Kristen Shilton is a national NHL reporter for ESPN.
Nov 28, 2023, 07:00 AM ET
There is no official “quarter mark” of the NHL season because of the quirks of the schedule. While most teams have now passed the 20-game threshold, the Ottawa Senators have played only 17 games and the Washington Capitals 18.
Nevertheless, it’s time to grade all 32 teams based on their performance to this point. There have been some pleasant surprises — the New York Rangers and Vancouver Canucks — and some unpleasant ones too — like the Minnesota Wild and Edmonton Oilers. Who gets a passing grade, compared to their preseason expectations? Who is falling behind? Read on for the report cards for every club.
Note: Teams are arrayed alphabetically by letter grade. Ryan S. Clark graded the Pacific and Central Division teams, while Kristen Shilton graded the Metropolitan and Atlantic Division teams. Stats are through the games of Nov. 26. Preseason over/unders are courtesy of ESPN BET.
ESPN baseball reporter. Covered the Washington Wizards from 2014 to 2016 and the Washington Nationals from 2016 to 2018 for The Washington Post before covering the Los Angeles Dodgers and MLB for the Los Angeles Times from 2018 to 2024.
When New York Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns attempted to assemble the best possible roster for the 2025 season this winter, the top priority was signing outfielder Juan Soto. Next was the need to replenish the starting rotation and bolster the bullpen. Then, days before pitchers and catchers reported for spring training, the lineup received one final significant reinforcement when first baseman Pete Alonso re-signed.
Acquiring a player with a singing career on the side didn’t make the cut.
“No, that is not on the list,” Stearns said with a smile.
Stearns’ decision not to re-sign Jose Iglesias, the infielder behind the mic for the viral 2024 Mets anthem “OMG,” was attributed to creating more roster flexibility. But it also hammered home a reality: The scrappy 2024 Mets, authors of a magical summer in Queens, are a thing of the past. The 2025 Mets, who will report to Citi Field for their home opener Friday, have much of the same core but also some prominent new faces — and the new, outsized expectations that come with falling two wins short of the World Series, then signing Soto to the richest contract in professional sports history.
But there’s a question surrounding this year’s team that you can’t put a price tag on: Can these Mets rekindle the magic — the vibes, the memes, the feel-good underdog story — that seemed to come out of nowhere to help carry them to Game 6 of the National League Championship Series last season?
“Last year the culture was created,” Mets shortstop Francisco Lindor said. “It’s a matter of continuing it.”
For all the success Stearns has engineered — his small-market Milwaukee Brewers teams reached the postseason five times in eight seasons after he became the youngest general manager in history in 2015 — the 40-year-old Harvard grad, like the rest of his front office peers knows there’s no precise recipe for clubhouse chemistry. There is no culture projection system. No Vibes Above Replacement.
“Culture is very important,” Stearns said last weekend in the visiting dugout at Daikin Park before his club completed an opening-weekend series against the Houston Astros. “Culture is also very difficult to predict.”
Still, it seems the Mets’ 2024 season will be all but impossible to recreate.
There was Grimace, the purple McDonald’s blob who spontaneously became the franchise’s unofficial mascot after throwing out a first pitch in June. “OMG,” performed under Iglesias’ stage name, Candelita, debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard Latin Digital Songs chart, before a remix featuring Pitbull was released in October. Citi Field became a karaoke bar whenever Lindor stepped into the batter’s box with The Temptations’ “My Girl” as his walk-up song. Alonso unveiled a lucky pumpkin in October. They were gimmicks that might have felt forced if they hadn’t felt so right.
“I don’t know if what we did last year could be replicated because it was such a chaos-filled group,” Mets reliever Ryne Stanek said. “I don’t know if that’s replicable because there’s just too many things going on. I don’t know if that’s a sustainable model. But I think the expectation of winning is really important. I think establishing what we did last year and coming into this year where people are like, ‘Oh, no, that’s what we’re expecting to do,’ makes it different. It’s always a different vibe whenever you feel like you’re the hunter versus being the hunted.”
For the first two months last season, the Mets were terrible hunters. Lindor was relentlessly booed at Citi Field during another slow start. The bullpen got crushed. The losses piled up. The Mets began the season 0-5 and sunk to rock bottom on May 29 when reliever Jorge Lopez threw his glove into the stands during a 10-3 loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers that dropped the team to 22-33.
That night, the Mets held a players-only meeting. From there, perhaps coincidentally, everything changed. The Mets won the next day, and 67 of their final 107 games.
This year, to avoid an early malaise and to better incorporate new faces like Soto and Opening Day starter Clay Holmes, players made it a point to hold meetings during spring training to lay a strong foundation.
“At the end of the day, we know who we are and that’s the beauty of our club,” Alonso said. “Not just who we are talent-wise, but who each individual is as a man and a personality. For us, our major, major strength is our collective identity as a unit.”
Organizationally, the Mets are attempting a dual-track makeover: Becoming perennial World Series contenders while not taking themselves too seriously.
