 4-6 at that point. It’s Game 11 and a hotshot NFL quarterback is going out of his way to lift that freshman up.”

It is hard to hold two things at once sometimes. Rattler can be decent, and he can have outsized confidence. He can show love for an unheralded freshman running back and be a showman.

Back in his “QB1” days, the cameras settled on Rattler in the middle of a game. As he often did back then, he was hearing it extra from his opponents.

“I don’t even know your name, bro,” he told one such opponent. “You know mine.”

That was a person who knew who he was. Knew you did too. And if you hated him for it, all the better because that hate gave him the chance to do what he loved.

“He likes to hush the crowd,” his father says.

When he replays the tape of that moment, hears his own words all these years later, he doesn’t grimace. That was a young version of himself, he says. He probably wouldn’t say it again, but he’s not ashamed of it, either.

Because he still knows who he is. And if the rest of us have forgotten or disagree or don’t even register him at all, well, that’s fine too. It’s just another crowd he can hush; one more chance to make everyone tune in.

In the days before his pro day in Columbia, Rattler was at home in Phoenix and bumped into his old high school coach. “I got pro day coming up,” Rattler told Zupke. “Man, I’m so fired up for it. I’m going to kill it.”


SPENCER RATTLER HAS spent the months leading up to Thursday’s draft proving why he has been impossible to quit.

At South Carolina’s pro day, he zipped 65-yard moon shots again, this time for contingents from the Falcons and Broncos, the Panthers and Raiders. At the combine, he atoned for his 4.95 40-yard dash with a throwing exhibition where he showed his command of velocity and touch. And at the Senior Bowl, he spent the week racking up plaudits as the best quarterback of the week (Williams, Daniels, Maye and McCarthy were not in attendance; Nix, Penix, Sam Hartman and Michael Pratt were) and, eventually, the MVP.

“If he continues on this trajectory, I think you’re going to really like what you get,” says one NFL scout.

The question, of course, is who will get him, and when.

Nagy thinks there’s a case to be made that some eight or nine quarterbacks from this class project to be starters in the NFL. Rattler sits squarely in those ranks, but he’ll almost assuredly hear four of those quarterbacks’ names called before his own. Maybe five. Perhaps six, or — gasp — seven. His highs are so high: Flashes of excellent pocket movement, a knack for making throws from any conceivable angle, that lightning-quick release and effortless delivery. But his lows can be so low: A tendency to take bad sacks, a propensity for interceptions, the uncanny ability, as Mel Kiper Jr. has said, to look like a first-rounder one game and a late-rounder the next. He can make teams at once squeamish and starry-eyed, all which makes his draft projection as clear as mud.

That’s far from those dreamy days filled with top-draft-pick prognostications, but he is no draft afterthought, even after a fall from grace. That’s not nothing.

For one: “It seems like every couple years, there’s a guy that comes outside of the first round and ends up being a really good starter,” Nagy says. “And I think Spencer’s got a chance to be that guy.”

For two: Rattler, as ever, is sure of what lies ahead for himself, even if — especially if, if he’s being honest — not everyone else is too. Where would he draft himself?

“Shoot,” he says, then smiles just a little. “First round.”

He is settled in a lounge chair in the courtyard of his apartment building in Scottsdale. It’s a sprawling complex that looks like it deserves its own zip code, but in his small patch of shade, he gets a brief respite. There has been so much noise these past few months. NFL teams asking questions and scouts projecting and talking heads talking. But for now, there is also quiet. Rattler takes a moment to consider all that distance, from where he started to where he thinks he’ll go next..

“Sleep on me,” he says. “For now.”

He doesn’t say it in this moment, but the idea is there, looming, ever present. Watch this.

Continue Reading

Sports

Source: Hoosiers, OC Shanahan finalizing deal

Published

on

By

Source: Hoosiers, OC Shanahan finalizing deal

Indiana is expected to finalize a new three-year contract with offensive coordinator Mike Shanahan, a source confirmed to ESPN on Thursday, as the school reinforces its commitment to coach Curt Cignetti’s staff.

