
College Football Playoff 2024: Quarterfinal first look
More Videos
Published
9 months agoon
By
adminBeginning with snow in South Bend, the College Football Playoff made its on-campus debut this weekend. The scenes have not disappointed.
Up next is the quarterfinal round, which features four games played at traditional postseason sites: the Rose Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, Sugar Bowl and Peach Bowl. Much like the first round, the quarterfinals will span two days. No. 3 Boise State kicks things off and will make its first-ever CFP appearance — albeit in a very familiar game, the Fiesta Bowl, where 18 years ago much of the country learned about the Broncos in their unforgettable win against Oklahoma. They’ll face No. 6 Penn State.
The New Year’s Day slate begins with perhaps the most surprising CFP entrant: Arizona State, which was picked to finish last in the 16-team Big 12 and won the league to earn the No. 4 seed. Coach Kenny Dillingham’s Sun Devils will be in the Chick-fil-A Peach Bowl for the first time since 1970 and will face No. 5 Texas. Up next will be the Rose Bowl Game presented by Prudential, in which No. 1 seed Oregon, the nation’s only undefeated team this season, will take the field and face No. 8 Ohio State in a highly anticipated rematch. An incredible day finishes up in New Orleans, where No. 2 seed Georgia, the only team in the CFP field to win a national championship in the past four seasons, will face No. 7 Notre Dame at the Allstate Sugar Bowl.
Ten teams are left in the hunt for a national championship, following a season of unpredictability. Here’s a look at the first two quarterfinal matchups and what to expect Dec. 31 and Jan. 1. — Adam Rittenberg
Jump to:
Penn State vs. Boise State
Texas vs. Arizona State
Ohio State vs. Oregon
Notre Dame vs. Georgia
Vrbo Fiesta Bowl: No. 6 Penn State vs. No. 3 Boise State
When: Dec. 31, 7:45 p.m. ET. TV: ESPN
What we learned in Round 1: Perhaps we learned Penn State has an elite defense, but that seemed pretty clear before the 38-10 win over SMU in which the D picked off Kevin Jennings three times in the first half, returning two for touchdowns. Moreover, those interceptions were as much a statement about SMU’s incompetence on the execution of those plays as Penn State’s brilliance. Perhaps we learned that, once again, the 106,000-plus fans in Happy Valley can create havoc for opposing teams, but that won’t be an advantage through the rest of the playoff for Penn State. Perhaps we learned coach James Franklin can win a big one. He had been just 5-21 vs. top-12 teams at Penn State entering this year’s playoff. But while SMU might have earned its No. 11 ranking, the talent disparity on the field clearly favored Penn State, and had the Mustangs not imploded of their own accord so early, there might’ve been real hand-wringing over Franklin’s perplexing fourth-down call from his own 20-yard line up 14-0 or the offense’s inability to break big plays against SMU until the score was entirely lopsided. In other words, Penn State’s win was encouraging, because things mostly went right, and the Nittany Lions did what they were supposed to do. But beyond that, an easy victory against an SMU team that helped by beating itself didn’t exactly prove that this year’s Penn State is finally capable of getting over the hump against a genuinely top-tier opponent. The really good news is, the Nittany Lions are going to get at least one more chance to do just that.
X factor: QB Drew Allar. Allar and the Penn State passing game have been a mixed bag over the past two years. The top-line numbers speak for themselves. Allar wins, he doesn’t turn the ball over, and he has moved the ball consistently against lesser competition. But the downfield threat has never quite materialized for Allar, even as the offense’s explosiveness has improved with Andy Kotelnicki calling plays in 2024. Part of that comes from the lack of a true speed demon on the outside, and part of it comes from a game plan built around two talented tailbacks. But there will come a time in these playoffs — and quite possibly against Boise State — when Allar needs to change the dynamic, force a defense to respect the vertical threat and win some battles downfield.