The commemorative purple Grimace seat installed at Citi Field in September — Section 302, Row 6, Seat 12 in right field — remains there as part of a two-year contract. Last week, the franchise announced it will feature a New York-city themed “Five Borough” race at every home game — with a different mascot competing to represent each borough. For a third straight season, USA Today readers voted Citi Field — home of the rainbow cookie egg roll, among many other innovative treats — as having the best ballpark food in baseball.
In the clubhouse, their identity is evolving.
“I’m very much in the camp that you can’t force things,” Mets starter Sean Manaea said. “I mean, you can, but you don’t really end up with good results. And if you wait for things to happen organically, then sometimes it can take too long. So, there’s like a nudging of sorts. It’s like, ‘Let’s kind of come up with something, but not force it.’ So there’s a fine balance there and you just got to wait and see what happens.”
Stearns believes it starts with what the Mets can control: bringing positive energy every day and fostering a family atmosphere. It’s hard to quantify, but vibes undoubtedly helped fuel the Mets’ 2024 success. It’ll be a tough act to follow.
“It’s fluid,” manager Carlos Mendoza said. “I like where guys are at as far as the team chemistry goes and things like that and the connections and the relationships. But it’ll continue to take some time. And winning helps, clearly.”
Kristian Campbell had just finished his news conference Saturday afternoon when he was getting ready to join a group photo with his parents and Boston Red Sox ownership.
He was standing between his mom and dad when his mother, Tonya, reached forward and adjusted the 22-year-old rookie’s sport jacket before the group looked at the photographer.
His bigger life-altering moment came earlier this week.
On Wednesday, he agreed to a $60 million, eight-year contract, less than a week after his major league debut.
“It was a life-changing opportunity for me and my family,” Campbell said. “It was something I couldn’t pass up.”
It was Boston’s second Fenway news conference on a signing in as many days, after the club held one for Garrett Crochet, who agreed to a $170 million, six-year contract. They acquired him in an offseason trade from the Chicago White Sox.
“We’ll keep doing this every day as long as people want to keep extending,” team CEO and president Sam Kennedy said.
“The word to describe your son around camp, from where I sit anyway, is humility,” Kennedy said, looking at Campbell’s mother and father, Kenneth, seated in the front row to his right. “That’s probably life’s greatest achievement, so congratulations.”
An infielder and outfielder, Campbell made his big league debut March 27 as Boston’s youngest Opening Day starter at second since Reggie Smith. He was slated to start in center on Saturday, but the game against the Cardinals was postponed due to rain.
“Here we are today, sharing what I would call a massively significant moment for this organization because Kristian was not drafted in the first round, he was not a top prospect entering the organization,” chief baseball officer Craig Breslow said. “What he was is a good player who made himself a great player because of his work ethic.”
Campbell is hitting .423 with two homers and five RBIs in eight games.
So, why did the club come to the decision to sign him to an extension so quickly?
“From a baseball sense, teams are getting better and better of forecasting what players are able to accomplish,” Breslow said.
For a player who was drafted in the fourth round two years ago from Georgia Tech, it was a rapid rise to the majors.
“They made the process really easy for me,” Campbell said. “They developed me from Day 1. As soon as I got drafted, made me who I am today.”
Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.
DENVER — Ryan McMahon took a one-hopper and turned it into three outs. It’s the first time he has been a part of a triple play.
The Colorado Rockies have the baseball from the fifth triple play in franchise history, just not the win as the Athletics rallied for a 7-4 victory on Saturday night.
For that, the Athletics can credit Jacob Wilson, who hit into the second-inning, 5-4-3 triple play. Wilson’s two-run double in the sixth dropped on the left-field line and gave the Athletics the lead after trailing 3-0.
“It felt, obviously, really good to be able to bounce back,” Wilson said. “That was kind of big for me.”
Here’s how the triple play unfolded: With two on, Wilson sent a chopper to McMahon and he fielded it with his momentum going toward the bag. McMahon stepped on third and quickly threw to second baseman Kyle Farmer, who tossed the ball to first baseman Michael Toglia.
One-two-three, just like that.
“Once I saw that I hit it pretty much almost right over third base, I was like, ‘All right, this is gonna to be bad,'” Wilson said. “But it’s something you’ve just got to let go. We ended up winning the game. Either way, I’m happy.”
For McMahon, this was a new experience at the hot corner.
“Never even attempted one before,” McMahon said of a triple play. “That was my first attempt.”
The previous time Colorado turned a triple play was Sept. 1, 2015, against Arizona. It was the first time the Athletics have hit into a triple play since Sean Murphy on June 20, 2021, at the New York Yankees.
Despite the triple play, the Rockies dropped their sixth straight game. The team is now 1-7, which is tied with the 2005 club for the worst mark through the opening eight games.
“We’re going to show up and play as hard as we can every single day,” McMahon said. “We’ve got a lot of guys in the locker room who care. … We’ll get our groove. We’ll get going, we’ll get the bats going, we’ll get the defense going, we’ll get the pitching going, we’ll get it all going.”