The deal will keep Shanahan as Indiana’s offensive playcaller for the 2026 season and potentially through 2028. Shanahan has worked on Cignetti’s staffs since 2016, at IU-Pennsylvania, Elon and James Madison before coming to Indiana in 2024.

Indiana last week secured a new contract for defensive coordinator Bryant Haines that will make him among the nation’s highest-paid assistants. Cignetti lost only one assistant from the 2024 staff and will have at least his two primary coordinators back next fall.

The (Bloomington) Herald-Times first reported Shanahan’s new deal with the Hoosiers, who secured their first outright Big Ten title since 1945 and have the top seed entering the College Football Playoff. Indiana will face Oklahoma or Alabama on Jan. 1 in the College Football Playoff quarterfinal at the Rose Bowl presented by Prudential.

Led by Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback Fernando Mendoza, Indiana’s offense ranks third nationally in scoring (41.9 PPG) and rose to 10th in rushing (221 YPG), a significant increase from 2024. Since Shanahan’s arrival, Indiana leads the FBS in scoring at 41.6 points per game.

Shanahan, 35, is a former Pitt wide receiver who started his career at his alma mater before joining Cignetti.

Continue Reading

Sports

Muschamp returns as Horns fire DC Kwiatkowski

Published

on

By

Muschamp returns as Horns fire DC Kwiatkowski

The Texas Longhorns are bringing back Will Muschamp to replace defensive coordinator Pete Kwiatkowski, who was fired along with defensive passing game coordinator Duane Akina on Thursday.

Longhorns coach Steve Sarkisian announced that he wasn’t bringing back Kwiatkowski, who had served as his defensive coordinator since 2021, and Akina in a major shakeup for a unit that didn’t meet expectations during a 9-3 season in which the preseason No. 1 failed to make the College Football Playoff.

Sarkisian is turning to Muschamp, who returns to Austin after serving as Texas’ defensive coordinator from 2008 to 2010 and was once the program’s head coach in waiting under Mack Brown.

“Having the opportunity to hire Will Muschamp provides us the leadership to take our defense to another level,” Sarkisian said in a statement. “Will is a guy I’ve known for a long time, always admired and is as good of a defensive mind and coach as I’ve ever coached against. His defenses are relentless; he absolutely gets the best out of his staff and players and is such an extremely well-respected coach.

“I know Longhorn Nation knows him well. He led some incredible defenses here on the Forty, and I’m so fired up to be bringing him back to Texas. He’ll be an awesome addition to our staff.”

In his previous stint at Texas, Muschamp helped the Longhorns get to the BCS national championship game in 2009 with a unit that ranked No. 1 against the run, on third downs and in takeaways. He was set to someday succeed Brown, but he instead departed after a 5-7 season in 2010 to become the head coach at Florida, succeeding Urban Meyer.

Muschamp went 56-51 as a head coach at Florida and South Carolina. He joined Kirby Smart’s staff at Georgia in 2021 and served as the Bulldogs’ co-defensive coordinator in 2022 and 2023 before transitioning to an analyst role in 2024 and then stepping away from coaching in 2025 to spend more time with his family.

Muschamp has done some advance scouting for Georgia during the season while spending most of his time in Tennessee, where his son, Whit, is a quarterback at Vanderbilt.

“This is an exciting day for the Muschamp family,” Muschamp said in a statement. “We loved our time in Austin and truly enjoyed everything about working with Texas Football. We’re thrilled to be coming back to a program with one of the richest and proudest histories and traditions in college football. With what Coach Sark has done in rebuilding this program — knowing there are even better days ahead — I was fired up for the opportunity.”

Texas’ defense was expected to be among the best in the country in 2025, with several returning All-SEC starters, but it gave up 29 points in a road loss to the Gators and allowed 30 or more points in four of its last five games, including a 35-10 loss at Georgia that effectively knocked the Longhorns out of the CFP race.