How Penn State wins: It’s unlikely Penn State can completely run back the blueprint for beating SMU, as it’s not often a defense is gifted so many big plays by the opposing quarterback, but the basic framework for a win should look a good bit like what the Nittany Lions did in Round 1. It’s no secret Boise State’s magic is created by tailback Ashton Jeanty, so if Penn State can force the game into Maddux Madsen’s hands instead, there’s reason to think it can cash in on some QB mistakes, just as it did against SMU. Of course, that’s easier said than done. Jeanty has faced his share of stacked boxes this season, so not only does Penn State need to game-plan to stop Jeanty on defense, but Abdul Carter, Dani Dennis-Sutton & Co. have to actually bring down the Heisman Trophy runner-up before he can escape into space. — David Hale
Key player: RB Ashton Jeanty. Jeanty has turned in one of the best seasons college football has ever seen from a running back, rushing for 2,497 yards and 29 touchdowns, to finish second in the Heisman voting. He needs 132 yards to break Barry Sanders’ single-season rushing record, which has stood since 1988 (when bowl stats did not count toward official stats). Jeanty can do it all: get tough yards, break long ones, catch passes. And he has done it as the focal point from opposing defenses in a way few players ever are.
X factor: QB Maddux Madsen. There isn’t really a question of what the Broncos will get from Jeanty. He’s going to deliver when the chances are there and, probably, when they aren’t. In the Mountain West, he was dominant enough to minimize the importance of the passing game. That won’t be the case in this game. The Broncos will need complementary football and Madsen to rise to the occasion. In the regular season, Madsen did an excellent job protecting the football — he threw 29 touchdowns to just three interceptions — and that has to be the case against Penn State. The Nittany Lions terrorized SMU quarterback Kevin Jennings, and SMU never stood a chance with his poor performance.
How Boise State wins: When the Broncos lost by three at Oregon in September, they went toe-to-toe with the Ducks from start to finish. That performance earned them a lot of credibility with the selection committee and is perhaps the blueprint for how to advance. The key part here is not falling behind early. They never trailed by more than a score against Oregon, and that allowed Jeanty to stay as involved as possible. He’s going to see loaded boxes, as usual, but the opposing talent level is much higher than anything the Broncos have seen since Oregon. If Boise State can hang on to the ball and avoid third-and-long, it will have a puncher’s chance. — Kyle Bonagura
When: Jan. 1, 1 p.m. ET. TV: ESPN
What we learned in Round 1: Texas can morph into whatever form necessary to advance. Quinn Ewers started 8-for-8, but he cooled off after a ball bounced off DeAndre Moore Jr.’s hands and turned into an interception. But the running game took over Saturday for the Longhorns. After running for a total of 60 yards in two losses to Georgia this year, the Longhorns had two 100-yard rushers against Clemson, just the fourth pair of running backs to top the century mark in the playoff. Jaydon Blue, who had 38- and 77-yard touchdown runs — the second the Longhorns’ longest run of the season — added some explosiveness to an offense that has been methodical all season. This Texas team has dimensions where it can shift gears.
X factor: Texas tight end Gunnar Helm is a reliable security blanket for Ewers and the Longhorns, catching a touchdown with 33 seconds left in the first half, and three of his other five catches went for first downs, all coming on first down. The threat of Helm on early downs over the middle softens up looks for the rest of the offense. The 6-5, 250-pound senior is now first in Longhorns history in catches by a tight end and second in yards and touchdowns by a tight end in a season.
How Texas wins: Run the ball and shut down Cam Skattebo. The Texas pass defense was gashed by Clemson at times, giving up three passing TDs after surrendering only four all season, but without Jordyn Tyson, the Sun Devils might not have enough weapons to keep spreading out the nation’s best pass defense. If Texas can contain Skattebo (in the passing game, too) and feed its own running backs behind a strong offensive line, the Longhorns can stifle the Sun Devils and milk the clock while making them play from behind. — Dave Wilson
Key player: RB Cam Skattebo. What is not to love about the way Skattebo plays? His emergence became one of the best storylines of the season, as he ended up finishing fifth in the Heisman voting. He rushed for 1,568 yards and 19 touchdowns while adding 506 yards and three touchdowns receiving — the only player in the country with 1,000-plus yards rushing and 400-plus yards receiving (even with one missed game). As if that weren’t impressive enough, the last player to hit those marks was Christian McCaffrey in 2015. Skattebo got better as the season progressed — and his performance in the Big 12 championship game speaks to that. He was named Most Outstanding Player of the game after scoring three touchdowns (two rushing, one receiving), with 208 yards of total offense.
X factor: DB Xavion Alford. It is hard to call one of the best defensive players in the Big 12 an X factor, but so much of the focus on the Sun Devils has been on their offense that Alford deserves some of the spotlight — and he is likely to have an opportunity to come up big. An All-Big 12 first-team selection, Alford has been the model of consistency and an ironman of sorts. He played the fourth-most snaps in coverage in the Big 12 this season (424, 33rd among all FBS players) and allowed just seven receptions, the third fewest in FBS (minimum 300 coverage snaps). Teams have learned to not throw his way — he has been targeted just 17 times this season. As a result, he has allowed only 76 yards in coverage, fourth lowest among FBS players.
How Arizona State wins: Texas presents the biggest, most physical challenge up front that Arizona State has faced this season. The Longhorns completely owned Clemson at the line of scrimmage in their first-round game, so to defeat them, Arizona State will have to match or beat that physicality — and force Ewers into making mistakes. We all know what Skattebo can do, but Texas ranks as one of the best defenses in the country — so keeping that group off-balance is going to be key. Sam Leavitt has shown incredible poise as the starting quarterback, but the offensive line is going to have to make sure to keep Texas at bay so he does not get rattled. — Andrea Adelson
When: Jan. 1, 5 p.m. ET. TV: ESPN
What we learned in Round 1: Despite falling to Michigan, Ohio State is plenty capable of winning the national championship. The Buckeyes bounced back in a big way, throttling one of the SEC’s top teams all year in Tennessee. Ohio State jumped to a 21-0 lead in the first quarter and never looked back. Wide receivers Jeremiah Smith and Emeka Egbuka got open at will, and quarterback Will Howard put the ball on the money. Defensively, linebacker Cody Simon set a physical tone, cracking Tennessee quarterback Nico Iamaleava‘s helmet on the opening drive with a devastating hit. It’s hard to see anyone else in the playoff defeating this version of the Buckeyes.
X factor: The Volunteers simply couldn’t cover Smith, who ignited the Ohio State scoring barrage with a 37-yard scoring grab on the opening possession. Ohio State curiously gave Smith only two targets in the Michigan loss, with both coming in the third quarter, resulting in just one catch for 3 yards. This time around, offensive coordinator Chip Kelly’s game plan against Tennessee clearly was to get the Big Ten Freshman of the Year and Wide Receiver of the Year involved early and often. The Buckeyes have capable veteran playmakers (Egbuka, TreVeyon Henderson, Quinshon Judkins), but Ohio State’s offense is at its most dangerous when Smith is touching the ball.
How Ohio State wins: In their first meeting, the Buckeyes allowed Oregon quarterback Dillon Gabriel to operate with a clean pocket (no sacks, only two QB hurries). The Heisman Trophy finalist made them play with 341 passing yards, highlighted by several completions downfield and two touchdowns on the way to the 32-31 victory. As the Tennessee game illustrated, Ohio State has the pass rushers — notably Jack Sawyer and JT Tuimoloau — to overwhelm the opposing quarterback. Getting to Gabriel in the rematch will be paramount for the Buckeyes. — Jake Trotter
Key player: QB Dillon Gabriel. This is why Gabriel left Oklahoma and made his way to Eugene, to play in games like this. The fifth-year senior will lead Oregon into the Rose Bowl with a chance to stay undefeated and get one step closer to his ultimate goal of winning a national championship. Only Shedeur Sanders had a better completion percentage than Gabriel this season, an impressive feat when you consider this is his first year in the Ducks’ offense. Gabriel fit in seamlessly into offensive coordinator Will Stein’s unit and has produced his best games when Oregon has needed him the most — 341 yards and two touchdowns against Ohio State and 283 yards and four touchdowns in the Big Ten title game against Penn State. For Oregon to advance, Gabriel will need to not just replicate those kinds of performances, but likely dig deeper for more.
X factor: DE Jordan Burch. Oregon’s defense hasn’t exactly lacked for much given its depth and talent, but Burch has been a force. Despite missing four games with an injury, he has been able to tally 8.5 sacks (20th in the country), including a 2.5-sack outing against Washington in the regular-season finale. Having an extended rest period between the Big Ten title game and the Rose Bowl is a boon for a player like Burch, who could single-handedly tilt the game in the Ducks’ favor by wreaking havoc in the opposing team’s backfield.