Kwiatkowski was a finalist for the Broyles Award as one of the top assistant coaches in college football in 2024, and the Longhorns finished with the No. 3 scoring defense in FBS during a 13-3 season that ended in the CFP semifinals against eventual national champion Ohio State. During his five years in Austin, Kwiatkowski helped Texas achieve back-to-back CFP appearances and top-four finishes, and developed 12 NFL draft picks on defense, including first-rounders Jahdae Barron and Byron Murphy II.

Akina, a former longtime Texas defensive backs coach, just finished his first year back with the program after stints at Stanford and Arizona. The Longhorns’ pass defense ranks No. 102 in the FBS this season.

The No. 13 Longhorns will finish their season against No. 18 Michigan in the Cheez-It Citrus Bowl on Dec. 31 (3 p.m. ET, ABC).

Continue Reading

Sports

‘No fear of failure’: Miami’s Malachi Toney is ready for prime time

Published

on

By

'No fear of failure': Miami's Malachi Toney is ready for prime time

CORAL GABLES, Fla. — Carson Beck remembers the first time he saw Malachi Toney making plays against the Miami defense in the spring. He was running routes like a veteran and making moves that Beck calls “inexplicable.”

Beck stood on the sideline, unable to throw while rehabbing an elbow injury, but he had seen enough to know the receiver would be a star. He asked Toney to watch game tape with him, so they could be on the same page once fall camp started. The two spent hours together inside the Miami facility: Beck, the sixth-year veteran; Toney, the 17-year-old true freshman who should have been preparing for his senior year of high school.

They watched tape of Georgia, where Beck played the previous season. He pointed out the way receiver Ladd McConkey, tight end Brock Bowers and running back Cash Jones ran option routes to perfection.

“I want you to do it this way,” Beck told him.

Toney listened and nodded.

“Sure enough, we go out to practice in the fall, and everything is identical.”

But the moment that Beck knew Toney was different came during Miami’s game against Florida State, in early October. Miami lined up to go for it on fourth-and-2 from the Florida State 40-yard line, hoping to build on its 14-3 lead. Toney lined up just behind the right tackle, and the Florida State defense showed a specific look the two went over in the summer.

When the play started, Toney ran around the right side of the tackle to an open spot beyond the first down marker as the Florida State defense lost track of him for a split second. That was long enough. Toney quickly turned around, Beck got him the ball and Toney made one juke move to get him racing past the defense and into the end zone for a touchdown.

Beck stood there, incredulous. Toney had remembered exactly what to do, months after they went over the play. What Beck did not know was that Toney had been waiting all season for that moment.

“I knew once I got that look, it’s a touchdown,” Toney said. “It was all like slow motion.”

Toney finished with seven catches for 107 yards and two touchdowns in the 28-22 win. He had a third score that was called back because of a penalty. Afterward, Toney deflected praise, instead thanking the coaches and his teammates for believing in him while crediting his mom for his work ethic. “Getting up early and staying late, that comes from watching my mom,” he said. “If she can do that, why can’t I?”

Early the next day, at around 3 a.m., Toney sent a message to his high school coach, Mike Smith. It included a picture from the state championship game his freshman year in 2022, when Toney fumbled as the team was driving for a game-tying score.

Toney wrote, “This changed my life forever.”


AS MIAMI PREPARES to play Texas A&M in the first round of the College Football Playoff on Saturday (noon, ABC), Toney has emerged as one of the most fascinating players in the 12-team field. The ACC Rookie of the Year, Toney had 84 catches for 970 yards and seven touchdowns, rushed for another and threw for two more, lining up at every position on offense minus the offensive line.

“Hell, he even might be able to do that,” Miami offensive coordinator Shannon Dawson says.

Texas A&M defensive coordinator Jay Bateman said this week that Toney is “maybe the best player we’ve played all year.” Beck heaps even bigger praise on Toney, saying he is already one of the best players he has played with in his entire career. “If he continues on the path he’s on,” Beck says, “he will be the best that I’ve ever played with.”