How Oregon wins: The Ducks have the benefit (or the curse, depending on how you look at it) no other team in the quarterfinals has: They’ve already beaten their opponent once. Against the Buckeyes in October, Oregon fought fire with fire, out-gaining, outmatching and ultimately outscoring Ohio State by a single point in Eugene, thanks to a handful of explosive plays, fewer penalties and winning the turnover battle (2-0). The margin between these two teams is already slim and on a neutral site, Oregon will have to be more explosive, more disciplined and simply better — especially on defense, where they allowed 467 total yards — to be able to beat a tough opponent twice. The way the playoff bracket shook out is not how the No. 1 seed Ducks would have likely preferred, but what we get as a result is a rematch that could provide us with an all-time classic between arguably the two best teams in the country this year. It’s only fitting that the setting will be the Rose Bowl. — Paolo Uggetti
When: Jan. 1, 8:45 p.m. ET. TV: ESPN
What we learned in Round 1: Notre Dame has a championship-level defense with stars at all three levels. Safety Xavier Watts won the Bronko Nagurski Award in 2023, but he’s actually even better this season and showed why against Indiana with 10 tackles and an interception. Jaiden Ausberry led a playmaking group of linebackers and Rylie Mills created havoc up front, as Notre Dame flexed on third down (7 of 13 conversions). Notre Dame’s offense isn’t always the most fluid unit, but with so many running options, chunk plays are always possible, and Jeremiyah Love can deliver them, as he showed with a 98-yard touchdown, the longest play in CFP history.
X factor: WR Jordan Faison, a standout lacrosse player thrust into action at wide receiver in 2023 because of attrition, has become a sneaky good target for quarterback Riley Leonard. Despite missing three early-season games with a sprained ankle, Faison has made multiple catches in every contest he has appeared in, and he had a career-high seven receptions for 89 yards against Indiana. “He’s a playmaker, man,” coach Marcus Freeman said. The sophomore also has a knack for shining in the postseason, as he earned Sun Bowl MVP honors last year with 115 receiving yards and a touchdown against Oregon State. Notre Dame can’t beat Georgia strictly with its run game, and it will need wideouts such as Faison to make notable contributions.
How Notre Dame wins: The Irish must harass Georgia quarterback Gunner Stockton, likely filling in for injured starter Carson Beck, just as they did Indiana’s Kurtis Rourke on Friday. Notre Dame’s defense, which has carried the team much of the season, recorded 10 tackles for loss and three sacks against Indiana and rarely let the Hoosiers operate on schedule. The Irish also need to replicate the offensive balance they showed against Indiana while being a bit more consistent on the ground. Remove Love’s 98-yard touchdown, and Notre Dame had 95 net rushing yards on 34 carries. Notre Dame also must play a cleaner game on special teams after having a field goal attempt blocked and an onside kick recovered by Indiana late in the game. — Rittenberg
Key player: QB Gunner Stockton. With Bulldogs starter Carson Beck probably sidelined for the CFP because of an elbow injury on his throwing arm, they’ll turn to Stockton, who is expected to make his first start in the Sugar Bowl. Stockton completed 12 of 16 passes for 71 yards with no touchdowns and an interception in Georgia’s 22-19 victory over Texas in the SEC championship game. He came off the bench to rally the Bulldogs back from a 6-3 deficit at the half. The third-year sophomore has completed 78.1% of his attempts for 206 yards in parts of three games in 2024. Stockton is more of a runner than Beck, but he has far less experience. At Rabun County High School, Stockton had 13,652 career passing yards and 177 passing touchdowns to go with 4,372 rushing yards and 77 rushing touchdowns in his four-year career. He set Georgia state high school records for career passing touchdowns, passing yards and rushing touchdowns.
X factor: RB Trevor Etienne. The Florida transfer returned from a nearly monthlong absence because of a rib injury and ran for 94 yards with two scores in the SEC championship game. He ran for 87 yards with three touchdowns in a 30-15 victory over the Longhorns in the regular season. Etienne can become a big safety valve for Stockton because of his ability to catch the ball out of the backfield — he has 28 receptions for 168 yards. Etienne is also a more-than-capable blocker, which will be important if Notre Dame’s defense decides to dial up the heat on Stockton. The Irish are 39th in run defense in the FBS (133 yards per game), and they held Indiana to only 63 yards in the first round.
How Georgia wins: With Stockton stepping under center, the Bulldogs are going to need their defense to rise up big time. This hasn’t been Georgia’s best defense under coach Kirby Smart; it ranks 21st in scoring defense (20.4 points), 36th against the run (127.8 yards) and 35th in total defense (334.8 yards). The defense has played well in some of Georgia’s biggest games, including wins over Texas and Tennessee. Linebackers Smael Mondon Jr. and Jalon Walker will need to control Notre Dame’s running game, and they’ll need to force the Irish into a couple of turnovers. — Mark Schlabach
You may like
Sports
‘Bragging rights for all eternity’: An ode to the Iron Skillet rivalry
Published
26 mins agoon
September 18, 2025By
admin
-
Dave WilsonSep 17, 2025, 12:03 PM ET
Close- Dave Wilson is a college football reporter. He previously worked at The Dallas Morning News, San Diego Union-Tribune and Las Vegas Sun.
If you needed a metaphor for what has become of the TCU–SMU rivalry, once one of the best in college football, consider the trophy that’s on the line Saturday. The Iron Skillet itself is not what we think it is.
The two schools, 40 miles apart, were once football royalty, Southwest Conference enemies playing with national championships on the line. Now, after multiple rounds of realignment, after NIL and revenue sharing and a path to the playoff became a priority, a rivalry is playing its final scheduled game. Disdain is not a business model anymore, unfortunately, for fans who long to feel it in their hearts.
The Horned Frogs and Mustangs first met in 1915, and within 20 years, the 1935 game was known as the “Game of the Century,” an SMU win so thrilling that legendary sportswriter Grantland Rice, who rode the train from New York to cover it, considered it perhaps the greatest game ever played in the first 60 years of the sport.
By 1946, the rivalry was so bitter that the two schools, both of which had suffered vandalism on campus by opposing students, apparently decided that the thing that would stop all the shenanigans would be to create a trophy the winner could hold for a year. And that thing was a pan. The Iron Skillet rivalry was born, inspired by Michigan and Minnesota‘s battle for the Little Brown Jug.
But over the years, the tradition faded, teams stopped handing it over to each other and the original was lost. In 1993, both schools’ student governments resurrected the tradition, and an iron skillet adorned with a plaque became a trophy once again. But a nod to the past couldn’t inspire much more than nostalgia: The Frogs went 4-7 that season and SMU finished 2-7-2. These were the dark days of a once-great series. TCU, which won more games (90) than any other major school in the country from 1929 through 1938, would be ranked in the AP poll just twice between 1961 and 1999.
SMU, which produced a Heisman Trophy winner in the great Doak Walker in 1948, fell into mediocrity, then roared back to prominence in the Pony Express days of the 1980s, finishing in the top 10 three times between 1981 and 1984. But after the NCAA’s hammer fell on the Mustangs and they were given the “death penalty” for repeated recruiting violations, SMU did not play any games during the 1987 and 1988 seasons and would not be ranked again until 2019. The two never came close to peaking at the same time, except in 2011, when June Jones’ 8-5 SMU team beat Gary Patterson’s 11-2 Frogs, who were coming off a 2010 Rose Bowl win, 40-33 in overtime.
By 2018, TCU had kept possession of the Skillet for 15 of the past 17 seasons, including the previous seven. When a staffer went to retrieve it for the 2018 game, the rusted pan had broken at the handle. Sources, under condition of anonymity because of the sensitive nature of the covert kitchenware operation, have revealed that the current Iron Skillet is an impostor, a Lodge cast iron pan bought at an Ace True Value hardware store (retail value: $49.99) shortly before the game, and fitted with the engraved nameplate.
It’s an appropriate representation of the reverence that the Frogs had for the rivalry during all those lean years. TCU had ascended from the leftovers of the Southwest Conference to move to the Big 12 in 2012 while the Mustangs lingered in the WAC, Conference USA and the AAC.
Still, they played, because it was a rivalry fueled by spite at the school and city levels. Nationally, Dallas and Fort Worth are lumped together, but for most of their history, they’ve wanted nothing to do with each other. And that was especially true for Fort Worth, and more specifically for one Amon G. Carter, the city’s biggest booster who founded the Fort Worth Star-Telegram in 1906.