At 5-foot-11, 188 pounds, he is not the biggest player on the field. Nor is he the fastest. But Dawson says Toney’s football knowledge, capability, body control and peripheral vision set him apart now, just as they set him apart as a youth football player in South Florida.

The Toney legend grew early on, when he started playing quarterback at age 7 because his team needed one. On his 8U team, he scored a game-winning touchdown on a quarterback sweep that went 40 yards to get his team into the playoffs. One of his youth coaches dubbed him “Baby Jesus,” and the nickname took off from there — though the devout Toneys avoid using it themselves.

Once Toney arrived at American Heritage High in 2022, the plan was for him to play receiver. In his very first game, he had 100 yards.

Toney was a bona fide varsity star, and it was hard to keep him away from football. He’d plead with his coaches to play in junior varsity games, too. He spent all his extra time on the game. Then came the Florida Class 2M state championship game against Miami Central. American Heritage trailed 38-31 with two minutes left and started driving for the tying score.

Toney caught a pass in the flat, and he took off. But as he was getting hit, he fumbled at the 28-yard line. Future Miami teammate Rueben Bain Jr. recovered with 1:17 remaining to give Central the championship. Toney sobbed as he headed for the sideline, inconsolable, believing he had cost his team the game.

His mom still has a photo of him on the floor of the locker room, in tears.

“That feeling that you cost your team a great moment, like a moment that will never be remade, that was the turning point for me,” Toney said. “Knowing that feeling will never go away, that’s why I work so hard.”

His mom saw a different Malachi from that moment forward.

“That freshman season put something different inside of him,” Shatravia “Toni” Toney said.

Malachi Toney doubled down on the work. Every day during lunch, he would go on the Jugs machine and catch 200 balls. He watched game tape religiously, competing against Smith for most hours watched in a week. Once, he got up to 14 hours and told Smith, “I’m going to catch you.” Toney would often call Smith in the middle of the night with questions about coverages, and plays they should run.

“Malachi,” Smith would say. “Go to sleep.”

By the time his junior year rolled around, Toney decided to reclassify and leave high school one year early to play in college.

“I had some coaches ask me, ‘Do you think he’s ready? Is that a smart idea?'” Smith says. “For 99 percent of kids I would say, ‘No.’ But for Malachi? I knew that kid was ready. This is what he’s been wanting to do his whole life.”

American Heritage made the playoffs again, but Toney was out of the regional semifinal against Fort Lauderdale’s Dillard with a sprained ankle. By his own admission, Toney was hobbled and unable to run at full speed. But trailing 14-0, Smith felt a tap on his shoulder.

“Coach, can I go suit up?” Toney asked.

Smith held him off, but only for so long. Toni saw her son, in a walking boot, headed back to the locker room and ran after him, knowing he was getting ready to put on his uniform to play.

“Malachi, you can’t do that,” Toni said.

“I’ve got to try something,” he told her. “We can’t go out like this.”

Toney came out after halftime to play receiver, but a few plays into the second half, starting quarterback and Texas commit Dia Bell went down with an ankle injury of his own. Smith turned to Toney and told him he would have to go in at his old position: quarterback.

Coming in cold with literally zero quarterback reps in three years? Toney smiled at Smith, the way he always did. Toney used to joke around in practice that he was a human Jugs machine because he could deliver the ball with both speed and precision. He threw his first pass so hard that his receiver dropped it. No biggie. Toney proceeded to lead American Heritage to 24 unanswered points and the victory.

They rolled to wins in their next two games before meeting Orlando Jones in the state championship game — the moment Toney had waited on since his freshman year. Only this time, he had the ball in his hands as the quarterback. Toney threw one dime after another — starting the game 15-of-15 as American Heritage won its first state title since 2020.

“I feel like I repaid the program,” Toney said. “I stayed down ’til I came up.”