So it’s only fitting that when SMU and TCU meet Saturday (noon ET, ESPN2) for the last time (as far as anyone knows), that it will be played at the Frogs’ Amon G. Carter Stadium.
Carter, known as “Mr. Fort Worth,” had such contempt for Dallas that he would pack a brown-bag lunch for his sojourns to Big D so that he didn’t spend any of his money there. He was so incensed that Dallas was awarded the Texas Centennial in 1935 that he successfully lobbied his friend, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, to use New Deal-era funds to build a coliseum in Fort Worth so that he could put on his own centennial celebration.
“Fort Worth responded by erecting the world’s second-largest sign opposite the main entrance of Dallas’ exposition,” wrote D Magazine, a Dallas publication. “The green and red neon sign was one hundred and thirty feet long, sixty feet high and its message blinked day and night: WILD & WHOO-PEE 45 MINUTES WEST, FORT WORTH FRONTIER. Fort Worth was spelled out in green neon letters seventeen and one-half feet tall. The sign was second in size only to a chewing gum display overlooking Times Square.”
The two cities celebrate their differences. Fort Worth is “Where the West Begins” and “Cowtown,” a working-man’s city where they wore cowboy boots that got dirty. Dallas always had aspired to be a business center built more like the East Coast power centers, where boots were a status symbol. Fort Worth’s nickname of “Panther City” was embraced as a thumb in the eye of a snobby Dallas lawyer who, in 1875, said that Fort Worth’s downtown was so boring that he’d seen a panther napping there.
So on Nov. 30, 1935, when a national championship was on the line in the Iron Skillet, the frenzy around the game reached a level that equaled any rivalry matchup in history.
Amon G. Carter Stadium held 22,500 seats at that time, and by every account of the contest, between 36,000-40,000 fans crashed the gates and crowded into the place to see No. 1 SMU and No. 6 TCU, both undefeated, play for a trip to the Rose Bowl. Previously, no Texas team had ever been invited, and fans were so desperate to witness it that tickets were resold for as much as $100, equivalent to about $2,350 today, and the game was broadcast nationwide on NBC radio. SMU won 20-14 in a game far ahead of its time.
The Mustangs, led by Bobby Wilson, a consensus All-American running back, held off the Horned Frogs and the advanced aerial attack of coach Dutch Meyer helmed by Slingin’ Sammy Baugh (who, that year, led the College All-Stars to victory over the Green Bay Packers and became an NFL All-Pro as a rookie while leading Washington to the NFL title). It also ignited a lifelong fascination for a young fan, 6-year-old Dan Jenkins, who sat in the stands and fell in love with college football before becoming one of the great writers of the game.
“Pro football consisted largely of a group of second-class citizens waddling around in the baseball parks of blue-collar cities,” Jenkins wrote in a 1981 issue of Sports Illustrated. “Not until my first car date years later did I experience anything as thrilling as the Saturday afternoon of Nov. 30, 1935. It was the day TCU and SMU played a football game of such monumental dimensions that my dad took the precaution of bringing an extra flask of ‘cough medicine’ to the stadium.”
Jenkins, who died at 90 in 2019, recalled it as a game of “unbearable importance.” To Fort Worth and Dallas, he said, “the game meant something more: bragging rights for all eternity.”
SMU earned those rights, surviving Baugh’s 43 passes, which Jenkins wrote was “unheard of among civilized people.” The school newspaper, the Semi-Weekly Campus, celebrated the win as “the greatest exhibition of football, no holds barred, that ever hit the Southwest; perhaps the greatest ever given in the country. Rice stated after the game that he had never seen anything to equal it.”
For SMU, saddled with debt amid the depression after building its own on-campus stadium, the victory was a lifeline, potentially saving its athletic programs, according to “One Hundred Years on the Hilltop: The Centennial History of Southern Methodist University,” by Darwin Payne.
“SMU’s share of the Rose Bowl proceeds [from the January 1936 game against Stanford] was $78,183. The successful football season that drew large crowds had already boosted dividends to $88,292, some $24,000 more than expected. SMU’s trustees happily paid off the worrisome $85,000 note on Ownby Stadium and had money left over.”
And that leads back to why we are where we are today: The two schools, fighting for their athletics futures in an era defined by NIL and revenue sharing, are caught in a numbers game. In the modern era, the rivalry has too few fans — TCU has about 103,000 living alumni, SMU 140,000 — and for decades, they were mired in mediocrity.
For many years, there were no national broadcasts for either university. SMU was crushed by the NCAA in 1987, two years after TCU’s coach, Jim Wacker, turned his own team in to the NCAA for boosters’ payments and lost 35 scholarships and two years of television revenue, devastating sanctions for a program that had won just 18 games between 1973 and 1983, including four one-win seasons. The Southwest Conference fizzled and popped, and the teams fell on hard times. SMU, embarrassed by its reckoning after pursuing big-time athletics, decided to purposely marginalize football and not prioritize funding or realignment as TCU did. After football returned to campus — and old Ownby Stadium — in 1989, SMU won one or zero games seven times in the next 20 seasons, finishing .500 or better just twice in those two decades, once in 1997 and again in 2006. That year, the Daily Campus wrote that the average student attendance at home football games was between 1,500 and 2,500 students, an issue that has long plagued the Ponies.
Amon G. Carter Stadium, meanwhile, would not host another top-10 matchup after that 1935 thriller until 2014, when Bill Snyder’s brought his No. 7 Kansas State team to face Patterson’s No. 6 Frogs. TCU won that game 41-20, showing that its ambitions were oriented higher than toward Dallas. The damage was done, and apathy reigned as Patterson dominated the series. In 2000, his first year as a head coach, he led TCU to a 62-7 win over SMU and then went 16-4 against the Mustangs.
Ironically, the only reason the series became a rivalry again in recent years was because of the arrival of Sonny Dykes at SMU in 2018. He beat Patterson in their last two meetings, including a 41-38 triumph in 2019 in Fort Worth (claiming the new Lodge skillet) and a 42-34 victory in 2021 in Fort Worth (the 2020 game in Dallas was canceled due to COVID). Afterward, Patterson went on a tirade, saying SMU players had hit assistant coach Jerry Kill with a helmet and knocked him down, which was disproven by video, showing Kill had tripped. Suddenly, there was some drama again in the ol’ Skillet.
Patterson was fired that fall, and TCU turned to Dykes, who would’ve made Carter proud by bolting the Hilltop for purpler pastures — at the time, TCU was in a power conference and SMU was still searching for a seat at the table. Dykes beat SMU and his former offensive coordinator, Rhett Lashlee, the first two times he played them. Then last year, SMU blew out TCU 66-42 and Dykes was ejected because of two unsportsmanlike conduct calls, much to the delight of the SMU fans who had packed the place.
“When I got over to SMU … there just didn’t seem to be a lot of juice from the players for it, so we tried to play it up to a degree and we had some success and then it kind of became more of a rivalry,” Dykes said Tuesday.
Dykes knew what the game meant to SMU, because he had lived it. It was their one shot to take down a big league team. After 2022, when the Frogs beat Michigan in the Fiesta Bowl and made it to the national championship game, the school and former athletic director Jeremiah Donati instead focused on scheduling nonconference games that brought in revenue to build the department. Playing an away game at SMU every other year suddenly didn’t seem to make sense anymore. Fans might want to play rivalry games, but playoff runs are what keep coaches and administrators employed.
The sport has changed, and so then does the calculus, even after SMU landed a spot in the ACC in 2023 and became a Power 4 team on TCU’s level again last season. But the reality is that Big 12 and ACC teams don’t get the benefit of the doubt that SEC and Big Ten teams do, so every loss is magnified.
Even Lashlee, who suffered a 48-45 overtime loss to Baylor earlier this season, another sentimental nonconference regional matchup that fans appreciate, seemed to agree with that logic Tuesday, pointing to Clemson‘s seven-point loss to No. 3 LSU, and how large it looms after the Tigers dropped an ACC game to Georgia Tech.
“Rivalries are what made our sport awesome,” Lashlee said. “It’s what made TV want to cover our sport. And then the irony of it is TV is somewhat hurting rivalries. Now you’re putting schools in a position. If we still want big-time nonconference games, we better make it more accessible to get in the playoff because if you’ve got to play nine conference games and it’s all a popularity contest, does it benefit you to go lose a marquee nonconference game?”