“When he came in as a freshman and they were like, ‘This is Baby Jesus,’ I’m like, ‘I am not calling that kid Baby Jesus,'” Smith said. “But by the end of his career, after the state championship, I said, ‘You know what? I will call you Baby Jesus now.'”


TONEY ENROLLED AT Miami in January. He took his work habits to a new level with the Hurricanes. Every minute of every day was dedicated to either football or class, with little time for anything else.

What Beck saw in those first practices is what the coaches saw: a player who was not only hard to cover, but fearless. Put him in a two-minute drill and watch him make every catch and score. Jump up for a catch, land with perfect balance, then keep going? Check. That is why Mario Cristobal said last March, after a handful of spring practices, “They keep calling him Baby Jesus. You guys know who I’m talking about, right?”

Everyone in South Florida knew exactly who Cristobal was talking about. The rest of the country would find out soon enough. Miami opened the season against Notre Dame, in a national spotlight prime-time game.

“It was easy for us to see this kid’s special,” Dawson said. “Then it went to: ‘Let’s don’t talk about it too much, because he’s never done it in a game.’ Then he just made plays against Notre Dame. The game was not too big for him. He had no fear of failure.”

Indeed, Toney had six catches for 82 yards and a touchdown against the Irish, finding ways to repeatedly get open against one of the best secondaries in the nation. Afterward, Cristobal lamented, “We tried to keep him a secret, but it didn’t take long.”

The word was out, and defenses adjusted. Toney saw more double teams. He heard more trash talk, as players yelled at him, “This isn’t high school anymore!” He got pushed more when he got tackled to the ground. Toney never said a word back.

Dawson got creative with the way he lined Toney up. Because he played quarterback, Toney has a unique ability to understand not only what everyone on offense should be doing, but what defenses are doing, too. That ability, matched with his desire to learn, gave Dawson more options.

“You move him around, it doesn’t faze him,” Dawson said. “If you show him something on a whiteboard, or you show him something that somebody did — and it may not be his position — but we’re going to line you up here, and you’re going to do this. Then you go out to the field, and it looks better than the damn kid that you showed him.”

That includes lining Toney up in the Wildcat position, or as Dawson has coined it, the “Malicat.” In the regular-season finale against Pitt, Toney lined up in the Malicat and took the snap. He dropped back to pass. His first read, a post route, was covered. So he threw a wheel route instead to Elija Lofton for the touchdown.

Cristobal has repeatedly praised Toney for carrying himself like an NFL veteran, pointing to his work ethic as exemplary.

Every morning, Toney wakes up at 4:55, the same time as his mother. He arrives at the facility 30 minutes before he is supposed to, then proceeds to get taped up and stretched before going to meet with coaches upstairs to go over the practice script and take notes.

After practice, he spends more time on the Jugs machine, gets in the cold tub, heads to class and comes back to the facility to watch more tape before going back home to do it all again the next day.

“I know what I had to do to get to this position, so I was willing to sacrifice things like sleep, not going to parties, missing out on time with my mom,” Toney says. “What you put in is what you’re going to get out, so that’s how I go about it. If I want to go out there and have a big game, I’ve got to put in the work.”

Once rivals, now teammates, Bain has watched Toney work since his arrival in January. When the offense has a 30-minute break between the end of practice and a lifting session, Bain sees Toney lead the receivers on the Jugs machine. “He’s the last guy to leave the building and the first guy to be in,” Bain says. “It’s a mindset for him, and it’s a way of life.”

He has not let Toney forget that fumble. This past Wednesday, after the first-team offense went against the first-team defense to close out practice, he went up to Toney and could not help but talk some trash, telling him, “I’ve got a play in your mind that will last the rest of your life.”

Toney played it off, but Bain is right.

Because every time he takes the field, Toney remembers the way he felt three years ago in the state title game. He channels that pain into action. He grips the football tight.

He has not fumbled since that night.

Continue Reading

Trending