Soon, the Iron Skillet will become like other rivalries lost to realignment, financial and playoff complications such as Pitt–Penn State, schools which have met 100 times, but just four times since 2000, from 2016 to 2019, and Oklahoma–Nebraska (88 total meetings, but just two since 2010). Cincinnati and Louisville, separated by 100 miles, played for the Keg of Nails trophy from 1966 to 2013 but have met just once since the Cardinals moved to the ACC, in the Fenway Bowl in 2022.
It’ll likely go the way the hiatus went between Texas and Texas A&M after the Aggies left for the SEC, with fans of the two constantly calling each other cowards or insisting their schedules were full — TCU says it is until 2032 — while rival fans consistently chirp at each other on social media, debating who would win if they actually lined up. The San Antonio Express-News called the Aggies-Longhorns feud the “dumbest rivalry in college sports” when they didn’t play for 13 years until Texas joined the SEC.
We have one last chance to witness history. The game won’t have much of a bearing on either team’s season, with a 12-team playoff leaving a window open for the loser, other than maybe making SMU’s path more fraught.
But Jenkins would agree that as the last one, this game will mean something more: bragging rights for all eternity. Or at least until another round of realignment reunites them.
Sports
Former S. Carolina QB Shaw stable after collapse
Published
26 mins agoon
September 18, 2025By
admin
-
Associated Press
Sep 18, 2025, 03:31 PM ET
GREENVILLE, S.C. — Former South Carolina quarterback Connor Shaw was in stable condition Thursday, a day after he collapsed while coaching his son’s flag football team.
The city of Simpsonville said Shaw was coaching at Gracely Park on Wednesday, and the incident occurred about 15 minutes after the game started.
Shaw, 33, was taken by emergency services to Prisma Health Greenville Memorial Hospital. The city of Simpsonville said he was in stable condition Thursday morning.
“The Simpsonville Parks and Recreation Department and City of Simpsonville have Mr. Shaw and his family in our thoughts and prayers and wish Mr. Shaw a full and speedy recovery,” a release from the city said.
Shaw was South Carolina’s starting quarterback from 2011 to 2013. He passed for 6,074 yards and ran for 1,683 while posting a 27-5 career record. He was inducted into the school’s athletics hall of fame in 2021.
Sports
Illinois DB Scott likely out vs. Indiana, says coach
Published
26 mins agoon
September 18, 2025By
admin
-
Adam RittenbergSep 18, 2025, 02:29 PM ET
Close- College football reporter; joined ESPN in 2008. Graduate of Northwestern University.
Illinois all-conference defensive back Xavier Scott will likely miss Saturday’s Big Ten opener at No. 19 Indiana following an injury last week.
Coach Bret Bielema told reporters Thursday that Scott has not practiced this week and at this point would be out for the ninth-ranked Illini. He’s seeking a second opinion from a doctor on an apparent right foot/ankle injury sustained in the fourth quarter of last Saturday’s 38-0 win against Western Michigan.
“I don’t know [whether] he’ll be back for Saturday or where it’s going to be in the season, but right now, no [for Indiana],” Bielema said Thursday.
Scott earned first-team All-Big Ten honors last season and was a semifinalist for the Jim Thorpe Award after recording 49 tackles, four interceptions, six pass breakups, a forced fumble and a sack. He tied for second in the Big Ten and ranked 15th nationally in interceptions. Tanner Heckel and Tyler Strain will see more time if Scott cannot play.
Scott earned honorable mention All-Big Ten honors in 2023, when he led the league in pass breakups (11) and passes defended (14) during the regular season. He has six tackles, 1.5 tackles for loss and two pass breakups this season.
Bielema said linebacker Dylan Rosiek, running back Aidan Laughery and wide receiver Justin Bowick all are expected to play at Indiana.
Trending
-
Sports3 years ago
‘Storybook stuff’: Inside the night Bryce Harper sent the Phillies to the World Series
-
Sports1 year ago
Story injured on diving stop, exits Red Sox game
-
Sports2 years ago
Game 1 of WS least-watched in recorded history
-
Sports2 years ago
Button battles heat exhaustion in NASCAR debut
-
Sports2 years ago
MLB Rank 2023: Ranking baseball’s top 100 players
-
Sports4 years ago
Team Europe easily wins 4th straight Laver Cup
-
Environment2 years ago
Japan and South Korea have a lot at stake in a free and open South China Sea
-
Environment12 months ago
Here are the best electric bikes you can buy at every price level in October 2024